In The Breakthrough, veteran journalist Gwen Ifill surveys the American political landscape, shedding new light on the impact of Barack Obam...
read full description
reviews
Aug 05, 2011
This is the book that got Ms. Ifill in trouble as she prepared to moderate the Vice presidential debate. All in all, it's less about Barack Obama and more about the new "Joshua generation" of African-American leaders. Cory Booker, Mayor of Newark, NJ, Deval Patrick, Governor of Massachusetts, Artur Davis, Alabama congressman in the House of Representatives and many others are profiled. This new group of politicians has not necessarily made the marches, fought to be served at lunch coun
More...
Nov 26, 2011
Continualknowledge
rated it: 
Gwen Ifill gives a cursory overview of several "breakthrough" black politicians across the United States. By breakthrough she means those African Americans in positions across the country that we wouldn't expect to find black politicians (mayors, governors, and in some instances congressmen). Ifill mentions quite a few names that we would expect (Deval, Booker, Franklin and Sellars). She talks about how these politicians rose to power against the established Civil Rights politicians
More...
Nov 08, 2009
Kaara
rated it: 
The introduction was fairly scattered and stream-of-consciousness, but once Ifill settled in to tell the stories she found, I was completely absorbed and interested. Her style is conversational, casual yet controlled, and detached, as a journalist should be, but with enough occasional passing personal commentary to remind the reader of Ifill's unique vantage point to the phenomenon she is exploring.
The two most interesting points she elaborated on, in my mind, had to do with a) the g More...
The two most interesting points she elaborated on, in my mind, had to do with a) the g More...
Feb 18, 2009
I like the way Gwen Ifill writes--it's very straightforward, news-reporting writing and there aren't hidden meanings that are lost on me. This book isn't so much a blueprint of the breakthrough, as it is a reportage of all the breakthroughs that have occurred of late.
This book highlights the big division between the old guard black politicos and the new. It reminds me a lot of articles I read a couple years ago that older women were pissed that younger women weren't saying "tha More...
This book highlights the big division between the old guard black politicos and the new. It reminds me a lot of articles I read a couple years ago that older women were pissed that younger women weren't saying "tha More...
Dec 29, 2010
Larisha
rated it: 
Gwen Ifill examines both old members and young members of politics who have made breakthroughs in their own right, and she leaves the reader thinking about how race will continue to play out as a factor in politics. Without pressing a singular opinion throughout the book, she presents both quotes and interviews from others establishing ground for us to form our own opinions and ideas.
Breakthrough is insightful and interesting, capturing a topic that would surely intrigue anyone living More...
Breakthrough is insightful and interesting, capturing a topic that would surely intrigue anyone living More...
Feb 18, 2010
Julie
rated it:
I found this to be a very well researched & unbiased book on modern politics by this journalist. I learned a lot, esp. about some of the new upcoming figures, and particularly one who may be running for governor in AL. where I live. Written shortly before Obama was elected, it gives one a better understanding of the fine line that politicans and voters face when it comes to race/gender issues and differences between the civil rights generation and current one. Leaves the reader with questions o
More...
Jun 18, 2009
John
rated it:
The first part likely meets expectations better - how the presidential race was seen in the black community, with the strongest chapter being the race vs. gender "quandry" of the primary season among African-American women. Second half consists of a sort of "Who's Who in Black Politics", almost entirely male, which Ifill admits in the brief audio postscript interview she found disturbing.
She does better than many authors in reading her own work (admitting in the intervi More...
She does better than many authors in reading her own work (admitting in the intervi More...
Jan 03, 2011
Minnie
rated it:
I read this book from time to time when things settle down with my writing. I love it that I can look back from today's political scene and see what Gwen Ifill predicts in this book for the future of politics. What caught her off guard was the election of Barack Obama as President of the U.S.A. I have to say she wasn't the only one. And some folks are still trying to "get over it." IMO, politics is a stage play of comedy and tragedy and all politicians the actors. I think she captures
More...
May 09, 2010
Gary
rated it:
T
How far along have we come in regard to race and politics and how does one measure success?
A poll done in 1958, more than half of Americans said they would not vote for a black candidate. Ifill gives us the history of how we got from 1958 to electing our first African American president.
During the last presidential campaign Obama went to the Boston Commons in Massachusetts and stood there with the governor of the state. They raised their hands in the air a More...
How far along have we come in regard to race and politics and how does one measure success?
A poll done in 1958, more than half of Americans said they would not vote for a black candidate. Ifill gives us the history of how we got from 1958 to electing our first African American president.
During the last presidential campaign Obama went to the Boston Commons in Massachusetts and stood there with the governor of the state. They raised their hands in the air a More...
May 09, 2010
Jeremy
rated it: 
This book was a great disappointment. It failed to teach me much of any utility or freshness. Written almost entirely from journalistic sources, and based on a lot of interviews, it is a staid, standard, static analysis of racial politics, lacking originality and courage, as well as solid prose. Just to give you an example of what awaits you as a reader--her great analytic insight is "sandpaper politics". What's that? The friction that arises when one generation gives up power to
More...
Apr 19, 2009
Carol/Bonadie
rated it:
Long a favorite new commentator of mine, Gwen Ifill is as sharp in print as she is on television. She uses the backdrop of the election of the first African American president to explore the dichotomy between the previous generation of civil rights activists (Jesse Jackson, Jr., Al Sharpton, Andrew Young, et al) and the current and up-and-coming generation of black activists and politicians (Harold Ford, Jr, Corey Booker, et al). She draws distinctions between the outlook of those steeped in t
More...
