Murder at Monticello (Mrs. Murphy, #3)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Murder at Monticello (Mrs. Murphy #3)

3.84 of 5 stars 3.84  ·  rating details  ·  2,568 ratings  ·  77 reviews
Mrs. Murphy digs into Virginia history—and gets her paws on a killer.

The most popular citizen of Virginia has been dead for nearly 170 years. That hasn't stopped the good people of tiny Crozet, Virginia, from taking pride in every aspect of Thomas Jefferson's life. But when an archaeological dig of the slave quarters at Jefferson's home, Monticello, uncovers a shocking sec...more
ebook, 0 pages
Published March 30th 2004 by Crimeline (first published 1994)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
!?! Tacitly apologizing for slavery (paraphrasing: "today the races are so far apart, but under Jefferson they were so close!")? Defending Jefferson's ever-so-tender slave-owning practices? Suggesting that the Hemings women were promiscuous? What was Brown smoking when she wrote this?

Rita Mae, I'd suggest that the reason the races were so "close" during slavery was that one was beaten to death if it didn't do what the other insisted. Sexual acts included.
Murder at Monticello is not a favorite of mine in the Mrs. Murphy series. In fact so far it's my least favorite. I pick up this series when I need light, easy reading and simple, enjoyable characters. So I was disappointed that this story didn't feature the characters (human and animals) as strongly as the previous two books. It was very much focused on the mystery, which wouldn't have been so bad if it wasn't so confusing. If you're particularly knowledgeable/interested in American History and...more
They say you can't judge a book by its cover, but let's face it...we all do it. Sometimes we are disappointed, sometimes we are pleasantly surprised.

This is case of "pleasantly surprised." I knew there would be talking animals, but that didn't faze me. Anyone who has a cat or a dog has long realized that their intelligence is great, although very different from that of human beings. The real surprise was the depth of the human characters in this book. Brown magnificently creates a cast of charac...more
The Harry and friends are investigating a murder that occurred in the 1800s at Monticello, Thomas Jefferson's home. Archaeology of the slave housing is occurring and a body is found under the foundations. The cold case is well written and interesting and how relates to present. Mrs Murphy, Tucker and Pewtor are secondary characters to the main plot.
Enjoyable mystery with Mary "Harry" Haristeen and her pet companions, Mrs. Murphy and Mrs. Tucker. This one begins with the discovery of hidden skeletal remains in a slave cabin at Monticello that seem to indicate a murder from the early 1800s, but the story moves steadily to a current murder with a twisted array of motives that work themselves out one by one. I liked the main characters, the central Virginia small town setting, the talking pets, and the mystery itself with its ties to the colon...more
Other than hope that this series will improve I don’t know why I keep reading. Every book is the same, the human characters are slow and the animals save the day. Really? At no time in Crozet, Virginia can you find a smart human?

I have never read these books in order, but then again, I don’t think that it is a requirement. The characters stay the same, the animals stay the same, only small portions of the locale seem to differentiate the books.

This time the reader is taken to Thomas Jefferson’s...more
On the upside, this book is very easy to read, and I did make it all the way to the end.

