Obedience to Authority

Obedience to Authority

4.17 of 5 stars 4.17  ·  rating details  ·  963 ratings  ·  63 reviews
The Dilema of ObedienceObedience is as basic an element in the structure of social life as one can point to. Some system of authority is a requirement of all communal living, and it is only the man dwelling in isolation who is not forced to respond, through defiance or submission, to the commands of others. Obedience, as a determinant of behavior is of particular relevance...more
Paperback, 256 pages
Published January 1st 1983 by Harper Perennial (first published 1974)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Predictably Irrational by Dan ArielyThe Power of Habit by Charles DuhiggThinking, Fast and Slow by Daniel KahnemanThe Tipping Point by Malcolm GladwellInfluence by Robert B. Cialdini
sparringmind.com's 50 Best Social Psychology Books
16th out of 60 books — 42 voters
The Selfish Gene by Richard DawkinsSway by Ori BrafmanEvolutionary Psychology by David M. BussObedience to Authority by Stanley Milgram
Lust
4th out of 4 books — 2 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 2,360)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Esteban del Mal
Science!

***

I like to tell people that my first religious experience was seeing the music video for Peter Gabriel's song Shock the Monkey. This experience, coupled with some subsequent churchgoing misadventures in my adolescence, is why I always have to suppress the desire to throw poop whenever I pass a church.

Hardly scientific, but it gets my point across: I don't do well with authority.

Stanley Milgram is a pioneer in social psychology. Why? Because he convinced people -- good, churchgoing pe...more
David
Stanley Milgram (1933-1984) made several groundbreaking contributions to our understanding of human behavior. He was a master of particularly inventive research: for instance, he devised the experimental method to investigate path lengths in social networks, establishing what is variously referred to as the "small world" effect, the Kevin Bacon effect, or "six degrees of separation".

He will always be remembered, however, as the man who conducted the “obedience studies”, a controversial series o...more
Rich V
Were Nazi soldiers just following orders in WWII? How would civilians in the U.S. respond to demands from authority figures to perform seemingly immoral acts? Where does the "just following orders" response fall on the scale of moral behavior?

Milgram conducted an experiment in which individuals were asked to administer increasingly intense shocks to an unseen test subject in the next room, whenever the subject answered a question incorrectly. Some individuals refused to continue administering s...more
Abraham
An oldie but goodie.

Milgram did the famous "Milgram Experiments" on obedience about 60 years ago, or more, but they are fascinating. For those of you who don't know, the Milgram experiments involved inviting unwitting people to come into a Yale laboratory to assist with an experiment that was allegedly about the effects of punishment on learning word pairs. In reality, the experiment was to see how far people would go in punishing other people whom they had never met. The "learner" (who was an...more
Dave
Jul 29, 2011 Dave added it
I think most people have at least heard of Stanley Milgram's famous experiment whereby he tested people's obedience to authority. The experiment is fiendishly clever. The subject is led to believe that they are the 'teacher' in an experiment about human memory. The 'student' is an actor. The 'experimenter' instructs the teacher to administer successively more powerful electric shocks to the student on each missed or wrong answer. Out of the thousands of people so tested, quite a few went all the...more
Steven Peterson
This is a classic work. It would also be unlikely to be approved by human subjects' review processes these days. Almost anyone who has taken an introductory psychology course will be familiar with the outlines of the piece of research described by Stanley Milgram in this book.

If you don't recall the author's name, you might recall the experiment. This is where people recruited to participate in the study were instructed to administer electric "shocks" to a person "wired" to a "generator." Of cou...more
Guy
This is a powerful cautionary tale about the nature of the human sheep. I see this book as an impetus for those truly interested in their own true individuality to begin the challenging, even painful, task of examining themselves in order to see and even understand where it is within them. Especially where they don't expect it, in the unconscious accepted truths of some so-called authority that they are following but which are invalid and destructive either personally or socially.

This book was...more
Joanne
There were sections that I found very interesting and engaging. Namely, the sections detailing the different experiments and the subjects' reactions to the experiment and their subsequent thoughts on it.

The chapters that were not so interesting to me were the ones about the reasons behind the actions of the subjects. While necessary I got lost in the sentences and really couldn't engage with these chapters of the books. It took me quite awhile to read these compared to the other chapters. Howeve...more
Brian
Extremely insightful and highly worth reading. If you're a rebel or conformist, you'll be surprised at all the trappings of authority, and how many people (men and women) went to 450 volts three times in a row simply because a fellow in a lab coat said so.

