Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “It Had to Be You (Chicago Stars, #1)” as Want to Read:
It Had to Be You (Chicago Stars, #1)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

It Had to Be You (Chicago Stars #1)

4.05 of 5 stars 4.05  ·  rating details  ·  39,622 ratings  ·  1,282 reviews
What if a woman who knows nothing about sports inherits a professional football team? The Windy City definitely isn't ready for Phoebe Somerville, the outrageous York knockout who’s taking over their home town team. And Phoebe is definitely not prepared for the Stars' head coach Dan Calebow, a sexist jock taskmaster with a one-track mind. This is the book that began it all ...more
Mass Market Paperback, 376 pages
Published March 5th 2002 by Avon (first published January 1st 1994)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about It Had to Be You, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about It Had to Be You

Bet Me by Jennifer CrusieCan You Keep a Secret? by Sophie KinsellaMatch Me If You Can by Susan Elizabeth PhillipsThe Notebook by Nicholas SparksIt Had to Be You by Susan Elizabeth Phillips
Best Ever Contemporary Romance Books
5th out of 2,965 books — 6,315 voters
Can You Keep a Secret? by Sophie KinsellaBet Me by Jennifer CrusieWallbanger by Alice ClaytonMatch Me If You Can by Susan Elizabeth PhillipsNatural Born Charmer by Susan Elizabeth Phillips
Humorous Romance Books
11th out of 2,049 books — 4,684 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.

The Windy City isn't quite ready for Phoebe Somerville—the outrageous, curvaceous New York knockout who has just inherited the Chicago Stars football team. And Phoebe is definitely not ready for the Stars' head coach, former gridiron legend Dan Calebow, a sexist jock taskmaster with a one-track mind. Calebow is everything Phoebe abhors. And the sexy new boss is everything Dan despises—a meddling bimbo who doesn't know a pigskin from a pitcher's mound.

Dan is alpha, opinionated, chauvanistic, th
Amy (Foxy)
***4.5 NOW stars***

You’re my only failure. My only failure, Phoebe.


Perfect book for getting in the spirit of the upcoming Super Bowl XLVIII (2/2/2014).

Phoebe is a sexy underestimated daughter of a football owner (Chicago Stars). When her father sudden dies she inherits his team. Unfortunately, her father’s “gift” wasn’t given out of kindness. Her father had always seen her as a failure and this opportunity to run the team was a test. She must win the championship or she will lose any inheritance
I don't care that this book was first published 20 years ago. Actually I think that is why I thought it was FANFREAKINGTASTIC! Seriously, ladies you will absolutely love Dan Calebow. I sure did.

 photo tumblr_inline_naayaqNmFH1rrosi0_zpslzgu7d2l.gif

I hope to get back to do a complete review because this book deserves one. RL is just a bit hectic at the moment.

This one is going on my favorites shelf and I will recommend it to everyone too! It was sexy, sweet and funny.

And Pooh....

 photo tumblr_mxf1oaeFce1rziwwco1_500_zps4zqwyif1.gif

Lady Heather


What an amazing read, and although I don't often read sports-romance books (especially football..hey I'm Canadian if anything, I'd read a romance with hockey..Eh?..LOL) this was really good!

This happened a lot while reading this story

 photo youknowyouhaveagoodbookwhen.jpg

I really, really, really liked Dan. I loved his complexity, strength, loyalty, gentleness, and his own desire for a HEA.
He is not what I'm used to in a 'hero', but he was written beautifully! He just seemed SO real, with many layers.
I was wonderful to read h
 photo tumblr_nej70pGreD1t5d99go1_500.jpg

What can I say? Another 5 star book? Most definitely!!! I’m starting to think Susan Elizabeth Phillips cannot write a bad book… either that or she has most definitely found the key to my heart. These books exemplify the delicate balance of intense emotion, witty dialogue and comic relief. I have nothing but high praise and giddy admiration for this author and her fabulous books.

 photo tumblr_ln7neiSUNx1qg6c3ko1_500.jpg

Phoebe Sommerville was a thirty-three year old outrageous Manhattan socialite, who was the notorious mistress
I just have no words to describe how much I loved this book. It was amazing! Maybe I was just in the right mood for this kind of read or maybe it really is a terrific read. I just know that apart from LK's Travises series, I had never, ever enjoyed a contemporary romance as much as I did this one and the Travises. And yes, it was that good for me. Well maybe not that good, lol, but definitely the closest I will ever find.

