Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “When Atheism Becomes Religion: America's New Fundamentalists” as Want to Read:
When Atheism Becomes Religion: America's New Fundamentalists
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

When Atheism Becomes Religion: America's New Fundamentalists

3.48 of 5 stars 3.48  ·  rating details  ·  695 ratings  ·  157 reviews
From the New York Times bestselling author of American Fascists and the NBCC finalist for War Is a Force That Gives Us Meaning comes this timely and compelling work about new atheists: those who attack religion to advance the worst of global capitalism, intolerance and imperial projects.

Chris Hedges, who graduated from seminary at Harvard Divinity School, has long been a
ebook, 224 pages
Published March 10th 2009 by Free Press (first published March 1st 2008)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about When Atheism Becomes Religion, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about When Atheism Becomes Religion

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,575)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Stu Minnis
I opened up this book fully expecting to find some well-formed criticism of the less intelligent aspects of the new atheist "movement." I too had felt that Hitchens and Harris especially paint Islam with too broad a brush. But instead of a the insight I've come to expect from Hedges in the past, what I found was a deeply dishonest work that paints not with a broad brush but with paint balloons. Hedges represents the ideas of "these atheists" so falsely, with so much ad hominem rudeness and remov ...more
Apr 09, 2009 Trevor rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Trevor by: Ginnie
Shelves: religion
The title of this one was bound to annoy me. I had, about a year ago, started another book with a similar title – God Does Not Believe in Atheists – and quickly came to the conclusion that God’s problem, in this case, is that he doesn’t exist and therefore can’t believe in anything.

Ginnie pointed to this book as worth reading and said that the title wasn’t a very good title or reflection of his main point in writing the book. It is not the title I would have chosen for the book, but then, it is
Joshua Stein
I swore to a friend that I would give this book a chance, and for a few moments I expected Hedges to provide a serious answer to the quandries offered to apologists by the Four Horsemen of atheism (Dawkins, Dennett, Harris and Hitchens). The book, unfortunately, failed me, as you can plainly see by my rating.

The fact is, Hedges' triteness makes the text unbearable and the fact that he does not even really provide any original ideas makes it all the more painful. The tooth-pulling sensation I got
This is truly bad. I kind of wanted to throw the book into a fire.

Chris Hedges makes sweeping generalizations about the "new atheists", ones that make it impossible to take his points seriously. I can't tell if he's being intentionally daft and lazy, in failing to cite almost ANY specifics (ie, say, a quote, because some of the things he says that Dawkins, for example, claim, are clearly taken way out of context and misconstrued). Or he really believes the conclusions he has reached, through re
Clif Hostetler
This book provides the best critic of the so called "new atheism" that I've encountered thus far. The book articulates the position that seeking the transcendent experience is an integral part of the human experience. Suggestions that progress in human knowledge and science make religion unnecessary is labeled as arrogance out of touch with human nature. The author comes from a Christian background; He even has seminary training. However, this book is a defense of all religions, not just Christi ...more
Reading this book was painful. There seems to be absolutely no logical structure to Hedges' argument. Hedges also presents himself as an expert on "human nature," making all types of conclusive statements and generalizations on the subject. Quotes from the "new atheists" are often presented with little context. He also doesn't really grapple much with the logical arguments for or against the existence of a supernatural omnipotent being. I think Hedges is a smart guy, but this was a really sad ef ...more
I see how a lot of people pan this book, and I think maybe it is because people are afraid to open their eyes and see the similarities between the New Atheists and fundamentalism. This book resonates with me, as it should with anyone who knows well people of all faiths. It is a call for moderation. It is a call to question wether science can answer all things. Hedges, and I, think it can't. Hedges points out the universe physically is morally neutral, our ability to learn and use the universe ar ...more
Tulpesh Patel
The story of how When Atheism Becomes a Religion got into my hands is almost more interesting than what’s contained within its pages. In 2009, whilst working at the University of California, Los Angeles, a friend tried to post me a copy, having found it in a Borders bargain bin and thinking, quite rightly, that it would be something I would be interested in. Two weeks later it was returned to her with "Unauthorized Circulation: Religious Content (Int'l) RTS" written on the package. She kept the ...more
To see the Hedges/Harris debate, go to YouTube and search, "Religion, politics and the end of the world." (I know I put this later in the review, but I thought it was worth it to go back and put it at the top.)

Premise: People do not advance morally at the same rate as they advance scientifically. “Those who teach that religion is evil and science and reason will save us are as deluded as those who believe in angels and demons. …Science and human reason, like institutional religion, have delivere
This is the best book I've read in a long time with the worst title I've ever seen.
Despite my love for Chris Hedges I shelved this book for awhile because the prologue focuses on Sam Harris, and I thought to myself, "I like Sam Harris but I don't need you to tell me he's a racist; that doesn't discount the non-Islamophobic things he says."

