Charlotte and Emily: A Novel of the Brontës

Charlotte and Emily: A Novel of the Brontës

3.77 of 5 stars 3.77  ·  rating details  ·  380 ratings  ·  106 reviews
Also known as The Taste of Sorrow.

From an obscure country parsonage came the most extraordinary family of the nineteenth century. The Brontë sisters created a world in which we still live - the intense, passionate world of JANE EYRE and WUTHERING HEIGHTS; and the phenomenon of this strange explosion of genius remains as baffling now as it was to their Victorian contemporar...more
Paperback, 373 pages
Published April 27th 2010 by St. Martin's Griffin (first published January 1st 2009)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,162)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Lila Gillard
Simply put...the best book I've read in recent history. In my top 10 of all time. Jude Morgan is a stunning writer at the best of times and no better than when paying homage to the literary geniuses of English 19th century (Passion was also superb). By the end I felt utterly wrung out of every emotion, satisfied and totally heart-broken. I feel like I've just stepped out of the Bronte Parsonage and have to readjust to the light.
Dolors
In this novel Mr.Morgan does it again, he achieves sublime precision to what the Brontë sisters' lives might have been, mastering the art of combining fiction with reality. The result: this achingly real tale of sorrow.
Although not a biographical work, it's incredibly easy to believe his version of the facts. Fiction? Maybe. I think some events described must have been invented, but still, Morgan shows his deep understanding of the time, the place and the people which crossed the path of these t...more
Fionnuala
Jude Morgan is an intensely expressive writer, the Brontës are underserved by fiction, and yet... I never really believed this novel was about them. Morgan's writing style is too purple prosey for the stark Brontës, and he seemed to flit from one character to another just as, I felt, we were on the edge of real revelation. The best portrayal is that of Emily, blunt and disengaged - she is genuinely funny as a creation, but Morgan never gets behind her oddness, which surely should be the point of...more
Desiree
I really enjoyed this look into the lives of the Brontë family, and the influences of the classic novels Wuthering Heights, Agnes Grey, and Jane Eyre. I selected this book because of the subject matter, rather than for some light summer reading. The lives of the Brontë sisters could be interpreted as quite depressing, if you are unfamiliar with their lives and classic writings.

The way Jude Morgan wrote the book seemed like poetry at times, other more as one would expect a novel. My only points...more
Jennifer (JC-S)
‘The page is where you should live, not die.’


In this wonderful novel, Jude Morgan writes about the lives of Charlotte, Emily and Anne Brontë. Charlotte, Emily and Anne are no strangers to sorrow: the book opens with the death of their mother and during the course of it they experienced the loss of two sisters, their aunt and then their brother.

‘That is the taste of sorrow: the hard necessary pebble in your mouth.’

As small children, the sisters and their brother Branwell, are able to escape into...more
Kate Dana
The historical facts about the lives of the Brontës to tell a fictional story were great. The story of the Brontës is an extremely sad one. First, their Mother dies leaving behind five daughters and a son with a staunchly religious Father. The two eldest daughters, Elizabeth and Maria die of consumption after being away at what was supposed to be a school of opportunities for poorer children. They were sixteen or seventeen upon their deaths.

Later on Branwell, the only son, dies of a combination...more
Mlg
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Teresa
Confession time again - I can't claim to have read everything written by the Brontes but I will admit to having a special place in my heart for this Yorkshire family. "Jane Eyre" is my all time favourite novel and a couple of years ago I had the honour of visiting Haworth Parsonage, staying a couple of nights in the village and supping a few beers (no laudanum though!). One might labour under the misapprehension that it's an easy thing to do - to captivate readers with such fascinating subject m...more
Lynne
Enjoyable, if dense, recreation of the Brontes' lives, trials and tribulations. Morgan is apparently a product of UEA's MA in CW and have to say, it shows. Beautifully crafted, though the taught element is never far away.Perhaps it's because I've just finished my own CW MA it's all that bit more obvious, but I found it hard to escape the fact that although much of this is admirable, it seemed evident how muc of the style had been learnt and how many techniques were from a CW MA.
Worth reading, th...more
Helen
A fictional retelling of the lives of Charlotte, Emily and Anne Brontë, beginning with their childhoods and ending just after Charlotte's wedding. However, it does not focus solely on the girls, and also looks at Branwell's demons and his decent from favoured son and heir, through drug addiction, debt and disappointment in love, to an early death.

