Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Sirius: A Fantasy of Love and Discord” as Want to Read:
Sirius: A Fantasy of Love and Discord
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
read book* *Different edition

Sirius: A Fantasy of Love and Discord

3.9 of 5 stars 3.90  ·  rating details  ·  501 ratings  ·  53 reviews
Sirius is a tale of immense tragic pathos in which Olaf Stapledon evokes the terrible lonliness of a dog born with the mind of a man. Thomas Trelone's life-work was to explore the possibilities of producing a superman by experimenting with hormone injections into various mammals. Sirius himself is infinitely the most successful of these trials. He is the only viable puppy ...more
Paperback, 188 pages
Published 1964 by Penguin Books Limited (first published January 1944)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Sirius, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Sirius

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,205)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Manny

During the early decades of the 20th century, many intellectuals devoted attention to the idea of what a "Superman" would look like. (George Bernard Shaw is a prominent example). After a while, the emphasis shifted; the Nazis gave the word unpleasant associations, though Professors Siegel and Shuster luckily managed to save it from oblivion with their discovery that the Übermensch would carry a cape and wear his underpants on the outside, an important point that had somehow escaped Nietzsche's a
...more
Andrew Walter
Oh man...

I'm either a sentimental animal-lover at heart or a preternaturally genius mind trapped in the lumpen, inefficient body of a mere animal (I jest, I jest) but this book really did move me in a way that not a lot of genre fiction has done.

Stapledon is best known for his twin individuality-shattering monuments Last and First Men and Starmaker which are probably the two most criminally underlooked examples of speculative fiction in my experience of the genre, particularly the first. I'm no
...more
Dave
Olaf Stapledon, is undoubtedly best known for his amazing novels "Star Maker" and "Last and First Men", but if that is all you have read from him then you have missed out on his writings which are in a more traditional style. "Sirius: A Fantasy of Love and Discord", published in 1944, is an excellent book as well, though not on the same scale as those earlier works. It is the story of a "super sheepdog" (Sirius), who was biologically engineered with hormones, and raised along with the daughter ( ...more
Jani
I had heard Stories about Stapledon. ("Stapledon is the ultimate SF writer. Olaf doesn't necessarily even have protagonists, only the history of the bloody civilization.") But instead of being intimidated, my interested was peeked. As a consequence, when I saw Sirius while shopping for my Christmas reading, I decided to pick it up, though to be fair I picked up the novel described as the most humane of his works.

Although Mr Stapledon was apparently mystified that his novels were so embraced by t
...more
Jenni
Whilst it may initially seem like it's going to be high-concept and philosophical, this books delivers in a much more subtle manner. Told from the view of an outsider - a man who knows the woman who knows the dog, and then gets to know Sirius himself later - it is compelling and often heart-breaking. Stapledon's focus on the relationships between the characters creates a sense of realism often lacking in science fiction, and Sirius stops being a philosophical concept and becomes a person. That's ...more
Laurel Rogers
This was a magical and thoroughly marvelous tale of a scientifically 'altered' canine named Sirius. The relationship between Sirius and his owner is heart wrenching and extremely genuine in its telling, and the trials and tribulations of the pair are devastating. In the end, however, the reader is left with a sense of sweet, sweet love between 'species'.
I highly recommend this book, and others by Stapledon, to any reader.
Juan
A pesar de tenerlo hace años en mi biblioteca no lo había leido. Pero recordé Ciudad de Simak y hojeándolo, para recordarlo, leí que decía que eran dos libros los que tenían buena fama sobre el tema de los perros y la CF, Ciudad y Sirio. Entonces, armado de paciencia y anticipando una lectura casi decimonónica fue que empecé a leer Sirio.

Y si, por partes es medio aburridón y previsible, pero son pocas partes realmente. En general se lee bastante bien y no se le notan mucho los años, que son bas
...more
Pustulio
**Reseña pronto, debo hacer unos photoshops.**

Ahora si chavos, mi reseña.

Si pudiera describir el libro en una sola imagen sería:



Es una historia de ciencia ficción, y está buena. Pero a veces me causaba un conflicto las situaciones en las que se encontraban los protagonistas. Y todo el tiempo no pude dejar de pensar en Sirius black dog edition de harry potter. No sé si J.K. Rowling sacó alguna de sus ideas de aquí, pero el perro solo por el color parece que es igual. Pero bueno ese no era el pu
...more
Freya
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
anhedral
'Sirius' is one of those haunting, one-of-a-kind books that will stay with you far longer than it takes to read its 190-odd pages. Sometimes joyful, often searing; through the eyes of his unique protagonist Stapledon takes a scalpel to humanity, and the skill of his dissection is reason enough to recommend this book.

