Tinsel: A Search for America's Christmas Present
by
Hank Stuever (Goodreads Author)
A heartfelt, hilarious look at the evolution of a half-trillion-dollar American holiday
Hank Stuever turns his unerring eye for the idiosyncrasies of modern life to Frisco, Texas, a suburb at once all-American and completely itself, to tell the story of the nation’s most over-the-top celebration: Christmas. Stuever starts the narrative as so many start the Christmas season:...more
Hank Stuever turns his unerring eye for the idiosyncrasies of modern life to Frisco, Texas, a suburb at once all-American and completely itself, to tell the story of the nation’s most over-the-top celebration: Christmas. Stuever starts the narrative as so many start the Christmas season:...more
Hardcover, 352 pages
Published
November 12th 2009
by Houghton Mifflin Harcourt
(first published 2009)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
505)
What do you think would happen if a liberal D.C.-based journalist decided to chronicle Christmas as celebrated by a group of Texans? If you think this sounds like it would result in some hilarious observations, you've got the basic idea of Tinsel.
Hank Stuever gets his liberal views in, subtly and not-so (one angst-filled monologue wonders about the choices of Americans: Why Crocs? ... Why Carrie Underwood? Why George Bush? (Why Hillary Clinton?). (Gotta love the oh-darn-if-I-mention-Bush-I-must-...more
Hank Stuever gets his liberal views in, subtly and not-so (one angst-filled monologue wonders about the choices of Americans: Why Crocs? ... Why Carrie Underwood? Why George Bush? (Why Hillary Clinton?). (Gotta love the oh-darn-if-I-mention-Bush-I-must-...more
Man, I am sort of on a roll with books I enjoyed! This book was a review on Christmas in this country. Like certain social networking sites, just because I am not a part of the fiesta, doesn't mean I am not interested in why other people are. The author picked an excellent town to review, an up and coming rich-ish suburb of DFW in Texas. He ended up reviewing 3 different types of families over 2006, 7 and 8 and while he didn't focus too much on the downturn that was 2008, it was still an excelle...more
3.5***
Stuever is a reporter and this non-fiction work chronicles his time spent in a suburb of Dallas Texas as the city and its families prepared for Christmas 2006. Porter’s reading of this work is quite good. He gets the cadence and rhythm of speech of his subjects, which brings a certain life to the work.
This is Christmas before the economy took a tumble, before mass foreclosures and lay-offs. When consumerism was still king, and especially so in the wealthier made-for-commerce suburban “co...more
Stuever is a reporter and this non-fiction work chronicles his time spent in a suburb of Dallas Texas as the city and its families prepared for Christmas 2006. Porter’s reading of this work is quite good. He gets the cadence and rhythm of speech of his subjects, which brings a certain life to the work.
This is Christmas before the economy took a tumble, before mass foreclosures and lay-offs. When consumerism was still king, and especially so in the wealthier made-for-commerce suburban “co...more
Hank Stuever has written an amazing look at the American way of Christmas. In 2006, Stuever, a reporter, went to Frisco Texas, to find one of the nations most over the top celebrations. Before the recession, the upscale neighborhood, with its mega churches, mega malls, mc-mansions, and big hair, he follows three families as they each try to find that perfect "mega moment"(you know, when it all comes together and just for a few moments everyone is happy).
From the crowds waiting in the dawn for Be...more
Would you be willing to let a stranger spend Christmas with your family? While he takes notes? Even when he asks how much you spent on everything?
