333rd out of 1,496 books
—
3,009 voters
La Perdida
by
Jessica Abel
Carla, una norteamericana distanciada de su padre mexicano, decide ir a la capital del país azteca para “encontrarse a sí misma”. Se instala en casa de un antiguo ligue que sigue las huellas de sus héroes William S. Burroughs y Jack Kerouac por los bares de la ciudad. Harry se toma con buen humor la reaparición de Carla en su vida hasta que se da cuenta de que ésta, que se...more
Hardcover, 288 pages
Published
March 7th 2006
by Astiberri
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,578)
When I first started to read La Perdida I really enjoyed it because I was excited to read a graphic novel about a young Mexican-American woman. I also enjoyed the author/artist Jessica Abel's sparsely drawn images of Mexico City landmarks (and Pilsen in Chicago).
Unfortunately, as the story progressed I started to become uncomfortable with the authors negative portrayal of Mexico City/Chilango youth culture. Raw honesty I appreciate, but the author painted a seedy world where you can't trust any...more
Unfortunately, as the story progressed I started to become uncomfortable with the authors negative portrayal of Mexico City/Chilango youth culture. Raw honesty I appreciate, but the author painted a seedy world where you can't trust any...more
I divide this book into two parts, even though it's not formally divided as such. There's such stylistic difference between them, it almost seems like there should be a formal divide. The first part of the book is a coming of age post-college, finding oneself while traveling, open-ended exposition. There's not much plot, just a lot of wondering around and talking to people. This isn't necessarily a bad thing -- I really enjoy those types of stories if they're done right. But what stopped me firs...more
Jun 12, 2007
Sotoleon
rated it
3 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
people who like identity-search type novels
Jessica Abel’s _La Perdida_ tells the story of Carla, an anglo-mexican U.S. citizen, who in an aimless sojourn in Mexico city falls into various situations and encounters a variety of people, all of which challenge her custom-made American identity. After a brief period of successfully (or so she thinks) acculturating to not only her local community (which include Marxist revolutionaries, drug dealers, and ESL students) but to Mexican society at large, an international incident occurs which ulti...more
Although it's not a memoir, La Perdida is based on the author's personal experience and is memoir-esque. On the surface, it sounds interesting: a half-Mexican woman goes to Mexico to get more in touch with her cultural heritage. It was pretty well regarded.
IT IS AWFUL, YOU GUYS.
I wanted to give it up halfway through the second issue because I was so bored. I just didn't care about anything! All the characters were annoying, and nothing fucking happened. Each issue seemed to be nothing more than...more
IT IS AWFUL, YOU GUYS.
I wanted to give it up halfway through the second issue because I was so bored. I just didn't care about anything! All the characters were annoying, and nothing fucking happened. Each issue seemed to be nothing more than...more
Jun 12, 2008
Jessica
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
brian gottlieb
Shelves:
mexico-mexico-city,
graphic-novel
I'd seen an excerpt of 'La Perdida' at an exhibit on the Graphic Novel Art in nearby West Stockbridge (Norman Rockwell Museum) some months ago and was intrigued. A graphic novel about Mexico City by someone named Jessica? How could I resist?! And then yesterday, while trying to hunt down a copy of the 'Savage Detectives,' I found "La Perdida" (The Lost One). So my interest and expectations were high...and for the most part, Abel satisfies them. The drawings are fluid and natural-seeming as is th...more
Mar 31, 2008
Maria
added it
Leídas unas cuantas reseñas aquí, voy a acabar escribiendo sobre algo en lo que no pensaba mientras leía el libro*. Las dos principales objecciones que recibe son el argumento rocambolesco de la segunda parte (estoy de acuerdo) y lo mal que cae la protagonista -es decir, que es difícil identificarse con ella- a lo cual me sale del alma contestar un simple "y qué", no sé si con interrogación o exclamación o ambos.
