The Lake Shore Limited
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview read excerpt* *Different edition

The Lake Shore Limited

3.28 of 5 stars 3.28  ·  rating details  ·  2,661 ratings  ·  502 reviews
Four unforgettable characters beckon you into this spellbinding new novel from Sue Miller, the author of 2008’s heralded best seller The Senator’s Wife. First among them is Wilhelmina—Billy—Gertz, small as a child, fiercely independent, powerfully committed to her work as a playwright. The story itself centers on The Lake Shore Limited—a play Billy has written about an ima...more
Hardcover, 270 pages
Published April 6th 2010 by Knopf (first published January 1st 2010)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Lake Shore Limited, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Lake Shore Limited

Mockingjay by Suzanne CollinsSpirit Bound by Richelle MeadClockwork Angel by Cassandra ClareLast Sacrifice by Richelle MeadThe Reckoning by Kelley Armstrong
Best Books of 2010
316th out of 1,193 books — 2,312 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Kay
I know what this book is about but I still don't know why I continued to read it. The characters are not very likeable. The story isn't very interesting and when I was done I was glad. In the past I have enjoyed Sue Miller but my opinion is changing. Her characters seem colder and difficult to care about even when you can see that the little kernel that is the base of the story has merit. In this case how different people feel when a "loved one" dies in a big event. Of course all of those people...more
Barbara
Oct 26, 2011 Barbara rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommended to Barbara by: NY TIMES, BOSTON GLOBE

Sue Miller has previously established her astute perspective of human nature and attendant behaviors in her many books, including The Good Mother and Inventing the Abbotts . She continues with this insightful perception with this novel.

Lake Shore Limited relates to events preceding and post 9-11. The major thrust of the story concerns a play which portrays a terrorist attack on a train, the Lake Shore Limited. It uniquely tells of the author, the characters , friends and many interconnecte...more
Kathleen
I read this novel gratefully after completing Anna Quindlen's latest novel, which I have not even reviewed yet. I use the word "gratefully" because Miller's approach allowed me to keep an arm's length between the characters and me, a healthy detachment, despite the richness of this novel. Centered around a play and the people connected to it, the novel read a bit like a play, with characters being laid out, dialogue, characters walking off to the right and left. Miller also works with life's man...more
Nancy
I really love Sue Miller's books, but---like an exotic dish or vacation destination--they're best read, and appreciated, at intervals. Miller's style--building motivation and storyline through the accumulation of details--is fascinating, and her characters very real. But the endless small acts and almost desultory conversations, while realistic, take considerable patience. The onus is on the reader to make connections and see where plot and characters are going; it's not spelled out.

This is a bo...more
Jill
Back in my dating years, I once heard some pop psychologist say something to this effect: in many early meeting situations, two people show up. You. And your representative.

The point, of course, is that each of us wears masks, and it takes some time for those masks to come off and reveal whom we truly are underneath. Sue Miller – in what I believe is her most ambitious and boldly rendered novel to date – explores precisely this phenomenon, but raises the stakes. Her main character – Billy Gertz,...more
Jane
Sep 09, 2010 Jane rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: Megan and Michael Hollinger, Judy, Molly, Marylynn, oh, all my friends.
I absolutely loved this book. You know how writers say that they write the books they want to read. If I could write fiction, this is the book I would have written because it is exactly the kind of book I want to read. I love the multiple perspectives. I love that people are certain about each other, and absolutely wrong, I love the way the play that one character, Billy, has written is woven into the novel in so many different ways. It is utterly intimate and yet so complicated.