I'll share this:

"The behavior revealed in the experiments reported here is normal human behavior but revealed under conditions that show with particular clarity the danger to human survival inherent in our make-up. And what is it we have seen?...more
Shiv
Starting in 1961 American psychologist Stanley Milgram started a series of experiments which were to become some of the most famous and revealing in history. After the Nuremberg Trials a lot of people were asking how the Nazis could have carried out the atrocities they did, and a common defense presented by those on trial was "I was following orders". It was hard to believe, however, that people could really commit such heinous acts simply because they were ordered to. Milgrams experiments showe...more
Claire
Jun 06, 2012 Claire rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: those into psychology, sociology, research fields in these areas, war atrocities
Reading about scientific experiments written up this was is so enjoyable for me! This books steps you through Milgram's classic studies - which are more numerous than I was aware of, in terms of variation. It's a good example of how acute and critical yet open thinking in research can bring about a deeper understanding of human behavior. He and whoever he was working with, clearly explored a good number of possible explanations for displays of obedience in the presence of an authority.

(view spoi...more
Ling
This is an absolutely fantastic book. I hesitate to give it 5 stars because I reserve 5 stars for my favorite books ever. But make no mistake, this book is fantastic.
I'm not usually interested in psychology related books and I hesitated reading this book, thinking it might be a great bore and I may not even finish it. But I was mistaken. I was pleasantly surprised by how readable it is and how endlessly entertaining it is. I highly recommend this book for general readers and social scientists al...more
Adam Kranz
Milgram's book came at a fortuitous time for me, a time when I was experiencing a paradigm shift towards an obsession with social determinism. I had to read the book as part of my University's Freshman Studies curriculum, but I found that it fit extremely nicely into my personal intellectual search to understand what I refer to as the "Problem of Civilization." I had learned that there was a problem (a very serious one, at that) and I had learned what that problem was and how it worked.

But I di...more
Colin
An in depth look at a the classic examination of people and their willingness to obey to others. This book is a look at the classic experiment that occured on the Yale campus in the the early 1960s. There were many other experiments done testing certain parameters within the original design set up by Milgram. At the end of the book a great quote/lesson from the experiment appears. It goes "it is not so much the kind of person a man is as the kind of situation in which he finds himself that deter...more
Bonnie
Mar 02, 2013 Bonnie added it
This book is a must read for all. It shows the social experiments in obedience to an perceived authority. This offers insight into many other social problems that occur in society under bad authorities. For example social institutions such as Nazi's, slavery or other regimes that are horrific executions to the demise of innocent people through an organized "legal" authority. It is good to practice civil disobedience in most cases however people tend to go along with cruel and inhumane acts if or...more
Kenneth
"Why did you do that?"
"Because I was told to."

Or put another way, which didn't wash at the Nuremberg war trials, "I was only following orders." This book explores, through a classic experiment, the horrifying lengths that pefectly ordinary people will go to in obedience to authority and how they think that authority relieves them of personal responsibility for their actions. The tragedy is that those of us like me, who have a deep suspicion of authority, will read this book. Those who have faith...more
Nicholas
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Nancy
This is a great followup to the Lucifer Effect, an account off the Stanford Prison Experiments, which I also recently read. Milgram gives a very readable and concise review of his famous experiments in which subjects were asked to administer painful shocks to strangers, ostensibly as part of a memory experiment. While the experimenters initially assumed that their subjects would refuse to go on as soon as the "learner" expressed discomfort, most continued despite hearing agonized screams, and ma...more
John Wiswell
Aug 18, 2007 John Wiswell rated it 5 of 5 stars Recommends it for: Psychology readers, philosophy readers, history readers, cultural readers
Stanley Milgram's experiments changed American psychology, for better and for worse. The test subject was attached to electrodes and answered a series of questions. If he got them wrong, he was electrocuted. He was hurt worse the more questions he got wrong. The shocks were administered a second man, while a third observed, gave the questions and gave the orders for shocks. But this wasn't a study of negative reinforcement; the test subject wasn't the real subject at all. He was an actor, preten...more
Canard Frère
Le descriptif d'une expérience psychologique des années 60, consistant à observer jusqu'à quel point l'obéissance à un ordre extérieur peut prendre le pas sur les scrupules de l'exécutant. Le livre est assez fascinant dans le détail des réactions des sujets (début d'effondrement nerveux pour certains, impassibilité feinte pour d'autres, etc), et finalement un peu inquiétant quand on constate la propension majoritaire à obéir de façon quasi-aveugle à des ordres pourtant iniques.
Ritja
Stanley Milgrams Experiment, dass die Gehorsamkeit der Menschen gegenüber der Autorität beweisen soll. Zudem soll festgestellt werden, wie weit Menschen gehen, wenn ihnen etwas befohlen wird. Ab wann widersetzen sich Menschen, wenn sie mit bestimmten Befehlen oder Anweisungen nicht einverstanden sind? Wie sehr nehmen sie Verletzungen und Schmerzen anderer in Kauf, um Anweisungen ausführen zu können? Sehr anschaulich beschrieben und zum Teil mit erschreckenden Ergebnissen
Yingtai Zhu
I thought I knew all about this experiment from reading other sources, but of course I was wrong. Milgram carried out something like 16 variations of the experiment, and he thought really hard and insightfully about it. He doesn't just quote Freud, Kohlberg, Asch and other psychologists of his time, but also philosophers like Hannah Arendt.

