Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “What Mattered Most” as Want to Read:
What Mattered Most
Linda Winfree
Rate this book
Clear rating

What Mattered Most

3.68 of 5 stars 3.68  ·  rating details  ·  626 ratings  ·  49 reviews
A man in the worst place he can be--between two women--and forced to choose which one lives or dies.

Houston homicide detective, John O'Reilly, is torn between two women. One is the woman he's loved without hope for years. The other carries his unborn child. Now, a man bent on revenge wants O'Reilly to choose, and any choice he makes could cost him everything.

Gutsy sheriff'
ebook, 210 pages
Published November 1st 2007 by Samhain Publishing, Ltd. (first published February 27th 2007)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about What Mattered Most, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about What Mattered Most

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,115)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
♥~♥Geri ~ the HEA junkie ♥~♥
Ugh! It's another one of those hard to rate books. I actually enjoyed this one. I'm pretty much a sucker for the unrequited love trope. There were high points in the book for sure but there are low points as well where I feel the story dragged a little bit.

And another thing I didn't get was the blurb. Totally misleading. The issue whether John will choose Lanie, the mother of his child or Beth, the woman he was hopelessly in love with for years were already resolved around 25% to 30% of the boo
Oh my gawd. I absolutely loved it! This is my first book by Linda Winfree and her story telling ability just blows me away.

A story about a man coming to terms with being in love with his baby mama a moment too late.

I will definitely dive into book #1 of the Hearts of the South series next.
John and Lanie. Two people who lived together, great sexual chemistry, an unplanned pregnancy, his conflicted feelings over his childhood and his emotions towards his partner and former lover, Beth (which was not known to Lanie). Beth considered him a good friend but did not and had never really loved him. John just happened to be there for her during her transition from an abusive marriage. A jealous ex husband who pops up and kidnaps both women and tries to force John to choose which one is mo ...more
This was an emotional cheating story,it had me gripped from start till the end,Lanie such a strong woman,she suffered so much pain from two most important men in her life-father and now John.John was involved with Lanie and they were going to have a baby but he had feelings for Beth which he kept from Lanie,she thought she loved John and John loved her now they were going to have a boy,they will happy but then everything came crashing down.John realizes his mistake and regrets it even know may b ...more
The blurb for What Mattered Most is outstanding. One of the most enticing "I have to get this book" blurbs I've ever read. It lured me in, I started reading the book and about 1/4 of the way into it I re-read the blurb and felt like I was duped. The description of "he has to choose between the woman he has hopelessly loved forever and the woman who is carrying his child". Right there, wow that's a strong statement, too bad the actual event doesn't live up to those words.

I have to say that I did
More of an emotional, tear jerker read. I thought it would be more of a romantic suspense but the suspense all happened pretty early in the story. Still it was a good solid read.
Linda Sims

Lanie and John are both police officers. They both love their jobs. They also live together and share a hot and. Passionate relationship.

But there are things that Lanie doesn't know, things that John hasn't told her. But everything is about to come out into the open with devastating consequences.

For years John has been in love with Beth, his partner at work. Beth is divorced from her crazy ex-husband. Beth does not return John feelings. But when her ex-husband comes after her
I think that this book could have been really good, but it just didn't deliver. The backdrop of this story is John O'Reilly who has been having an intense sexual relationship with Lanie Falconetti, until the condom broke and now he's trapped. And he shows it.

Lanie, of course, is in love with John, but refuses to show her anger with his lack of attention because she has her own issues (i.e. her mother trapped her father into marriage with pregnancy so her father never loved her, and she refuses t
For reviews, I can't say much that isn't the same as all the high rating reviews. The book blurb is completely misleading. The one girl he loves, doesn't love him at all, she was just grateful to him because he got her out of a horrid situation. The woman he knocked up doesn't even know about the woman he thinks he's in love with. A mad man captures both women and tried to make him pick which one is more important. yadda yadda yadda. Don't get me wrong, it was a decent thriller to read but there ...more
Kimberly aka Booklover #1
Awesome book with so much emotion. One of my favorites. H/h are living together, but H loves another woman (he thinks). Ex of OW comes back to kill OW, but severely hurts h (she is very pregnant) and that is when h finds out that H loves OW. Absolutely heartbreaking. They had to take the baby and H had to take care of baby and h until she recovered. During her recoupment H knows that he truly loves the h, not OW and tries very hard to make it up to her.

