50th out of 319 books
—
506 voters
Mystery and Manners: Occasional Prose
At her death in 1964, O'Connor left behind a body of unpublished essays and lectures as well as a number of critical articles that had appeared in scattered publications during her too-short lifetime. The keen writings comprising Mystery and Manners, selected and edited by O'Connor's lifelong friends Sally and Robert Fitzgerald, are characterized by the directness and simp...more
Paperback, 237 pages
Published
1970
by Farrar, Straus and Giroux
(first published 1969)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,667)
Oct 24, 2012
Richard
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommended to Richard by:
Mark
This book of essays gives us some of Flannery O'Connor's thoughts about what it was like for her to be a Catholic writer in the American South. Her writing shows the personality of someone who is confident of her own experience and ability, and yet (at least most of the time) quite humble about it too.
O'Connor writes with wit (ranging from wry humour to sarcasm) about the incomprehension or disapproval with which her short stories and novels were met by many contemporary readers. She stresses t...more
O'Connor writes with wit (ranging from wry humour to sarcasm) about the incomprehension or disapproval with which her short stories and novels were met by many contemporary readers. She stresses t...more
Ms. O'Connor sometimes seems to me like a didactic pedantic generalizer, but in general I like her. Flat-out loved the opening peacock essay and wish there were more slice of essayistic life in here to complement the must-read/essential essays that reveal her as a literary fundamentalist, albeit one whose ideation be animated by denominational spirits, a religiousity that's maybe her strength and weakness in this collection, as in the story collection I read earlier this year (A Good Man Is Hard...more
The first few sections in this are really killer. O'Connor has this down to earth, conversational way of talking about fiction and how it works. Her voice comes through in a lot of these pieces just as strongly as it does in her fiction. And what's more, she compellingly offers an idea of why fiction (or at least good fiction), with its willingness to present us with the profundities of human action instead of cheap, sentimental, reductive crap, is an essential form of expression. Unfortunately,...more
In reading Flannery O’Connor’s Mystery and Manners, I was inspired and found so many things relevant to my situation as a writer and teacher. I will respond to her book in two parts, first from the standpoint of a teacher and second from that of a fiction writer.
One of the tips that may be useful in teaching creative writing is her insistence that fiction must, before all else, be concrete and appeal to the senses. One of my students likes to write abstractly because, he says, it will allow diff...more
One of the tips that may be useful in teaching creative writing is her insistence that fiction must, before all else, be concrete and appeal to the senses. One of my students likes to write abstractly because, he says, it will allow diff...more
One of the most startling things about this posthumous collection of lectures and essays is to realize just how young Flannery O'Conner was when she died. Before age 39 she possessed more brazen confidence and piercing understanding of literary craft than I ever hope to achieve. Plus, her writing is full of style and personality, wit and a no-nonsense attitude.
If I tried to sum up O'Conner's take on how to write well, it might go like this: soak yourself in the "manners"--the daily actions, cust...more
If I tried to sum up O'Conner's take on how to write well, it might go like this: soak yourself in the "manners"--the daily actions, cust...more
O'Connor averred that she wrote as she did because she was Catholic, and that, as a Catholic, she couldn't write any other way. She may have most readily identified herself as a Catholic, but this collection is proof positive that she was first and foremost a writer. As a critic, she was an apostle of Henry James, deeply unsentimental (indeed, a hilariously unapologetic misopedist), an enemy of excess, a believer in humility ("the first product of self-knowledge"), and, above all, gloriously quo...more
Hmmm...there were parts that I 'really liked' but some other parts not so much, hence the 3 rating. Egocentrism? Not sure if it applies in the full sense of the word, but there is some sense of arrogance here? I have some issues with 'The Catholic Novelist in the Protestant South'...the word Christian being 'no longer reliable' when she is differentiating Catholic literature-ish. And then this little passage (speaking about writing from a Catholic point of view within the context of American geo...more
I'm always leery of posthumous collections of writing, especially when they're described as "uncollected occasional prose." This particular book contains a mish-mash of speeches, student workshop presentations, odd ruminations on Catholic fiction writers and their readers, and the standout essay at the beginning, "The King of the Birds." I would've been happy if I'd stopped after that one. But instead I plodded on, skipping over quite a bit, hoping for another winner that never came. O'Connor do...more