I loved Phoebe! She was an amazing heroine. Everything about her was so app

4 Stars! What started out as a book I thought I wasn't going to be too fond of, turned into a story I loved!

I read this entire series out of order. I started with Nobody's Baby But Mine, which was good, then Dream a Little Dream, which was excellent and my favorite in the series. Then it was on to Heaven, Texas, very good and funny, and now back to book one. So unlike me to do this, but hey, what can I say. Anyhoo, in those books you always hear about Phoebe and Dan Calebow, the owners of the St
I owe a huge debt of gratitude to my friends Karen, Mo and Sharon for clogging my feed with updates of binge reading books by Susan Elizabeth Phillips. Because of them I just may have found a new favorite author. I definitely discovered a delightful sports romance to add to my favorites bookshelf.

It Had to Be You is old-school romance at its finest and I’m not talking about the fact that it was written over 20 years ago. In fact, if it weren’t for some dated references (cassette tapes, VCR, a Wa
Written April 17, 2014

4 1/2 Stars - Jeez, Ms. Phillips has the talent to write wonderful charming romances.

After reading two amazing books by Susan Elizabeth Phillips was it time for the third. It Had to Be You recommended by my friend and fellow citizen Susanne (5 stars). The very best book by this author, according to her.

It Had to Be You is a 20 years old romance from 1994. ~ Already with ratings from more than 27.800 readers on goodreads is this SEP's most popular book here. ~ Further
Jun 10, 2009 Eastofoz rated it 3 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: Chick-lit with a side order of romance fans
Shelves: contemporary
I can’t say I really liked this book because it’s too chick-litty for me and I really dislike chick-lit so maybe for the chick-lit reader this is a good book.

I didn’t like the the hero or the heroine. The hero said too many mean and downright cruel things to the heroine that I don’t think could be taken back let alone forgiven. He also flew off the handle like some psycho for no reason. The heroine had too many issues and her whole switch in persona at the end was just too unbelievable.

There i
To be honest, I have always been a huge fan of historical romance since it takes me to a time that is so completely different from the current times. However, after reading this little gem of a romance novel, I started to gain interest in the world of contemporary romance. “It Had To Be You” was the first romance novel I have read from author Susan Elizabeth Phillips and after I had read this book, I am definitely looking forward to reading more of her wonderful books! “It Had To Be You” is full ...more
It was brilliant. I'm speechless and will not even try to write a review. It was terrible, and definitely not a feel good-cookie but so great. I cried and I laughed and the ending was so sweet, so right. This book was not what I expected but so much better. My heart broke for Phoebe in the beginning of the book and to follow her growth and healing process was amazing. It was so believable, so touching.

Updated 14/4/13

It was just as great the second time around. Even though I remembered almost ev
Jane Stewart
It was so fun to be in this book. I laughed a lot. I was tempted to quit work and just read for the day.

Phoebe’s mother died early and her father didn’t love her. He kept her away in boarding schools and camps. She was raped, but her father didn’t believe her. She creates a false front, looking and acting like a Marilyn Monroe-Mae West-blond-bombshell-bimbo. She’s afraid of sex, but she talks as if she has many lovers. She appears silly and not smart, but underneath she is very smart. Because o
Isn’t it nice when a book you read could not just make you laugh at some lines, but can make you smile almost all throughout the book (exemption are the pages where either or both major protagonists are in distress of course) and just as you are about to close it? But then, it just hits you that it’s over and then you’re wistfully happy?

It Had To Be You just has to be that book.

Phoebe Somerville, blonde hottie, has just inherited a football team. And she doesn’t even know the its in football. I
Sep 05, 2015 Alexis rated it 2 of 5 stars
Recommends it for: readers of fluffy romances who also like sports movies
Recommended to Alexis by: Erin
Shelves: romance, my-reviews
Phoebe Somerville inherits the football team that her father owned, but only temporarily. After being disinherited (basically because her father was a complete ass), he bequeaths her the team in order to make a woman out of her. But there's a big catch, and it takes Phoebe a while to rise to the occasion. Eventually, she starts to get involved with the team, and it becomes less about proving to her dead dad that she can do it and more about proving it to herself. But let's not forget about Dan C ...more
⊱ Irena ⊰

For me this book consists of five star material combined with infuriating characters that made me so angry I didn't enjoy parts of the book at all.