I'd also recommend 'Sirius' to anyone interested in writing sentient, communicative animals while respecting their underlying biology.

Yes, the main character is a bioengineered, talk
...more
Otis Campbell
Who was born in a house full of pain.
Who was trained not to spit in the fan.
Who was told what to do by the man.
Who was broken by trained personnel.
Who was fitted with collar and chain.
Who was given a pat on the back.
Who was breaking away from the pack.
Who was only a stranger at home.
Who was ground down in the end.
Who was found dead on the phone.
Who was dragged down by the stone.
Guy Haley
Stapledon's a very rare SF writer in that his books do not date. This one, set and written during World War II, concerns the creation of a highly intelligent "man-dog", and its repercussions.

Sirius is a fantastic reflection on the way dogs think, our relationship with them, and out own split natures. Written in Stapledon's characteristic reported style, here a biography penned by the lead female character's lover, the prose at first feels distancing, but as the book progresses allows a great dea
...more
Rebecca
My - heart - and - brain - just - broke
Lewis Shaw
Stapledon takes a seemingly throwaway 'high' concept ('what if a dog had the intelligence of a man?') and transforms it into a quite beautiful exploration of existential angst, drawing in a staggering array of themes from intimations of bestiality and incest to the philosophy of Hegel. All rendered in prose which, apart from the occasional insistence on over-hyphenation, still feels surprisingly fresh.
Kieran
I should not have read this book. I had set myself a task of working my way through the stack of books that I have been meaning to read for sometime. Something drew me to the book shop and in turn to the sci fi section, and then to Olaf Stapledon. Sirius seemed like it would be a nice little read. So I picked it up. I was wrong. It wasn't nice, it was incredible. I resented work and sleep as it prevented me from reading.
I will not go to much into the actual book itself as I don't like spoilers.
...more
Zack Zildjan
Who's a good book? You are! Yes, you are! You're my little 4 star book, aren't you? ooz a boo boo doo doo!

Sorry...I'm also currently dog-sitting for my brother right now.

...anyway.

Olaf Stapledon's psycho-social sci-fi-losophy (yeah, I said it) is, at times, as dry as a...something dry...use your imagination!...and, at times, as poetic as Shelley...or Blake if you don't like Shelley. Or just pick a poet you DO like.

The character development is next to non-existent for anyone other than Sirius him
...more
Altivo Overo
Mar 25, 2014 Altivo Overo rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: serious readers of speculative fiction
This book, though a bit dated, is a magnificent psychological work. If a dog had the intelligence of a human, yet remained with the physical faculties of his species (e.g. tremendously sensitive nose and ears, rather weaker eyesight than that of a human, and very significantly, no hands) what would he make of himself, his relationship to humans, and ultimately of the mysteries of life itself. Stapledon does a masterful job of presenting this as he relates the biography of Sirius, a manufactured ...more
Evan
A portrait of an English family between the wars, an engrossing spiritual biography, and a taste of English intellectual life in the 1930s. And the main character happens to be a dog endowed with the intelligence of man.
Cameron
This is a great story, however there are a couple of weaknesses and it hints at some really challenging stuff that means I cannot recommend it to everyone.

It explores the themes of a modern prometheus in a greater depth with more objectivity and allows the coexistent of the monster and its creators to reach a point where religious and peasant superstition and ignorance becomes the true monster.

It also works for me as the "Frankenstein's monster" is an intelligent animal that has its artificial
...more
Ketan Shah
A surprisingly compassionate look at the nature of intelligence. Sirius ,a 'super sheepdog' with human level intelligence struggles to understand his place in the world and alternates between viewing his unique situation as a curse and a gift. Although written in 1944 the author includes some surprisingly frank descriptions of sexual attitudes . Similar to Flowers for Algernon by Daniel Keyes . Flowers for Algernonand in some ways to Mary Shelley's Frankenstein Frankenstein
Kate Howlett
The blurb on the back says "Probably the finest novel with a non human protagonist ever written." I would have to agree. Sirius is a complex creature in a complex world. There are some things that he does that one would not agree with but, as with his contemporaries and his fictional biographer, one finds sympathy for his unique plight. Moreover Sirius' commentary about the human race is interesting and revealing.
Debby Kean
Sirius is amazing, I had read it back in the 1980s, and have just re-read it, and am so glad I did. Sirius' own desire was to 'show man to himself, from the outside' (as a sapient dog - now he would be genetically engineered, but as Stapledon was writing in 1944, the miracle of creating such an oddity was done with pre-natal hormones.)
This is a story that could never have a happy ending, and it's marvellous the way in which Stapledon showed that in spite of the inevitable tragedy, despair can be
...more
Edward Davies
This story of a super-intelligent dog is intriguing in its approach to the dichotomy faced by the dog, as he is less than human but more than beast. This question, and how both Sirius and those around him answer it, makes for a great read that is possibly one of the most unusual morality tales of our time.
Benny Wilkinson
Having now read this and Star Maker there's a clear style to Stapledon's writing that is unique among the authors I've read, providing a connection between books that otherwise have nothing in common. Sirius is about the tragedy of the titular character, a dog engineered with human levels of intelligence (or even above the level of many people). He's not just a human in a dog's body though, at times a slave to canine impulses. As the only one of his kind Sirius is ultimately as alone as anybody ...more
Jennifer
Jul 26, 2007 Jennifer rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: nobody
I bought this book because i was lured in by the idea of a super intellegent dog (genetically engineered) as a focal character. I was severly dissapointed, barely finishing the book and, upon completing it, walking immediately to my apartment complex dumpster and tossing it in. The is written from the perspective of a male narrator who falls in love with a woman only to discover that she is engaged in a complex, layered, relationship with the super intellegent dog (a creation of her father). The ...more
Chris
I don't know why I never read this before. I found it on one of my many bookshelves... who knows how long it was there?