With this collection of essays O'conner solidified my belief in the concrete. For both of us there is no such thing as writing a story so as to communicate some kind of philosophy--especially for the novice. There is only writing a story which by virtue of its having an author has a philosophy. If ideas are going to be communicated, they are going to be through the concrete. Ahab has his whale, Raskolnikov his ax, but to tell a story abstract object first is to fail to tell a story at all. Volta...more
How is it I've lived almost four decades and haven't read this book yet? I've always loved O'Connor's short fiction and recognized her genius, but these collected essays--all written (or, in the case of speeches, delivered) when she was younger than I am now--simply thrilled me with their insight, humor, and piercing vision. The last few sections of the book that focused on writing as a Catholic were particularly valuable: I saw so many parallels between the Catholic writing community, as well a...more
We should never be lured into the trap of accepting ONLY what an author has to say about the interpretation of her work. At the same time, we should pay special attention to such commentary as it reveals as much about the writer as it does about the art. As an orthodox Roman Catholic living in the South, O'Connor has much to tell us in this collection of essays about displacement, isolation, discipline, faith, craftsmanship, and the vocation of writing. Some of the most memorable quotes from O'C...more
More like 3.5 than a 3. She has some great insights into the nature and mystery of fiction writing, however, two aspects of these essays bother me:
1) Her focus on Southern fiction writing is so specific, those who are neither from the South nor interested in Southern fiction will probably find those essays unhelpful.
2) By the last essay, redundancy sets in and all the sagacity of the first several essays is merely regurgitated with a new subject in later essays.
Overall, a good book for writers i...more
1) Her focus on Southern fiction writing is so specific, those who are neither from the South nor interested in Southern fiction will probably find those essays unhelpful.
2) By the last essay, redundancy sets in and all the sagacity of the first several essays is merely regurgitated with a new subject in later essays.
Overall, a good book for writers i...more
Her specific commentary on Catholicism (as distinct from a more general anti-secularism which she absolutely nails) is generally the weakest part for me, but her sharp eye on writing, education, human nature, and both the South and the nation in general shouldn't be overlooked. There is a reason her stories have such depth; behind them lies a woman who is thoughtful, intelligent, confident, critical, and above all, a great believer in the mystery of existence. If that doesn't reach a reader of h...more
An excellent volume for anyone wanting to understand how O'Connor approaches writing, art, and religion. The essays are also plain fun to read. She has a great wit and writes without any pretense. It is so refreshing to encounter such intelligence devoid of jargon or arrogance.
"The Fiction Writer and His Country" and "Some Aspects of the Grotesque in Southern Fiction" are especially good.
Despite not being Catholic myself, I have great sympathy for a number of her views, including the presence of...more
"The Fiction Writer and His Country" and "Some Aspects of the Grotesque in Southern Fiction" are especially good.
Despite not being Catholic myself, I have great sympathy for a number of her views, including the presence of...more
O'Connor says, "I have found, in short, from reading my own writing, that my subject in fiction is the action of grace in territory held largely by the devil. I have also found that what I write is read by an audience which puts little stock in either grace or the devil." (118)
These lectures and essays allow us to hear her voice and her heart.
I think "Total Effect and the Eighth Grade" is brilliant. I would love to use it as a springboard for discussion among educations from various contexts -...more
These lectures and essays allow us to hear her voice and her heart.
I think "Total Effect and the Eighth Grade" is brilliant. I would love to use it as a springboard for discussion among educations from various contexts -...more
This is a must read for all those who want to be able to fully understand O'Connor's short stories. After reading this book, I have no doubt that Flannery O'Connnor is not only and amazing writer, but one who truly understands sin and redemption.
A few of my favorite quotes:
"I have heard it said that belief in Christian dogma is a hindrance to the writer, but I myself have found nothing further from the truth. Actually, it frees the storyteller to observe. It is not a set of rules which fixes wh...more
A few of my favorite quotes:
"I have heard it said that belief in Christian dogma is a hindrance to the writer, but I myself have found nothing further from the truth. Actually, it frees the storyteller to observe. It is not a set of rules which fixes wh...more
If you’ve hung around forums and websites for Christian fiction writers, you’ve no doubt bumped into a recurring set of discussions:
What are a faith-based writer’s obligations before God?