I don't remember the last time I liked a heroine and hated a hero this much.
Every single thing Phoebe does has meaning. Even when she makes a mistake, when she acts the way I thought was dumb, when she is too forgiving, even then I was on her side. I didn't expect this much darkness in this book. I went into it thinking it's light and funny. It's n
*I am not a fan of the cleavage cover mine had a city view.
This was my first read of this authors work and I listened on audio. The narration was fantastic the reader keep me glued to my ear phones. The story was bittersweet, heartbreaking, sweet, wonderful and very romantic.
I thought the chase was well timed out, there was enough time and strife for me to become invested with these characters. Ms. Phillips did a fabulous job of developing the side characters even, they all became important and
¡PRECIOSA! ¡Me encantó, me encantó, me encantó! Voy a intentar explicar con palabras lo mucho que me gustó. Esta, es una historia de amor DELICIOSA de dos personas… diferentes, que persiguen un sueño en común, y que lo encuentran donde menos lo esperan.
Dan y Phoebe son los protagonistas principales, y aunque me enamoré de Dan, debo decir que Phoebe es quien acaparó mi atención y me deslumbró. Es una mujer con una gran personalidad y un corazón enorme, que transforma sus debilidades en fortalez
Wow! I almost didn’t read this series but I’m sure glad that I gave it a chance. From beginning to end I could not put this book down. The funeral scene was absolutely hilarious and sucked me right in. Some of the scenes were so HOT that I had to read it over and over again, especially the kinky kiddy scene. I was so engrossed in the story that by the last scene, where Dan was looking back at his life, I had decided the Susan Elizabeth Phillips is another one of my favorite authors (even though ...more
Bark's Book Nonsense
This is the one about the gorgeous and outrageous heroine who inherits a football team from her less than loving deceased dad & butts heads & falls in love with the teams bullheaded jock Head Coach. I hate football (and most sports) so I had doubts about liking this book. Well, the first chapter had me in stitches and the snappy pace continued throughout the book. When I began my first thought was "Oh, no, the heroine is a major bimbo" but I soon learned she was so much more than she app ...more
**** 4.5 Touchdown STARS ****


“You woman are really something”. He sneered.
“When are you going to figure out God might have made two sexes for a reason. You can’t have it both ways. Either a man’s a man, or he’s not. You can’t take somebody whose nature is to be a warrior and then expect him – at your command- to curl up on the couch, spill his guts, and, in general, start acting like a pussy”.

It had to be you is the first book in the Chicago Stars series. Phoebe Somerville is a brainy blonde
3.5 stars

This is a decent enough read. I was worried at first and didn't know if I would make it very far. The heroine was totally in bimbo mode with a fluffy white poodle (I don't do bimbos and poodles). However, we are later educated that her sexy attire is just armour against men (oh yeah, that keeps'em away) and that she's really the stuff brain surgeons are made of.

The hero is an ex ballplayer that had moved on to coaching. He was all about the hostile and angry. (I totally do hostile and
4.5 stars. I listened to this book. Excellent narration. Top of the trees! Hats off to Anna Fields.

A buddy read with Ingela. My first buddy read experience. I'm so glad Ingela reminded me about this book. It was the only book in the Chicago stars series I had not read. Duh! The sequel, Heaven, Texas, with Bobby Tom and Daisy, is still my favorite in this series, but I also loved Natural Born Charmer with Blue and Dean, and Match Me If You Can with Annabel and Heath. Laughed out loud at the hila
Teresa Medeiros
I've never met a Susan Elizabeth Phillips book I didn't love. Of her earlier books, FANCY PANTS, HOT SHOT and HONEY MOON are my favorites but of her later, slightly lighter books, this introduction to the football team the Chicago Stars most definitely qualifies as a classic. The minute Phoebe Summerville shows up at her father's funeral with a French poodle and a Hungarian lover, we know that Chicago Stars coach Dan Calebow doesn't stand a chance of resisting the brainy beauty. Susan writes som ...more
I enjoyed this one a lot! It's really nice sometimes to read a book that isn't cover to cover over the top drama or sex...not that i don't sometimes like that sort of thing but it seems to be what the majority of books are about these days!