This book is not really about atheism. It's about the current wave of "new atheists" which, in Hedges mind, err just as foolishly as their Religious Right coun
The thesis, or at least the vague "Boo Hitchens, Dawkins, Harris, and Dennett!" sentiment that is meant to substitute for a thesis, is poorly argued, and the prose often drags for pages with enervating repetitions of simple contentions. In places the book turns to a boilerplate essay on the moral neutrality of science, with all the boredom and eye rolling that such usually entails. Here and there, Hedges manages to present criticisms of Harris, Dawkins and Hitchens (taken individually) which are ...more
Chris Hedges recently released American Fascists. i haven't read the book but i do know that it is a critique of the Christian fundamentalist movement in the US. Apparently, not wanting the atheists get away from his wrath, he penned I Don't Believe in Atheists. And wrath is exactly what the first two thirds of this work read like. Hedges rants and raves about the extreme positions of both atheist and fundamentalist thinkers. He tries to establish a middle ground but only sloppily so.

i do agree
Chris Hedges seems to have written this book just as a follow-up to some debates he did with Sam Harris and Christopher Hitchens. Fine, there's a lot to criticize in Harris (I haven't read Hitchens). His major criticism is a kind of "utopian fundamentalism" that he imputes to both atheist and religious extremists, presumably promoting moderation for everyone (although he basically only criticizes others rather than offering any positive ideas of his own). He blames, or at least implies blame on ...more
I was inclined to like this book just from its premise, but I was totally disappointed. Hedges claims that Hitchens, Dawkins, et al as mirror-image fundamentalists to Pat Robertson and Jerry Falwell, a view I cannot hold. Hedges rants and rants against atheist "fundamentalism" with hardly a citation.
Couldn't put this book down, a must-read.
Serge Boucher
What a dreadful book. It has its moments ("We have nothing to fear from those who do, or do not, believe in God. We have much to fear from those who don't believe in sin.") but as an attack on the new atheists, which is how the author presents it, it's appalling.

Hedges central argument mixes all the new atheists in one big lump, referring to them usually as "these atheists", and claim that what they offer is a utopian vision, some perfect society that we could all enjoy if only all their opponen
First, I should say that I read Hedges’s Empire of Illusion and loved it. After reading it, I characterized him as smart, well-informed, and courageous enough to speak the truth--not to mention an elegant writer. But I Don’t Believe in Atheists has problems.

The title alone is cutesy and reflects the vagueness of Hedges’s entire argument. It indicates that the book will be about atheists in general, although Hedges primarily targets the “new atheists” such as Harris, Dawkins, and Hitchens—sometim
On the back of the copy I found it said "The battle between these new atheists and the religious fundamentalists engages two bizarre subsets of American Culture. One distorts the scientific theory of evolution, applying it to complex social, economic and political systems it was never designed to explain. The other insists that the six day story of creation in Genesis is fact and Jesus will descend from the sky to establish the kingdom of God on earth. Neither God nor Science , will protect us f ...more
Justin Tapp
I read Dawkins, Harris, and Hitchens before reading this book, along with Stephen Hawking and Brian Greene. I would recommend reading this book after reading theirs. Chris Hedges debated Hitchens and Harris, inspiring him to collect the arguments in this book. Hedges is a foreign correspondent, covering multiple wars and directing the Middle East bureau of the NY Times. He is no evangelical, he grew up a liberal Presbyterian that rejects certain parts of the Bible as literal (This creates some l ...more
Fred Kohn
You know a book is great when you find yourself regretting finishing it. So if you find yourself rushing through the last few pages of a book because you're so anxious to be done with it, it's likely a horrible book. I couldn't bring myself to make this a one star book, because Hedges does bring to the table his vast experience as a journalist in the Middle East, among other troubled places. Thus he is in a good position to make a cogent critique of the ignorant rants against Islam by Sam Harris ...more
Louis, I agreed with you when you said that Hedges seems to equi-demonize Christian fundamentalists and the new atheists after I had read War is a Force that Gives Meaning.

I was trying to figure out after reading this book what bothered me. I can agree with so much, especially his sense of sin. Very Augustinian as he himself affirms.

But something is missing. He says a couple of times that man is irredeemable, or something to that effect. And I realized that what is missing is hope.

He seems to be
My circle includes atheists and some who believe in a higher power. I value the diversity of opinions in my group. But fundamentalist atheists don't want that diversity. Like fundamentalists of all stripes, they believe in a utopia that would be created if only everyone would just listen to their reasoning and run the world their way - dismissing those with contradictory opinions. It is that notion of dismissal that should scare us all.

Chris Hedges exposes the common threads of this (my pun int
This is a fine book with a suitably ambiguous title, which interestingly was changed to When Atheism Becomes Religion: America's New Fundamentalists, for the paperback. It challenges a number of important issues in fewer than 200 pages. First, he goes after the new atheists: Dawkins, Dennett, Hitchens, Harris. I have read many of Dawkins books on evolution. He's a calm and extremely lucid writer. Then came The God Delusion, a rant against religion, with Dawkins sounding like a secular Pat Robert ...more
Fortunately for the reader, Hedges decided to keep his overblown screed short. Really, there is little here for either the theist or atheist.

