Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “In the Shadow of Gotham” as Want to Read:
In the Shadow of Gotham
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

In the Shadow of Gotham (Simon Ziele #1)

3.47 of 5 stars 3.47  ·  rating details  ·  3,027 ratings  ·  463 reviews
Dobson, New York, 1905.

Detective Simon Ziele lost his fiancée in the General Slocum ferry disaster—a thousand perished on that summer day in 1904 when an onboard fire burned the boat down in the waters of the East River. Still reeling from the tragedy, Ziele transferred to a police department north of New York, to escape the city and all the memories it conjured.

But only a
ebook, 400 pages
Published April 28th 2009 by Minotaur Books
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about In the Shadow of Gotham, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about In the Shadow of Gotham

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
First Sentence: The scream that pierced the dull yellow November sky was preternaturally high-pitched.

Simon Ziele left being a policeman in New York City after a personal tragedy and injury. Now in the New York, East River town of Dobson, a young woman has been brutally killed while staying with her aunt. Simon is surprised when noted criminologist, Alistair Sinclair, proclaims he knows the killer. But does he?

I really did want to like this book but there were just too many things wrong with it.
Apr 04, 2011 Sue rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: readers of historical fiction, historical mystery and crime
Ah!! A new historical fiction series for me to enjoy. Set in 1905, this first entry involves a brutal murder in a small town just outside New York city and pulls in a former city policeman who now lives in that community. The reader is treated to a picture of the state of crime-fighting at that time, with wonderful visual pictures of the New York and suburban streets. New methods of understanding criminal behavior are being tested during the search for the killer.

Highly recommended for those who
Not very good at all. This book was nominated for the Anthony Award for best first and won the Edgar in the same category which frankly baffles me. The plotting was simplistic (Whodunit was painfully obvious), characters were thin and wooden, and even the historical details were not interesting. This ranks up there as one of the most boring books I have ever finished.
Talulah Mankiller
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
The reason it took me so long to get into this story is that Pintoff failed to create a realistic picture of New York in 1905 for me. She did plenty of research and threw in random facts about the era that distracted from the story, but I needed them to remind me that this was indeed historical fiction. Little things like a telephone in every residence with no mention of switchboard operators and a police photographer excessively snapping shots of a crime scene even though cameras were just rece ...more
Joyce Lagow
Winner of the 2010 Edgar Award for Debut mystery novel, In The Shadow of Gotham is set in the New York City of 1905. It pairs up a young detective with a criminologist--therefore setting up inevitable comparisons with Caleb Carr's series set in the same time frame and with somewhat the same setup. But the comparison begins and ends there, because Pintoff's novel comes nowhere near Carr's series in either writing quality, evocation of setting or, in particular, characterization. The last is most ...more
Catherine Siemann
Historical mysteries set in New York City are like catnip to me -- I love NYC history, and I love seeing how the author will play with the conventions. This one, set in 1905, was . . . pretty good. There were some anachronisms and other slips that jarred me: particularly a reference to a man's shirtwaist (wouldn't it be shirtwaists for women and shirts for men at that time?) and a couple of academic specifics about journal publication and "professor emeritus" (a 55 year old man who was still tea ...more
In the Shadow of Gotham (Minotaur 2009) introduces Simon Ziele, a police detective who lost his fiancee and the full use of his right arm in the 1904 wreck of the steamship General Slocum. Ziele has relocated from New York City to the town of Dobson, hoping for a quieter existence and time to recover from his loss, but the brutal and bloody murder of young mathematics student Sarah Wingate shatters his peaceful retreat. The investigation has barely begun when Ziele receives a communication from ...more
A completely enjoyable read by a new author. In the Shadow of Gotham is detective mystery novel that takes place in NYC at the very beginning of the 20th century. Detective Ziele partners up with a professor of criminology to find the person who killed a brilliant female math student. As far as detective novels go, it's not original or innovative, but it's extremely well-written and while I correctly identified the perpetrator near the beginning, Pintoff kept things mysterious enough that I alwa ...more
This is a very character driven book. That's certainly unusual for a mystery since setting and location often play a huge part in crime fiction. The story is set in the shadow of NY (hence the title) but the setting itself is very vague and not knowing NY very much at all I couldn't orient myself simply by namedropped landmarks and street numbers.