The life of the Brontes was a difficult one - and not just because of the fact that life in the 19th century was challenging on so many fronts. The fam...more
Diane
If you love the 19th century and the Brontës especially, you'll enjoy this book. It delves deep into the lives of Charlotte, Emily, and Anne, depicting the cold desolation of their home of Haworth and the hostile moors that surrounded it (and yet served as such an inspiration and, indeed, a necessary soil for Emily). Sensations are rife in this novel, but the plot is thin, leading from one glimpse of daily life to another, resulting in behind-the-scenes biography. That said, a love of this perio...more
Asma
At a young age, the Bronte children discover the shocking impact of sober adulthood. As a balance, the siblings retreat to a the world of words, one that sisters Charlotte, Emily and Anne return to when their professions, their expectations of their brother Branwell, and their endurance, fails them. The story of how the most celebrated sisters in literature gathered their dark stories throughout their life.

No words can explain how overwhelmed I was after reading this. Even though I've read some...more
Joy
May 31, 2011 Joy rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: Anglophiles and fans of the Brontes.
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Jeannine
Aug 22, 2010 Jeannine rated it 4 of 5 stars Recommends it for: readers who love the Brontes and Victorian Era novels
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Heather
There is something about this book that is intriguing. It pulls you in and breaks your heart. However, there is something not quite right with the pacing of the narrative. The author draws on some biographical information, but most of the book is a fictional narrative, so don't read this expecting non-fiction.

First, the characters. The author is mainly interested in Charlotte. Indeed, the book could have just been called 'Charlotte' because the amount of time devoted to Charlotte verses the othe...more
Robert Blumenthal
I have just recently been introduced to Jude Morgan (I don't remember how or where), and boy am I glad I was. This is the second novel of hers that I have read, the first being a delightful "Jane Austen"-esque romp. This one was purely biographical fiction, detailing the lives of the three Bronte sisters and how they came to write the masterpieces that they did. Charlotte, the oldest, was the practical, though troubled, leader of the pack. Emily was the somber loner, and Anne was the bright and...more
Patricia O'Sullivan
“It was as if silence were nakedness, and every moment must, for decency’s sake, be verbally clothed.”

The Brontё family lives on the windy moors of Yorkshire, but despite their numbers, six children, they are brought up in a kind of sacred silence that suits their father’s nerves and sense of propriety. Their mother dies young and the older daughters are sent away to school so that quietude might be preserved. But then the older daughters also die and the four remaining children, three girls an...more
Rob
A historical novel about the Bronte Sisters. It captivated and horrified from the start. Be prepared for loss as the two elder sisters go away to boarding school and return to die of consumption before Charlotte & Emily reach their teens. Quite an insight into the reasoning behind setting up charity schools and their minimal funding. The production of the first novels and the problems of getting anyone to print them, including the subterfuges to get around prejudice against female authors. H...more
Jamie
Do not read this. Read "Romancing Miss Bronte" instead. Not only does that book not give you whiplash with change-a-minute characterizations or seizures from repetitive AND contradictory statements (quite a feat) lined up head-to-tail, it focuses on the really compelling character--Charlotte-- and the interesting part of her life--writing and fame, and her prolonged courtship by, and eventual marriage to, Arthur Nicholls.

I will concede that Morgan can crank out uncommon phrasing that, at least...more
Catherine
I've never read any biographies of the Brontes, so I don't know how accurate this novel is, but I found this enjoyable. The novel is written in third person, switching from Bronte sibling to sibling several times within a chapter, or even within a few pages. I'm not sure why it's called Charlotte and Emily, since Anne is focused on as much as Emily, and Branwell has a strong presence as well. The main character, though, is Charlotte.