These are the questions Hank Stuever asks the reader in the acknowledgments of this book. As he hunkers down in the Texas 'burbs for the holidays, Hank tells the stories of three families as they prepare for their Christmases. All told, he'll spend Xmas '06, '07 and a bit of '08 with these people—a time frame that, for all the craziness that went down...more
These are the questions Hank Stuever asks the reader in the acknowledgments of this book. As he hunkers down in the Texas 'burbs for the holidays, Hank tells the stories of three families as they prepare for their Christmases. All told, he'll spend Xmas '06, '07 and a bit of '08 with these people—a time frame that, for all the craziness that went down...more
A fantastic look at Christmas culture in America, as seen through a typical mid- to upper-class subdivision-and-mall suburb of Dallas: McMansions, big box retail, megachurches, fake tits and fake trees. In the winter of 2006, Steuver spent the holiday season with three families and experienced the shopping, decorating, consuming, churchgoing, and family stress along with them ~ a poignant time, as it was the last "big" Christmas in America for lots of people. After the economy collapsed and we f...more
Review of the audiobook from Audible. I thoroughly enjoyed this book, especially as it was a refreshing change from the usual current holiday glurge. The author seems to give an honest picture of the families he followed, treating them with respect, affection, and humor. No, I don't think those attitudes are mutually exclusive. I think he did a pretty good job of capturing, from an outsider's perspective, what we all want Christmas to be, how we try to go about making it happen, and how it can s...more
This is a very interesting book. I found it fascinating because I live in the DFW area and it's rather strange to see "ourselves" portrayed in a book. The author is a transplanted Oklahoman that now lives in Washington so the smug superiority attitude he exhibits gets a little old. Oklahoma is just a stone's throw from Texas so I don't get the idea that we are somehow unique for overdoing the Christmas spending and decorating everything that doesn't move in the name of religion. Texas is certain...more
Since I am not normally a non-fiction fan, this is the first time I have read a book that takes a look at the modern day Dallas. I grew up in the heyday of the Dallas TV show of the 70s and the misconceptions of my hometown that grew from the show. However, it is interesting to see the 21st century Dallas through the eyes of a visitor. It is almost as if we have indeed morphed into the Ewing world. Perhaps because we are still a relatively “new” American city, we still have the land to do everyt...more
I'd like to give this 3.5 stars, but I just don't have it in me to bump it up to 4. Not that the book was bad; quite the contrary, actually. Stuever is an entertaining, if slightly hipster and derivative, writer, and the book was fairly enjoyable (thus the 3.5 stars). But it was...unsurprising. Were there any great insights we were supposed to gain as we read about three Frisco, TX, families and their observation of the Christmas season? With one single exception - a 30-something husband who cov...more
An interesting journalistic voyage into Christmas Before The Crash. Stuever follows three families in upscale Frisco (a suburb of Dallas) to chronicle the ways they celebrate Christmas, which, thanks to Stuever's cynical eye and keen sense of numbers, becomes a tale of hypocracy and commercialistic meaninglessness. It's a bit depressing, but that doesn't mean it isn't accurate.
Sadly, though, Stuever's complaints about Christmas--cost, the emphasis on more, how no amount of spending is ever enou...more
Sadly, though, Stuever's complaints about Christmas--cost, the emphasis on more, how no amount of spending is ever enou...more
Dec 29, 2009
Katie
marked it as to-read
New Yorker Review:
In 2006, Stuever set out to characterize the experience of Christmas—its aesthetics, economics, and metaphysics—in an average Texas town. The resulting dissection of the holiday is cultural anthropology at its most exuberant. According to Stuever, fakery, not excess, is the signature of the modern American Christmas. More than twice as many synthetic Christmas trees are trimmed each year as real ones. Santa figurines at a Christmas bazaar purported to be handmade and local are...more
In 2006, Stuever set out to characterize the experience of Christmas—its aesthetics, economics, and metaphysics—in an average Texas town. The resulting dissection of the holiday is cultural anthropology at its most exuberant. According to Stuever, fakery, not excess, is the signature of the modern American Christmas. More than twice as many synthetic Christmas trees are trimmed each year as real ones. Santa figurines at a Christmas bazaar purported to be handmade and local are...more
I wasn't sure what kind of angle this book might take, but I was plesantly surprised on the tone and direction the book took. Hank's writing style makes the book easy to read, but it's not just a narrative of his observations. He includes history tidbits about Christmas and facts and figures as well. I found myself thinking that I wish I could get my father to read this book. He's a fanatic decorator (and not just at Christmas) and loves to look at Christmas lights.
