The Italian Secretary: A Further Adventure of Sherlock Holmes
My rating:
didn't like it it was ok liked it really liked it it was amazing
add to my books

The Italian Secretary: A Further Adventure of Sherlock Holmes

3.06 of 5 stars 3.06  ·  rating details  ·  1,785 ratings  ·  241 reviews

Caleb Carr’s novel, The Alienest, was a blockbuster international bestseller and positioned its author as a modern master of the historical thriller. Now, Carr reaches back further, to the age of opium dens and Jack the Ripper, when fictional detective Sherlock Holmes made the science of murder as real as the gore on a killer’s hands…

FOUL WHISPERINGS…

Mycroft Holmes’s

...more
Paperback, 352 pages
Published October 27th 2009 by St. Martin's Griffin (first published 2005)
more details... edit details
There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!
sign in »

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is currently not featured on any Listopia lists. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 2,800)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Brad
The Italian Secretary is a pretty sweet piece of Sherlock Holmes apocrypha. There have been a number of attempts to write Holmes by authors other than Doyle, and those attempts have achieved varying degrees of success -- some dreadful and some impressive. Caleb Carr's attempt falls between these extremes, although it is tilted more toward the impressive end of the teeter-totter.

Carr does a fine job of capturing Holmes' rhythms and personality, and one never feels like one's reading a...more
Tyas
Number one, the translation caused me a headache.

The translation aside, this book is disappointing: the case might be 'sensational' and 'sadistic', but the way the case is solved did not satisfy me. I think that there are still questions left unanswered. And seriously, those ghosts are unnecessary, something like disturbing Holmes' world of logic. The ghosts would fit a Professor Challenger story, but in Italian Secretary it only boiled down to raised eyebrows (of the reader, whic...more
Snowfire
Conflicted thoughts here. Short version: Style is good, Watson's authorial voice is good, general overview of the plot is good. However, using Mycroft as a character still has problems, the spiritual / ghost angle ends up being lame IMHO, and - worst of all- the last quarter of the book has too many silly things and dumb yet irrelevant plot turns. Silly in a bad way. The final confrontation is also... bah.

So... rewrite the last quarter of the book to get the same point across b...more
Jennifer Petkus
I had such high hopes for The Italian Secretary by Caleb Carr. My husband surprised me with it just after I had started to renew my addiction to Holmes and had read several mentions of it at the Sherlock Holmes Social Network.

Of course, those mentions were not generally favorable, but the setting of a murder at the Royal Palace of Holyrood in Edinburgh, Scotland sounded so inviting. Here’s the basic plot: After several assassination attempts on Queen Victoria, Holmes and Watson are bro...more
Lisa
It's always difficult when you read a book that an author has written in a style faithful to an original work. There's often a sense of forced effort in bringing that different voice out; it's too easy to go over the top in attempting to recreate a style that is not the author's own.

In this case, Carr does tap into the expected Sherlock Holmes plot points, with the usual conclusions drawn from observation and mentions of previous cases, and the Watson created is generally well done....more
Catherine
I was a huge fan of the "The Alienist" and its prequel "Angel of Darkness," so I had very high expectations for this book. While Carr does a good job of capturing the voice and style of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and masterfully describes the haunting bleakness of nineteenth century Scotland, I find Carr's own style, set forth with such skill in "The Alienist" and "Angel of Darkness," much more engaging. Somehow, "the Italian Secretary," never real...more
Dana Kujan
I loved "The Alienist," passed it around my family, so I had really high expectations for Carr's take on Holmes. I have never been so disappointed! I hated this book so much by page 50 that I started writing post-it notes to myself and slapping them on the most offensive pages.

Page 83: Why are we still on the damn train!? We've spent 50 pages sitting. On a train. I know Mycroft's a big ol' potato, but Sherlock should have to stretch his legs. And what of Watson's leg wound?...more
Bruce
Bruce rated it 2 of 5 stars
Picking up his pen and writing a Sherlock Holmes story, as have so many authors since ACD published his collection so many years ago, Carr’s editorial comments in his early chapters seem to suggest that he is using this device in part to create a narrative about terrorism and the domestic response to it, no surprise given his concern about this issue that resulted in his non-fiction work of 2002, The Lessons of Terror, a work that I found troubling in its implications, espousing as it did preemp...more
Lori
I enjoyed Caleb Carr's The Italian Secretary. Any Holmes fan big or small can appreciate the effort put forth by Mr. Carr in this enjoyable novel penned as a "further adventure of Sherlock Holmes" The story takes place in the ghost infested Holyroodhouse which was the castle of the ill fated Mary Queen of Scots. A cryptic message from Mycroft Holmes protrayed here in a rather unpleasant light as the bigger less able brother of Sherlock sends Dr. Watson and Mr Holmes hurtling towards Ed...more
Kayt
This book seemed to go by quite quickly. It was good--having read Carr's two other history mysteries (The Alienist and Angel of Darkness) I was confident in this book; there was not the uncertainty I sometimes feel when reading a continuing-Holmes book by an unknown author.

