Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Edge of Evolution: The Search for the Limits of Darwinism” as Want to Read:
The Edge of Evolution: The Search for the Limits of Darwinism
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

The Edge of Evolution: The Search for the Limits of Darwinism

3.54 of 5 stars 3.54  ·  rating details  ·  281 ratings  ·  58 reviews
When Michael J. Behe's first book, Darwin's Black Box, was published in 1996, it launched the intelligent design movement. Critics howled, yet hundreds of thousands of readers -- and a growing number of scientists -- were intrigued by Behe's claim that Darwinism could not explain the complex machinery of the cell.

Now, in his long-awaited follow-up, Behe presents far more...more
ebook, 336 pages
Published June 5th 2007 by Free Press (first published 2007)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Edge of Evolution, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Edge of Evolution

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 657)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Rasheed
Argues for Darwin's assertion of universal common descent, but questions the over-touted ability of its proposed mechanism, namely undirected natural selection acting on random mutation, in the light of experimental evidence.
John
The Abyss of Reason: The Limits of Michael Behe’s Scientific Thinking


Theodosius Dobzhansky, the great Russian-American population geneticist, one of the prominent biologists responsible for the Modern Synthesis Theory of Evolution, observed that “Nothing in Biology makes sense except in the light of evolution”. It was true when he stated that decades ago; it is truer still today given the abundant wealth of excellent data from a diverse host of biological sciences: molecular biology and biochemi...more
Donald
anyone propagating the idea that the ID movement is a dead end, particularly after the Dover trials, should read this book. That there are differing views and interpretations of data must always be taken into consideration. But when there is this much controversy that generates the visceral comments from Behe's adversaries defies their allegiances to Darwinian orthodoxy. There is clearly another way to interpret all this data. Having now read this book in earnest, I'm afraid the controversy is f...more
Monk
Listened to this on CD and was VERY impressed. I had always assumed that "intelligent design" was just a code word used by fundamental Christians for creationism. Had no idea that anyone had thought the argument through so well. Behe mixes hard science (my 13 year-old swore he was speaking German) with clear analogies in order to present difficult concepts in a way that a non-scientist can at least follow. His arugments about the statistical problems with a purely Darwinist approach are very per...more
Cbpax
While not for light reading, well worth the reading. Dr. Behe established in "Darwin's Black Box" that the cell is not simple and would be impossible to thus just "happen" (i.e. evolve) and he continues to delve into his arguments in "The Edge of Evolution". He also writes of the positives of Darwinism but then demolishes any strongholds it may claim. Excellent book.
People say my name should be Jeff
Really? His last two books didn't humiliate him enough? What part of "irreducible complexity is an illusion based on ignorance" doesn't this guy get? And who the heck made him the expert on what evolution can do and can't do? A degree in chemistry? If that were true, my Linguistics training makes me a good author. Hey, its all language, right???
Brian
Behe is stuck in no-man's land between the Creationist and radical Darwinist. As such, I suspect he will not have many supporters, even if he is on to something. I went online and tried to find a single reasonable critical review and was disappointed by all of the ad hominem rubbish out there. As much as I don’t care for Dawkins, his review was the best I could find, and it was poor. The bottom line: There are gaps in the Darwinian synthesis. Darwinists say Behe appeals to God, and they appeal t...more
Anthony Edridge
Although evolutionists have soundly criticized Behe for challenging their certainty of evolution, Behe does make the point that living organisms have limits, determined by cellular processes, that prohibit a new genome from straying too far from it's starting point. Within those limits, however, we see all kinds of adaptation to environmental pressures, which can sometimes lead to loss of some functionality. Where multiple genetic changes occur, some are mildly beneficial, most are deleterious,...more
One..
Once, and then twice I passed this book when I saw it in this little bookshop I frequent, lying on the philosophy shelf.
The third time I bought 'The Edge of Evolution'.
Behe's previous book 'Darwins Black Box' was paradigmatic in my thought, as it was in launching the whole intelligent design idea, so I figured I might as well read this one.

It rekindled an old love for biochemistry. The little machinery inside biological cells is just breathtakingly intricate and beautiful. I found myself just...more
Lynn
Sep 18, 2007 Lynn rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: no one
An interesting try that's flawed by a logical fallacy called 'begging the question'. The author assumes the thing he's trying to prove and incorporates it into his arguement. Good data, bad science.

Lynn Hoffman, author of bang BANG
Cliff
Another great book. Can random mutations account for the diversity of life on this planet? Science says no. Behe details why. Fantastic!
Caleb Stephens
This book is a wonderful read by a obviously intelligent and observant author. Admittedly some information is over my head regarding micro cellular processes and protein formation. However this book is written for both mass audiences and observant scientists who desire to increase their understanding of evolution. To the chagrin of a pro-darwinian evolutionist, Behe outlines the logical extent to which Darwinian evolution can be expected to take any organism. Demonstrating observations on the ev...more
Mike Ogilvie
I’m happy to be done with The Edge of Evolution: The Search for the Limits of Darwinism. In examining the existence of life on Earth and the process of “Darwinian” evolution, Michael J. Behe attempts to make the case for Intelligent Design. The essence of his argument is that the complexities of the processes of life are mathematically not possible through “Darwinian” evolution. Therefore those processes must have been put there on purpose – thus “designed”.

