23rd out of 222 books
—
250 voters
The Subtle Knife (His Dark Materials #2)
Will is twelve years old and he's just killed a man. Now he's on his own, on the run, determined to discover the truth about his father disappearance.
Then Will steps through a window in the air into another world, and finds himself with a companion - a strange, savage little girl called Lyra. Like Will, she has a mission which she intends to carry out at all costs.
But the...more
Then Will steps through a window in the air into another world, and finds himself with a companion - a strange, savage little girl called Lyra. Like Will, she has a mission which she intends to carry out at all costs.
But the...more
Paperback, 341 pages
Published
October 16th 1998
by Scholastic Point
(first published July 22nd 1997)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
Two very strange things happened last week. I gave I Am Half Sick Of Shadows: A Flavia De Luce Novel two stars and am now giving this book five star. It is strange because the former book’s protagonist, my dear Flavia De Luce is my favorite obstinate pre teen. On the contrary, Lyra, another stubborn, precocious, pre-teen absolutely annoyed me in the previous book. Right now though, I can not for the life of me imagine why I did not like the first novel and Lyra. Well, at least I adore her right...more
The second entry in a trilogy is often, in my opinion, the best. The author doesn't have to introduce the universe or the characters, as they did in the first installment, but they don't need to worry about wrapping up all the plot points either. Instead, the focus can be on 'the good stuff': elaborating on the story, teasing us more, giving action, chopping off Luke's hand and so on. Instead of the good stuff, in The Subtle Knife I feel as though we've had a bait and switch pulled on us.
In The...more
In The...more
I am not a fan of forwarded emails. They frustrate me, because they usually come from the same group of people, people I like a great deal but who never send me a normal "hey, how's it going?" message. Just "Support our Troops" or "Tell every woman you know she's special" or "Microsoft is running a test and if you send this you could get a check for $1,000!" When I see the letters FWD in the subject line, I usually simply delete it.
I lost track of the number of emails I received telling me about...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Later...
It is so surprising to me that the thing I found vastly irritating right at page one of the first of this series - the daemon - so quickly captivated me. You have this daemon in you, all of us, just as the story goes. And as a child it is anything, it has the fantastical vision that children have, there is nothing to stop it. But then we mostly grow up and we mostly lose the idea that we can do anything, we lose imagination, we lose the unconscious bravery of our childhood, we lose the i...more
It is so surprising to me that the thing I found vastly irritating right at page one of the first of this series - the daemon - so quickly captivated me. You have this daemon in you, all of us, just as the story goes. And as a child it is anything, it has the fantastical vision that children have, there is nothing to stop it. But then we mostly grow up and we mostly lose the idea that we can do anything, we lose imagination, we lose the unconscious bravery of our childhood, we lose the i...more
When I first read this book I was young enough to still pronounce the 'b' in 'subtle', and now I can't look at this book without doing it again. I still think it sounds better that way - it gives the word a sort of dull power that I think depicts the mysterious magic of the knife much better than the silly, flippant 'suttle'. Saying 'sub-tle' opens up previously-unimagined worlds which extend indefinitely into the distance.
And this is what is good about this series. I've come up with a list of...more
And this is what is good about this series. I've come up with a list of...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Jan 02, 2008
Bonnie
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
high school and above
Not happy with the ending otherwise it would have gotten 5 stars. Well written, kept me hanging on the edge of my seat.
I have the third one downloaded on my Sony e-book and will start soon.
One thing I can say about Pullman is that he is a master at detail, at character, at setting. His imagination is immense.
I don't like revealing plots in a review so I won't tell what happens but I am impressed.
I can see where some might feel challenged regarding this book. It throws a lot of church dichotomy...more
I have the third one downloaded on my Sony e-book and will start soon.
One thing I can say about Pullman is that he is a master at detail, at character, at setting. His imagination is immense.
I don't like revealing plots in a review so I won't tell what happens but I am impressed.
