Experience and Education
by
John Dewey
Experience and Education is the best concise statement on education ever published by John Dewey, the man acknowledged to be the pre-eminent educational theorist of the twentieth century. Written more than two decades after Democracy and Education (Dewey's most comprehensive statement of his position in educational philosophy), this book demonstrates how Dewey reformulated...more
Paperback, 91 pages
Published
November 1st 2007
by Touchstone (Simon & Schuster) New York
(first published 1938)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,679)
It is highly curious that outside the arena of teaching the process of education itself remains very much misunderstood. In fact until you actually enter into the process of teaching - education seems very much like an act of guiding others with your bountiful knowledge. Of course very few realise that teaching is as much about learning as it is about passing knowledge. And that education also extends far beyond merely providing knowledge. It is however highly important that educators properly u...more
Many of the world's greatest authors have weighed in on the subject of how children should be taught. The Greeks' main educational theorist was none other than Plato, who wrote with great clarity and precision (although some of his ideas, like getting rid of the poets, were preposterous). The Romans had Quintilian, whose massive treatise, "The Orator's Education," is elegantly written and chock full of sensible educational principles. Two thousand years later in the United States of America, we...more
I'm not found of theoretical reading - call it a side-effect of working on a doctorate while working full-time and cramming 500 - 1000 pages of reading into a two day period. So it was no surprise that I wasn't excited to pick up Dewey, but I needed to do because I have a proposal to write. I know Dewey. At least I think I know Dewey. As a traditionally-trained teacher, I first learned about Dewey 20+ years ago as an undergraduate. I know how others (professors and researchers) have interpreted...more
There is much more to this little book than many young, aspiring teachers realize. John Dewey had some great ideas and most were discussed in the first several chapters of the book in very vague terms. On the surface, they seem fine and good. But in chapter 7, Progressive Organization of Subject Matter, the pragmatic, materialist philosophy behind his educational ideas is explained more clearly. It is very alarming to those of us who still believe that unchangeable truth exists-that some things...more
This book, originally written in 1938 has some important things to say. That children are not built to sit for hours and listen to lectures, but rather to be in motion. That experience is a more effective teacher than rote learning. That ignoring the voice of the student in education is to disconnect from the process by which she will learn. I think Dewey is right on many fronts, including the idea that a thoroughly planned and skillfully executed experimentally based education is more effective...more
Oct 01, 2009
Mike Jensen
added it
The speeches printed here (published in 1938) were given at a controversial time in education theory, as traditional education was in tension with experimental progressive approaches. Dewy, a champion of progressive education, tries to find a synthesis for the best education possible, which he says begins with and must always include experience. Education experience is explored in myriad ways, and education for knowledge that may be useful in adulthood is examined. Dewy concludes that science a...more
This concise, incredibly dense volume on Dewey's philosophy of education is as relevant today as it was when it was published in 1938. Dewey argues that students need rich experiences to learn, and encourages a cooperative learning environment that teaches studenst not only content, but also the skills to function as citizens in a democratic society. Remarkably, Dewey's theory experiential education, which he developed through observation, has been since proven to be completely aligned with the...more
Another course requirement. The rating is a minus for readability - the philosophy is excellent, but hard to get to. I found rereading the first chapters after studying chapters 4-8 to be a better way of grasping the book. The latter chapters are more concrete than the former, as admitted by the author. This book highlights the issues with the Progressive Education movement at the time, but certainly has implications for any educational reforms, and also states views on education that are still...more
even 74 years after its first edition, this book is really interesting. Dewey's philosophy of experience for education shares many views with the so-called "new ideas" of this century. the action-centered approach put forward by the european commission's CECR is directly influenced by Dewey's ideas and by the english TBLT.
i also really appreciated the clear statement of the author about not being opposed to the traditional method. Building a new education system or philosophy by simply being in...more
i also really appreciated the clear statement of the author about not being opposed to the traditional method. Building a new education system or philosophy by simply being in...more
(7/10) Dewey is kind of the grandfather of the radical education movement, and being someone who never met a freeschool he didn't like I thought it would be worth checking him out. As it happens, this book seems like almost a conscious attempt to move away from that radicalism and towards a kind of centrism, attacking both traditional education and radical pedagogy. There's some interesting stuff in here about experience as the centre of education, and I think that's a really valuable idea, alth...more
Experience and Education is John Dewey's attempt to clarify the criteria and conditions for a philosophy of education which elevates experience as the primary form of learning.
In Experience and Education, Dewey continually stresses the importance of not fleshing out the progressive philosophy of education in reaction against the traditional. He argues that an educational philosophy needs to build upon itself and its own ideas and not just be a negative of the philosophy which came before. In thi...more
In Experience and Education, Dewey continually stresses the importance of not fleshing out the progressive philosophy of education in reaction against the traditional. He argues that an educational philosophy needs to build upon itself and its own ideas and not just be a negative of the philosophy which came before. In thi...more
With theory, it's all about definitions. Even in less than a 100 pages, Dewey finds a way to muddle some of his together which damages the clarity of his theories. And there are two egregious typos on the summary on the back of the book... where was the editor!!??
That being said, this is an excellent argument for experiential education that is bold and unflinching, and a wonderful distillation of many of Dewey's ideas. And covering as much ground as he does in less than a 100 pages is also a rem...more
That being said, this is an excellent argument for experiential education that is bold and unflinching, and a wonderful distillation of many of Dewey's ideas. And covering as much ground as he does in less than a 100 pages is also a rem...more
Smart and sensible. Maybe even timeless (we'll see in a century or so).