Oct 04, 2009
Darrell
rated it:
This was a very insightful book. It breaks down the difference between black leaders during the civil rights era and leaders today. Many during the time of martin Luther King and others have a extremely different view of where our country is and are resistance to a new paradigm. This book highlights the differing opinions of both eras
If you are interested in the politics of Black America this is a good book to read
If you are interested in the politics of Black America this is a good book to read
Jun 14, 2010
Mary
rated it:
PBS's Gwen Ifill brings her razor-sharp intellect to Obama's contemporaries, the post-Civil Rights era black politicians whose appeal extends beyond black and white. She profiles Artur Davis, Cory Booker and Deval Patrick, focusing on legacy politics, generational divides, and the race-gender clash. Along the way, we also learn about key black women politicians such as Shirley Chisholm, Carrie Meek, Donna Brazile, Kamala Harris and Karen Bass.
Jun 16, 2009
I waited for my turn to get this book from the library for months...it was worth the wait. A very quick read. Ifill did interviews with a lot of up and coming African American politicians in addition to President Obama and tracks their paths to leadership in a very interesting way. I only wish she had featured--or even mentioned--Keith Ellison. The chapter on how these new young leaders deal with the continual question of whether they are "black enough" or "too black" is wort
More...
Oct 12, 2010
Larry
rated it:
Gwen Ifill's book is a very well written look at the current state of African-American politics. It highlights the current crop of black leaders and shows how they view themselves and their place in American politics. The most interesting aspect of the book is the apparent division between the civil rights era leaders and the current leaders, who view their roles differently. While Obama's election is a pivotal moment in race relations in America, the book doesn't really focus on him alone, but
More...
Mar 29, 2009
Mary
rated it:
A fascinating portrait of AfroAmericans in politics and the "new way" they see their core mission. The first person to "nail" my conflict between Clinton and Obama during the campaign(I'm sixty and female)and ended up supporting Obama. I liked the decoding of many events that I only partially understood but emotionally felt at the time.
Oct 10, 2009
Bill
rated it:
I really enjoyed this book. I think Ifill captured this new generation of politicians' quandary between serving the black community and the larger population quite well. She also did well describing the ambivalence the Civil Rights generation towards these new leaders. I wish she would've delved more into Kwame Kilpatrick, though. As the exception to the perceived rule of this new generation, I think his plight could've been far more illuminating than this book gives it credit.
Mar 19, 2009
MariAn
rated it:
Excellent read of the many African American persons who have contributed to the place in history we are now experiencing - an African American President. Gwen is a journalist on PBS and hosts the show - Washington Week in Review - weekly. Very knowledgeable - she hosted one of the debates during the primary campaigns.
Jul 29, 2009
Marianne
rated it:
Interesting discussion of the changing role of African Americans in the U.S. political system. Ifill interviewed many of the current and former heavy weights in politics and governance and sketches the careers and focus of many of the "new" players.
Jul 21, 2009
Shawanna
rated it:
If you want to brush up on the who's up and coming in the world of black politicians, this is the book for you. Ms. Ifill gives a background on politicians form the civil righst movement on up to today, highlighting today's new leaders. The book was published around election time 2008. She also gives some information on the conficts between the old guard politicians/civil rights leaders and the new jacks (Obama, Fenty, Booker and Jealous).
Apr 05, 2009
Steven
rated it:
Great book. Ifill explores the issues clearly and explains cogently. She responds to a lot of the wonderings I've had in the past year or so about race and politics and where we are now. Excellent book, very well written.
Aug 08, 2009
Aldafan
rated it:
Ann loaned me this, probably wouldn't have picked it myself. The generation difference between the Civil Rights leaders and current leaders (preachers vs. lawyers/busines men/women) was interesting.
Aug 02, 2011
Paula
rated it:
Very interesting narrative based on interviews and research about the changes in the political landscape for African Americans, including the generational shift.
Apr 24, 2009
Sarah
rated it:
I thought Ifill had a lot of insight in the first several chapters, but her momentum kind of slowed down by the end. She also overused the metaphor of "sandpaper politics" in my opinion. But I enjoyed reading especially her account of the 2008 presidential campaign. Read as a campaign book or a book about Obama, this is quite satisfying.
Aug 21, 2010
SweetPea
rated it:
Quick read with some interesting insights into how Obama's election impacted politics.
Dec 16, 2009
Stories of the new generation of black leaders, with ivy league educations, creating new relationships among the races.
Aug 10, 2011
Jessica
rated it:
The introduction was better than the book. Despite that, it's an interesting exposition on the old guard v the new guard in black leadership. It would have been better as a NYT Sunday Magazine piece.
Jul 06, 2009
Shanley
rated it:
Gwen did an excellent job with this book. It was a compelling and interesting read. Though many of the issues may not be all that new, she provided a more in-depth review of the many perspectives of race in politics than I have seen in a single piece elsewhere. I loved the chapter on race and gender, and I thought that the profiles of the new generation of government leaders were really interesting. I appreciated learning about some of the inspiring people in state and local government that don'
More...
Jul 13, 2009
Alisha
rated it:
Definitely a great read. Still, I was more interested in the chapters on race, gender, and legacy politics over the profiles of prominent African-American politicians.
