Plain, Honest Men: The Making of the American Constitution
In May 1787, in an atmosphere of crisis, delegates met in Philadelphia to design a radically new form of government. Distinguished historian Richard Beeman captures as never before the dynamic of the debate and the characters of the men who labored that historic summer. Virtually all of the issues in dispute—the extent of presidential power, the nature of federalism, and,...more
Paperback, 544 pages
Published
February 9th 2010
by Random House Trade Paperbacks
(first published 2009)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
880)
The popular view of the Constitution is pretty well expressed by John Milton, and I'll quote it here:
God, from the Mount of Sinai, whose gray top shall tremble, He descending, will Himself, in thunder, lightning, and loud trumpets' sound, ordain them laws.Well, G-d did it through the intermediaries of the founding fathers, but most often that's a detail that's glossed over. The Constitution, in American political thought, is Holy Writ. The truth is far more interesting and messy, h...more
-Paradise Lost
This book is what it is, and so any recommendation of it becomes a question of what you're looking for when you pick it up to read. If you're looking for a thorough explanation of the process whereby the terms of U.S. Constitution were negotiated and (sort of) agreed upon during the constitutional convention of 1787, this book will serve you well. It takes the reader through an day by day chronological examination of the issues discussed, proposals made and, ultimately, agreements settled upon....more
“While some have boasted it (the Constitution) as a work from Heaven, others have given it a less righteous origin. I have many reasons to believe that it is the work of plain, honest men.” – Gouverneur Morris, delegate to the 1787 Constitutional Convention
This week, like many other weeks for the last 223 years, people are making arguments before the Supreme Court about whether a law is constitutional. In other words – is the law in agreement with the intent of the United States Constitution? Of...more
This week, like many other weeks for the last 223 years, people are making arguments before the Supreme Court about whether a law is constitutional. In other words – is the law in agreement with the intent of the United States Constitution? Of...more
Beeman, Richard. PLAIN, HONEST MEN: The Making of the American Constitution. (2009). ****. Beeman is a professor of history at the University of Pennsylvania and a famed scholar of the Constitution. In his preface, he notes that he has thought about writing this book for forty years. He’s finally done it. What he has done is to take us through the work done by the men who sat on the Constitutional Convention committees in 1787 and arrived at the framework of our Constitution. This is a step-by-s...more
This was an excellent book about our constitutional convention which had the advantages of being written by a history professor who did painstaking research both from original writings of the delegates themselves as well as other histories written about the convention. It also included thoughtful and in depth analysis--but it does not read like a dry textbook, it was well written, at times it read like a novel with suspense and a look into the personal lives of the delegates.
The result is that I...more
The result is that I...more
This is a very good retelling of what happened in the summer of 1787, with the writing of the Constitution--the tensions that existed between the Federalists and those who valued states rights, the lack of interest in the process except for a very few, the work of James Madison in writing the document, and formulating the style of the document, the tensions between the slave states and the non-slave states, and while a bulk of the book goes almost day by day for awhile throughout that summer, he...more
Jun 01, 2009
Bookmarks Magazine
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
july-aug-2009
The challenge of writing an account of the Constitutional Convention is that so many accounts already exist. "Do we need another narrative history of the Constitutional Convention of 1787?" asks the Washington Post. While Beeman's book does not revolutionize the genre, it garners praise for examining the "the nuances and complexities of the compromises that the framers made" (New York Times) and for its detailed recreation of the Philadelphia debates. The most pointed complaint comes from Walter
...more
This the story of about 40 men gathered together in a stuffy room, returning daily for months, to discuss drafting a legal document. It would be only too easy to make it terribly dry and boring. Instead it has become a lively book with in places a touch of humor, written in a crisp, clear style.
The author chose to devote most time and pages to the topics that were controversial even at the time: The nature of the US government, the balance of power between the small and large states, the process...more
"Laws are like sausages—it is best not to see them being made," is a statement misattributed to Otto von Bismarck. However, "Plain, Honest Men: The Making of the American Constitution," an engrossing history of the concerns, debates, compromises, arguments, & revisions that went into forging our government's fundamental document & then getting it ratified, is a book I wholeheartedly & enthusiastically recommend to every American with concerns about the direction in which our country...more
What a phenomenal summer read, being apropos since the Constitutions was created over the summer of 1787. The book accounts for pretty much a day by day account of what transpired during that historical summer in Philadelphia. It takes the three major contentious issues: Nationalism vs. Federalism, the role of the President, and slavery, and presents a philosophical accounting of all the major players. It brings to light the provincialism of some, and the genius of others, especially James Madis...more
This book hit one of my sweet spots in reading. It is highly biographical. Famous and somewhat obscure men are discussed. It runs along a chronological line with asides to discuss the men that mattered in the particular part of the debate.
