43rd out of 90 books
—
1,579 voters
The Door in the Wall
The bells clang above plague-ridden London as Robin lies helpless, cold, and hungry. The great house is empty, his father is fighting the Scots in the north, his mother is traveling with the Queen, and the servants have fled. He calls for help but only the stones hear his cries. Suddenly someone else is in the house, coming towards Robin. It is Brother Luke, a wandering fr...more
Paperback, 128 pages
Published
August 10th 1998
by Laurel Leaf
(first published 1949)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
This is a sweet and simple story of triumph over adversity in a time when answers to illness were rare, wars were plenty and commitment to duty often meant great sacrifice. Lots of hard lessons for a ten year old to learn in any time period and in any culture, but Robin learns his lessons well and in believable ways. The author is almost prosaic in her use of language as the story flows with a lovely rhythm and meter throughout Robin’s adventures. Her mastery of the medieval language structure a...more
Genre: Historical Fiction
Summary: Robin, a young boy that is separated from both his mother and father, becomes crippled and loses the use of his legs. After being rescued by a friar and taken to St Marks, Robin learns his mind is a very powerful thing
Critique:
a. Area for comment: This book carries many themes but one that stands out is perseverance.
b. As a young boy being groomed to become a brave knight, losing his the use of his legs at an early age is hard to comprehend. To make things wors...more
Summary: Robin, a young boy that is separated from both his mother and father, becomes crippled and loses the use of his legs. After being rescued by a friar and taken to St Marks, Robin learns his mind is a very powerful thing
Critique:
a. Area for comment: This book carries many themes but one that stands out is perseverance.
b. As a young boy being groomed to become a brave knight, losing his the use of his legs at an early age is hard to comprehend. To make things wors...more
Marguerite de Angeli, you may remember, wrote The Skippack School which I recently reviewed.
The Story.
Robin should have been training with Sir Peter de Lindsay in the noble ways of knighthood. Instead, he is lying in London on a sick bed – crippled. Thinking that he would be joining Sir Peter soon, Robin’s mother, Lady Constance is serving the Queen, while his father is fighting with the king. Robin feels helpless and alone – what will become of him?
Praise be, a monk by the name of Luke takes hi...more
The Story.
Robin should have been training with Sir Peter de Lindsay in the noble ways of knighthood. Instead, he is lying in London on a sick bed – crippled. Thinking that he would be joining Sir Peter soon, Robin’s mother, Lady Constance is serving the Queen, while his father is fighting with the king. Robin feels helpless and alone – what will become of him?
Praise be, a monk by the name of Luke takes hi...more
ISBN 0440402832 - A Newbery Award Medal Winner and winner of the Lewis Carroll Shelf Award, The Door in the Wall is an excellent book about finding your own way.
Robin's father is off fighting for the king, his mother is lady-in-waiting to the queen and the plague is sweeping through London. Robin finds himself alone and unable to use his legs; he tries to be brave as a knight should be, but he's scared and feeling bad for himself. When Brother Luke finds him and brings him to the hospice, he tel...more
Robin's father is off fighting for the king, his mother is lady-in-waiting to the queen and the plague is sweeping through London. Robin finds himself alone and unable to use his legs; he tries to be brave as a knight should be, but he's scared and feeling bad for himself. When Brother Luke finds him and brings him to the hospice, he tel...more
I love a story with a wealth of meaning behind its words. This one is exemplary. Within, young Robyn’s father has left for the Scottish wars, his mother has gone to wait on the ailing queen, and Robyn awaits John-the-Fletcher who will escort him to the manor of Sir Peter where Robyn will serve as squire. But Robyn takes ill and loses the use of his legs, John-the-Fletcher never arrives, and the servants flee for fear of the plague that rages through London.