I'd have been interested to read more about their writing proc...more
Arabella
Slightly mixed feelings about this novel. At times the prose is eloquent and evocative and at others it seems awkward. It dramatizes the lives of the Brontes; Anne, Emily, Charlotte and their brother Branwell and their father Patrick. It does offer some insight into their lives and writing, it is a good read and yet it didn’t quite seem to satisfy fully but that is a very personal response. Morgan does write particularly well on the subject of Charlotte’s time in Brussels and his examination of...more
Anita
I tried and tried to read this..maybe I simply know too much of the real Bronte histories. The imaginings of author Morgan range from shallow to nearly desperate. Don't bother, unless you've a strong capacity for flights of fantasy.
Sorry, but even brother Bramwell deserves better; how much more so Charlotte, Emily and Anne.
Another reviewer said it far better than I, the 'purple prose' was just so off for the time and the characters. I could never take seriously the premise that these were The RE...more
Adrienne Clarke
Although much is known about the Bronte sisters and their shared passion for writing (it’s difficult to make it through high school without reading one or both of Jane Eyre and Wuthering Heights) Morgan’s exploration of the Bronte family, their struggles, and the early losses that shaped their writing is so fresh it makes you want to read their work all over again. The author effortlessly draws you into the Bronte’s world, their lonely isolation, the constant struggle for money, and the profound...more
Gaile
Abandoned!Too too boring.
Meenoo
This is one of the best books I've read in a long time. It's a beautiful introspective story of a close-knit family that relies on itself for support, understanding, entertainment, and escape from a grim childhood and grimmer future. Of course, the family are the Brontes, and their inner and outer lives are revealed in this remarkable book. All of the characters, Charlotte, Emily, Anne, Branwell, and the emotionally absent father Patrick are rendered carefully. This is a melancholy book (what ca...more
sandy
Really enjoyed this book though at times it was slow. I wondered if the editor nodded off here and there given occasional repetitive, awkward and anachronistic phrasing. I love the subject matter so much, however, so I didn't mind. Each time I've read biographical writings on the Brontes I am amazed that so much writing talent came out of such a cloistered family and I am struck anew by the harsh realities they faced. Morgan's rendition is a little off-putting at times due to unusual pacing, jum...more
Alison
This book is long and tedious -- my first impression when I opened it was of the small type, and I thought, "I will never be able to finish it!"

And, in fact, it took quite a bit longer than normal for me to get through it, but not because it wasn't good. In fact, it was brilliant. But as I said, it is tedious. Like Jane Eyre and Wuthering Heights, and even the Tenant of Wildfell Hall, there isn't a great deal of happiness throughout. The sad happenings and high emotions are difficult to get thro...more
Beth
Our story opens with Pastor Patrick mourning the imminent
death of his wife, in part because he will miss her, but lamenting
that she is leaving him alone with 5 girls and a boy, the youngest,
Anne, still only a toddler. His deceased wife sister comes to live
with them and help manage the household, and then the four oldest
girls are sent off to boarding school, a miserable experience of
social ostracism, bad food and homesickness. Anne and Elizabeth, the
eldest sisters, take ill (like many of their cl...more
Margaret
Published in the U.S under the more pedestrian title Charlotte and Emily, this novel was an impulse pick-up at the library from the “Books You May Have Missed” shelf. Based on its cover art – windswept women in white on a hillside with a vaguely menacing looking building in the distance – I was afraid it might turn out to be some dreadful gothic potboiler version of the lives of the Brontes. What a gratifying surprise to find instead a richly researched and very compelling piece of historical fi...more
Bookworm1858
Charlotte and Emily by Jude Morgan
Also known as "The Taste of Sorrow" in the UK
St. Martin's Press, 2009
373 pages
Historical fiction

Summary: A literary treatment of the lives of the Brontes with special focus on Charlotte as the longest lived.

Thoughts: This is the Bronte book I most wanted to read when I signed up for the Bronte challenge so I'm glad it finally came to the states and that my library owns it. I am not a fan of the title (there are THREE author sisters! and there was a lot of sorrow...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 38 39 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
The Taste of Sorrow (Paperback)
The Taste Of Sorrow
The Taste Of Sorrow (Hardcover)
Charlotte and Emily (Paperback)
El sabor de las penas (Paperback)

Jude Morgan was born and brought up in Peterborough on the edge of the Fens and was a student on the University of East Anglia MA Course in Creative Writing under Malcolm Bradbury and Angela Carter.

A pseudonym used by Tim Wilson.

Also writes under the name Hannah March.
More about Jude Morgan...
Indiscretion An Accomplished Woman Passion: A Novel of the Romantic Poets A Little Folly The King's Touch

Share This Book

Your website
“And what does she mean by love, anyway? People use that word and mean all sorts of things by it.” 5 people liked it
“But we disposable women have to be realistic in this life, you know. Else we get itchy and discontented and start contemplating the kitchen knife and wondering whether it wouldn't look nicer between someone's shoulder-blades.” 3 people liked it
More quotes…