I can see where some might feel challenged regarding this book. It throws a lot of church dichotomy...more
I tend not to be terribly engaged with the second book of a trilogy (too much effort without much in the way of a pay-off, given that nothing is ever concluded in book #2), so I wasn't expecting great things from this. On the whole, though, it was a diverting way to spend a weekend. The novel's premise - having the fantasy world of *The Golden Compass* collide with the "real" world - was really quite cleverly executed. I found Lyra's move from main character to a supporting role for Will's perso...more
The imaginative parallels of the 'real world' of the reader and the 'olde world' of the tale's espoused geographical and demographic referential similarities outlined by Philip Pullman in the first installment of 'His Dark Materials' (entitled 'Northern Lights') are proven, from the outset of the Subtle Knife's exciting continuum to be merely one small aspect of the universe Pullman has created to capture our full attention.
From the outset the reader is swerved into thinking the second book is...more
From the outset the reader is swerved into thinking the second book is...more
For a moment, just imagine that after reading Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone you were so enthralled by the protagonist (even if you weren't bare with me), his friends and the entire world that has been established. It has moral undertones, but at it's heart it is a fun fantasy novel. Then you pick up Harry Potter and the Chamber of Secrets and suddenly Harry has been downgraded as a protagonist in favor of Dan, our brand new second main character. He's super awesome and whatnot and sort o...more
Um, what?
I said that a couple times out loud while listening to book 2 of the His Dark Materials trilogy, "The Subtle Knife."
I would re-listen and sometimes still say "um, what?"
The second book finds Lyra in another world, a crossroads world, where she bumps into Will, also from another world. Together they journey together to find Wills father, a great in explorer lost many years ago.
The book starts where the first left off. And I loved that that there wasn't a lot of recap of the first novel,...more
I said that a couple times out loud while listening to book 2 of the His Dark Materials trilogy, "The Subtle Knife."
I would re-listen and sometimes still say "um, what?"
The second book finds Lyra in another world, a crossroads world, where she bumps into Will, also from another world. Together they journey together to find Wills father, a great in explorer lost many years ago.
The book starts where the first left off. And I loved that that there wasn't a lot of recap of the first novel,...more
I apologize to Mr. Pullman, for as much as I adore The Golden Compass, I cannot bring myself to finish The Subtle Knife, or the rest of His Dark Materials, for that matter.
Before I begin explaining why I stopped, let me put it out there that I am not a religious person and that I was not attracted to HDM for the controversy. In fact, I decided to read it because it was recommended as a similar read to Philip Reeve's Mortal Engines. And have no doubts, it was, and I enjoyed The Golden Compass imm...more
Before I begin explaining why I stopped, let me put it out there that I am not a religious person and that I was not attracted to HDM for the controversy. In fact, I decided to read it because it was recommended as a similar read to Philip Reeve's Mortal Engines. And have no doubts, it was, and I enjoyed The Golden Compass imm...more
The Subtle Knife which is the second volume in His Dark Materials trilogy fails to live up to the first installment.
In Nothern Lights (or The Golden Compass, as it was titled in the US) readers were treated to a rich alternative universe. It was clear that the Philip Pullman had an active imagination and was good at constructing his worlds just as any good fantasy author.
That's one of the reasons why I didn't enjoy this volume as much as the first one. As it was stated that the books will take p...more
In Nothern Lights (or The Golden Compass, as it was titled in the US) readers were treated to a rich alternative universe. It was clear that the Philip Pullman had an active imagination and was good at constructing his worlds just as any good fantasy author.
That's one of the reasons why I didn't enjoy this volume as much as the first one. As it was stated that the books will take p...more
Di banding buku pertama, saya jauh lebih suka yang pertama. Petualangan Lyra di buku ini tidak menggemparkan di banding di Kompas Emas. Terasa biasa. Tapi yang pasti kesamaan dari buku ini dengan sebelumnya adalah sukses membuat saya tambah pusing tujuh keliling. Cukup 3 bintang untuk itu Pullman.
