Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Perfect Madness” as Want to Read:
Perfect Madness
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Perfect Madness

3.61 of 5 stars 3.61  ·  rating details  ·  904 ratings  ·  187 reviews
The paradigm-shattering bestseller that investigates how women have fallen into the trap of "total motherhood," and how that mind-set damages them and their relationships with their husbands and children.

Judith Warner is the author of a range of nonfiction books, among them You Have the Power: How to Take Back Our Country and Restore Democracy in America (with H

Hardcover, 336 pages
Published February 28th 2005 by Penguin Group (USA) (first published February 17th 2005)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Perfect Madness, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Perfect Madness

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 2,002)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Chris McKenzie
Jun 22, 2008 Chris McKenzie rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: moms who are sick of stress
There was a time when working moms were vogue and stay-at home moms (today known as SAHMs) were regarded as pathetic and unfulfilled. These days, the pendulum seems to have swung back, at least in my experience as Bad Working Mommy. At a birthday party for my nephew not long ago, I was asked by a homeschool mom, "So, do you homeschool your children?" When I said no, that I taught in a Christian school where my children also attend, I got what I have come to recognze as The Look: smug, superior, ...more
i did not care for this book. warner maintained such a smug tone throughout, it was nearly impossible to read. supposedly she was inspired to investigate the uniquely dysfunctional approach to parenting that america mothers have adopted over the last thirty years, inspired by the culture shock she experienced when she moved back to the states after having her babies in france. france offers socialized health care & government-subsidized child care called creches. obviously there's nothing li ...more
May 17, 2007 Elizabeth rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Everyone
I was initially skeptical, as the author began by talking about her experiences with her young child in France, but it turned out to be a really interesting book. It deals with the larger social reasons why so many middle-class mothers are so hypervigilant about the tiniest details of their children's lives. It gives mothers who work outside the home equal weight to mothers who stay home, which is nice, and examines whether or not we really have a choice when it comes to staying home or not, reg ...more
Although I find this book a bit depressing, it really resonates with me. In a grossly simplified nutshell, Judith Warner describes how we, generation X women, are living out hollow societal promises from our childhood. Feminism of the 70s and the "you can have it all" mantra taught to us in the 80s have failed to pan out. We are not equal members of society, and we can not have it all. As mothers we have limited choices and a lack of support and we must make sacrifices (professional and personal ...more
Nov 18, 2008 Jeannette rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: all crazy women
Recommended to Jeannette by: Michelle LaRose
IF you are a mother or even thinking about becoming a mother, you need to read this book. I was totally awakened to the complete insanity in which we (as women, with procreative powers and professional aspirations) are expected to function. Ok, I guess I have been living it first hand, but I have never slowed down enough to really think about, and reflect on, how absolutely asinine and competitive modern motherhood has become. I was talking to my friend Andrea about some of my epiphanies while r ...more
There were times when I loved this book and times when I hated this book. It was an amazing look at motherhood today. The one thing that I will take away from this book the most is that it has helped me look at different mothering decisions with a more open mind. There was a page in the book where it talked about a particular tribal society where women had to keep working even after the birth of a baby, or she risked starving. It made me think about genetic diversity and how it is important for ...more
Jan 28, 2008 Katie rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Parents. All women.
Shelves: non-fiction
Moms, don't miss this. My caveat: I don't know enough about how one writes a non-fiction book to know whether she has ample sources or citations for her opinions, but I do know that her anecdotes and observations ring very true for me and what I see. We are really getting mixed up about motherhood and what it takes to be a good mother/good woman. It's shocking to see where these messages are coming from and how they got to be in our brains. It's seriously time for women to start talking to each ...more
I was going through a phase where I just happened to be reading books by many urban East Coasters, and I was amazed at how neurotic they seem to be. This covers the specific pressures of motherhood, and yes, if everyone else is going in that direction, it would be hard not to pick up on the neurosis, even if your natural tendency was towards sanity.

Warner was able to provide an alternate perspective, having also spent time in Europe, where mothers receive more support, and face less pressure. Sh
Another political parenting book to chew through! I feel I am really learning a lot about family policies in the U.S. through all this reading. Here are some things I want to remember.

"Listen, you don't just have this child for a couple of months. You'll have her for the rest of your life. You have to have a life of your own. Because if you are happy, she'll be happy. If you're fine, she'll be fine."- Makes me think that in this age of over-parenting we HAVE to take time for ourselves, cultivate
Donna Lyn
i finished the book! it was compelling enough (the history of feminism was interesting) but overall negative and depressing. A complete 'worldly' view of mothering and this book just affirmed to me even more how my Faith gives me a sense of who I am, whose I am, and gives me a purpose and joy in living. There is no joy in this book. the author opens the book with how wonderful and different parenting in France is, spends the middle of the book complaining about how much our American life sucks, ...more
An incredibly well-researched and insightful commentary on modern motherhood. Our generation of women has been raised on the feminist message that we can "have it all" and for many of us (given good educational opportunities, sufficient finances, and general class privilege) that has proven true right up to the point of motherhood where we hit a wall. Sadly, rather than looking outwards to enact societal change (paid family leave for both genders; government standards for universal, high-quality ...more
On one level, this book is about "mommy madness." As Warner explains in her foreward, this is "the insane sort of perfectionistic and hyper-controlling behaviors that so many mothers engage in today." But it is also about a crazy time in American history where the middle class is being reduced to nothingness. As Warner explains:

"It's about the way that mothers' (and fathers) behaviors have been perverted by social and economic forces that they feel they cannot control. It's about how that feelin
Reading this book was a schizophrenic experience - I wavered between complete agreement with the author and total irritation at her inconsistencies and inaccuracies. She nails the feeling of free-floating anxiety that surrounds the contemporary practice of parenting, and correctly points a finger at U.S. society's failure to find collective childcare solutions. But a lot of undeserving targets, from natural birth to comfortable mom clothes, get tarnished by her broad brush, and her need to susta ...more
Apr 13, 2008 Melody rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Melody by: Antonia (Gift)
Parts of this book are interesting, like the feminist and social history sections. Unfortunately the author really annoyed me with her over the top generalizations of different types of parenting approaches. She uses what I would characterize as "extreme" examples to make a point, when in reality the issues she talks about are much more complex and nuanced. I had to force myself to get 3/4 of the way through the book. Just couldn't finish it. Maybe her book describes a certain niche of parenting ...more
Sep 24, 2008 Ryan rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Meredith
Recommended to Ryan by: Library display
This is an interesting book that I would recommend to certain others. Although I imagine this book has considerably fewer male readers than female ones, I think that is unfortunate. This book is especially useful for any male that wants to understand why modern motherhood is characterized by so much anxiety. Warner does a good job of communicating the exasperating aspects of American cultural expectations on motherhood, but I found the historical path of feminism she traces from the 1950's throu ...more
Angie Libert
I laughed and cried while reading this book because it so perfectly pinpointed modern motherhood and all its intricacies. It has certainly given my motherhood journey a better perceptive and helped me to laugh at all I do and see others do. The cycles of history, even in motherhood, are so real.
I love this book so far! Judith makes so many valid points about how in out strive to become perfect Mothers, we miss out on the joys of being a Mom! Stressed out parents aren't necessarily the ideal parents. American Moms have much to learn from European Moms about not feeling guilty when Dad picks up the kids or does the dishes! I am sure I will be able to pick up many useful tips from this book. So far one of the lines that made me chuckle was (paraphrasing) "Is a Girlscout Bakesale at 8pm fu ...more
This was a bookclub selection for us and our general consensus was that there was no conclusion. She started off by letting us know how much better childcare and support for mothers is in France and then proceeded to hop all around American history trying to explain the seesaw of support here in the states. You get the idea that she believes mothers need to be happy in order for their children to be so, (and you cheer for this) and yet, there is no solution and no real structure. It just ends up ...more
I enjoyed the discussion of motherhood and the needs of modern day mothers in the beginning and end of this book as well as the comparison of the child-care systems in different countries. It was thoughtful, pertinent and a call to action. The books speaks to the fears of parents who want the best for the kids and how difficult it is to achieve balance for our lives and that of our children in what can be a crazy, mean and competitive world. There is also a history of the feminist movement and o ...more
Louisa Morris
Loved this book. It's the perfect antidote to Sears' attachment parenting drones, or is that drivel? Okay, I admit it, Sears was my bible until I realized I was losing it, and that I was more than just a mommy sacrificing everything for my child! Judith Warner has her head on straight and has been there. I am glad she took the time to write down her thoughts and offer some sanity in the attachment parenting perfectionism so many seem to aspire to in my little town in northern CA.
Just when I started congratulating myself on being a fairly relaxed parent compared to some of the mothers interviewed for this book, the author began a discussion of how the American economy and educational system make it extremely difficult for middle-class parents to afford quality daycare and schooling for their children. Cue sweaty palms and racing pulse. On the whole, an honest, mostly unpatronizing glimpse into contemporary middle-class motherhood.
I'm fairly sure I agreed with almost everything in this book (why, just the other day I wished aloud that I could let my child run the streets, trusting my neighbors to march her back home by the ear if she so much as drops the f-bomb in public) but I may be wrong because the writing was so self-righteously dull that it's possible I was just narrating my own thoughts in my head.
"Perfect Madness" discusses the issues relating to motherhood in today's society. Although first published in 2005, the "Perfect Madness" is entirely still relevant today. The most common theme throughout the book is: working moms vs stay-at-home-moms. To this debate, she answered with a confident: do what makes you happy. Some reviews of this book criticize the fact that Warner did not come up with a solid solution for the bigger issues, such as what we can do as a society, but she did take on ...more
This book was an interesting look at the history of cultural shifts in motherhood. While figuring out how we got here is great, I was hoping for more analysis on how to overcome the negative cultural aspects. This book had none.
WOW. Fascinating info and insight into mothering in this day and age. Reading it was amazing company and therapy to my worries and concerns as a mother of 2.
Liz Engstrom
The irony of this book is, that as a busy mother, I found her writing so dense at times and bogged down by historical facts, etc. that I was developing anxiety. I truly believe Warner has an awesome message -- we mothers are too hard on ourselves. As I skimmed and scanned, I got that; I enjoyed her personal anecdotes and the info from other mothers. Unfortunately, the facts and constant "reporting" took away from the authentic message that is somewhere beneath it. For anyone with time or for goo ...more
Thank you, Judith Warner.