How theologically-correct does a story have to be? How evangelistic?
How realistic can the depictions of a fallen world and unsaved characters be?
Where exactly is the line for profanity? violence? pornography?
When does it slip into being gratuitous and become a stumbling block?
Vital questions to be sure, and ones...more
What are a faith-based writer’s obligations before God?
How theologically-correct does a story have to be? How evangelistic?
How realistic can the depictions of a fallen world and unsaved characters be?
Where exactly is the line for profanity? violence? pornography?
When does it slip into being gratuitous and become a stumbling block?
Vital questions to be sure, and ones...more

I cannot recommend this book highly enough. If I had the financial means to put this on every reader's bookshelf I would. So I will do my best with literary means- words. Here are the first seven reasons for reading this book that came to mind.
1. You will return to (or arrive at for the first time, in which case you're in for a powerful and wonderful ride) her short stories with a deeper appreciation.
[Full disclosure: when I first picked up O'Connor's fiction I could not see why so many people...more
I'm kicking myself for not reading MYSTERY AND MANNERS years ago. Flannery O'Connor is a fiction writer, I told myself; what could she teach me about spiritual memoir writing? And yet some of these are the best essays I've ever read about addressing the spiritual life in prose.
If a writer is any good, what he makes will have its source in a realm much larger than that which his conscious mind can encompass and will always be a greater surprise to him than it can ever be to his reader.
--Flanner...more
If a writer is any good, what he makes will have its source in a realm much larger than that which his conscious mind can encompass and will always be a greater surprise to him than it can ever be to his reader.
--Flanner...more
Nov 03, 2009
Cassy
rated it
3 of 5 stars
Recommended to Cassy by:
Creative Writing Professor R. Liddell
This is a collection of essays and speeches complied after O’Connor’s death. It is divided into six parts. I thought I’d organize my review accordingly.
I. A Short Story – very entertaining. I am glad the editors included this story among all the essays. I had never read any of her short stories or novels. This established my respect for her talent.
II. Southern Literature – fairly interesting, although maybe obsolete. I had not really realized that there was such a genre, which is pretty sad sinc...more
I. A Short Story – very entertaining. I am glad the editors included this story among all the essays. I had never read any of her short stories or novels. This established my respect for her talent.
II. Southern Literature – fairly interesting, although maybe obsolete. I had not really realized that there was such a genre, which is pretty sad sinc...more
Who knew an isolated lupus-suffering hyper-religious Catholic in the smack middle of Georgia could be so hot damn funny!
Seriously, a victory.
I think what makes Flannery O'Connor's aesthetic so brilliant is its combination of two themes: what she calls the "violent" and the "comic." Her literature, like her essays, is both funny and deeply, unabashedly brutal. For O'Connor writing, like reading, isn't a science or an exercise in sentimentality. We don't -and shouldn't- read for enjoyment. We read...more
Seriously, a victory.
I think what makes Flannery O'Connor's aesthetic so brilliant is its combination of two themes: what she calls the "violent" and the "comic." Her literature, like her essays, is both funny and deeply, unabashedly brutal. For O'Connor writing, like reading, isn't a science or an exercise in sentimentality. We don't -and shouldn't- read for enjoyment. We read...more
So much great advice in these essays, and O'Connor is so quotable. Much easier to quote than to emulate. On this reading I took the time to read the four essays—which I'd previously skipped—relating to the writer and religion and was surprised to find embedded in there some otherwise sound advice that even a non-catholic writer could put to use. For the most part, though, those four essays seemed to be aimed at critics of her religious bent, or at writers such as Sartre and Camus, as in this bit...more
This is an excellent book about fiction, why (in one practitioner's opinion) to write it, read it, and value it. Flannery O'Connor has a matter-of-fact approach to big topics like the philosophy of art, and suffers neither fools nor mediocrity. This collection of her lectures and essays is so pithy that I was often moved to jot down quotes for later use. Some of these follow my review.
The last part of the volume, which concerns being a Catholic writer, writing the Catholic novel, et cetera, is o...more
The last part of the volume, which concerns being a Catholic writer, writing the Catholic novel, et cetera, is o...more
Indispensable. Flannery O'Connor's post-humously collected essays and discussions on Southern writers, the Catholic writer, and her own work has taught me more about writing than all the craft books I've read of late. Her candid attitude toward theory and meaning, namely, that if the writer has direction, has motive, the meaning will reveal itself in the story with no need for theory (or academia).