Lyra, yang tanpa sengaja bertemu dengan Will di dunia persimpangan Citagazze mengalami pengalaman yang mengharuskan Lyra menentukan pilihan. Menemukan Debu atau membantu Will menemukan ayahnya yang hila...more
Lyra, yang tanpa sengaja bertemu dengan Will di dunia persimpangan Citagazze mengalami pengalaman yang mengharuskan Lyra menentukan pilihan. Menemukan Debu atau membantu Will menemukan ayahnya yang hila...more
We tackled and conquered the second in Philip Pullman's Dark Materials series, The Subtle Knife. This one, unlike The Golden Compass, starts with a wild chase and a death, which got The Child's attention right away. We see the after effects of Lord Asriel ripping open the sky and familiar characters such as Serafina Pekkala and Lee Scoresby provide encore performances. It put him to sleep after a few pages, so it took us some time to get through.
I think the The Subtle Knife suffers from the The...more
I think the The Subtle Knife suffers from the The...more
This is a wonderful chapter in a great adventure story. More than that, though, if I were a young adult, I think it would be mind blowing.
If you're just beginning to explore your religious beliefs, the roots of Christianity and it's place in American society, and attempting to reconcile that done in the name of religion with the religion itself, this book would be a an eye-opening experience. It is a great starting point from which to do your own reconnoitering.
As I'm a bit older and more detac...more
If you're just beginning to explore your religious beliefs, the roots of Christianity and it's place in American society, and attempting to reconcile that done in the name of religion with the religion itself, this book would be a an eye-opening experience. It is a great starting point from which to do your own reconnoitering.
As I'm a bit older and more detac...more
May 13, 2008
Rebecca
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
fantasy fans
This book was far more engaging than its predecessor, most likely because Pullman decided to tone down the amount of page time that Lyra got and instead developed Will's character. Will is by far the better protagonist, and we can only hope that Lyra will benefit from being near him and that some of his maturity will rub off on her. As with the first in the trilogy, the writing was a joy to read in this book. If the third is better than this one, I'm in for a real treat.
My only main criticism is...more
My only main criticism is...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
The adventures of young Lyra continue, and now she's with Will Parry, a 12-year-old boy from our world. The two meet when Will, trying to escape trouble in his home city of Oxford, England, slips through an invisible window (kind of like a sheet of air inside air) into a third world, Cittagazze, where he bumps into Lyra. They piece together their stories and deduce that there are many worlds, all "hooked on" to each other, coexisting, and only those who have discovered the windows can travel amo...more
Another fabulous installment in the trilogy. Plenty of adventure but also a real depth to the characters that makes them so compelling. Like The Golden Compass, this one has an abrupt ending that only reminds you how much the three volumes are really one big story.
Since I listened to this one (great audio version) I couldn't mark a specific passage, but there was one towards the end in which Will's father presents a dichotomy of humility and using your brain (that's simplifying it, but the basi...more
Since I listened to this one (great audio version) I couldn't mark a specific passage, but there was one towards the end in which Will's father presents a dichotomy of humility and using your brain (that's simplifying it, but the basi...more
Jan 30, 2008
Annalisa
rated it
2 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommended to Annalisa by:
Ryan
What I did like about this book is that it starts with Lyra, a girl we have become acquainted with from another world, meeting Will, a boy from our world. Bringing the fantasy into our own reality was surreal and interesting. But only for a minute and then it became a bore. The story was slow and at some points stopped altogether to allow Pullman his theological preachings of anti-church and anti-god. If the story had been metaphorical I would have enjoyed it more, but it became less fiction and...more
This book doesn't end, so much as stop. Nothing is resolved in The Subtle Knife and you are left with a cliff hanger. So, if you read this book, plan on reading book three immediately afterwards.
In general the author is not a good writer. More like a philosopher trying to write fiction. The descriptions are poor, it's plot heavy and not very emotional. That all being said, as a lover of philosophy, I have enjoyed books I and II in the trilogy and I will go on to read book III.