However, it was so difficult to get into. First of all, the character names are utterly ridiculous. Who can take characters seriously when they have names like Nick Nichols and Market Shiftlet? Who names a cat Mr. or Mrs. anything? Additionally, the characters' personalities were about as appealing as their names. Mary "Harry" Minor Haristeen is the typical feminist cookie cutter woman, who doesn't need a man...more
Jul 14, 2013 Ferne rated it 2 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Anyone interested in genealogy.
I am appreciative of American history and the study of genealogy and that combined appreciation is the only reason I continued to read this book. If asked about my favorite parts of this book, I would have to applaud and point out the beautiful illustrations by Wendy Wray and hope the individual that asked the question really listened that I mentioned not a word about the writing. Perhaps my expectations were too high following so many delightful reads about the characters of thoughtful Jim Qwil...more
My second disappointing book in a row! What a bummer. I liked learning a little bit about Monticello and Thomas Jefferson, but the book was a little too focused on it. I read this series for the personal danger that faces the citizens of Crozet and how they come together to deal with it, and a mystery from 1803 didn’t do it for me. You do get that sense of danger eventually, but it’s past the halfway point of the book. And while I don’t normally mind the commentary offered by Mrs. Murphy, Tucker...more
i LOVE this series!!! it has talking cats, but it's still GOOD WRITING!! i think this is the 1st book in the series that i read and i was HOOKED after that. i LOVE the characters. it takes place in the South, which i seem attracted to (mostly) and the author frequently interjects a bit of history of the south, which i find interesting.
who would have ever thought?!! i hated history as a student. but if history were presented in schools in the form of a STORY rather than textbook reading and memor...more
Paul Lunger
From 1994 comes an installment in this series that's part historical fact & part historical fiction. The primary mystery involves the discovery of a skeleton beneath the hearth during an excavation at Monticello. From this point onward our cast of characters embark on a quest to uncover exactly what is behind this mystery from 1803. There's also a secondary murder that involves a jilted lover that almost feels like a bit of filler if only to add an element to what isn't entirely a bad plot b...more
Murder at the Monticello was a fun, exciting, and quick read. This book is not the first that I had read from Brown in her Mrs. Murphy series, but it has been a while since I had read one. Harry is the perfect leading character along with her animal friends, Mrs. Murphy and Tucker, and all three do a great job in detecting the truth about the book's mystery. I like how Brown includes some great secondary characters both human and animal (showing the family like network of both groups) that add t...more
Ryan Mishap
I don't remember which one was first.

At first, I liked these silly little mysteries set in the South of the U.S.--genteel Southerners in a quirky little town who love their horses and whatnot. Oh, and two cats and a dog are thinking, acting characters. Since I like the fantasy, I'm not embarrassed to read such trifles and the first few mysteries are fun.
As they go on, though, there is a sort of sympathy to the conservative, Southern view that reveres oppressive or malign traditions of their p...more
May 05, 2009 Samantha rated it 2 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Samantha by: Judy Ward!
Okay. I love the Mrs. Murphy murder mystery series, but this one was a little...dry. Perhaps it was the subject matter or maybe it was the 'walk-on' characters, but this installment was just 'okay.' A murdered, centuries-old skeleton is uncovered at an archeological dig at Monticello and, as would be expected, Harry, Mrs. Murphy and Tee Tucker jump right into the thick of things to save the day and, as usual, things get a little hairy! (HA! Hairy. Harry. Cats. Dogs. Get it!? It's lost sleep...ig...more
I listened to this book at bed time, and I had a hard time getting into it. The author threw in a lot of historical facts, and the cats kept breaking in with comments, which bothered me to hear their voices in the story. This wasn't a favorite read.
What a great mystery within a mystery! I loved the historical backstory in this one.
I don't think I'd really like these that much now, but I happened to have them thrust upon me by a shut-in neighbor lady as a thank-you for bringing her groceries. My tastes have obviously changed since 8th grade but at the time I was really into the Mary Higgins Clark/mystery genre so I read em' because I liked to read (side note, she had a TON of "smut novels" which I have to admit I realllly wanted to read as well back then). Long story short, this lady willed me this series of books after sh...more
Pretty basic Rita Mae Brown. Main character lives near Monticello. Archeologist discovers a dead body buried in the slave quarters. Which of course leads to revelations about present-day people, enough that someone will commit some murders when the wrong people find out too much. Moves along, with a couple of good red herrings. All in all, a good mystery. There's also the lives of the pets of the main character, who try to help out. This wasn't as central as in other books of hers I've read, and...more
Finding RMB's interspecies mysteries virtually everywhere I went in Vienna, I was very curious not about this book specifically, but about the writing in general. Sadly, the cover of my 1990s edition is the best thing about Murder in Monticello. For a crime story, the events unfold painfully slowly. Add to it dealings in conservative gender and power roles, a totally weird understanding of how to be critically white, and some sloppy dialogue. Still haven't given up on reading Rubyfruit Jungle on...more
Perfect timing for me - all about genealogy, just when I'm starting my own research (just a lucky library pick at the time). A 200-yr-old corpse of a wealthy white man is found buried at the site of an old slave cabin at Thomas Jefferson's estate, Monticello. Uncovering the story turns out to be dangerous for a few Crozet citizens. The past comes back to haunt the present. I thoroughly enjoyed the history with this one. (See description for "Claws and Effect" for more info on the series.)
Lynn Pribus
A dear friend -- now gone -- gave me this book when I moved to Charlottesville about 2 miles from Monticello. It is, she told me, set in the fictitious town of CROZit. Ah, says, I. It's an actual town and it's called Crow-ZAY. My granddaughter-in-law teaches in Crozet.