When the traged...more
switterbug (Betsey)
This measured and substantial novel is the capstone of Sue Miller's literary career and clearly removes her from the realm of just "women's fiction" and into a more Jamesian sphere of natural realism. Miller provides penetrating and complex characterizations--it doesn't get any better than this--through robust interior monologues, counterpoint between characters and scenes, overlay, keen perceptions and multiple perspectives, and an artful metaphor between stage/theater and real life. Her quarte...more
Jane
Leslie,the sister; Rafe, the actor; Billy, the former girlfriend and playwright; and Sam, Leslie's former client: these four characters take turns providing a point of view on the story. Leslie's brother died in a terrorist attack on a train; Billie, his former girlfriend writes a play inspired by the event. How we deal with guilt after the end of a relationship, how we put on masks to show people the feelings we think they want to see - these are the motifs explored. At first I didn't care for...more
Tanya Merchant
This is one of the first book I won on Goodreads Giveaways, and I was really excited about it--until I realized that the average review was only 3 stars. I hesitated to read the book because of the lukewarm reviews. For some reason, I decided to pick the book up this week, and I can honestly say that I really enjoyed it. I expected a mediocre read and instead was treated to a compelling read. I loved the characters--I especially loved their flaws. I wept aloud as I read about 9/11--perhaps becau...more
Steve Lindahl
This is the first Sue Miller novel I've read. It took me awhile to get used to her style, but in the end it was worth it. This book was a reaction to the terrorist attacks on September 11, 2001. Billy, the main character, lost her lover, Gus, who was killed when the plane he was on was flown into one of the twin towers. But this wasn't a simple story about losing someone you love in a senseless act of terror. There were problems with Billy and Gus' relationship and those problems left Billy feel...more
Diane
I've enjoyed Sue Miller's novels in the past, but the style of this novel is different. In this story, four individuals, each carrying their own personal baggage, are brought together by a two act play called, The Lake Shore Limited. The play takes place at a small theater in Boston. The play hits home on many levels. The main character, Rafe, learns that there has been a terrorist bombing on the train that his wife was a passenger on in Chicago's Union Station. To make matters worst, he was pla...more
Ron Charles
There are several contenders (Anita Shreve, Gail Godwin), but Sue Miller might be the best poster child for the poison condescension bestowed by the term "women's literature." She didn't publish her first novel, "The Good Mother" (1986), until she was in her 40s, but since then she's been prolific and popular (another mark against her), writing about families and marriages, infidelity and divorce -- what we call "literary fiction" when men write about those things. Last year, a grudging review o...more
Mara
Un libro che apre il vaso di Pandora facendo emergere un pensiero inconfessabile che noi non ammetteremmo mai, poiché desiderare la morte di qualcuno è un pensiero che appartiene agli angoli più brutti dell’animo umano e nessuno confesserebbe di aver formulato almeno una volta questa speranza a proposito di un proprio congiunto, semplicemente per la voglia di immaginare un’esistenza nuova. Una vita alternativa, insomma, dove, con l’innocua “eliminazione” di qualcuno, si realizzi l’utopia della l...more
Ellen
I just finished listening to Sue Miller narrate her own work. Sometimes authors do superbly (Sherman Alexie, Neil Gaiman) and sometimes they flop (Madeleine L'engle.) Miller makes a fair job of it, but maybe she should have taken a cue from Billy, her playwright protagonist, and let an actor do the job. Billy, who seemed to me rather prickly and self-deceiving, gets a sympathetic reading from Miller.

The Lake Shore Limited (name of book, name of play in the book) looks at how loss affects the li...more
Mary
I loved this book, every word of it. There are four main characters. Their stories are fascinating in and of themselves but also in the context of their relationships with each other. The play that parallels their lives, that connects them and separates them, is a character in itself. I learned as much about myself through the interplay of the narrative and the play as the characters learn as they see themselves reflected in art and the process of art.

Often when a book's structure shifts between...more
Victoria Watson
Having read 'The Senator's Wife' a few years ago, I saw this Sue Miller novel and decided to give it a go.

Featuring four main characters, this story is told through their eyes during the run of a play, written by Billy, a 9/11 widow. The difference about Billy, though, is she was preparing to end her relationship with Gus, her younger lover, when he got on a plane on September 11th, 2001. She has never told his older sister, Leslie, this though and she is still in touch with Leslie which is why...more
Mary Taitt
When I saw this book at the library, I almost didn't pick it up. I was thinking some previous book by this author had left a bad taste in my mouth, but I couldn't remember which. I decided to get it anyway, and I am delighted that I did! It was one of the best books I've read in a long time. It is honest, thought provoking, human, difficult, unhappy and happy and realistic and good.

The entire book revolves around the play, The Lake Shore Limited, which is about a terrorist attack on a train in C...more
Michelle
Beautiful, quiet, evocative novel told from multiple viewpoints. The viewpoints don’t shift rapidly like most books employing this method, thus The Lake Shore Limited reads like several short stories, but more connected. One immediately interesting device was that instead of this being a novel about 9/11 it’s a novel about a play that’s about 9/11. I found that a very clever twist. Also, I loved the delving into of Billy’s creative process for writing her play.

This is not a loud book. The plot...more
Meegan McCorkle
This is actually more of a 3.5, almost 4. I think what I liked most about The Lake Shore Limited is the idea that someone who has tried to cut love out of her life (partly because of guilt from a failed relationship with a very complicated finish) can still find love, despite herself. Every once in awhile, I really need a sweet, happy ending.