The author does hav...more
In general the author is not a good writer. More like a philosopher trying to write fiction. The descriptions are poor, it's plot heavy and not very emotional. That all being said, as a lover of philosophy, I have enjoyed books I and II in the trilogy and I will go on to read book III.
The author does hav...more
His Dark Materials is what a true trilogy should be - each successive book deepens the power of the story and builds an intricate crescendo of events and twists. In "The Subtle Knife," the attack on free will and knowledge continues, and the revelation of how far its reach has extended is astounding. Though we face that attack day-to-day in our world, Pullman's mastery is that he forces readers to reject their apathy about this and realize the horror of this attack, not just in this world but in...more
My experience with the first two books in this trilogy was somewhat disappointing. Is it only me, or do the stories only pick up in the last quarter of the book? I found myself trudging slowly from the beginning to the so-called rising action (which didn't really raise much excitement from me). In fairness, the premise is good and the characters are mature in the literary sense, but it's the pacing and the way the events are woven together that I really have an issue with. Somehow it lacks oomph...more
Jan 31, 2009
Diana
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
favorites-to-read-again
This book takes the story of Lyra a step further on her destined heroic journey; she shares the journey in this book with Will Parry, who embarks on his own journey. What I love about this series is the fact that we have a pair of heroes. I've read a few of the other reviews here that expressed some disappointment that Lyra seems to "take a back seat" to Will in this story, but I have to disagree. Because it's a trilogy, we now get to see Will's journey, his story so we can get invested in his c...more
I *love* this series! The characters are believable, and even the Fantastic parts are/can be explained in terms of modern science, along with mythic or religious explanations.
It continues the story of Lyra, and adds the character Will. But there is a lot more going on, and it's all tied together to the basic narrative which is of truly epic proportions. The books could easily be enjoyed by the young adult (high school) audience, but I think adults in many stages of life could enjoy reading it....more
It continues the story of Lyra, and adds the character Will. But there is a lot more going on, and it's all tied together to the basic narrative which is of truly epic proportions. The books could easily be enjoyed by the young adult (high school) audience, but I think adults in many stages of life could enjoy reading it....more
I originally started re-reading this series when I first saw The Golden Compass preview on TV. Since it has come to annoy me, as having recently read the book again, I can tell they've altered the story. Unfortunately, I put down The Subtle Knife for a long time while concentrating on school books and other reads. Surprisingly, picking it up again after a long span of time, I was able to jump right back in, and it was every bit as compelling. But it does make reviewing it a little harder.
We pick...more
We pick...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Devlin's Advocate...: The Subtle Knife (His Dark Materials 2) by Philip Pullman | 1 | 15 | Feb 29, 2012 04:35am |
from his official website:
"I was born in Norwich in 1946, and educated in England, Zimbabwe, and Australia, before my family settled in North Wales. I received my secondary education at the excellent Ysgol Ardudwy, Harlech, and then went to Exeter College, Oxford, to read English, though I never learned to read it very well.
"I found my way into the teaching profession at the age of 25, and taught...more
More about Philip Pullman...
"I was born in Norwich in 1946, and educated in England, Zimbabwe, and Australia, before my family settled in North Wales. I received my secondary education at the excellent Ysgol Ardudwy, Harlech, and then went to Exeter College, Oxford, to read English, though I never learned to read it very well.
"I found my way into the teaching profession at the age of 25, and taught...more
Share This Book
21 trivia questions
More quizzes & trivia...
“Every little increase in human freedom has been fought over ferociously between those who want us to know more and be wiser and stronger, and those who want us to obey and be humble and submit.”
—
92 people liked it
“I know whom we must fight...it is the Church. For all its history, it's tried to suppress and control every natural impulse.That is what the Church does, and every church is the same: control, destroy, obliterate every good feeling.”
—
26 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...










view all 4 comments































