Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Le Comptable indien” as Want to Read:
Le Comptable indien
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Le Comptable indien

3.51  ·  Rating Details  ·  1,137 Ratings  ·  207 Reviews
Un jour de janvier 1913, le célèbre mathématicien anglais G.H. Hardy remarque parmi son courrier une enveloppe venue d'Inde. Intrigué, il y découvre une dizaine de feuillets noircis de formules et une lettre dans laquelle l'expéditeur, un modeste comptable de Madras du nom de Srinivasa Ramanujan, prétend être venu à bout d'une des énigmes mathématiques les plus ardues, l'h ...more
Paperback, 721 pages
Published 2009 by Denoël (first published 2007)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Le Comptable indien, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Le Comptable indien

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 2,410)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
David
Jan 14, 2008 David rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: read-in-2008
So how exactly are we to understand the phrase 'historical biography'? Apparently, as practiced by David Leavitt, it involves picking over the lives of his chosen victims - for some reason he has a predilection for gay English intellectuals - and tarting up the factual record with embellishments that appear to be more a projection of Leavitt's own unresolved issues than any kind of added insight into the character being assassinated. Maybe Professor Leavitt would be better served by seeking out ...more
Jonathan
Sep 30, 2007 Jonathan rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
This is an ambitious book that succeeds on great characterization and Leavitt's highly readable prose. Leavitt manages to juggle numerous characters, and he tells his story from multiple perspectives. Occassionally, the change in point of view is disorienting -- in these spots, Leavitt is like a film director who moves the camera too quickly -- but it's a technique that reinforces the themes of the novel. Leavitt lets us see how his characters -- many fictionalized versions of real people -- mis ...more
Kia76
...mmmmmm..... Da un libro intitolato "Il matematico indiano" mi sarei aspettata di scoprire qualcosa in più di quanto non si possa trovare su Wikipedia su Srinivasa Ramanujan, questo personaggio straordinario che ha influenzato la storia della matematica con le sue teorie. Invece, dopo tante pagine, di lui non ci viene detto quasi nulla di essenziale, nè del suo lavoro scientifico. Molto invece ci viene detto di G.H. Hardy, il protagonista assoluto del libro è lui (e la sua omosessualità, osere ...more
Brenda
Mar 21, 2008 Brenda rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
I can't believe how much I liked this book. It is essentially a fictional biography of mathmaticians--who could possibly care about them? But the author entices you along with fascinating pictures of English intellectual life. And then you get to meet the real genius. Fascinating.
Stephen
Feb 10, 2008 Stephen rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: modern
I cannot recall with clarity how I first became aware of The Indian Clerk by David Leavitt. NPR? Amazon? Whatever the case, I am very glad that I followed up on the lead.

The title is in reference to S. Ramanujan, the mathematician. It is a name I had heard, but the name and profession were previously the extent of my knowledge. The book begins with the English maths don G.H. Hardy helping bring Ramanujan over to Cambridge from his post as a minor clerk in Madras. From there it proceeds through
...more
Ellen
Jun 08, 2013 Ellen rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
One of the best books I've read in months.
I don't understand anything about theoretical mathematics, but I know something about collaboration, and this description of what it is to work with another person on an intractable but fascinating problem is beautifully realized. I found all of the characters compelling, the story, based as it is on historical incidents and people, moving and ultimately heart-breaking. Images in this have stuck with me for weeks now (a British woman feeling out of plac
...more
Gary  the Bookworm
May 11, 2015 Gary the Bookworm rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
A very impressive effort by David Leavitt. The main characters, based on historical figures, are believable and the story he tells is engrossing. I can't comment on the mathematic theorizing because it was way beyond my comprehension, but it added authenticity to this story about Cambridge mathematicians during WWI. The appearance of many famous figures from academia, the reenactment of a meeting of the Apostles, a secret society at Cambridge, and pacifist activities there and in London, contrib ...more
José Luis
http://30dediferencia.com/2015/08/11/...

Una historia entretenida, fácil de leer y sin embargo no estoy muy seguro de si se la recomendaría a alguien. Seguramente yo iba buscando una historia en la que Ramanujan fuese más protagonista, pero he tenido la sensación de que en buena parte de la historia figura nada más que como un invitado de lujo, es la excusa perfecta para contarnos otra historia. La historia se centra mucho más en otro matemático, Hardy, y Ramanujan queda excluido en muchos moment
...more
Yooperprof
If there were a "truth in book titles" law, this novel should really be called "The Cambridge Don."

Bravo to David Leavitt for doing a lot of research on Cambridge intellectual society shortly after the turn of the century. Who would have thought you could write a 500 page novel about early 20th mathematics and make it interesting? Here's the rub: based upon Leavitt's effort here, it's probably not possible. Actually, the "campus politics" aspect of the book keeps the plot simmering for the first
...more
Elizabeth (Alaska)
This is a true historical novel - all of the characters were real people. I freely admit I'd never heard of them. None of them are likely to come up in any conversation I might have either.