A monk named Brother Luke carries Robyn...more
A monk named Brother Luke carries Robyn...more
HATE! HATE! HATE! HATE! HATE! To clarify...HATED IT! Ok so I was willing...totally willing to give this dumb book a chance, what do I get? THIS! The kid got sick and because in that time there were very little cures for anything, especially serious illnesses, the kid is now a cripple. He is a brat. The book clearly states that. I can't remember whether directly or indirectly. But ANYHOW he is such a brat that he scares away anybody and everybody willing to help him or care for him...Oh yha and h...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Newbery medal winners are usually excellent and this book is no exception. Readers get a child's-eye view of the Middle Ages, a plucky hero, and a feel-good story. Young Robin (our hero) rises above a handicap (he can't walk), his times (including the plague), and his loneliness (his parents are far away). The book has the virtue of being short (about 120 pages). This said, it is difficult, written for the young people of 1949 who had either bigger vocabularies or more patience than the average...more
1950 Newbery Winner.
I liked this more than other Newberys set in the middle ages. I liked the writing more in Good Masters! but this was much more pleasant overall (for kids) and had less death and suffering...maybe it's not as true to the experience of living during that time but it's a good story to get kids interested in Medieval England. I'd have them read this before Good Masters!.
"The weather was neither rainy nor fair, neither hot nor cold, but somewhere in between, "as English weather...more
I liked this more than other Newberys set in the middle ages. I liked the writing more in Good Masters! but this was much more pleasant overall (for kids) and had less death and suffering...maybe it's not as true to the experience of living during that time but it's a good story to get kids interested in Medieval England. I'd have them read this before Good Masters!.
"The weather was neither rainy nor fair, neither hot nor cold, but somewhere in between, "as English weather...more
Yesterday I had the pleasure of finally reading a book that qualifies for my 2013 Pre-1960 Classic Children's Books Reading Challenge that I'm hosting this year and since this is the first book that I read for the challenge I'm glad the one I chose to read was a good one.
The Door in the Wall is a classic piece of historical fiction for children written by Newbury Award winner Marguerite de Angeli and after reading it I can certainly see why it is held in such esteem. The book takes place in Engl...more
The Door in the Wall is a classic piece of historical fiction for children written by Newbury Award winner Marguerite de Angeli and after reading it I can certainly see why it is held in such esteem. The book takes place in Engl...more
Apr 24, 2012
Valerie
added it
I'm not rereading this book. I never read it in the first place. This is the kind of book I avoided assiduously as a child.
It doesn't begin promisingly. The blurb promises only a very slight modification of those romans de chivalrie that I hated from the start. Not just the militarism, but the abusive stoicism. Why SHOULDN'T a little boy cry if the sound of the bells is painful? But the militarism is troubling, as well. As a descendant of Scots, I find the casual assumption that non-English Brit...more
It doesn't begin promisingly. The blurb promises only a very slight modification of those romans de chivalrie that I hated from the start. Not just the militarism, but the abusive stoicism. Why SHOULDN'T a little boy cry if the sound of the bells is painful? But the militarism is troubling, as well. As a descendant of Scots, I find the casual assumption that non-English Brit...more
An interesting book, quite short, set in 14th century England, wartime and the time of the plague. A young boy, Robin, has to confront adversity and disability, having lost the use of his legs. Furthermore, his parents are away at war and at court, so he is on his own until he is rescued by monks. He slowly heals well enough to use crutches, learns woodworking, reading, swimming, etc.
The good aspects of the book is that it deals straightforwardly and matter of factly with Robin's struggles with...more
The good aspects of the book is that it deals straightforwardly and matter of factly with Robin's struggles with...more
Beginning next year my school system will be adopting the National Curriculum and in tandem our county's middle schools will be using the units developed in this book, http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/12.... The first unit which is called "Characters with Character" focuses on "believable" character in books that are set in the Medieval period. This is the reason that I read this book. Now I don't know whether to use it or not.
The book has some merits. The principle one is the themes of persev...more
The book has some merits. The principle one is the themes of persev...more
This 1950 Newbery medal winner is charming and cute, but it lacks depth. Increasingly as I continue the quest to read all Newbery books, I'm finding that the earlier ones simply are not as engaging or powerful as those written in the last ten years.