While it seems that the stated premise of this book is that the Constitution was more the work or plain, honest men (downplaying the "miraculous" origin of the constitution). Yet, as the drama unfolds, the successful outcome defies any logic. I recommend this a...more
While it seems that the stated premise of this book is that the Constitution was more the work or plain, honest men (downplaying the "miraculous" origin of the constitution). Yet, as the drama unfolds, the successful outcome defies any logic. I recommend this a...more
This book is a very well written narrative history of the writing of the Constitution. The title does not really seem appropriate. I am sure the delegates would would be glad to be referred to as honest but plain does not seem a description they would prefer.
The topic of the book is a fascinating event. 55 men spent the summer writing a document which is the blueprint for a nation that has changed immensely and is the longest lasting constitutional republic in the world.
The process of writing t...more
The topic of the book is a fascinating event. 55 men spent the summer writing a document which is the blueprint for a nation that has changed immensely and is the longest lasting constitutional republic in the world.
The process of writing t...more
Jul 20, 2012
Amblingbooks.com
marked it as to-read
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
audiobooks,
history
Plain, Honest Men is a full-scale account of the deliberations of the Founding Fathers from the opening of the Constitutional Convention on May 25, 1787, to its concluding session on September 17. Following closely the chronology of the convention, the book takes listeners behind the scenes and beyond the debates to show how the world's most important constitution was forged through conflict, compromise, and eventually fragile consensus.
Listen to Plain, Honest Men on your smartphone, notebook or...more
Listen to Plain, Honest Men on your smartphone, notebook or...more
The first chapter gets off to a very slow start, telling the reader unnecessarily which hotels delegates checked into, what they were eating, or equally mundane details. Better it would have skipped forward to when real constitutional decisions are being made, those parts are fascinating.
The most riveting section is where the 3/5 of a person concession is made to the slave state representatives. Even if the fact of slavery could not be addressed at the time, it's extra insulting that the slave...more
The most riveting section is where the 3/5 of a person concession is made to the slave state representatives. Even if the fact of slavery could not be addressed at the time, it's extra insulting that the slave...more
The book focuses on the Constitutional Convention that took place in Philadelphia in the summer of 1787. All the "big names" were there--Washington, Jefferson, Franklin--and, of course, William Paterson of New Jersey. While slow in a couple of spots, the information gleaned from this treasure of a book is well worth it. The book not only covers what happened inside the convention, but who was dining with whom, or staying in the same boarding house, outside the convention. Interestingly, the Foun...more
Excellent read!
Richard Beeman brings history to life in this creative retelling of the events of the Constitutional Convention and its ratification by the states. It goes more in depth than any other book I've read on the convention and it does in it a way that reads more like a story, which makes the information overload much easier to comprehend.
I wholeheartedly recommend this book to anyone interested in that era of American history or anyone who wants a better understanding of the challeng...more
Richard Beeman brings history to life in this creative retelling of the events of the Constitutional Convention and its ratification by the states. It goes more in depth than any other book I've read on the convention and it does in it a way that reads more like a story, which makes the information overload much easier to comprehend.
I wholeheartedly recommend this book to anyone interested in that era of American history or anyone who wants a better understanding of the challeng...more
Feb 04, 2011
David Melbie
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Historians
Recommended to David by:
Found this book myself
This is a good read, for sure. I found it ironic that the same arguments that these men were having in 1787 are still being argued today! I think the beauty of the original document is that Article VII is where it states that this thing will have to be amended, and often.
I think the most startling item in this tale is the women who was stoned on the streets of Philadelphia that summer, accused of being a witch. She died days later and it is the saddest part of that summer.
The fact that these men...more
I think the most startling item in this tale is the women who was stoned on the streets of Philadelphia that summer, accused of being a witch. She died days later and it is the saddest part of that summer.
The fact that these men...more
May 08, 2013
Eddy Allen
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
arts-and-historical
From distinguished historian Richard Beeman comes a dramatic and engrossing account of the men who met in Philadelphia during the summer of 1787 to design a radically new form of government. Plain, Honest Men takes readers behind the scenes and beyond the debate to show how the world’s most enduring constitution was forged through conflict, compromise, and, eventually, fragile consensus.