He almost exclusively sticks to the pr...more
Kirsten
Behe's arguments make so much sense that they are almost boring. It's like having someone tell you something that you already intuitively know. Still it is valuable to have someone break it down mathematically and explain the flaws in Darwin's theory, of which there are many. The problem with the way science is taught today, at least from what I experienced in college, is that most faculty are absolutely convinced that Darwin was right. They don't even question his theories anymore which is extr...more
Gary W
This book is an argument for intelligent design - the theory that the development of life on Earth has had supernatural or divine guidance. The author, Michael Behe, explains that what we call the theory of Evolution is really a composite of three theories. 1) that all life on Earth is related having developed from some primordial life form 2) that the individuals members of any living species acquire variations or mutations over time and 3) natural selection - that in the struggle for food, saf...more
Ben
Aug 19, 2009 Ben rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Anyone interested in science, biology, apologetics, malaria, medicine.
An exciting read, even for non-biologists. Having worked in a heavily malaria stricken environment (D.R. Congo), I enjoyed learning about how malaria works, how the body fights it, and why it is the best test bed for evolutionary theory to be played out. Behe demonstrates from Malaria that evolution has very distinct boundaries... micro evolution, sure... macro evolution, no way. Although this is a defense of the Christian worldview, this book is very scientific in nature and it's intent is not...more
Tyler Mickley
After reading "Darwin's Black Box" and not liking it, I figured I'd give Behe another shot. I liked this book a lot more but was still disappointed. He spends the entire book trying to debunk evolution with implications of a designer and then at the end he tells us that it doesn't really matter anyhow. That we should just fill in the blank. He doesn't really bring us into his ideas of what/who a designer is let alone the idea of how. He struck again with illogical ideas, ill conceived analogies...more
Patrick
Amazon:
"With this book, Michael Behe shows that he is truly an independent thinker of the first order. He carefully examines the data of evolution, along the way making an argument for universal common descent that will make him no friends among young-earth creationists, and draws in new facts, especially the data on malaria, that have not been part of the public debate at all up to now. This book will take the intelligent design debate into new territory and represents a unique contribution to...more
Michael
Devastating. I hope the challenges of this book are taken seriously one day (preferably sooner rather than later). Enough hand-waving and empty pleas to "reason." The data doesn't match the theory anymore, and it needs to be addressed.
Patrick
This is a good read. Behe is clever and very readable. I sometimes got lost in the numbers, but I expected that. A better intelligent design book than Demski's The Design Revolution.
Tony
Behe, Michael J. THE EDGE OF EVOLUTION: The Search for the Limits of Darwinism. (2007). ***. I’ve been reading this book off and on for weeks now. I have to admit that most of it goes over my head. My training in biology, most of it ending in 1959, was just before most of the discoveries in molecular biology began to come to the fore. My education was pretty much limited to learning the Krebs (one “b” or two?) and pithing a variety of frogs. Dr. Behe’s thesis is that Darwin’s theory of random mu...more
Joseph D. Walch
This book dives deeply into the nitty-gritty of molecular biology and complexity. It’s discussions malarial mutations thalassemia blood disorders, protein-gene interactions, etc. are probably more than would interest a layperson (I skipped a few of the technical parts of the chapters), but it has an interesting philosophy which says 1) natural selection plays a large role in many processes including bacterial antibiotic resistance, and 2) there is a large body of evidence that supports common de...more
Wendy
Michael Behe is a friend of a friend. My friend, Gary, possesses an 200+ IQ (I'm guessing...It may only be upper 190's...), has one of the best sense of humors of any person I have ever met, and is the most down to earth Christians that you will have the pleasure of talking to. When he says that Behe know's what he's talking about, I'm ready to believe him 100%.

I'll admit, saying I've 'read' this book is a stretch. I skimmed it heavily, just to get to some of the good bits.

In a nutshell, I don...more
Mazola1
This book is Michael Behe's latest effort to advance the cause of intelligent design. Behe, best known for his concept of irreducible complexity, argues that most beneficial "random" mutations are are beyond the capacity of evolution to produce. It's a slightly new twist on the old idea that mutation and natural selection can account for "microevolution," but some higher power is needed to produce macroevolution.