I'm not a huge fan of holiday...more
I'm not a huge fan of holiday...more
Journalist Stuever travels to Frisco, Texas for three consecutive Christmas seasons (November to January) to invade the lives of three individuals/couples. Tammie the Christmas decorator guru who single-handedly decorates 30-40 homes in one season from Thanksgiving to December 11 (if they aren't done by then they are way behind in their planning is what she implies), Jeff and Bridgette Trykoski (http://www.trykoskichristmas.com/) whose light and music choreographed home draws hundreds to their n...more
An interesting and fun read. I was given the book by my niece who is neighbors with one of the couples in the book. This is how I came to have a signed copy of the book. I enjoyed the stories and the style so much that I subsequently found another book by Stuever to read: Off Ramp. Reading this book, I snickered to myself, I cringed a little, and I got outright upset about some of the behaviors he wrote about. This is a Christmas story initiating in and around the Big D. If you know anything abo...more
What started out as an exploration of America's consumer Christmas culture, developed over the several years Stuever researched and lived among his mall-loving Texan subjects, into a clear-eyed, but also respectful, even loving, look not only at the shopping madness, but also into the hearts of people he came to be close to. Beyond the gizmos and fad gifts, and the Black Friday frenzy, the residents of Frisco, Texas, want only what we all want: connection, and, as one of puts it, "the total mome...more
I couldn't put this down. I just bought it for a friend, and that is why it is on my mind, to write this review.
The way we celebrate Christmas in America is really over-the-top these days, and it seems very unique to America, although I could be wrong.
The book follows some people from Texas, who all have a big connection to Christmas in some way. A woman who has a business "putting up Christmas" for busy working women... a guy who makes one of those giant light displays set to music... and more...more
The way we celebrate Christmas in America is really over-the-top these days, and it seems very unique to America, although I could be wrong.
The book follows some people from Texas, who all have a big connection to Christmas in some way. A woman who has a business "putting up Christmas" for busy working women... a guy who makes one of those giant light displays set to music... and more...more
I don't know why people describe this book as funny ... it seemed to tell it like it is, almost dispassionately. (Why yes, people in the wealthier Dallas suburbs DO do all these things.) Someone else used the word "poignant," and I guess that fits it pretty well. What I appreciated most was that the author didn't seem to exaggerate anything, which is prone to happen when coasties write about Texas.
The book was tightly written -- almost too tightly, since I wanted to know more about all these ch...more
The book was tightly written -- almost too tightly, since I wanted to know more about all these ch...more
This is how Christmas began, after all, way before the time of Christ (and for centuries after his death), when it was a pagan celebration of the winter solstice. People gathered and danced by fires. The harvests were in and everyone gorged.
As a newspaper entertainment journalist, I have stood on red carpets. I have talked to Meryl Streep and Jude Law and Kate Winslet on Oscar night. At parties, I've made small talk with Beyoncé and Helen Mirren and Jake Gyllenhaal. I have thought of something t...more
As a newspaper entertainment journalist, I have stood on red carpets. I have talked to Meryl Streep and Jude Law and Kate Winslet on Oscar night. At parties, I've made small talk with Beyoncé and Helen Mirren and Jake Gyllenhaal. I have thought of something t...more
Hank Stuever took off 15 months as a culture writer for the Washington Post Style section to find people in “drought-prone Sunbelt states dreaming of white Christmases they know will probably never come” (11). He lands in Plano and Frisco, Texas, stalking four people: Tammie, who decorates houses for women who don’t have time to “figure out the mantel” (22); Caroll, who every year on Black Friday gets a free snowglobe at JC Penney; and Jeff and Bridgette, who stage a visible-from-space lightshow...more
There's a few oft-remarked-upon parts of Christmas; our own irrepressible nostalgia, the religiously crazed and their antics, and - the most frequently mentioned with chagrin - our over-commercialization of a holiday which we all feel should actually be about someone who purportedly started life in a barn with next to nothing. This book is simultaneously about none of all that and about nothing but all that.
Hank Steuver moved to Frisco, Texas for the Christmas of 2006, and the three families he...more
Hank Steuver moved to Frisco, Texas for the Christmas of 2006, and the three families he...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
If you're looking for a feel-good Christmas book, this is not it. Stuever gives us a close look at what an exurban Christmas looked like in 2006, before things went bust. The setting is Frisco, TX, but except for references to A&M and mild weather, it really could have been just about any place in the country similarly afflicted with affluenza. He tells us how the season plays out, from the shopping and decorating crescendo that starts in the fall, through to the packing up of ornaments and...more
I thought this book was interesting - if only for the fact that it gave a good description (in hindsight, of course) of the state of the economy from 06-08 and it's effect on Christmas. Some of the people I just wanted to smack for the careless spending of imaginary money.