Primary impression: They don't write books as audacious as this in our timid conformist age. No forelock-pulling to the prejudices du jour whatsoever. A challenge for all of us to be less timid.

Secondary impression: It was nice to see the grand philosophical vision of "Star Maker" immanentised in the person of one superintelligent dog, and to get a feel for what Stapledon was c
...more
Jeff
I wanted to get Odd John, but the bookstore didn't have a copy. [Later found a book with this plus O.J. but never got around to reading OJ because i was so nonplussed about Sirius.]

The style of an OLD book, definitely British, fascinated with place and telling readers everything as if talking to us. A straightforward treatment in resolving the issues of who is writing the tale and why -- the issues i seem most concerned with as a "literary critic." Not a book to swoon over for this lover of orna
...more
Gail
Fascinating. Highly readable. Thought provoking.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40 41 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • R.U.R. & War with the Newts
  • Arslan
  • Of Men and Monsters
  • Helliconia Trilogy
  • The Complete Roderick
  • Dark Benediction
  • Floating Worlds
  • The Continuous Katherine Mortenhoe
  • Drowning Towers
  • The Affirmation
  • The Deep
  • Unquenchable Fire (Unquenchable Fire, #1)
  • Life During Wartime
  • The Rediscovery of Man
  • Take Back Plenty (Tabitha Jute, #1)
  • Downward to the Earth
  • Rogue Moon
  • The Centauri Device
64177
Excerpted from wikipedia:
William Olaf Stapledon was a British philosopher and author of several influential works of science fiction.

Stapledon's writings directly influenced Arthur C. Clarke, Brian Aldiss, Stanisław Lem, C. S. Lewis and John Maynard Smith and indirectly influenced many others, contributing many ideas to the world of science fiction.
More about Olaf Stapledon...
Star Maker Last and First Men Odd John Last and First Men/Star Maker Odd John/Sirius

Share This Book

“But what a universe, anyhow! No use blaming human-beings for what they were. Everything was made so that it had to torture something else. Sirius himself was no exception, of course. Made that way! Nothing was responsible for being by nature predatory on other things, dog on rabbit and Argentine beef, man on nearly everything, bugs and microbes on man, and of course man himself on man. (Nothing but man was really cruel, vindictive, except perhaps the loathly cat). Everything desperately struggling to keep its nose above water for a few breaths before its strength inevitably failed and down it went, pressed under by something else. And beyond, those brainless, handless idiotic stars, lazing away so importantly for nothing. Here and there some speck of a planet dominated by some half-awake intelligence like humanity. And here and there on such planets, one or two poor little spirits waking up and wondering what in the hell everything was for, what it was all about, what they could make of themselves; and glimpsing in a muddled way what their potentiality was, and feebly trying to express it, but always failing, always missing fire, and very often feeling themselves breaking up as he himself was doing. Just now and then they might feel the real thing, in some creative work, or in sweet community with another little spirit, or with others. Just now and then they seemed somehow to create or to be gathered up into something lovelier than their individual selves, something which demanded their selves’ sacrifice and yet have their selves new life. But how precariously, torturingly; and only just for a flicker of time! Their whole life-time would only be a flicker in the whole of titanic time. Even when all the worlds have frozen or exploded, and all the suns gone dead and cold there’ll still be time. Oh God, what for?” 6 likes
“Why did you make only one of me? It's going to be lonely being me.” 3 likes
More quotes…