A must read!!
The reason I give this book 3 stars is the author's ability to give the reader heart-wrenching descriptions of the heroine's pain when finding the man she loved betrayed her in the most cruel way. The reader in me could physically feel the tumor Juliet was experiencing. I was there with her pain and devastation. That created an emotional connection I felt for Juliet and I was rooting for her get her justice aftermath.

However, I could not accept the author's execution of the final confrontation w
Cindy ~ SnS Reviews
This is truly a gut wrenching book... There is no HEA until the final pages. But it’s a great book that was the start of Linda Winfree's Heart's of the South series. This book introduced us to Cait Falconetti who goes on to be in all but the first book of the series.

This book is about her cousin Lanie Falconetti who is a Deputy with the Sheriff's department and who is also 8 months pregnant. She has been living with the father of her baby John O'Reilly who is a detective with the Houston Police
4.5 Stars. I really enjoyed this book. It had angst and groveling. The heroine was great...made him work got it! The only thing missing IMO is an epilogue
i saw this book recommended on one of the amazon discussion sites and it sounded interesting enough that i got the sample, then when i got the sample, just had to have the book. one of the beauties of owning a kindle is that instant gratification thing they have going on! without spoiling it too much, it's about a man who is living with and has impregnated one woman while secretly in love with another. angst-filled but totally believable. now i'm wondering if winfree's other books are as good as ...more
Awal sampai pertengahan buku pace-nya cepat dan penuh action, tengah sampai akhir buku sudah agak membosankan karena cerita hanya berkutat pada insecurity hero dan heroine-nya.

Ceritanya tentang Lanie Falconattie yang tinggal serumah dengan detektif John O'Reilly. Hubungan mereka tadinya hanya bersifat kasual namun kehamilan yang tidak rencanakan membuat mereka seperti terperangkap. Lanie sangat antusias dengan kehamilannya sementara John sama sekali tidak tertarik dan berusaha keras menghindari
Lu Bielefeld *Hates.Cliffhanger.Endings!*
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Jemma Gutierrez
I didn't want to write a review of this at first because i haven't sort out my emotions yet and this book is one hell of a roller-coaster-emotional ride.

I usually hate this kind of plot. Where the hero is in love with another woman. I don't like it. I spent half my life thinking I'm just a second option and so i you can understand my distaste. But i can be a stupid, masochist most of the time so i gave it a try.

What Mattered Most is all about second chances. Finally! A heroine who can stand her
A very very very amazing read!!!After i completed reading this my reaction was
Its that goog !
This is the second book that i think no matter how many times i read i am never gonna get bored of it.
I just loved John n Lennie
Loved there chemistry <3
The most intriguing thing was the female protagonist knew how to stood up for herself she was no helpless damsel .

Usually i dont like the other women whom the hero is in love with but i did in this one.
Not gonna give way anything more now you are g
ending seemed rushed...otherwise it was quite heart wrenching/bittersweet;p to read about how the characters forgive each other and move on together ;)

overall 5 stars!!;)
Maybe 3.5 stars.

Very good angsty, torn between two lovers story. When the guy makes his choice, he has a lot of work ahead of him. Grovelicious!
Rhian Cahill
I loved this book. Linda isn't afraid to dig into the hard subjects. she had me on the edge of my seat the whole way through.
Anne OK
(Christy Reece recommendation 12/11)

Natasha Anders
A very emotional read.
Kaycee Sapinoso
The blurb caught my attention.