Carla cae fatal. (Carla se da un aire a Holden Caulfield.) Es una mujer mexicano-ame...more
Carla cae fatal. (Carla se da un aire a Holden Caulfield.) Es una mujer mexicano-ame...more
Jessica Abel’s sizeable fictional travelogue La Perdida is the annotated postcard of the protagonist Carla’s visit to Mexico to find herself. As she navigates relationships and challenges, from disagreements with her wealthy ex-boyfriend expatriate, Harry to the difficulties of learning an unfamiliar culture, she also journeys through delusion, self-discovery and accountability.
While Carla is not always likeable, Abel’s skillfully expressive bold-line drawings and revealing dialogue keep the rea...more
While Carla is not always likeable, Abel’s skillfully expressive bold-line drawings and revealing dialogue keep the rea...more
The graphic novel La Perdida by Jessica Abel (check her cool website by the way) follows Carla, a naïve American girl who moves to Mexico City in the hopes of finding her Mexican roots (her estranged father is Mexican) and presumably in the process jazzing up her life.
Carla doesn't speak Spanish and has never previously visited when she first arrives, but vigorously sets about trying to differentiate and distinguish herself from the American expat community. Maddeningly for her she is never full...more
Carla doesn't speak Spanish and has never previously visited when she first arrives, but vigorously sets about trying to differentiate and distinguish herself from the American expat community. Maddeningly for her she is never full...more
as a graphic novel, i think "La Perdida" is a total success, the way the awesome illustrations tell the story and are supported by the text. i picked it up and started reading and couldn't put it down. brilliant!
unfortunately, the story lacked the depth and analysis about certain issues (class privilege, racism, tokenism..) that would have made it great. the clueless main character annoyed the shit out of me by making horrible choices and basically just being a total idiot. the story offers grea...more
unfortunately, the story lacked the depth and analysis about certain issues (class privilege, racism, tokenism..) that would have made it great. the clueless main character annoyed the shit out of me by making horrible choices and basically just being a total idiot. the story offers grea...more
This is a well-told coming-of-age story featuring an American woman, Carla, who wishes to "find herself" by visiting Mexico and hunting down her roots (her father was a Mexican.) Initially constructing her idea of "Mexican" from bohemian clothing choices and Frieda Kahlo's artwork, Carla is immediately confronted with the fact that she is a stranger in a strange land, blood relationship notwithstanding. She struggles to learn the language and the customs, argues and bickers with her ex-boyfriend...more
This gets compared to the work of the Bros. Hernandez, but aside from the art style (and only occasionally), the fact that the main character is a woman, and the fact that it's set in Mexico, I'm not really seeing it. La Perdida is told in flashbacks, and is surprisingly suspenseful, despite the fact that we know the protagonist turns out more or less all right. There is something compelling about watching a character make tiny bad decisions, one after another, that inexorably push her towards a...more
I have to say, I was extremely lukewarm to this book. It seems like the kind of thing I would like, but overall I didn't see what all the hype was about. The entire plot rests on the main character being annoying, stupid, and so desperate to please her 'real Mexican' friends that she throws common sense out the window. By the end, you just want her to stop white guilt whining about how HARD it is to be privileged and to stop trying to win the favor of people who she can never win over. The endin...more
I can't really believe I'm only reading this now, especially since GN travelogues are one of my purported interests. For the first half of the book I had the impression that it was barely fictionalized autobiography, but soon figured out that it's a more fully invented true graphic novel. This is the story of a girl trying to imbed herself in the culture of Mexico. She is half-Mexican, but barely speaks the language when she goes to "visit" a former fling and "forgets" to make her flight out of...more
I really enjoyed reading these comic books when they were first published a few years ago, and I re-read them recently for a book club discussion I didn't end up going to. Jessica Abel's five-part story of a girl who moves to Mexico City on a whim - partially to reconnect with the Mexican heritage she never knew, partially to follow an ex-boyfriend, and partially just because it was something new and different to do - held up just as well on a second visit as it did my first time through.
The ma...more
The ma...more
I don't even recall how I stumbled across Jessica Abel's La Perdida—probably in doing research on Love & Rockets—but I'm glad I found it. While far from perfect, the first three-fifths of the graphic novel or so are wonderful, and while it kind of devolves into a melodramatic plot that unfortunately reeks of stereotypes of Mexico, overall it is still strongly characterized and well-drawn.