This is a story set in the middle ages. Young ten year old Robin is the son of a knight who is destined to follow his father's footsteps until he looses the use of his limbs.
When Robin's mother leaves to serve the Queen and his father goes to war with...more
This is a story set in the middle ages. Young ten year old Robin is the son of a knight who is destined to follow his father's footsteps until he looses the use of his limbs.
When Robin's mother leaves to serve the Queen and his father goes to war with...more
Robin, at the age of ten, was well past the time of hanging about his mother’s skirts. Time was a wasting, best ship the kid off study in the art of knighthood. His father was off knighting it up against the Scots and his mother was needed to attend to the queen, and the plague was running rampant through England. Robin, left to wait for his transport to a brother knight’s castle, falls ill with some unknown disease the moment his mother leaves him on his own in London. The malady strikes his le...more
Jun 30, 2011
Cathy
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommended to Cathy by:
Newbery Medal Winner - 1950
Shelves:
award-winning,
childrens-classics
Set in the fourteenth century, the classic story of one boy's personal heroism when he loses the use of his legs.
Sir John de Bureford has been called to fight for the King against the Scots. His wife, Lady Maud, has been summoned to wait on the Queen. Their son, Robin, is left in the care of the servants and then the plague breaks out. Though left alone he is finally rescued and taken in by the nearby monks. So begins the trials and adventures of a young boy in medieval England. Overcoming obsta...more
Sir John de Bureford has been called to fight for the King against the Scots. His wife, Lady Maud, has been summoned to wait on the Queen. Their son, Robin, is left in the care of the servants and then the plague breaks out. Though left alone he is finally rescued and taken in by the nearby monks. So begins the trials and adventures of a young boy in medieval England. Overcoming obsta...more
Spencer and I just read this together. It's set in England in the middle ages. The main character is a ten-year-old boy who is inadvertently left alone during a bout of the plague. His legs become paralyzed during his illness, and a monk finds him and takes him to a monastery to help him heal. This monk helps him find "a door in the wall" by teaching him to read, write, swim, and carve instruments out of wood. These skills help him to become a hero in the end, even though he doesn't completely r...more
A young boy in medieval times is left home with his noble family's servants. His father is off to war with the king. His mother has been called as a personal attendant to the queen who is ill. The boy is just waiting for his transportation to another knight's home to begin his training. Paralysis seizes his lower legs and he is too embarrassed to send word to his parents. The servants feed him until the plague grows too threatening and they flee to the country without him. We are at about page 2...more
I wanted to like this more than I did, but found I just couldn't click the 3-star button. The characters were all right, but I didn't find the story very engaging, there were hardly any female characters, and it was a bit message-heavy. As far as boy-in-medieval-times-Newbery-winners go... I preferred ADAM OF THE ROAD.
If you enjoy good old-fashioned children's books like The Secret Garden, you will probably enjoy this one. I definitely did. The story is simple, maybe even predictable, but the frank, straightforward prose is refreshing, approaching difficult concepts such as illness and death in a way that aren't overwhelming for young children (The protagonist is ten). There is a little bit of a religious element, since the boy lives in a monastery for a while, but it is mostly just a period setting, not prea...more
The bells clang above plague-ridden London as Robin lies helpless, cold, and hungry. The great house is empty, his father is fighting the Scots in the north, his mother is traveling with the Queen, and the servants have fled. He calls for help but only the stones hear his cries. Suddenly someone else is in the house, coming towards Robin. It is Brother Luke, a wandering friar, who takes Robin to St. Mark's Monastery, where he will be cared for until his father sends for him.
At last, a message co...more
At last, a message co...more
http://xoxoxoe.blogspot.com/2012/04/d...