A man in the worst place he can be between two women and forced to choose which one lives or dies. One is the woman he loved without hope for years. The other woman carries his unborn child.

I was conflicted about the book. I don't know if I'm going to read it, and I'm glad that I did. What Mattered Most was such a good book. I was hooked from the start, and couldn't put the book down.

Lanie Falconetti was pregnant with his lover John O'Reilley's baby. She's looking
I had really high hopes for this book based solely on the summary attached to it, but it fell kind of flat for me. Don't get me wrong this was a decent read, but based on the description of the book, I had expected the issues faced by our main character, John, choosing which woman he loved the "most" to take up more of the book, but after less than 200 NookBook pages(out of about 600) THAT particular situation was over, and then from there it just fell in line with being just another romance boo ...more
wow... this was a book I really wanted to read and the angst did not let me down.... wow what would you do if a madman had the woman you have been in love with for a long time, whom you moved states to be near...whom you still partner with hostage....along with the woman you have been living with (her house) and sleeping with and who is currently 7/8 months pregnant and he has them both and you have to choose.... that is the premise of this book and it is heartbreaking and heart twisting in ever ...more
The synopsis for this book is so wrong. It makes you think that the entire book is going to be about him chasing after the ex-husband and then having to choose between the two women, but that's only like the first 20%.

What this book is really about is John trying to correct his mistakes and trying to get Lanie to forgive him. It's a very difficult journey for them, but I liked it because I like seeing people regret stuff and then suffer for it. Haha, that makes me sound sadistic, but this is on
The story is good. I kinda addict to second-chance and tear-jerker stories. Not all the time, of course XD
But at some point, the development stopped me from giving 5 stars. hmm... I wonder why.. Maybe because I don't like how Beth turned into the 'wise and good' one? -.-; It's quite hard to read and believe that, when most Lanie's pains involved around her. (It just makes me wanna kick her and said get lost)
That facts made me have this tiny little doubt at John's change of heart. It's just seeme
Rosely Medina
Really strong story! How to grow up emotions and feelings. How to redeem. How to forget and forgive.

Liked it a lot!
This book was good. I have never read from this author Linda Winfree before and I enjoyed the style of her writing. This is an emotional story from the very beginning. The two main characters John O'Reilly and Lanie Falconetti are living together and having a baby that was unplanned. Lanie feels like John and her are really doing great together to have had there relationship start this way. The sex is great she feels like John really cares for her and she really cares for him. But then a betraya ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 37 38 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Books like this? please? 6 35 Aug 27, 2014 08:16AM  
Hero torn between two women 2 39 Dec 30, 2012 02:21AM  
  • The Coming Home Place
  • The Ultimate Betrayal
  • The Fourth Child
  • The Marriage Bed
  • What Price Paradise
  • A Marine for Christmas (Harlequin Super Romance (Larger Print))
  • Marriage Meltdown
  • The Rake's Rainbow
  • Lady Gallant (European Renaissance Duo, #1) (Ladies, #1)
  • No Longer Mine
  • Some Enchanted Season (Bethlehem, #2)
  • Caress and Conquer
  • The Trouble with Tomboys (Tommy Creek, #1)
  • Adam's Promise
  • Risk Everything (The Blackthorn Trilogy, #3)
  • A Perfect Marriage (Silhouette Intimate Moments, #621)
  • Passionate Bid (Blue-Eyed Four, #1)
  • Courting His Countess
How does a high school English teacher end up plotting murders? She uses her experiences as a cop’s wife to become a writer of romantic suspense! Linda Winfree lives in a quintessential small Georgia town with her husband and two children. By day, she teaches American Literature, advises the student government and coaches the drama team; by night she pens sultry books full of murder and mayhem.
More about Linda Winfree...
Truth and Consequences (Hearts of the South, #1) Anything But Mine (Hearts of the South, #4) Hearts Awakened (Hearts of the South, #6) Hold On to Me (Hearts of the South, #3) His Ordinary Life (Hearts of the South, #2)

Share This Book