The delegates met in an atmosphere of crisis, many Americans at that time fearing that a combination of financ...more
The delegates met in an atmosphere of crisis, many Americans at that time fearing that a combination of financ...more
I started reading this book at a time that I was really questioning whether the American Experiment will last much longer. The idea of letting the smartest men in the country sit down and whittle out a government for themselves sounds grand, but when I picked up this book I was feeling like that government is about to crumble under its own weight. I've never really read historical nonfiction before, but I figured that in the context of today's polarized political climate it would be interesting...more
I read this to feel more qualified to work at the National Constitution Center. :) From colleagues I've talked to, this is one of the best-written accounts of the Constitutional Convention. It's the only one I've read so far, but every one I read after this will be compared to this one. It's written in such a way that even though I know how the history ends, there's still a sense of suspense and feeling emotionally invested in teh story. In addition, it's simply an intellectually rigorous, evenh...more
The history of the making of the Constitution is presented here as it was created by an impressive group of individuals. Richard Beeman's excellent detailed account of the summer of 1787 relates the revolutionary results of these individuals in the context of their time. I was impressed with the character of the men who were able to work in secrecy for months even though their views were passionate and varied from state to state and even within some delegations. Holding the group together were t...more
A little dry in parts, and a little long, but certainly a definitive work on the founding fathers and the development of our current system of government. Beeman really gets into the nature and depth of discussions among the delegates on settling issues of small states interests vs. large states, the nature of a chief executive, or even if there should be one, how he would be elected, and how we ended up with the Electoral College system. The book contains many interesting insights into the writ...more
They used to teach this in the public schools. I can see why todays progressives want to repress it. If you were'nt taught this in school then you it is a must read.
Publishers Weekly Review:
A day-by-day account of the Constitutional Convention of 1787 in Philadelphia can't yield up much drama or fireworks, or even much sparkling talk, at least as recorded by a few participants, especially James Madison. But in this masterful account, Beeman (Patrick Henry), a noted historian of the late 18th cen...more
Publishers Weekly Review:
A day-by-day account of the Constitutional Convention of 1787 in Philadelphia can't yield up much drama or fireworks, or even much sparkling talk, at least as recorded by a few participants, especially James Madison. But in this masterful account, Beeman (Patrick Henry), a noted historian of the late 18th cen...more
A little dry, but overall, a fascinating look at the "players" and their meeting at the Constitutional Convention in Philadelphia in 1787 where they developed the U.S. Constitution.
Some things that struck me as interesting in my reading:
I am not a huge fan of Ben Franklin, but his final speech, urging the delegates to put the need for a harmonious union above their own interests and ideologies, to check their egos at the door, in essence, marked a decisive moment in the process of the making of...more
Some things that struck me as interesting in my reading:
I am not a huge fan of Ben Franklin, but his final speech, urging the delegates to put the need for a harmonious union above their own interests and ideologies, to check their egos at the door, in essence, marked a decisive moment in the process of the making of...more
With all the talk these days from the "Tea Party" movement about what is in the constituion this book would be great for them to read. To really understand what happen in 1787-89 when these men wrote the most remarkable political document ever written. Beeman focused on this great collection of men and their struggles to create a new kind of goverment. This book is not a textbook it is the drama of creating a new world order.
Been some time since I read a book about the 1787 Constitutional Convention. This is the best of any fairly recent effort (so I've read elsewhere). Let's be honest, though: this is a book about a summer-long meeting in Philadelphia. How exciting can it REALLY be? Interesting to note that the Constitution was the last decent thing to come out of that crappy city. Am I right?!?
Highly recommended! Beeman discusses the wide range of positions on each of the topics contained in our Constitution, helping the reader to understand why the resulting language is a compromise between the factions. This approach provides a deep understanding of the nuanced discussions and fragile agreements that began the creation of the system of government we have today.
Good account of the Constitutional Convention. Written in a narrative style. At times a bit of a page turner! If Hollywood ever decided they wanted to make a movie about the creation of the Constitution they could do worse than using this book as the basis. ALso, don't be put off by the title...the author is not afraid to expose the flaws in those involved!!
I've been wanting to learn more about the creating of our American constitution, but I didn't want a dry book, or one with a lot of biases. This was perfect. He threw in lots of little tidbit information, and did a great job of really helping you put yourself there in the convention room with these amazing - albeit - plain, honest men. Highly recommend!
Quiet possibly the most comprehensive and well written account of the Constitutional Convention. If you want to know anything about the Constitution (prior to the Bill of Rights), the nature of the debates at the Convention, and an in depth but short biography of all the relevant delegates, this is the book to read.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »

Loading...
view 1 comment

