However, I'm not sure Carr's writing style translated completely well to a Holmes story. The case was confusing--halfway through, I had to struggle to remember what the actual problem was. The characters themselves...more
Donna
I have only read one Conan Doyle Sherlock Holmes story before, The Hound of the Baskervilles. Spotting The Italian Secretary in a secondhand bookshop, I picked it up because it was written by Caleb Carr, and I didn't really notice it was a Sherlock Holmes story until I got home.
Caleb Carr was a great choice to write a further adventure of Sherlock Holmes. His own novels The Alienist and The Angel of Darkness are about a Victorian detective too although this time in New York, and he certa...more
Kathryn
I have always liked Caleb Carr’s books (both fiction and nonfiction), and I love Sherlock Holmes stuff, and Richard is of the same mind as me on Carr and Holmes. So when Richard found this unabridged audiobook, we both decided that it would be good to listen to on our vacation, and so it was; we both enjoyed it immensely.
All good Sherlockania is in the voice of Doctor Watson, and so this book is; the book starts in Baker Street, with a crytic telegram from Holmes’ older brother Mycroft, de...more
Liz Nutting
As someone who used to dabble in the world of fan fiction, I've always been baffled by the resistance of some authors to fan-originated treatments of their characters. I understand the standard response: Works of literature are the author's bread and butter and to allow someone else to encroach on the same territory cheapens the original product, the way a faux Gucci bag sold on a New York City street cheapens the original Gucci brand. But I think there is a fundamental flaw in that logic, at le...more
Laura
Caleb Carr was commissioned by the estate of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle to write a book that could be considered the official "further adventures of Sherlock Holmes" and so he set out to recreate Conan Doyle's original style in all its Victorian glory. And I think that for the most part Carr has succeeded: the language, the sentence structure, and the general "feel" of the original stories are faithfully recreated in Carr's book, and although he can't resist adding a few more gor...more
Joseph
I got about three quarters of the way through the book before realizing that I'd read it before some years ago. Normally, I'd blame this on my own shoddy memory, but I think this is a case of the book just not being very memorable. While the book isn't bad, per se, Carr adds nothing to the Holmes canon.

His characterization is merely adequate. Holmes seemed strangely passive, while Carr was clearly more interested in Watson. It's nice that he found more for him to do than stand around...more
Jenny
This was a quick read but I thought it wasn't very well thought out.

There were minor details mentioned that were brought in later on - but because they were in one line of dialogue, I missed the first time. Maybe I wasn't a thorough-enough reader, but there were a lot of times I found myself flipping back through the pages trying to figure out what was going on. (I.e. trying to keep track of where the Queen was - Edinburgh or Balmoral) Also why was Miss McKenzie hiding? Gah.

...more
Mike
This book takes the bronze of the three Caleb Carr's that I have read so far. I would not be terribly surprised if the next book I read by him knocks The Italian Secretary out of medal contention completely. I really enjoyed The Alienist and The Angel of Darkness and I liked the second half of this one, but the first part of this book seemed as if Carr was trying too hard to be Arthur Conan Doyle. His writing was convoluted and confusing at first and caused me to lose my focus, however as the bo...more
Janellyn51
The Italian Secretary started out as part of a Sherlock Holmes short story collection, by contemporary writers, with the basic theme having something to do with the supernatural. It was too long for a short story. Interesting from the standpoint that Sherlock is all about science and Conan Doyle was a huge believer, and supporter of Spiritualism. I liked the book, although compared to The Alienist, it didn't hold a candle. I did think that in reading it, I could plainly picture Nigel Bruce huffi...more
Maeve
Maeve rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: mystery readers
Just started reading this today. It's a Sherlock Holmes adventure written by Caleb Carr (he wrote the Alienist). I guess you could call it a Sherlock Holmes sequel. Seems a good, quick end-of-summer read.
Tim Dickenson
I was so excited to find another crime novel by Caleb Carr. I've enjoyed his historical fiction in the past like The Alienist. I quickly realized that The Italian Secretary was his continuation of the Sherlock Holmes genre, which seemed ok at first. But either I don't enjoy the Sherlock Holmes stories as much as I rememberered, or he missed the mark in his plotline and detail. I wasn't reading closely, but was continuously confused about the characters and the conclusions. The inclusion of ...more
Jeff Carpenter
Commissioned by the Sir Arthur Conan Doyle estate, Caleb Carr does a credible job of continuing the Holmes legacy. I have read some reviews where the reader felt like the ghost(s) detracted from the story. I did'nt personally feel this way, however, I did not think they added much to it either. The thought of the great Sherlock Holmes going up against a supernatural entity is pretty interesting although it did not really play out that way in this story. I don't want to give away too many details...more
Carly
Carly rated it 4 of 5 stars
Shelves: 2009
Carr is fast rising the list of authors I really adore. For Christmas, I asked for "Caleb Carr" books, and I must say, I was a bit nervous when I saw that this was a "Sherlock Holmes" book--I feared (ungrounded I now know) that while attempting to write in a Doyle-ish style, Carr might not be able to live up to the first book of his that I read--The Alienist. However, Carr performed amazingly. Although it has been a few months since I have recently read a Holmes story/book...more
Jason
I admit, I couldn't finish it, so you may wish to dismiss this review as unfair based on that fact.