Carla, the protagonist may be a post-college naïve-as-hell gringita prone to willful ignorance and drunke...more
Carla, the protagonist may be a post-college naïve-as-hell gringita prone to willful ignorance and drunke...more
Another graphic novel that I just pulled off the shelf without knowing anything about it and another good one at that.
Carla is half Mexican and half American. When an ex-boyfriend moved to Mexico, she decided to go too and find the other half of her roots. Carla leaves with little money and no real plans except to see everything that she can see. She has a ticket home but she doesn't really plan on going back. She shows up on Harry's doorstep with no real plan, knowing that she intends to live w...more
Carla is half Mexican and half American. When an ex-boyfriend moved to Mexico, she decided to go too and find the other half of her roots. Carla leaves with little money and no real plans except to see everything that she can see. She has a ticket home but she doesn't really plan on going back. She shows up on Harry's doorstep with no real plan, knowing that she intends to live w...more
Should be called La Dumbass. The heroine(?) of this novel succeeded in irritating me with her idiocy and horrible choices as no one has since....Ann Coulter?
When the drug lord offers you a sample of cocaine, the wise choice is to LEAVE, not take it! Sigh.
I guess I could consider Jessica Abel successful because she created a character who inspired strong feelings in me, even if those feelings were mostly annoyance.
When the drug lord offers you a sample of cocaine, the wise choice is to LEAVE, not take it! Sigh.
I guess I could consider Jessica Abel successful because she created a character who inspired strong feelings in me, even if those feelings were mostly annoyance.
This is more like a 3.5 for me, but I'm rounding up.
In some ways, I think the format of the graphic novel is somewhat limiting to the subject matter, since it involves issues of race and identity, and what it means to be of mixed ethnicity--which is some rather complicated stuff to convey with simple line drawings, dialog and occasional narrative.
The main character, Carla, has grown up in the U.S., always speaking English and only English, but moves to Mexico City and gets caught up in trying t...more
In some ways, I think the format of the graphic novel is somewhat limiting to the subject matter, since it involves issues of race and identity, and what it means to be of mixed ethnicity--which is some rather complicated stuff to convey with simple line drawings, dialog and occasional narrative.
The main character, Carla, has grown up in the U.S., always speaking English and only English, but moves to Mexico City and gets caught up in trying t...more
To be precise, I'd say this is more of a 3.5 than a four or three - but I don't get a middle option with the stars.
This is a well-told piece of fiction. I understand the beef some have with the portrayal of the seedy side, however she is portraying the people that Carla CHOSE and makes a strong point in the very end that there were many other options, many good people... she was blinded by her own cultural assumptions, and by her personal arrogance.
At first I was wondering "why bother" telling...more
This is a well-told piece of fiction. I understand the beef some have with the portrayal of the seedy side, however she is portraying the people that Carla CHOSE and makes a strong point in the very end that there were many other options, many good people... she was blinded by her own cultural assumptions, and by her personal arrogance.
At first I was wondering "why bother" telling...more
The dust jacket is the only reason this book should get a single star, its beautifully done and with a grat color pallette. Besides that, this is the perfect book to take to a campmfire if you are out of wood or fuel. Terrible story, full of cliches, awful black and white drawings. Maybe if it had been done in full color it could have been eye catchy, but its not. It does not seem to start that bad , but as you continue it only gets worse. The depction of mexico city at the beginning is quite fa...more
I did not finish this book.
First of all, the art is all black and white. I have no problem with that, however when an artist restricts themselves to b&w, they need to be careful not to get too detailed or the pictures will get very crowded and busy. La Perdida is a good example of that. The art itself is not bad but I found the level of detail in each panel a bit distracting and for me it detracted fro the experience.
Maybe that wasn't such a bad thing however because the story itself is a b...more
First of all, the art is all black and white. I have no problem with that, however when an artist restricts themselves to b&w, they need to be careful not to get too detailed or the pictures will get very crowded and busy. La Perdida is a good example of that. The art itself is not bad but I found the level of detail in each panel a bit distracting and for me it detracted fro the experience.