Also, got a little tired here and there of the author's Blue State East Coast liberalism. He thinks he's smarter than us Red Staters in the middle of the country, just because we believe in something he doesn't. He's allowed hi...more
Also, got a little tired here and there of the author's Blue State East Coast liberalism. He thinks he's smarter than us Red Staters in the middle of the country, just because we believe in something he doesn't. He's allowed hi...more
This book was released late in '09, and that's unfortunate. I wish there had been more pre-Christmas time for readers to find the book and get into it. Hank Stuever did some great participant observation about over-the-top decorating in Frisco, TX. I never dreamed that so many people (Griswalds) are into lighting. Stuever delivered an interesting
facet of this affluent suburb, but he managed to keep it funny and non-critical. He even developed warm friendships with the people he studied.
facet of this affluent suburb, but he managed to keep it funny and non-critical. He even developed warm friendships with the people he studied.
Very enjoyable commentary and insights on the celebration of Christmas not only in the US, but in Dallas Texas. The author does his best to not trip over his own ego and bias-however in the end he has a hard time shielding his self righteousness from the reader.
I gave it four stars because it was enjoyable- and beyond that, it made me think causing a bit of introspection and ultimately did change how I view and will celebrate Christmas in my own home.
I gave it four stars because it was enjoyable- and beyond that, it made me think causing a bit of introspection and ultimately did change how I view and will celebrate Christmas in my own home.
Dec 14, 2010
Sharon Archer
added it
well...there were a number of themes in this book....mega churches, overblown decorations, rampant commercialism...the most disturbing to me was friends who couldn't go see a dying friend because they didn't want to see her like that....folks will send cards and otherwise put things that unpleasant aside...if you have friends or family that are ill, see them and talk to them...can't wait to see what my book club says about this!!
Nov 01, 2009
Amanda
marked it as to-read
Our little (okay, not-so-little) suburb is the backdrop for this new book!
Amazon.com says: In Tinsel, Hank Stuever turns his unerring eye for the idiosyncrasies of modern life to Frisco, Texas, a suburb at once all-American and completely itself, to tell the story of the nation's most over-the-top celebration: Christmas.
I am oh-so very curious...to see...if this does indeed capture what Frisco is all about!
Amazon.com says: In Tinsel, Hank Stuever turns his unerring eye for the idiosyncrasies of modern life to Frisco, Texas, a suburb at once all-American and completely itself, to tell the story of the nation's most over-the-top celebration: Christmas.
I am oh-so very curious...to see...if this does indeed capture what Frisco is all about!
Enjoyable and remarkable look at Christmas celebrated in Frisco, Texas in 2006 before America's economic troubles. Written by a journalist, and you can feel his note-taking presence at the family celebrations and shopping excursions he was generously allowed to attend. Most enjoyable to me were his forays into Pastor Keith's megachurch. The end of the book brings you up to date with trips back in 2007 and 2008. Very touching.
Not a history of past Christmases, but a snapshot view of Christmas in the early 21st century. Sort of documenting the holiday lives of three families in a Dallas suburb, and told from the perspective of an East Coast liberal, I expected more of a satire or at least some snarky writing, but the author was clearly taken in by the kindness of the families who allowed the author into their lives. The veracity of the author's emotions resonated with me, and I really enjoyed reading it.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Hank Stuever was born in 1968 in Oklahoma City and grew up there, and left, and got into journalism. He has worked for newspapers in Albuquerque and Austin and, since 1999, has covered pop culture for The Washington Post's Style section. He is currently the paper's TV critic. OFF RAMP, a collection of his feature stories and essays, was published in 2004. His 2009 book, TINSEL, follows three subur...more
More about Hank Stuever...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...
















Dec 09, 2010 07:36am