It is the world of mathematics in the early 20th Century at Trinity College, England. The Indian Clerk of the title is Ramanujan, who is described by G.H. Hardy, then a famous mathematician, as being "the greatest mathematician of the last 100 years, perhaps the last 500 years." There are formulas interspersed
...more
Frumenty
Dec 04, 2013 Frumenty rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Full marks to David Leavitt for writing a novel about mathematics and mathematicians that is so readable. The research is impressive and the writing is very accessible. The "Indian clerk" is a self-taught mathematical genius with very little formal education who, despite all his disadvantages, succeeds in interesting a leading Cambridge mathematician, G.H. Hardy, in his ideas.

I've known the name G.H. Hardy since high school; he was the Hardy who didn't write The Mayor of Casterbridge and Tess of
...more
Toto
Jan 13, 2015 Toto rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Compulsively readable, very deeply imagined historical bio-fiction about the life and times of two brilllian mathematicians around the turn of the last century. Learned a lot about, not mathematics, but mathematicians at the Trinitiy College of Cambridge during World War I. Best kind of historical fiction: true to detail, well drawn characters, and a great story.
Deirdre
Oct 15, 2007 Deirdre rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
i think it would have been better if the editor had a heavier hand. but some interesting stuff about life in the university setting in the UK right before and during WWI, including attitudes towards race, marriage, class, sex.
Marcy
Oct 24, 2014 Marcy rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
I wanted to like this novel more than I actually did. The novel is about Srinavasa Ramanujan, the extraordinary Indian mathematician and his relationship with the English mathematician G.H. Hardy. But unfortunately the novel ventures more fully into the life of Hardy, as it is primarily told through his point of view, than it does Ramanujan. The parts where Hardy is lecturing to students at Harvard University--which is always prefaced by some caveat suggesting he intended to share these thoughts ...more
Cthonus
Feb 20, 2015 Cthonus rated it it was ok  ·  review of another edition
As much as I continue to hold the author in high esteem for the notable "Family Dancing" and "The Lost Language of Cranes" this work is unfortunately not on a par with those distinguished novels. It is a story about the tail end of the Edwardian period, its peculiar mannerisms, social distinctions and colonialism that could only be written by someone from another country for all its cliches and blatant howlers.

You probably have to be a Brit-picker to catch some of the nuances that offend and irr
...more
Emily
Nov 08, 2009 Emily rated it liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: 2008
he Indian Clerk, by David Leavitt, is a novel that I respected more than enjoyed. It's a fictionalized story about the Cambridge mathematician G.H. Hardy's relationship with the Indian prodigy Ramanujan during the First World War. After receiving a startling letter from Ramanujan, which seems to rediscover complicated theories and lay out entirely new ones, Hardy encourages him to come to England. They work together productively for just a few years before Ramanujan's health begins to fail and h ...more
Amy Cousins
Dec 27, 2013 Amy Cousins rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Loving this book, although at the moment I cannot find it. Slipped under the bed perhaps?

Quite a bit later on:

I very much enjoyed this book, in much the same way that I loved Colm Toibin's The Master. It is quiet book; when your main characters are almost all people who end up on the quiet fringes of society during a massive World War, the drama that evolves is smaller, although no less deep for that. I have no opinion as to the book's accuracy as regards its treatment of these historical and r
...more
Bookmarks Magazine

Based on a lecture given by a real-life Hardy in 1913, this intellectual and historical novel explores the beauty of mathematics, the nature of creativity, sexual repression, class relations, and the frailty of human connection-all set against the decline of empire and war. David Leavitt, best known for While England Sleeps (1993), impressed critics with his research and the novel's accessibility; even his discussions of the Riemann hypothesis and the secret order of the primes offered them inte

...more
Sherelyn Ernst
Apr 08, 2015 Sherelyn Ernst rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
I really enjoyed this book although I'm not sure why. Themes of higher mathematics and gay issues in England/Oxford during the early 1900's figure prominently in this, and neither theme is high on my list of favorites. Nevertheless, it's based on actual people so I learned much about things I wouldn't have learned if I hadn't read this book and found them very interesting. I even felt I at least briefly understood the passion some find in higher mathematics. Wow! That took some doing!
Ishan Gupta
One of he close views of how Ramanujan affected Hardy in the search of Infinity.
Roger Brunyate
May 03, 2016 Roger Brunyate rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
The Ramanujan Conjecture