"This is pretty heavy stuff for a book aimed at 3rd grade and up. It may move a little slowly at first for today's kids, who have been raised on sparkly vampires and Spongebob. It's a bit like the classic The Secret Garden in terms of pacing. The action takes place in the 1300s, an era that may seem too far away to be interesting, but The Door in the Wall struck a chord. As I was reading I couldn't help but think a bit of Bran from Game of Thrones, and som...more
"This is pretty heavy stuff for a book aimed at 3rd grade and up. It may move a little slowly at first for today's kids, who have been raised on sparkly vampires and Spongebob. It's a bit like the classic The Secret Garden in terms of pacing. The action takes place in the 1300s, an era that may seem too far away to be interesting, but The Door in the Wall struck a chord. As I was reading I couldn't help but think a bit of Bran from Game of Thrones, and som...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
I think I understand why this won the Newbery, since the message of the book is a good one - with patience and hard work one can overcome great obstacles. However, for me, the book felt a bit flat. Not only were some of the characters a bit unrealistic (why does Brother Luke take such an interest in Robin?), but the historical background felt inauthentic (friars are not monks, for example) and often too generic (no date, the king is never named, etc.). The story itself plods along, and even the...more
Robin, the son of a knight, is all set to set off for the home of a noble lord where he is to begin training as a page. Then tragedy strikes. Robin is beset with an illness that leaves him unable to walk. His servants come down with the plague and he is left alone. Just in time he is rescued by a monk who carries him to safety at a monastery, a monk who helps him find the door in the wall Robin needs to leave his castle home and the doors in the wall Robin needs to find in order to make his life...more
10-year-old Robin is alone with a few servants when he falls seriously ill. His father is at war. His mother is serving the Queen. It’s the Middle Ages, and the plague is sweeping through London. Robin does not have the plague, but another illness that leaves him lame. Unable to get out of bed, he is eventually abandoned by everyone, until Brother Luke brings him to a nearby monastery.
Brother Luke teaches Robin how to whittle and to swim to strengthen his arms. Robin makes his own crutches and b...more
Brother Luke teaches Robin how to whittle and to swim to strengthen his arms. Robin makes his own crutches and b...more
I’ve noticed I have a penchant for unlikely heroes. Robin is the son of Sir John de Bureford and Lady Maud. He is expected to be a knight someday, but as London is rocked by both the plague and the war his father goes off to war and his mother to serve the queen, but he is left in the care of strangers while waiting for his new liege lord to fetch him. However he takes ill and loses the use of his legs and in the chaos everyone abandons him, but a monk by the name of Brother Luke comes to his ai...more
Will I continue to kind of regret it if I continue to go back and read the early Newbery winners? It seems like I might.
This is too precious, with little conflict/interest to engage the reader, and none of the characters have much in the way of depth or likability. Everyone is so charitable all the time! Except for the bratty ingrate main character, the two thieves the travelers meet along the way, and the faceless referred-to-but-not-really-met Welsh and Scottish. Yes, all of them.
I did kind o...more
This is too precious, with little conflict/interest to engage the reader, and none of the characters have much in the way of depth or likability. Everyone is so charitable all the time! Except for the bratty ingrate main character, the two thieves the travelers meet along the way, and the faceless referred-to-but-not-really-met Welsh and Scottish. Yes, all of them.
I did kind o...more
I love this book! A story of a young boy by the name Robin once dreamed of being a Knight just like his father but his dreams were instantly shattered when he became ill and was no longer able to use his legs. Doctors research and try to conclude a reason to Robin's illnes , but no solid conclusion could be made. Robin also experience some betrayl in this novel the doctor were to come and help Robin, but did not come and hos family was away from home. Suddenly Robbin is given a big break when Br...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
For more information, please see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Margueri...
More about Marguerite de Angeli...
Share This Book
3 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...
“A fine and beautiful life lies before thee, because thou hast a lively mind and a good wit. Thine arms are very strong and sturdy. Swimming hath helped to make them so, but only because thou hast had the will to do it. Fret not, my son. None of us is perfect. It is better to have crooked legs than a crooked spirit. We can only do the best we can with what we have. That, after all, is the measure of success: what we do with what we have.”
—
6 people liked it
“It is better to have crooked legs than a crooked spirit.”
—
4 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...



































12 de Dic 06:09