It was rather fascinating to read a historical mystery set at the turn of the century just when criminology and the attempt to understand the criminal
Deborah Cater
Feb 06, 2014 Deborah Cater rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Nobody!
This novel won the author two awards for best first crime novel and I am trying to figure out why. The premise of the novel is good - turn of the (20th) century New York is the location, combined with an insight into the suffragette movement, the emerging sciences of forensics and psychological profiling, a detective who has a decent back-story and a suitably disturbed killer. Sadly, Pintoff failed to deliver.

There was no feeling of place – New York was as flat as a theatre back-drop; the charac
Here's a debut well worth reading. If you like forensics, the workings of the criminal mind or books like Caleb Carr's Alienist, In the Shadow of Gotham should be on your TBR list.

After losing his fiancee in the Slocum Ferry disaster, police detective, Simon Ziele, in hopes of fleeing his memories, escapes New York City and relocates several miles north to Dobson, a quiet village. His quiet is soon interrupted with the brutal stabbing and death of Sarah Wingate. Very early on Ziele is contacted
Barbara Storey
I picked up this book - and the sequel to it - just before Christmas because they were remainders and cheap, and the reviews on the covers compared them to Caleb Carr's "The Alienist." And I have to say . . . I really regret buying both of them. Because "In the Shadow of Gotham" is BAD.

The idea - the mystery itself and the plot - are okay, and would have been much more interesting in the hands of a good writer. Sadly, Pintoff is not a good writer. She overwrites extensively - putting information
When I started looking for a final book for the Criminal Plots III Reading Challenge (Read a novel that's been nominated for and Edgar in the last five years), I was relieved to find In the Shadow of Gotham by Stefanie Pintoff sitting on my shelves since I'm trying really hard to read more from my own stacks. I'm not much for reading more recent books, but I had picked this one up last May while browsing in our Friends of the Library used book store. It was purely a whim--based on the cover, the ...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
I was rather disappointed by this book. It was well-written but the story was pretty pedestrian and the mystery aspect was rather weak. It was obvious from early on who the murderer was and the motive was predictable as well, leading to a boring ending. The lead character was not much of an investigator and did not display impressive police skills. I picked this up due to the comparisons to "The Alienist", which I loved, but this book is not in the same ballpark.
Historical fiction and murder mystery all rolled into one book. Really loved how the author used the early days of forensics to solve her crimes. This one was a real page turner and while I was able to figure out whodunit, this one still kept me guessing with some of the details up until the end. I can see why Pintoff was a finalist for the Edgar award. I am happy to see there is another book with Detective Simon Ziele.
Three and a half stars.

Very good detective mystery novel with a historical setting of New York in 1905. The author did her homework in the forensics of the era so the authenticity rings true. I am also in awe of any mystery novel in which the identity of the murderer remain unclear to me until the end. The story does offer lots of red herrings. Overall a pleasant mystery worth the time to read.
This is a great first novel. I can only imaginge that Ms. Pintoff's future books will get better and better.
I think the word "lacking" best describes my feelings about this story. It's lacking in characterization, twists, and the the author's ability to edit unnecessary *stuff*.

Characterization: I really couldn't care about any one character. Everyone is horribly boring and one-dimensional. Even the backstories we're given are weak and predictable.

Twists: Maybe because I've read a lot of Deaver, I've become spoiled and expect great twists in detective fiction. I'm usually pretty bad at figuring out w
It is 1904 and Detective Simon Ziele fled New York City to take a job in the small town of Dobson, New York after his fiancée is tragically killed. Soon after he arrives, the horrific murder of a young woman in her own home is committed in Dobson and it eventually leads Simon back the city and Columbia University where renowned criminologist, Alistair Sinclair helps him investigate a man he has studied that he believes is the prime suspect in the case.

In the Shadow of Gotham by Stefanie Pintoff
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
It’s the year 1905 in Dobson, New York. On a mild winter evening, someone brutally murders Sarah Wingate in her bedroom while she’s visiting relatives. A brilliant mathematician, she had a promising future ahead of her. So why would anyone want to kill her?