I enjoyed this book a lot, but I am not sure that others would. A cross between fact and fiction, it tells the story of two men, Srinavasa Ramanujan, a self-taught mathematical genius from India, and G. H. Hardy, England's most celebrated mathematician, who brought Ramanujan to England just before the First World War, and either enabled or exploited him, depending on one's point of view. The result is a sprawling novel of great scope that touches on many things besides ma
...more
Karen Hayes
Feb 10, 2016 Karen Hayes rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
An interesting look into the life of an English mathematician at Cambridge University during World War I. During this period the professor G. H. Hardy sponsors a young man from India whom he believes possesses extraordinary mathematical skills. The author must have spent hours researching the history of these two men and the mathematical theories and proofs that are discussed. I found the book to flow nicely although at first I was distracted by the number of historical characters that were ment ...more
Lindsey
After the first 50 pages, I was ready to give up on this book. Hardy's life just seemed so strange-the Apostles with their embryos and angels-and Hardy himself just wasn't a very likable character. And the math! I know this was based on the real lives of famous mathematicians but, honestly, when the math formulas and explanations made an appearance, I just glazed over. But I persevered and the story did pick up once Ramanujan arrived on the scene. I still never warmed up to Hardy-he just seemed ...more
Teju
Sep 27, 2015 Teju rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
I should confess that I was binge reading books on mathematicians, especially Ramanujan- so i picked up the book. After i realized that this is a work of fiction... I see that the author ties the story together with some well known facts. He takes his liberty in fiction quite adeptly. It is certainly worth a read, he folds in the first world war, the eccentricities of academics (which surprisingly does not change in generations) interestingly.
Jeffrey Rasley
Dec 08, 2011 Jeffrey Rasley rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
This is an amazing piece of historical fiction. The research is impeccable and astonishing. The writing is brilliantly creative. I so enjoyed how fiction and nonfiction were blended into the POV of G.H. Hardy. It is not a light read and an interest in math and history is helpful.

I knew nothing of Ramanujan before reading the book. I'm glad I met him and honor the memory of his short life.
Aparna Dubey
Nov 30, 2014 Aparna Dubey rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Beautifully woven stories that revolve around Ramanujan's journey covering the life and times of British thinkers during World War One; the coteries governing the most respected institutions of learning . A very nice historical recreation of Ramanujan's personality and his travails from a Western perspective, especially introspective and amusing for a rasam loving vegetarian Hindu like me!
dawna
Jan 30, 2012 dawna rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
this is the first book I've read by this author and I was absolutely charmed - the writing is incredible, thick and baroque, it gives you the feeling of velvet and cut flowers - I had a sloooow time reading it because I was savouring! I'm sorry for no commentary on the story but I cant yet escape the glorious orgy of imagery that made up the story.
John Habermann
Jul 13, 2013 John Habermann rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Beautifully written book about mathematics, England during WWI, and the difficulty of relationship.
Marilyn twisted my arm...5 stars. I'm such an easy grader. Perhaps I wanted things to turn out differently for our main characters!
Mark Bowman
In this historical fiction saga, Leavitt weaves together the stories of British academics in mathematics (highlighting Ramanujan, the brilliant self-taught Indian), social changes in England in WWI (a la Downton Abbey) and early gay consciousness in the upper classes. Leavitt's extensive research and excellent writing makes it possible to understand enough of complex math exercises to follow along the story. I was captivated and thoroughly engrossed in the unusual mix of story here, but the stor ...more
Shauna Elias
I was torn the whole time I was reading this book as to how I would rate it. I've settled on a two because while the story of Hardy and Ramanujan is interesting it was diminished by the amount of time spent on discussing the actual mathematics that the subjects of the book worked on (which most readers have no knowledge of and therefore can't relate to), as well as the way he presented the topics of the social environment of Cambridge and homosexuality in England prior to and during WWI. I'm not ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 80 81 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Married Man
  • Fellow Travelers
  • The Abomination
  • Ready to Catch Him Should He Fall
  • The Spell
  • Love in a Dark Time: and Other Explorations of Gay Lives and Literature
  • A Madman Dreams of Turing Machines
  • A Perfect Waiter
  • A Son Called Gabriel
  • Eighty-Sixed
  • Sea of Tranquillity
  • The Waterfront Journals
  • The Folded Leaf
  • The Notorious Dr. August: His Real Life and Crimes
  • Winterton Blue
  • The Calculus Wars: Newton, Leibniz, and the Greatest Mathematical Clash of All Time
  • You Can Say You Knew Me When
  • Plays Well with Others
28978
Leavitt is a graduate of Yale University and a professor at the University of Florida, where he is the co-director of the creative writing program. He is also the editor of Subtropics magazine, The University of Florida's literary review.

Leavitt, who is openly gay, has frequently explored gay issues in his work. He divides his time between Florida and Tuscany, Italy.
More about David Leavitt...

Share This Book



“Spouse or collaborator, it comes to the same thing. And there is work to be done. Always, always work to be done." -David Leavitt, "Partition," _The Indian Clerk_” 1 likes
More quotes…