I will say the first half (describing the experiments) is more worth reading than the second half (discussion), which I skimmed.
Erin
May 09, 2011 Erin rated it 5 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Erin by: self
An extended documentation of Milgram's classic experiments structured much like a peer-reviewed journal article, but less academic and more elaborated. Brilliant idea, tight method, and eloquent theory-based conclusions. At times, repetitive => my only complaint.

I was most impressed by Milgram's use of psychological theory from disciplines other than his own (i.e., social psychology). His integration of cognitive and psychoanalytic theory into explanations for findings demonstrates that he w...more
Charles
This was the first book I bought from Half Priced Books. I picked it from the top of a pile of copies that I assumes were part of a classroom set, and it was a real eye opener (back in high school, anyway). the lesson I took away from it was that Authority and Right are not the same thing and that while the former is easy enough to recognize (and Right much more tricky), it should not be confused with the latter.
Kevin2
Apr 19, 2010 Kevin2 added it
This book was a book that i used to help me in my Exhibition paper. this book is about a psychologist's experiment and about how he interpreted it. it talks about how the people of the experiment acted and how it connected to the holocaust during WWII. the one thing that shocked me was the results on how many people went through and some of their comments after they knew what was going on.
Brian Ayres
Of all of the areas of disagreement in the West from a psychological standpoint, the one that always pops up in my psychology courses is the idea that our behavior is caused by free will or choice. I encourage anyone who doubts the influence of authority and our natural instinct to form and follow social units to read Milgram's study that lays out the conditions for obedience. This books lays out the 18 variations of his classic "shock" experiments at Yale. People who are willing to deliver dead...more
Gayle Gordon
I have heard of this experiment for a long time and I'm thrilled to have finally read Milgram's account of it. It amazes me that so many people in so many permutations and repetitions of the experiment failed to defy the experimenter! It's a scary view of human nature, but one we have to take seriously.
Billie Mulcahy
This is the classic study done by Stanley Milgram on how compliant subjects were to authority. The study was carried out in the early 1960's and the results are frightening. This study could not be done today because of more stringent rules regarding the use of human subjects. This is a book that everyone should read.
Danie Jorgenson
i loved reading this book even though it was research for a paper in my sociology because of its lessons it had to teach. The lessons are scary but necessary to confront in any time of how far the human species can go and truly feel with all their heart "their just following orders"
Derek Sillerud
Simply terrifying. We would all like to think that we would be smart enough not to play along, but it's something we do everyday without even realizing. At least, that's what I got out of this.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 78 79 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
Obedience to Authority: An Experimental View (Paperback)
Obedience to Authority: An Experimental View (Paperback)
Obedience to Authority (Paperback)
Obedience to Authority: An Experimental View (Paperback)
Das Milgram   Experiment. Zur Gehorsamsbereitschaft Gegenüber Autorität

134222
Stanley Milgram (August 15, 1933 – December 20, 1984) was a social psychologist at Yale University, Harvard University and the City University of New York. While at Harvard, he conducted the small-world experiment (the source of the six degrees of separation concept), and while at Yale, he conducted the Milgram experiment on obedience to authority. He also introduced the concept of familiar strang...more
More about Stanley Milgram...
The Individual in a Social World: Essays and Experiments Television and Antisocial Behavior: Field Experiments Obbedienza all'autorità Obedience to Authority: Current Perspectives on the Milgram Paradigm

Share This Book

Your website
“ordinary people, simply doing their jobs, and without any particular hostility on their part, can become agents in a terrible destructive process. Moreover, even when the destructive effects of their work become patently clear, and they are asked to carry out actions incompatible with fundamental standards of morality, relatively few people have the resources needed to resist authority.” 6 people liked it
“But the culture has failed, almost entirely, in inculcating internal controls on actions that have their origin in authority. For this reason, the latter constitutes a far greater danger to human survival.” 6 people liked it
More quotes…