I cannot say that I agreed with every argument; However, it isn't necessary that I do. The point, whether you agree with the nuances or not, is that mothers are killing themselves trying to be perfect. They are guilt ridden and anxious. I know I am. And the very people that we should be turning to for support, the very people that need our support, other mothers , are the very ones that we consistently judge and criticize. There are too many examples to count so I'll us
Mixed bag. Warner's ideas are challenging me to think in new ways about some of the problems and neurosis of modern motherhood, which I welcome as a mother of two young kids. However, her analysis is heavily weighted towards the problems, not the solutions, so I found the book to be more discouraging than helpful overall.

The gist of her argument is that Roe-v-Wade caused the feminist movement to shift its understanding of women's freedom to the individual, private (and often bodily-oriented) re
I felt like much of this books purposed solutions to motherhood anxiety that go in direct opposition to what I believe. So reading it was one big frustration. But it was an interesting point of view. I think though that the author's biggest problem is the people she associates with. Because their perspective and ideas on motherhood could leave one feeling very jaded.

The first paragraph in the conclusing chapter states, "I began this book with one daughter in preschool and the other a baby at hom
I started off really enjoying this book. I agree that there are serious issues with the expectations of modern motherhood - why are moms expected to have it all while striving to raise perfect children?

However, in this book, Judith Warner focused on the concept of 'attachment parenting' as the root of current mothering pressures, but didn't base her hypothesis on anything more than experience and a collection of mothering articles in popular magazines. I found this interesting because advocates
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 66 67 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Mommy Myth: The Idealization of Motherhood and How It Has Undermined All Women
  • The Mask of Motherhood: How Becoming a Mother Changes Our Lives and Why We Never Talk About It
  • The Price of Motherhood: Why the Most Important Job in the World Is Still the Least Valued
  • Misconceptions: Truth, Lies, and the Unexpected on the Journey to Motherhood
  • A Life's Work: On Becoming a Mother
  • Abortion & Life
  • Flux: Women on Sex, Work, Love, Kids, and Life in a Half-Changed World
  • A Strange Stirring: The Feminine Mystique & American Women at the Dawn of the 1960s
  • The Parents We Mean To Be: How Well-Intentioned Adults Undermine Children's Moral and Emotional Development
  • Momma Zen: Walking the Crooked Path of Motherhood
  • Becoming the Parent You Want To Be
  • Breeder: Real-Life Stories from the New Generation of Mothers
  • Of Woman Born: Motherhood as Experience and Institution
  • Bad Mother: A Chronicle of Maternal Crimes, Minor Calamities, and Occasional Moments of Grace
  • The Means of Reproduction: Sex, Power, and the Future of the World
  • Why Have Kids?: A New Mom Explores the Truth About Parenting and Happiness
  • The Feminine Mistake: Are We Giving Up Too Much?
  • Taking Back Childhood: Helping Your Kids Thrive in a Fast-Paced, Media-Saturated, Violence-Filled World
We've Got Issues: Children and Parents in the Age of Medication Hillary Clinton: The Inside Story: Revised and Updated We've Got Issues Newt Gingrich: Speaker to America Your Conflict Cookbook: A Teacher's Handbook for Helping Students Deal with Anger and Violence

Share This Book

“Too many of us now allow ourselves to be defined by motherhood and direct every ounce of our energy into our children. This sounds noble on the surface but in fact it's doing no one-- not ourselves, or our children -- any good. Because when we lose ourselves in our mommy selves, we experience this loss as depression. When we disempower ourselves in our mommy selves, we experience this weakness as anxiety. When we desexualize ourselves in our mommy selves, it leads us to feel dead in our skin. All this places an undue burden upon our children. By making them the be-all-and-end-all of our lives, by breaking down the boundaries between ourselves and them so thoroughly, by giving them so much power within the family when they're very small, we risk overwhelming them psychologically and ill-preparing them, socially, for the world of other children and, eventually, other adults. Nursery school and kindergarten teachers are already complaining that our children are so indulged, made so royal at home, that they come to school lacking compassion for others and with real problems functioning socially.” 2 likes
“For too many women in America are becoming sick with exhaustion and stress as they try to do things that can't be -- shouldn't be -- done. Too many are eaten up by resentment toward their husbands, who are not subject to the same heartless pressures. Too many are becoming anxious and depressed because they are overwhelmed and disappointed. Too many are letting their lives be poisoned by guilt because their expectations can't be met, and because there is an enormous cognitive dissonance between what they know to be right for themselves and what they're told is right for their children. Too many feel out of control.” 2 likes
More quotes…