After the death of his fiancée on the General Slocum ferry disaster in the summer of 1904, Detective Simon Ziele transfers to a police department north of New York, away from the city, to heal. He didn’t expect to encounter a vicious homicide
I picked up Stefanie Pintoff's "In the Shadow of Gotham" looking for a good historical fiction with plenty of thrills. As someone who enjoys murder mysteries and New York's history, this book had a lot of promise. Unfortunately, it did not deliver.

The story itself meanders quite a bit and is very talky, with little excitement. There is a great deal of focus on criminology, which the author clearly researched is some detail. While the plotline does eventually take some interesting twists and is i
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
I saw Pintoff’s books recommended in an article by Jason Pinter, and knew immediately that I had to add them to my wish list. This was an entertaining depiction of turn-of-the-century investigation, where one often had to rely more upon luck than physical evidence. Not only do we see the earliest days of forensics, where even fingerprinting is brand new, but we see the beginnings of the use of criminology. It’s a time period I find particularly interesting to read about; a world caught somewhere ...more
Kelly Belvis
Having read several mysteries recently, I found this to be a pleasant variation on the theme. This particular mystery is set in 1905 New York. I enjoyed the historical details, the criminolgy and the characters. I don't read mysteries because I enjoy trying to solve the puzzle of the murder, I read mysteries because I want to solve the puzzle of the detective, what is his motivation, is he truly good or is he just the flip side of the criminal coin? In this case the detective was Simon Ziele, a ...more
Excellent first mystery! This book has been compared to The Alienist, and while I see this, I like the police procedural aspect of it.

Simon Ziele has left New York City proper to move north to Dobson, so live the small town life. A horrible murder is committed there, which brings him back to the city, as it seems the murderer may have come from there. A criminalogist from Columbia University gets involved very quickly, as the murder was done in the manner of one of his research subjects. This no
My first historical true crime novel. I guessed who the killer was about 1/2 way through. Prose could be kind of wooden at times but I learned some interesting things about NYC at the time.
Deb Novack
This being a debut novel, it was unbelievable. How wonderful and attention holding it was. I loved Simon the lead detective, Alastair and Isabella his daughter in law. I have become quite a fan of Victorian historical mysteries.

Ms. Pintoff did her research well, when she could use actual facts she did and when she had to add to the actual facts she did a wonderful job. I am currently reading the Secret of the White Rose and only just beginning it I know it will be another good one.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Hades
  • The Rhetoric of Death
  • The Fifth Servant
  • King of the Godfathers
  • The Frightened Man (Denton, #1)
  • Blind Man's Alley
  • The Battle for Gotham: New York in the Shadow of Robert Moses and Jane Jacobs
  • Dolly Departed (Gretchen Birch, #3)
  • The Marx Sisters (Brock & Kolla, #1)
  • River of Darkness (John Madden, #1)
  • American Passage: The History of Ellis Island
  • Crossing the Lion (Reigning Cats & Dogs Mystery, #9)
  • Game of Patience (Aristide Ravel, #3)
  • The Cold Light of Mourning (A Penny Brannigan Mystery #1)
  • In a Gilded Cage (Molly Murphy, #8)
  • Beyond Seduction (The Red Choo Diaries) (Harlequin Blaze #321)
  • Getting Old Is to Die For (Gladdy Gold, #4)
  • Some Danger Involved (Barker & Llewelyn, #1)
Stefanie Pintoff is the Edgar award-winning author of HOSTAGE TAKER and the Simon Ziele historical mysteries. Her writing has also won the Washington Irving Book Prize and earned nominations for the Anthony, Macavity, and Agatha awards. Pintoff's novels have been published around the world, including the United Kingdom, Italy, Croatia, and Japan. She lives on Manhattan's Upper West Side, where she ...more
More about Stefanie Pintoff...

Other Books in the Series

Simon Ziele (3 books)
  • A Curtain Falls (Simon Ziele, #2)
  • Secret of the White Rose (Simon Ziele, #3)

Share This Book