Good reminder for learners and teachers that their respective roles are, ideally, complementary and overlapping; that public education is essentially a social process serving social purposes; and that new knowledge is useful only if it speaks meaningfully to past experience and lays groundwork for a richer series of future experiences.
Pithiness is both this book's strength and its weakness -- strength because it imparts its...more
Good reminder for learners and teachers that their respective roles are, ideally, complementary and overlapping; that public education is essentially a social process serving social purposes; and that new knowledge is useful only if it speaks meaningfully to past experience and lays groundwork for a richer series of future experiences.
Pithiness is both this book's strength and its weakness -- strength because it imparts its...more
Dewey argues that too often, young people have a miseducative experience, which prevents them from becoming mature learners. To solve this problem, he establishes a pragmatic middle ground, between the two educational extremes of authoriative instruction and aimless exploration. A truly educational experience must breed maturity, or the ability to utilizes continutity to discriminate between educational experiences and choose certain stimuli, over other stimuli, and make choices on where to go n...more
In this short book, John Dewey presents his theory of education, a theory based on the belief that "all genuine education comes about through experience." In doing this, he argues that we should move away from the traditional model, one that views education more as a formation of an individual from external sources, and proceed towards one where the individual is developed from within his or herself.
To support his view on education, Dewey systematically puts forth a theory of experience, laying...more
To support his view on education, Dewey systematically puts forth a theory of experience, laying...more
John Dewey is an exceptional educational theorist, and his input on 'traditional' versus 'progressive' schools is a must-read for anyone interested in the field, as well as for everyone who has been through the education system. Dewey does a good job of de-constructing the labels around the education debate and getting to the root philosophy of traditional and experiential ways of learning. In his opinion both fail at creating the best product possible, since neither focuses on the underlying ph...more
Oh, John Dewey - I wanted you to just spit it out, and just say what you had to say, rather than saying what you were thinking about maybe theorizing about saying. Dewey has a very interesting (although slightly frightening) idea about using education to change society from the ground up, but because this is all about his theories, there's very little that's concrete to latch onto. Interesting, but not overly so.
Yet another bible of logical thinking on education by the late Mr Dewey. Refreshing, even when read nearly a century on, is his comparison of 'traditional' and 'progressive' notions of education. He does not oppose one over the other, but instead finds validity in elements of both approaches. A must read for anyone interested in the problematic nature of being an educator.
Im giving this 5 stars because he managed to state his positions in 91 pages! I loved the concise page length of the book. PLUS, as I read this book I realized that his concepts have been rebranded, and reformatted again and again by other educational writers that came later. So again, I'm giving 5 stars to this book, because it really started the progressive framework. Its worth a read.
This is my favorite of all Dewey's books. He wrote it in an attempt to correct many misinterpretations of his work and writing. The "bad" progressive practices being done in his name are part of the legacy I feel like I still fight against as an educator. It's not an easy text (although compared to some of his others it is) but it is very clear and very good.
This was an unbelievably clear piece that matched with every one of my beliefs about education, including the pitfalls of progressive education. It is remarkable that this was written in the '30s. Our children would be much better served if we heeded his advice. I'm glad I waited until I had taught a few years to read his. What a great read to start my summer.
At less than a hundred pages, this is more of a pamphlet than a book. Apparently, many people find it difficult to read and assimilate, but I didn't have that issue. I will grant that it was written in the 1930s, so that could be an issue for some as far as the style of writing. I didn't find it overly difficult, but I did find it intriguing. Dewey has a lot to say about progressive school reform (he was known for it), and this is one of the things he wrote that was published toward the end of h...more
This short book is about the reasoning to a philosophy of experience to education. It is easy to read, but I feel like it could have delved deeper with more examples of actual education. I found myself thinking how even though this was copy-written in 1938 with the first edition being in 1963, we still have many of the same questions, opinions, and frustrations brought up about education. It has me thinking about how to extend the philosophy of experience to education.
Quote: "What we want and need is education pure and simple, and we shall make surer and faster progress when we devote ourselves to finding out just what education is and what conditions have to be satisfied in order that education may be a reality and not a name or a slogan." ~John Dewey
I am interested in Dewey's call for a philosophy of experience and education, as it relates to adult education and also to spiritual formation and discipleship. He frames the traditional vs. progressive educatio...more
I am interested in Dewey's call for a philosophy of experience and education, as it relates to adult education and also to spiritual formation and discipleship. He frames the traditional vs. progressive educatio...more
Considered to be one of the classic must read books for any educator, it discusses traditional and progressive education in a very non-confrontational and honest way. If you ever read any writings for Dewey, make this one your first read. It's a bit tough to read at times, and I found myself re-reading sections of the material to get a better understanding as sometimes I lost my way or just didn't get it. Worth the read and worth the time spent to understand where Dewey is coming from.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
John Dewey was an American philosopher, psychologist and educational reformer whose ideas have been influential in education and social reform. Dewey, along with Charles Sanders Peirce and William James, is recognized as one of the founders of the philosophy of pragmatism and of functional psychology. He was a major representative of the progressive and progressive populist philosophies of schooli...more
More about John Dewey...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“There is no such thing as educational value in the abstract. The notion that some subjects and methods and that acquaintance with certain facts and truths possess educational value in and of themselves is the reason why traditional education reduced the material of education so largely to a diet of predigested materials.”
—
14 people liked it
“We always live at the time we live and not at some other time, and only by extracting at each present time the full meaning of each present experience are we prepared for doing the same thing in the future.”
—
10 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...






































Jul 26, 2012 07:04am
Oct 12, 2012 06:09am