I'm always impressed at how complete Miller's portraits are. You come away with a full sense of the good and bad, strength and weakness in all of the main c...more
Linda
For those of you who like "quiet" fiction which delves into the psychological makeup of each character and why they act the way they do, this author is wonderful. This was an interesting novel, centered around a play called "The Lake Shore Limited," which dealt, in an indirect fashion, with the aftermath and effects of survivors of 9/11. The story moved from character to character, and as it did the reader learned more and more about each one. This is a complex, quiet love story, and for me, a v...more
Kdevoli
I really loved this book. I love Sue Miller, and this one didn't disappoint. I would give it four and a half stars. The title takes its name from the name of a play, written by one of the main characters, a woman named Billy. The play centers on a fictional terrorist attack aboard Chicago's Lake Shore Limited train, which echoes Billy's experience on 9/11 when her boyfriend/lover died on one of the planes. But Billy was feeling ambivalent about her boyfriend before he died, and the ambivalence i...more
Annie
This is a difficult one to sum up. I've always liked Sue Miller's books but this one's even more character based and introspective than most. I almost gave up in the first quarter - Billy's a playwright who produces a work based on her personal experiences, the other key characters go to watch it (or act in it), and the author describes the whole play. I didn't think that worked particularly well. But the characterisation thereafter is excellent, and you get tremendously involved in the lives, l...more
Laura
I heard Sue Miller read the first chapter and talk about the book. The seed of the idea is based on a person who didn't leave her boyfriend when a tragedy struck his family. I'm enjoying Billy as a character who is impulsive. The writing really shows her desire to connect and be alone. The book closes with Sam. Sam is set up as a potential romantic interest for Billy. I really enjoyed the book, but would have enjoyed a more traditional resolution.
Kyla
I love Sue Miller and have decided before I even begin one of her books that I will love it. I'm never anticipating any twists, turns, or over-dramatized plots... Just extremely well-written, fully developed characters that are so relate-able you have sympathy for them immediately.

In The Lake Shore Limited, my feeling is the same however while the intertwined-stories of 4 characters are told from each their own point of view, I felt the book would have been stronger if just told from 3. Essenti...more
Eleanor
I really liked this book. I almost gave it 5 stars because I liked it so much .. The story hinges around a playwrite and her play .. and I must say I liked every character in it -- I liked the depth Miller gave each character and I could relate to all of them - as well as the setting - This is a very good book for a book club discussion. Many, many things to talk about, relate to and to understand -
Carinya Kappler
The Lake Shore Limited by Sue Miller Book Review
Carinya 22.05.2014
I found this novel refreshing in its approach to the never ending search for true love. Emotional equality, although not an attribute necessary for maternal or filial devotion, seems mandatory to the success of long term romantic attachment.
Effective communication is possible only if emotional equality exists. This point is highlighted by the doomed relationship of Billy and Gus. Billy perceives her live in lover Gus has the emoti...more
Carol
I have become very critical about what I read, I find. I actually liked this book. I wasn't crazy about all of the characters, but I did like the questions it brought out. And isn't that the definition of a good book...one that leaves you mulling it over after your have closed it, whether about the characters, the plot, the themes? I'm looking forward to the book discussion in October.
Stephanie
It's been a long time since I've read a book by Sue Miller. How I've missed her! Is there any better novelist at revealing the turmoils of human relations and the inner debates about their effects on the spirit? If so, I'm not sure who. Her touch is light but always affecting. In "The Lake Shore Limited" four stories are intertwined, brought together by a play of that name. Written by one of the protagonists, the play puts four people at odds as they wait to hear the fate of victims of a terrori...more
Ingrid
Jun 28, 2012 Ingrid added it
One of my favourite writers.


I found it more of a struggle than usual to really immerse my self in this novel, then about a third of the way I was hooked.

She has a profound empathy for her characters and their human difficulties.
Margo Brooks
This novel explores 9/11 through the construct of a play based on a terrorist attack written by an author who lost a boyfriend during 9/11. It is an odd construct, bringing the reader both closer and further from 9/11 than may be appropriate. It works to some degree in that it allows for an exploration of some of the reactions to 9/11 that people had that might have otherwise been difficult to acknowledge. Unfortunately, the writing, like the narrative structure also tends to distance the reader...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Swimming Pool
  • The Widower's Tale
  • No Time to Wave Goodbye
  • The Message to the Planet
  • Sing Them Home
  • Swim Back to Me
  • The Nobodies Album
  • This Must Be the Place
  • Mr Lynch's Holiday
  • Father of the Rain
  • Men and Dogs
  • Brother of the More Famous Jack
  • The Language of Secrets
  • The Door Through Space
  • Elegies for the Brokenhearted
  • Red Hook Road
  • The Season of Second Chances
  • Secrets of Eden
3517
Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the GoodReads database with this name. See this thread for more information.

Sue Miller (born November 29, 1943 in Chicago) is an American writer who has authored a number of best-selling novels. Her duties as a single mother left her with little time to write for many years, and as a result she did not publish her first novel until 1986, after spend...more
More about Sue Miller...
While I Was Gone The Good Mother The Senator's Wife Family Pictures World Below

Share This Book

“We want. When we stop wanting, we feel dead and want to want more. (p.232)” 4 likes
More quotes…