I'm not much for talking cats. In truth, I'm not even much for non-talking cats. But having been to Monticello and written about it as recently as this month, it was fun to read.

Thanks, Margrette, wherever you are...
I'm on page 180 of 284 of Murder at Monticello: More than halfway though and not enjoying the story much yet --not a good sign. The book is broken up into short chapters, each focused on a different set of townspeople, of which there are many. Too many. The abrupt shifts make the narrative choppy, giving you nothing to grab onto. The animals' musings are random and un-enlightening, too --a particular bummer for me.

This is probably the first and last book of this series for me.
I liked this book even better than book 2 in the series! The flow is improved and the author has better depth of characters. The story is woven around an archeological find at the home of Thomas Jefferson. The find reveals a 200+ year old murder and opens up a racial stir that brings the characters to emotional and personal conflicts. The story is filled with twists and hard to put down for very long.
Hard to follow at parts, but I also was reading it at a time when focusing wasn't one of my better skills. Considering it delves into bloodlines a few hundred years old and involving many people sharing names, confusion isn't surprising, and in fact was noted in the book. I love this series, and if it weren't for all the people getting murdered, I'd want to live in this town.
Margo Brooks
This is the first book in this series I've read. I found the talking animals somewhat annoying, although I got used to them. I did, however, find the mystery, which revolves around a hidden skeleton found during archeological excavations at Montecello, quite interesting. The 200 year old mystery was deftly tied into a modern secret that leads to more murders..
Nichole Rottinghaus
I liked the mystery, but I had a hard time keeping the characters straight. I've noticed that Rita Mae Brown likes to use characters with similar sounding names a lot - I've learned to deal with it, but when she added the historical Jefferson family and their descendents to this one, I really got confused.
Those who read cozies and feel the need to pick them apart need to lighten up. It would be like choosing to read Dickens then complaining nonstop about him being wordy.
I enjoyed this because of the characters and setting...but Im not sure I buy Thomas Jefferson's squeaky cleanness portrayed in this book.
Murder at Monticello, by Rita Mae Brown
The murder in question happened during slave times, but then there’s also a current murder and Sneaky Pie Brown (a lovely intelligent cat) and her pet Harry Haristeen, headmistress of the little post office do their usual sleuthing.
I am a native Virginian, so I found the historic part of this book very interesting. Some of the descriptions of Monticello are out-of-date, but that is to be expected. I can see how the history might be too much for some readers, it did tend to overcome the story line.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Cat Who Saw Stars (Cat Who... #21)
  • Pussyfoot (Midnight Louie, #2)
Rita Mae Brown is a prolific American writer, most known for her mysteries and other novels (Rubyfruit Jungle). She is also an Emmy-nominated screenwriter.
More about Rita Mae Brown...
Rubyfruit Jungle Wish You Were Here (Mrs. Murphy, #1) Murder, She Meowed (Mrs. Murphy #5) Rest in Pieces (Mrs. Murphy #2) Pay Dirt (Mrs. Murphy, #4)

Share This Book