For lovers of O'Connor's work, this collection sheds much light on where the writer was coming fro...more
For lovers of O'Connor's work, this collection sheds much light on where the writer was coming fro...more
I love Flannery O'Connor's fiction, so when I discovered I still hadn't read this book six years after I bought it for a class as "supplementary material", I got excited.
Turns out I should have only been partly excited. O'Connor is predictably opinionated about all the topics within this book. For the most part, that wasn't a problem for me. I like her no-false-modesty stance on why she wrote ("because I'm good at it"); I like her annoyance at the idea that writing can be taught ("if it's not na...more
Turns out I should have only been partly excited. O'Connor is predictably opinionated about all the topics within this book. For the most part, that wasn't a problem for me. I like her no-false-modesty stance on why she wrote ("because I'm good at it"); I like her annoyance at the idea that writing can be taught ("if it's not na...more
I have long been a fan of Flannery O'Connor's fiction but I had not read her non-fiction or essays until two months ago. She may have died over 40 years ago, but her take on the writing scene and the nature of writing is accurate--it as though she wrote it recently. As a former Catholic, I do understand her religious and spiritual references. If those give pause to some readers, I would still recommend the book for its clear-eyed, non-sentimental look at the education in America and why the work...more
For the kids:
Most of us have learned to be dispassionate about evil, to look it in the face and find, as often as not, our own grinning reflections with which we do not argue, but good is another matter. Few have stared at that long enough to accept the fact that its face too is grotesque, that in us the good is something under construction. The modes of good have to be satisfied with a cliche or a smoothing-down that will soften their real look.
I love this book. It's Flannery O'Connor at her best, her nonfiction best, that is: wry, funny, and razor sharp. I can't believe she died when she was 39; or, more specifically, I can't believe she could write all she did, know all she did and live it all before age 40. Remarkable. God had a hold on her.
This book is a collection of O'Connor's speeches, some excerpts from letters and essays she wrote. She's relentless in her commentary/critique of bad--sentimental--art and laziness. And she's exh...more
This book is a collection of O'Connor's speeches, some excerpts from letters and essays she wrote. She's relentless in her commentary/critique of bad--sentimental--art and laziness. And she's exh...more
2/27 - I actually finished this Wednesday but I've been busy since then (thankfully).
The essays in the middle are the best, while I did enjoy the last few cuz of my recent interest in Catholocism, I'm sot sure if they say anything not already better-said in the previous ones. The beginnings one were sorta whatever to me, I should re-read her stuff that I am (think I am?) a Real Reader
2/20 - she's pretty cranky! i like it!!!
2/18 - I skimmed/skipped most of the "southern writer/fiction" stuff at t...more
The essays in the middle are the best, while I did enjoy the last few cuz of my recent interest in Catholocism, I'm sot sure if they say anything not already better-said in the previous ones. The beginnings one were sorta whatever to me, I should re-read her stuff that I am (think I am?) a Real Reader
2/20 - she's pretty cranky! i like it!!!
2/18 - I skimmed/skipped most of the "southern writer/fiction" stuff at t...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Book Talk: Mystery and Manners | 2 | 4 | Jul 09, 2012 07:16am |
Mary Flannery O'Connor was an American novelist, short-story writer and essayist. O'Connor's writing often reflected her own Roman Catholic faith, and frequently examined questions of morality and ethics.
Her The Complete Stories received the 1972 National Book Award for Fiction. In a 2009 online poll conducted by the National Book Foundation, the collection was named the best work to have won the...more
More about Flannery O'Connor...
Her The Complete Stories received the 1972 National Book Award for Fiction. In a 2009 online poll conducted by the National Book Foundation, the collection was named the best work to have won the...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“Art never responds to the wish to make it democratic; it is not for everybody; it is only for those who are willing to undergo the effort needed to understand it.”
—
369 people liked it
“Anybody who has survived his childhood has enough information about life to last him the rest of his days.”
—
330 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...

































updated Oct 30, 2012 12:01am
Oct 29, 2012 11:14pm