Death on the Barrens: A True Story of Courage and Tragedy in the Canadian Arctic
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Death on the Barrens: A True Story of Courage and Tragedy in the Canadian Arctic

3.56 of 5 stars 3.56  ·  rating details  ·  157 ratings  ·  53 reviews
Set in the remote arctic region of Northern Canada, this book takes readers on a harrowing canoe voyage that results in tragedy, redemption, and, ultimately, transformation. George Grinnell was one of six young men who set off on the 1955 expedition led by experienced wilderness canoeist Art Moffatt. Poorly planned and executed, the journey seemed doomed from the start. Ig...more
Paperback, 296 pages
Published April 20th 2010 by North Atlantic Books (first published January 1st 1996)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Death on the Barrens, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Death on the Barrens

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 270)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Nancy Oakes
I can't give this a rating, because my expectations of what this book was about were quite different from the reality and it wouldn't be fair to the author.

George Grinnell, the author, lays out the story of how in 1955 he and four other guys, all under the leadership of one Arthur Moffatt, spent about three months on a canoe trek from Stony Rapids in Saskatchewan to Baker Lake in Nunavit to get away from the world for a while. Moffatt was the kind of guy who would much rather be communing with...more
Marvin
Any book about wilderness survival is also about coming-of-age no matter what your age is. There is something about tragedy and survival situations that not only brings the best and worst out of people but also forces them ro examine themselves as individuals and spiritual beings. Grinnell has written a book that puts all this in perspective. Death on The Barrens is a riveting wilderness adventure story of an ill-fated and ill-planned expedition that resulted in the death of its leader and the r...more
Nancy
Thank you Goodreads!--another First Reads win!

This is the true account of a harrowing journey to find inner peace that took the author, George Grinnell 50 years to find the right words to write. As a young man of 22, he and four others (the youngest only 18) accompanied experienced guide Art Moffatt on a canoe trip into the Canadian wilderness of the Barron Grounds. Grinnell is frank about revealing the individual members of the group’s failings, including his own. The story is compelling as we...more
Sara
A fantastic book, especially for those who are interested in wilderness travel. George Grinnell doesn't shrink from describing his party's strong points, as well as their weak ones. No one is idolized, no one is vilified--he pains a very believable portrait of what he and the five others in his group were like when they set out on their canoeing trip across the Canadian Barrens.
I enjoy getting out in the wilderness, but I have never tackled anything quite like this. I probably never will. Regard...more
Kris Madaus
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Susannah
Holy crap! My aunt recommended this book to me, and said the big question in her mind was "What were they thinking?!" I'd have to agree. I found the story itself gripping--you know right from the beginning who's going to die, and you know it's coming soon--but I also found the frequent philosophical musings thought provoking. I feel mildly more converted to Buddhism after reading this book, even though the author is probably an atheist. I also feel a little exhausted, because the book becomes ex...more
Elizabeth
do not like to give away a story in a blog. I just want to let you know this is a great read. I had a very hard time putting it down.
These young men go through so much yet learned many things. They face trials and tragedy & triumph . This also reflects on many things in the past that we all can relate to. It also brings you to the present to reflect on things that are most important in life.

A must read for all who like true stories . Great book....Loved it.
Chris
Incredible journey! I loved that the story was written by one of the men who went on this disastrous trip! Unfortunately, I am NOT into poetry, so the author lost me towards the end. I often wonder where the will to survive comes from, and why it is stronger in some, than in others. Excellent book............. highly recommended if you like true stories, and have an appreciation for poetry. I am so glad I won this on First Reads.
MK
Mar 16, 2014 MK rated it 3 of 5 stars
Shelves: reviewed
Full review at http://fernweh428.wordpress.com/2014/...

The author recounts an ill-advised, poorly planned Arctic trip from the distance of 50 years. This is a memoir, not an autobiography.

Favorite quote:
Hardworking, a judicious kisser of a**, and mentally unstable, I had all the basic qualifications for a PhD.


If you like this book, you may also like
Into Thin Air  A Personal Account of the Mt. Everest Disaster by Jon Krakauer
Pamela ☼where's my aspirin☼ Tee
Important Lesson: Don't Dally!

I simply loved this book. I found it an interesting and entertaining read-- if one can say that such a tragic trip can be entertaining.