Maybe that wasn't such a bad thing however because the story itself is a b...more
Jan 17, 2010
Nelly Paulina
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
chicano-lit,
comic-books
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
The art in this book is great, and I enjoyed the story too. I just have some quibbles with how it was done. The language thing was clunky (especially the footnote translations), but then again, I suppose it was somewhat important to capture the transition from uncomprehending gringa to Spanish speaker. It was hard to read, though. The other thing that was annoying was that the set-up took such a long time. But I guess that's also essential - if things had happened more abruptly, it would be hard...more
While, I thought the art work was really good for a graphic novel (clear while artistic at the same time)I didn't connect with the characters, especially the narrator/main character Carla. She seemed a bit superficial and seemed to take in very little of the Mexican culture she claimed to so desperately want to learn about. Her continual search for an "authentic" experience in Mexico City (versus her American ex-boyfriend's) seems to push her to hang out with low-lifes (if I can say that without...more
La Perdida by Jessica Abel is an amazing graphic novel about Carla, a biracial American, who travels to Mexico to seek to understand the father she has never met. She ends up becoming disillusioned with her boyfriend and his idea of how to live the expatriate life and leaves him to seek out a more "authentic" experience. Falling in with a crowd of disaffected young men who quickly become petty and not-so-petty criminals, Carla is swept into a lifestyle that becomes more and more uncomfortable un...more
This graphic novel by Jessica Abel follows Carla, a half-Mexican, half-German woman who moves to Mexico City in order to find her roots and herself. She arrives barely speaking Spanish and eventually makes a life for herself, but, as the title suggests, she doesn't exactly find herself. I really connected with Carla's feelings of curiosity and confusion around her ethnic heritage. The plot slows down a bit in the middle, but then it really picks up and goes full speed ahead to the end. I wasn't...more
Yes, Carla is an idiot on the whole, but taking the drugs is what you do when you're in another country. That's the time to do them, when none of your back-home acquaintances will be gossipping about it tomorrow. That's the time to find the squalid neighbourhood to live in, to get too drunk and yell, to have pointless conversations with obstinate Marxists.
And she's not so much of an idiot that she doesn't recognize her own indiocy, and I like her for that. Plus, her frustration at the fact that...more
And she's not so much of an idiot that she doesn't recognize her own indiocy, and I like her for that. Plus, her frustration at the fact that...more
May 19, 2010
Patti
rated it
2 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
graphic-novels,
summer-2010
I heard rave reviews of this coming-of-age graphic novel about a young Chicana woman's experiences in Mexico. Unfortunately, since the protagonist was completely unlikable and unbelievably stupid and the other characters were essentially stereotypes, the novel's attempts at emotional depth fell flat. An abrupt plot- and tone-shift midway through raises a crime-ring plot that seems forced and disjointed. And the Spanish glossary in the back makes it patently clear that the target audience is US r...more
This novel made me uncomfortable, but I couldn't put it down either. In fact, I tried to stop reading it, put it back on the shelf in used, but ended up taking it right off the shelf again and staying up till 1 in the morning finishing it. Anyone who has experienced the great "abroad" during, or after college knows what it feels like to be in a foreign land, surrounded by the great other (that we often try to emulate) as well as fellow ex-pats. A lot of the feelings, and mis-steps were familiar...more
More than anything a coming of age graphic novel where the young person is not only the narrator but their identity and that of a county lurching into the 21st century. The narrative trips over itself a few times and the dialogue can feel a little set-upy instead of natural. But make no mistake. La Perdida is a huge-friggin achievement, amazingly drawn, so sure of its setting in Mexico City and place in time (late 90s) that it feels as much a diary or historical document. Or just a conversation...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Jessica Abel (Chicago, 1969) started making comics in college, at the University of Chicago. Her early efforts appeared in the student anthology Breakdown. After college, in 1992, she won the infamous “Stinky Date” contest in Peter Bagge’s Hate comics, and, since she had arranged to meet the artist at the Chicago Comics Convention, she decided to put together a sampler of her comics to show him an...more
More about Jessica Abel...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »











view all 21 comments






