The novel did manage to capture the trappings of the original in language and feel, and the author obviously has an excellent grounding in the period, and seemed well-versed in the Doyle originals--as they were casually referenced here and there in passing, but for all that, I just...couldn't...finish. I wanted to. I really wanted to enjoy this novel. But a combination of a never-endin...more
Laurie
I enjoyed it. From what I can recall of the style of the way Doyle wrote for Holmes and Watson, Carr seemed to keep true to the characters. There was a nice whimsical humor to the mystery that was pleasant. I loved the Mary Queen of Scots angle, as I enjoy reading historical fiction about royalty...so this was right up my alley. But the ending was a bit crazy. The thing is if I had not been so blown away by The Alienist and the sequel of The Alienist, I would have given this a higher rating...more
GuavaGal
I bought this book because I really enjoyed Caleb Carr's other books. . .and because it was really cheap.

It turns out that Carr is still an excellent story-teller and does a great job of mimicking Arthur Conan Doyle's style, but (as I vaguely remembered while reading the book), I don't love ACD's writing style. Still, thanks to the movie, I always think of Robert Downey Jr. as Holmes and Jude Law as Watson, so that was fairly entertaining. And, I enjoy an old-fashioned detective st...more
Linda
The subtitle of this book is "The Further Adventure of Sherlock Holmes." The author, Caleb Carr, was authorized by the estate of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle to write a Sherlock Holmes novel in his style. I think he accomplished this task very well. It reads like a Conan Doyle mystery, even with the original author's flaws. Conan Doyle was never big on character development, so Carr isn't either. Holmes wants to solve the mystery, but could care less for people's motivations for the cri...more
Joy
I'm not one to turn the pages so easily when it comes to Sherlock Holmes stories because of the writing style. It's not necessarily old English, but because of the formality and sentence structure, I read it very slowly to absorb what's happening. This one is a great story but it's filled with action, I was expecting a great display of Holmes's power of deductive reasoning but the way he's always subtle on things when he knows the answers is consistent. There were some dragging parts in the stor...more
Mary
I originally was drawn to this book because I have read others by Caleb Carr and enjoyed them. It was then a surprise to me to find that it was a "Further Adventure of Sherlock Holmes" book. A collection of new Sherlock stories that are written by contemporary mystery authors at the request of the Conan Doyle Estate. Having never read a Sherlock Holmes story before I cannot speak to how accurate it is to the original writing, characters or plot lines. I can say I enjoyed the stor...more
Stephanie
This is a fun mystery done as though it were another Sherlock Holmes mystery. I thought he had the tone just right (and the language is a good imitation of Conan Doyle's Victorian prose, especially the dialogue), but there are multiple gaping plot holes and unaddressed plot points. I kind of felt that the author had done it in a hurry and forgot to polish it. The ending is rushed, and I disagreed with his handling of some points in Holmes' character, but overall just a fun, light read for tho...more
Jennifer
Loved it! Other than Laurie R. King's Russell/Holmes mysteries, this book and author have come closest to recreating an authentic Holmes than any other author. Don't be lulled in by other books. This is the real deal! If you're like me and love Mary Russell's Holmes by Laurie R. King - go read this book immediately!! It created a Holmes so real, that I am convinced he did truly exist in our world! This book had so much to share of history, and the world of Holmes that I reread this book at least...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 93 94
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Goodreads Feedback: incorrect page count 3 27 Jan 04, 2012 07:40am  
The Italian Secretary (Mass Market Paperback)
The Italian Secretary: A Further Adventure of Sherlock Holmes (Hardcover)
The Italian Secretary: A Further Adventure Of Sherlock Holmes
Italian Secretary, The: A Further Adventure Of Sherlock Holmes (Paperback)
The Italian Secretary: A Further Adventure Of Sherlock Holmes

Readers Also Enjoyed

27779
Caleb Carr is an American novelist and military historian. The son of Lucien Carr, a former UPI editor and a key Beat generation figure, he was born in Manhattan and lived for much of his life on the Lower East Side.[1] He attended Kenyon College and New York University, earning a B.A. in military and diplomatic history. He is a contributing editor of MHQ: The Quarterly Journal of Military History...more
More about Caleb Carr...
The Alienist (Dr. Laszlo Kreizler, #1) The Angel of Darkness (Dr. Laszlo Kreizler, #2) Killing Time The Angel of Darkness and The Alienist The Devil Soldier

Share This Book

Your website
Pin It

L3
L3
5 members
last activity Jan 25, 2012 06:28am
shelf: read
Baker Street Irregulars
Baker Street Irregulars
251 members
last activity 3 hours, 12 min ago
shelf: to-read
East Texas Library Friends
East Texas Library Friends
79 members
last activity Jan 21, 2012 07:39am
shelf: to-read