I read book 4, Dream a Little Dream, last year thinking that i was never going to read any of the other books since it stood alone quite nicely, but i'm so glad i decided to go back and read the rest (thanks to my GR friends' reviews!!). There was just the rig
Bueno, aunque me costó entrar un poco en la historia, tengo que decir que me ha encantado, y no puedo más que adorar a Dan... Grrrrrrrrrrrr ¡¡vaya pedazo de hombre!!

Me ha gustado sobre todo la segunda mitad del libro, dónde su affaire está un poco más centrado, y qué decir de la parte final, con ese partido de infarto, que no tengo ni idea de fútbol americano, pero lo he vivido a tope (eso sí el vocabulario deportivo en inglés, uf no lo llevo muy bien)

Genial las escenas subiditas, sin abusar y
All of a sudden this book keep popping in my feed last week and I realized although I had read some of SEP's book, I never actually read this Book 1 of Chicago Stars before. Those were the time when I read anything that's available in the library as standalone. Even though this book is 20 years old, it doesn't feel dated at all.

Dan Calebow is such a Neanderthal, overbearing, sexist redneck. I don't even know why I end up liking such a character. He is no Prince Charming and all he think about i
Michelle, the Bookshelf Stalker  Queen of the Undead
I'm at 82% but I won't read anymore. I said if there was ONE more misunderstanding in this book, I'd stop. So, I'm stopping.

I actually think the book is probably really good, I'm just tired of these type of romance novels.
Tammy Walton Grant
This book is a perfect example of the problem I have with contemporary romances.

I used to read books like this in the early 90s - I took a hiatus from historicals (for some reason I thought they were silly) and I read tons of books just like this one. Not a problem in 1994, but a big one in 2011, when references to football coaches being interviewed by OJ Simpson (poor SEP, it looks like this book was originally released barely 2 months after Nicole Simpson and Ron Goldman were murdered and the
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
SEP lovers Buddyread April 11-13, 2014 58 80 Aug 15, 2015 02:24AM  
Let's Talk Love S...: It Had to Be You - Buddy Read 12 13 May 16, 2015 06:07AM  
Malaysian Reads: Alpha Male 11 166 Apr 26, 2015 10:30PM  
  • See Jane Score (Chinooks Hockey Team, #2)
  • A Lot Like Love (FBI/US Attorney, #2)
  • Slow Heat (Pacific Heat, #2)
  • Blue-Eyed Devil (Travises, #2)
  • Sliding Home (Richmond Rogues, #4)
  • After the Night
  • Paradise (Second Opportunities, #1)
  • Tall Tales and Wedding Veils (Playboys, #2)
  • Body Check (New York Blades, #1)

The Huffington Post says the books of Susan Elizabeth Phillips provide a “gateway drug to the whole [romance] genre,” which she assumes is a good thing. Bookpage magazine calls her “the crown jewel of romantic comedy writers,” which is definitely a good thing. Since she wrote her first novel on a typewriter in her kitchen, her books have been published in over 30 languages
More about Susan Elizabeth Phillips...

Other Books in the Series

Chicago Stars (8 books)
  • Heaven, Texas (Chicago Stars, #2)
  • Nobody's Baby But Mine (Chicago Stars, #3)
  • Dream a Little Dream (Chicago Stars, #4)
  • This Heart of Mine (Chicago Stars, #5)
  • Match Me If You Can (Chicago Stars, #6)
  • Natural Born Charmer (Chicago Stars, #7)
  • Untitled (Chicago Stars, #8)
Match Me If You Can (Chicago Stars, #6) Kiss an Angel Natural Born Charmer (Chicago Stars, #7) Nobody's Baby But Mine (Chicago Stars, #3) Dream a Little Dream (Chicago Stars, #4)

Share This Book

“I guess we're oil and water. (Phoebe)

I'd say we're more like gasoline and a blowtorch. (Dan)”
“The door closed behind her (Phoebe), and the two men regarded each other for a moment. Viktor spoke first. "I must have your promise, Coach, that you won't hurt her." Dan: "I won't." Viktor: "You spoke a little too quickly for my taste. I don't quite believe you." Dan: "I'm a man of my word, and I promise I won't hurt her." He flexed his hands. "When I murder her, I'll do it real quick so she won't feel a thing." Viktor sighed. "That's exactly what I was afraid of.” 111 likes
More quotes…