Many proponents of intelligent design/creationism, would no doubt be surprised and...more
Shawn
Although I enjoyed this book, at times it was a bit too technical for me to truly grasp the full impact of some arguments. On the other hand, Dr. Behe did an excellent job of writing to the nontechnical reader using simple analogies and explanations to enhance his points. Generally speaking, the central thrust of the book is that the complexity of life at the molecular level (and higher levels) is so sophisticated that it cannot be explained by a series of random events over the period of time s...more
Neal
I had written a very extensive review of this book, and then I discovered a very cogent criticism of it, which essentially dismantles Behe's whole argument. Basically, the article proceeds by explaining that the hammartia of Behe's argument is a very complex biological phenomenon that, the biologist who wrote the article explains, is so difficult to truly comprehend that even some scientists might find it daunting, but even so, he proceeds. The crux of the issue is this: Behe apparently grossly...more
Beth
Very readable, fascinating look at evolution in action. He explores the pressures created by the malaria parasite and the resulting adaptations in both humans and the parasite. With some elementary math applied to what is known about malaria he calculates how frequently traits are likely to appear as a result of Darwinian evolutionary mechanisms. Given a population size and mutation rate, a reasonable "edge of evolution" can be estimated.
Neem
It's a very interesting book to read if you are seeking for details, very well explained. But it establishes the fact that Darwinism is not the answer to all evolutionary questions. However gets into trouble in the second half a bit shaky; not because of the author but because no further discoveries have been made which can be talked about.
Momma
For anyone who still believes in Darwin's Theory. This book shows that Darwin's theory is not scientifically viable. With all the new knowledge that we have discovered in the last 10-20 years, he shows that random mutation and natural selection to the extent that it would have been needed for Darwin's Theory is not scientifically possible, without some kind of intelligence to design it. He is very balanced and goes through his thought process very thoroughly. Because it is highly scientific, it...more
Weston Mccarron
Take a standard deck of cards. Shuffle them thoroughly. Now record the exact order of the cards. Did you know that the odds of shuffling a deck of cards into that exact order are 1 in 8×10^67? There have only been 4×10^17 seconds since the Big Bang, meaning that in order for a deck to randomly be arranged in that specific order you would have had to shuffle the deck 2×10^50 times every second since the Big Bang till now. That's 200,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000,000...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 21 22 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Signature in the Cell: DNA and the Evidence for Intelligent Design
  • The Politically Incorrect Guide to Darwinism  And Intelligent Design
  • Darwin on Trial
  • Intelligent Design: The Bridge Between Science & Theology
  • Miss Leavitt's Stars: The Untold Story of the Woman Who Discovered How to Measure the Universe
  • The Devil's Delusion: Atheism and Its Scientific Pretensions
  • The New Pearl Harbor: Disturbing Questions About the Bush Administration & 9/11
  • Scaling the Secular City: A Defense of Christianity
  • The Recursive Universe: Cosmic Complexity and the Limits of Scientific Knowledge
  • A Life Decoded: My Genome: My Life
  • The Creator and the Cosmos: How the Greatest Scientific Discoveries of the Century Reveal God
  • Not Even Wrong: The Failure of String Theory and the Search for Unity in Physical Law
  • Christian Apologetics
  • The Conscious Universe: The Scientific Truth of Psychic Phenomena
  • Where the Conflict Really Lies: Science, Religion, and Naturalism
  • The Truth About Muhammad: Founder of the World's Most Intolerant Religion
  • Mind and Cosmos: Why the Materialist Neo-Darwinian Conception of Nature Is Almost Certainly False
  • Jesus Under Fire: Modern Scholarship Reinvents the Historical Jesus
27523
Michael J. Behe is Professor of Biological Sciences at Lehigh University in Pennsylvania. He received his Ph.D. in Biochemistry from the University of Pennsylvania in 1978. Behe's current research involves delineation of design and natural selection in protein structures.

In addition to publishing over 35 articles in refereed biochemical journals, he has also written editorial features in Boston R...more
More about Michael J. Behe...
Darwin's Black Box: The Biochemical Challenge to Evolution Science and Evidence for Design in the Universe Experimental Evolution: Loss-of-Function Mutations, and "the First Rule of Adaptive Evolution" Intelligent Design: The Bridge Between Science & Theology Darwinism Under The Microscope: How recent scientific evidence points to divine design

Share This Book

“Real arms races are run by highly intelligent, bespectacled engineers in glass offices thoughtfully designing shiny weapons on modern computers. But there's no thinking in the mud and cold of nature's trenches. At best, weapons thrown together amidst the explosions and confusion of smoky battlefields are tiny variations on old ones, held together by chewing gum. If they don't work, then something else is thrown at the enemy, including the kitchen sink - there's nothing "progressive" about that. At its usual worst, trench warfare is fought by attrition. If the enemy can be stopped or slowed by burning your own bridges and bombing your own radio towers and oil refineries, then away they go. Darwinian trench warfare does not lead to progress - it leads back to the Stone Age.” 6 likes
“Is the conclusion that the universe was designed - and that the design extends deeply into life - science, philosophy, religion, or what? In a sense it hardly matters. By far the most important question is not what category we place it in, but whether a conclusion is true. A true philosophical or religious conclusion is no less true than a true scientific one. Although universities might divide their faculty and courses into academic categories, reality is not obliged to respect such boundaries.” 5 likes
More quotes…