It's an account of a river journey made by five youngsters in their early twenties and late teens, and 36 year-old 'leader' through the wilds of northern Canada. Between you and me it's surprising that the whole lot of them didn't perish, they were so ill-prepared. Not only did they leave without the supplies they intended to take, b...more
Heather
This book was sent to me free for review.
Death on the Barrens is the true story of six young men who embark on a canoe voyage over 900 miles long in the Canadian Arctic during the summer of 1955. Lost in the spirituality of the land the men allow the journey to drag on at too leisurely a pace. The group soon finds themselves low on food with winter moving in. A devastating canoe roll over leaves 5 of the men in the icy cold water. The leader freezes to death after this incident and the others ar...more
Ursula
I like adventure and outdoors tales, so I thought this book would be a good fit for me. George Grinnell tells of a canoe expedition he went on in 1955 across some of the most desolate parts of Arctic Canada. The leader, Art Moffatt, dies on the trip after their canoes go over a waterfall.

Grinnell was young, and he was looking for something with more meaning than his privileged background had provided up to that point in his life. After dropping out of Harvard and a stint in the military, he was...more
Eileen Granfors
George James Grinnell brings tragedy of "Into the Wild" and the philosophy of the poets to his non-fiction account of a three-month pleasure trip by canoe and portage across the Canadian Barrens in 1955.

"Death on the Barrens" focuses Art's death and his laissez-faire approach to leadership and schedules. He endangers the group to begin with. They are caught behind schedule in their quest to canoe and portage from Stony Rapids in Saskatchewan, Northern Canada to Baker Lake, near the Arctic Circl...more
Alli Pedersen
I can't think of the last time I was this irritated with an author. This is not a true story wilderness adventure story. It's the story of an arrogant man "finding his way". Can I tell you how arrogant? This is my favorite. He didn't. Bring gloves. To. THE ARCTIC. He said he and others had earlier in the trip, before the Arctic, you know, was the Arctic, poked fun at the one guy who brought a good sleeping bag, gloves, etc. What? I don't even understand you.

Poor little rich kid from prominent fa...more
Lisa Kearns
In Death On The Barrens, George Grinnell tells the story of a fateful three month trip across "The Barrens" - a desolate tundra area in the far North of Canada. Art Moffatt, a 36 year old drop-out dreamer, gathered together five young men to accompany him on a canoe trip during the summer. With only a little food, not enough warm clothing or outdoor equipment, these six men set off in August of 1955.

Grinnell goes into great detail about the conflicting personalities these men had, and how their...more
Toby
It is strange in some ways to say that I 'enjoyed' this book since the whole story is a slow march towards disaster. Are you supposed to say that you 'enjoy' a story where you know people die? But in a sense, that's the whole point. You really know that life is on the line. It's adventure! Real adventure, where people that you come to care about are in peril. Real adventure where not everything turns out okay. But it is also the journal of a man who has experienced deep pain and loss. I never di...more
Carla
What a huge disappointment! Being a Canadian, I was looking forward to this true life adventure/courageous story of a northern Canadian canoe expedition from 1955. The writer, as he told the reader many times, came from a privileged schooling background. He sounds like a bit of a "rebel", and a spoiled brat. He idolizes the "leader" of the expedition Art Moffat.

The story is just so disjointed and some kind of introspective of idolization. It was just so weird!! At the end of the book, the autho...more
Sharlene
This book took me nearly two years to read. I set it down frequently and read other books, but always felt compelled to come back and finish the story. The author spends a lot of time in the book with the characters and the trials and tribulations of his group of 6 assorted companions getting through the Canadian Barrons.

While his narrative was interesting, I wish the last 1/4 of the book hadn't seemed so rushed. It was as if he didn't want to dwell on the accident and the tour leader's death,...more
Chrystyna
This was definitely not the best wilderness survival book I have read (and I have read a lot of them). This is an account of a wilderness trip into the Canadian barrens by 6 men. it was an ill-fated adventure with a lot of different social dynamics at play. The main premise of the book is not so much what happened on the expedition, but the introspection of the author. He contemplates the meaning of life, his identity and his overall self when faced with various trials and tribulations, includin...more
Kristina
This was an excellent memoir. For the outdoor and nature types I recommend this one highly. George, referring to himself as Jim in the book, tells us a heart wrenching and harrowing journey of six men through the Barrens.


