Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Scalpel and the Butterfly:The War Between Animal Research and Animal Protection” as Want to Read:
The Scalpel and the Butterfly:The War Between Animal Research and Animal Protection
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Scalpel and the Butterfly:The War Between Animal Research and Animal Protection

3.38  ·  Rating Details ·  21 Ratings  ·  5 Reviews
An engrossing and eloquent study of the history and ethics of animal experimentation

The heart of a pig may soon beat in a human chest. Sheep, cattle, and mice have been cloned. Slowly but inexorably scientists are learning how to transfer tissues, organs, and DNA between species. Some think this research is moving too far, too fast, without adequate discussion of possible
...more
Hardcover, 390 pages
Published September 26th 2000 by Farrar, Straus and Giroux
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Scalpel and the Butterfly, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Scalpel and the Butterfly

Community Reviews

(showing 1-52)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Nathan
Apr 28, 2010 Nathan rated it did not like it
I make no pretense of being impartial, unbiased or even objective; I am an abolitionist who holds that animals have the right not to be used as instruments for human ends, in any case whatever. My reading of this book, therefore, is shaped by that position. As it was, I was conflicted. Rudacille recounts the earliest days of the animal rights movement in succinct, though hardly original fashion, and touches on the major movements, past and present, that played any sort of role in the issue of vi ...more
David
Dec 24, 2009 David rated it it was ok
Uneven mix of: (a) sporadically interesting content about animal welfare, animal research, and science history (e.g., internal politics of the early years of PETA, eventual conclusion that polio epidemic arose from excessive hygiene in modern America, such that kids no longer got it in infancy [when for reasons I couldn't grasp you don't get paralyzed by it:] and built up immunity)and

(b) ponderous, boring writing. Obviously a matter of taste and hard to justify, but I guess the best way I can de
...more
Alleah Boisvert
Although I'm sure I could learn a lot from this book, it was just too dry for me.
Katherine
A very good overview of the history of anti-vivisection that I would recommend, but again some viewpoints are one-sided and not fully explained.
Elizabeth
Aug 02, 2011 Elizabeth rated it really liked it
Shelves: activism
Some parts I had trouble seeing how it related to animal rights/experimentation. I liked that it gave both sides of teh argument though. I've read better.
Cassandra
Cassandra rated it liked it
Mar 31, 2014
Mo
Mo rated it liked it
Nov 13, 2010
Peter
Peter rated it really liked it
Feb 26, 2014
Link Herrman
Link Herrman rated it really liked it
Oct 12, 2012
Morgan Watson
Morgan Watson rated it really liked it
Aug 27, 2013
Summer
Summer rated it it was amazing
Oct 02, 2013
Elizabeth
Elizabeth rated it liked it
Feb 11, 2012
Liesalu
Liesalu rated it liked it
Nov 22, 2014
Queendani
Queendani rated it it was ok
Mar 12, 2013
Vampire-lk
Vampire-lk rated it really liked it
Apr 15, 2014
Erin
Erin rated it liked it
Aug 20, 2008
Yan
Yan rated it it was amazing
Jun 09, 2015
Jim
Jim rated it liked it
Dec 09, 2012
Becky
Becky rated it liked it
Aug 06, 2015
Gary
Gary rated it really liked it
Jun 02, 2007
James McGregor
James McGregor rated it liked it
Feb 22, 2015
Jacquelyn
Jacquelyn rated it it was amazing
Apr 03, 2011
andrea
andrea marked it as to-read
Jun 29, 2008
Megan
Megan added it
Jul 18, 2008
Andrea
Andrea added it
Sep 11, 2008
Jennifer
Jennifer marked it as to-read
Jan 03, 2010
Peacegal
Peacegal marked it as to-read
Aug 05, 2011
Chloe Lappin
Chloe Lappin marked it as to-read
Nov 15, 2013
Alistair
Alistair marked it as to-read
Jun 17, 2014
Amanda
Amanda marked it as to-read
Jul 14, 2015
Alys Jackson
Alys Jackson marked it as to-read
Aug 08, 2015
BookDB
BookDB marked it as to-read
Oct 31, 2016
jeffrey
jeffrey marked it as to-read
Jan 25, 2017
Elizabeth
Elizabeth marked it as to-read
Jul 25, 2007
Andi
Andi marked it as to-read
Mar 19, 2008
Audrey
Audrey marked it as to-read
Jul 09, 2008
Erin
Erin added it
Jan 04, 2009
Alisa Polk
Alisa Polk marked it as to-read
Feb 02, 2009
Heather
Heather marked it as to-read
May 02, 2009
Lauri
Lauri marked it as to-read
Nov 11, 2009
E
E marked it as to-read
Apr 12, 2010
Steph
Steph marked it as to-read
Oct 10, 2010
Sara
Sara marked it as to-read
Dec 02, 2010
Corinna
Corinna marked it as to-read
May 07, 2011
Kelly
Kelly marked it as to-read
Sep 08, 2011
Meredith
Meredith marked it as to-read
Mar 13, 2012
Molly
Molly marked it as to-read
May 31, 2012
Danielle
Danielle marked it as to-read
Jul 03, 2012
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »

Share This Book