I found myself in a strange position going into this book as a follower of Hedges' journalism and an atheist who is not the biggest fan of the so-called "new" atheism. Hedges targets Christopher Hitchens and Sam Harris specifically in places, but slips between indicting those two, the "new" atheists, and atheists in general. This ends up being a fatal flaw
Often Partisan
In some ways, I'm not quite sure what to make of this book. I have read [Book: The God Delusion], The End of Faith & Letter to a Christian Nation, God is Not Great and Breaking the Spell, so I am familiar with the work of the "New Atheists". I read the books quote a while ago, and read this one a few months ago. I honestly think it's a bit difficult to review, simply because my views (not on the god debate, but politically) have changed since both I read the New Atheists and since I read thi ...more
Dec 07, 2008 Tucker rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Tucker by: I saw a clip of Chris Hedges interviewed on the Colbert Report
Instead of following the predictable career trajectory for a man with his Master of Divinity degree and an undergraduate degree in literature, Chris Hedges spent two decades reporting from the worst war zones all over the world. His opinions on human nature are especially valuable simply because they stem from this unique combination of education and experience.

My opinion of the book is mixed. Based on the title, I expected it a reactionary Christian screed, and was pleasantly surprised to find
Jun 29, 2009 Christopher rated it 1 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: nobody
Shelves: abandoned
This book was rubbish. It was nothing but an opportunity for the author to air out some personal grievances he has with a couple of prominent atheists he happened to debate.

His main argument is that atheists are similar to Abrahamic fundamentalists in that they --

1. Use their belief in Utopia to justify all manners of violent atrocities.
2. Are inherently racist towards Muslims.
3. Are unwilling to entertain opinions and viewpoints that differ from their own.

I read about half of the book before I
Matthew Klippenstein
I'd approached the book cautiously, not knowing much about Hedges, but recognizing that, after reading Dawkins and Hitchens, I owed it to myself to read their critics. (At least the ones who don't hold to literalist interpretations of their particular religious writings.)

To my surprise, the author blew me away with his methodical dissection of the New Atheism. His demonstration that the more strident New Atheists adopt the same rhetorical tactics as their Fundamentalist opponents was on its own,
Chris Hedges points out why both religious fundamentalists, and the crop of recent atheist authors, are wrong in their belief system. Unless you're making a study of these subjects, however, you may find it hard to stay focused, as I did, at least in the audiobook format. It seemed as if Hedges quoted every philosopher and author, ancient and current, in making his point(s), but other than showing why the absolute fundamentalists and atheist's are both wrong, I'm not sure I understood what Hedge ...more
A few of the chapters made it worth reading, but this is at times a toilsome, repetitive book; the premise of which I agree with. I do not believe that humanity progresses morally, and I believe that religions are a helpful and often necessary framework for morality and to explain the human condition. There is a dark side to religion because there is a dark side to humanity itself. Religion is a powerful tool that can lead to great beauty and altruism, or to elevate rules, written word and custo ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 52 53 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Limitation 4 32 Jan 28, 2012 11:37AM  
  • Reason, Faith, and Revolution: Reflections on the God Debate
  • The Twilight of Atheism: The Rise and Fall of Disbelief in the Modern World
  • God and the New Atheism: A Critical Response to Dawkins, Harris, and Hitchens
  • Kingdom Coming: The Rise of Christian Nationalism
  • Atheism: A Philosophical Justification
  • Love the Sin: Sexual Regulation and the Limits of Religious Tolerance
  • Philosophers Without Gods: Meditations on Atheism and the Secular Life
  • Why I Am Not a Christian: Four Conclusive Reasons to Reject the Faith
  • Engaging the Powers: Discernment and Resistance in a World of Domination (Powers, #3)
  • Fifty Key Contemporary Thinkers: From Structuralism to Postmodernity
  • C Street: The Fundamentalist Threat to American Democracy
  • Atheism: A Reader
  • The Atheist's Fatal Flaw: Exposing Conflicting Beliefs
  • Losing Faith in Faith: From Preacher to Atheist
  • Life is a Miracle: An Essay Against Modern Superstition
  • The U.S. Constitution: And Fascinating Facts About It
  • It's Really All about God: Reflections of a Muslim Atheist Jewish Christian
  • The Irony of American History
Christopher Lynn Hedges is an American journalist, author, and war correspondent, specializing in American and Middle Eastern politics and societies.
Hedges is known as the best-selling author of War is a Force That Gives Us Meaning (2002), which was a finalist for the National Book Critics Circle Award for Nonfiction.
Chris Hedges is currently a senior fellow at The Nation Institute in New York Ci
More about Chris Hedges...
War Is a Force That Gives Us Meaning Empire of Illusion: The End of Literacy and the Triumph of Spectacle American Fascists: The Christian Right and the War on America The Death of the Liberal Class Days of Destruction, Days of Revolt

Share This Book

“The greatest danger that besets us does not come from believers or atheists; it comes from those who, under the guise of religion, science or reason, imagine that we can free ourselves from the limitations of human nature and perfect the human species.” 39 likes
“The danger is not Islam or Christianity or any other religion. It is the human heart—the capacity we all have for evil. All human institutions with a lust for power give their utopian visions divine sanction” 5 likes
More quotes…