This was excellent because it was told by someone that was there and experienced it; that always makes for an exceptional story. The way it is told by Jim made me feel like I was sitting in my living room with him, and he was sharing his adventure.


Not only is the adventurous sid...more
Teresa
This book was not what I expected. Initially, it looked to me like a harrowing tale of death and survival in the brutal wilds of nature, along the lines of Jon Krakauer's "Into Thin Air" or Nando Parrado's "Miracle in the Andes." It's not. It is an interesting enough story, but Grinnell's frequent lapses into anti-establishment rants and bizarre spiritual musings can be quite annoying. The book does not strike me as a story of "courage and tragedy," as the subtitle indicates. Nobody displayed mu...more
Amy
Oct 14, 2008 Amy rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: anyone who likes survival stories
okay...so i have to admit that i've only read the last few chapters of this book. nick was reading it, and then i started to read it aloud with him when he was about 2/3's through. but, it's a crazy story of survival and tough to put down. so, after nick would fall asleep, i'd keep reading.

basic plot: a bunch of guys set out on a canoe trip in northern canada, are ill-prepared and end up losing their guide in rapids. the remaining guys need to find their way to the outpost as winter quickly seep...more
Rick
A story of an expedition to the arctic done in 1955. Well-written, but I found it hard to like the teller of the tale. It ended up being more about the author's personal psychology on an extended wilderness trip rather than the trip itself. As such, it was fairly dark. One of the six paddlers died of hypothermia on the expedition following a capsize after they did not stop to scout a rapids. The author tragically lost his father to suicide two years prior to the trip. The trip leader became some...more
Marty
This was excellent. When I read a really good (true) story, I want to know more - what happened to the others on the trip. But this was such an interesting story, I can forgive this slight exclusion.
I was glad when I saw I had won this on Goodreads as I wanted to read the story. I was reminded of "In To Thin Air." I thought this book by Mr. Grinnell was much better; flushing out a very hard and devastating look at an event that not many would or could survive.
This is an excellent look of what ha...more
Drew Danko
This book is really about two expeditions. The one covering the canoe trip from about the 59th latitude to the 64th latitude in the Canadian artic. The other about the character development of the expedition members,a journey within as the author puts it. I would have preferred more emphasis on the first one. I enjoyed the maps, the illustrations, the quotes and the trip details as far as they went. But for me there was too much focus on the author's quest for enlightenment and his hard to accep...more
Nick
Aug 14, 2010 Nick rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: anyone who has spent more than an hour in a canoe, or in the tundra
Anyone who has ever done a canoe pack trip in the great north or who has run rapids in a canoe will appreciate the beautiful descriptions of autumn tundra scenery and the harrowing tale told. The story flows beautifully between the physical descriptions of the canoe trip and the invisible bonds forming, dissolving, and reshaping between the paddlers. It is also a cautionary tale for anyone tempted to enter the great north unprepared. Consider buying this as a gift to anyone who is into canoe tri...more
Bo Day
I thought this book was really beautiful, a soul's work. Sometimes you read a book, and you know the author has put their life into it. This is one of those books. It meditates on a very difficult situation, and the consequences of isolation and unpreparedness for the tasks at hand.

Tiffany
First, I should disclose that I won this book. My expectations were that I was going to hear the story of the expedition to the Barrens and Arthur Moffatt's death and then the remaining men's survival story. Some of that was included, but the book contained alot of the author's thoughts and philosophy on life. He also intertwined current facts and his theories into the story. While I didn't love the book, it was an interesting read. The second half of the book was much better than the first.
Elizabeth
I do not like to give away a story in a blog. I just want to let you know this is a great read. I had a very hard time putting it down.
These young men go through so much yet learned many things. They face trials and tragedy & triumph . This also reflects on many things in the past that we all can relate to. It also brings you to the present to reflect on things that are most important in life.

A must read for all who like true stories . Great book....Loved it.
Taylor Schena
It was a good book, but not the best writing I've encountered. I found he tended to veer off into stories of his youth in prep-school at random points and he kind of rambled off at the end about life after the adventure. The actual story of the canoe trip itself was great and I would have loved a little more detail. I think this story would be much better as a verbal story than as a written one.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »

Share This Book