245th out of 2,086 books
—
3,720 voters
Seeing Voices
by
Oliver Sacks (Goodreads Author)
Like The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat, this is a fascinating voyage into a strange and wonderful land, a provocative meditation on communication, biology, adaptation, and culture.In Seeing Voices, Oliver Sacks turns his attention to the subject of deafness, and the result is a deeply felt portrait of a minority struggling for recognition and respect--a minority with...more
Paperback, 240 pages
Published
November 28th 2000
by Vintage
(first published 1989)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
I enjoyed this, as I enjoy all Sacks, and it's not his best. It's light on neurology. Given its 1989 publication, it's quite out of date. It predates baby sign language and both behind-the-ear speech processors and fully implantable cochlear implants. In addition (and since I read it as an audiobook, I can't easily double-check this), Sacks makes two errors of a sort I don't usually see from him. First, he treats Kaspar Hauser is a viable example of late language attainment. I believe that by th...more
When I was a child my cousin asked me if I would rather be blind or deaf. I didn't hesitate, I would much rather be deaf, I thought - a world of perpetual darkness was to be avoided at all costs.
To be honest, I never really thought about this question again until reading this book. I had no idea what costs deafness can bring with it.
Sacks go through many of these costs and explains, in remarkably simple language, some of the 'age dependent' structures that form our minds - how certain rules of l...more
To be honest, I never really thought about this question again until reading this book. I had no idea what costs deafness can bring with it.
Sacks go through many of these costs and explains, in remarkably simple language, some of the 'age dependent' structures that form our minds - how certain rules of l...more
think about what you know about deaf people. anything? nothing?

ha, ha. very funny.
when we think of the 1800s, we generally like to think that we've come a long way since then. women's rights. civil rights. health care. clean food facilities and preparation. and in many ways, we have improved. but in seeing voices by oliver sacks, sacks points out a way that we have actually backtracked as a society: how we teaching the deaf/hearing impaired. sacks points out that in 1850s, half the deaf people w...more

ha, ha. very funny.
when we think of the 1800s, we generally like to think that we've come a long way since then. women's rights. civil rights. health care. clean food facilities and preparation. and in many ways, we have improved. but in seeing voices by oliver sacks, sacks points out a way that we have actually backtracked as a society: how we teaching the deaf/hearing impaired. sacks points out that in 1850s, half the deaf people w...more
Oliver Sacks is a fantastic writer; thus, this book is a fascinating read. The reason it got only 3 stars from me is because he did not write this book yesterday... he wrote it more than 20 years ago. I'm a speech therapist, and I work with many children who are deaf or hard of hearing in a school setting. So much of this book is now dated - the technology, the ideas, the arguments about deaf culture - even the words he uses to describe people who are deaf are outdated. Cochlear implants didn't...more
I am a huge fan of Dr. Sacks. When you ask me who I would most like to meet if I could meet anyone on this planet, well, Dr. Sacks makes the top 3.
This is the only book of his that I've had trouble with, and it was only because I spent 17 years as an educator of young hearing-impaired children. I believe strongly in teaching deaf kids to talk. There are very few children, regardless of their level of deafness, who can't learn to communicate in this way.
Unfortunately, Dr. Sacks, in his beautifu...more
This is the only book of his that I've had trouble with, and it was only because I spent 17 years as an educator of young hearing-impaired children. I believe strongly in teaching deaf kids to talk. There are very few children, regardless of their level of deafness, who can't learn to communicate in this way.
Unfortunately, Dr. Sacks, in his beautifu...more
Most of the information that we get about the world comes through the sense of sight. Therefore it would seem that it there is one sense that we would be loath to part with, it would be this one. And yet, it is the sense of hearing that has the greatest impact on the acquisition of language and subsequently on the formation of our minds. If we don't acquire language really early on in our lives, we are bound to lead a very limited existence as compared to most other people. It is these facts and...more
'Seeing Voices' is Oliver Sacks' essay on sign language, divided into three parts: one, history of sign language; two, sign language as natural evolutional consequences of deaf people's neurological consequences; three, revolution of deaf culture and communities.
Sacks is known for his ability to move readers by capturing subjective, personal experiential aspects neuronal disorder. His famous books are among others: 'The Man Who Mistook His Wive for a Hat and The Awakenings.
Sacks is known for his ability to move readers by capturing subjective, personal experiential aspects neuronal disorder. His famous books are among others: 'The Man Who Mistook His Wive for a Hat and The Awakenings.
I was very excited by the prospect of reading about Sign Language and, in a broader context, the deaf community; in some aspects, this book delivered on (or exceeded) my expectations, but in other aspects, I was left wanting more. First, the positives...
This book opened my eyes to many issues concerning the deaf community. The first section of the book cast a spotlight on the struggles they’ve had over the last few centuries, e.g., overcoming the stigma that they were inferior or damaged; establ...more
This book opened my eyes to many issues concerning the deaf community. The first section of the book cast a spotlight on the struggles they’ve had over the last few centuries, e.g., overcoming the stigma that they were inferior or damaged; establ...more
I enjoy reading Oliver Sacks. He combines a brilliant scientific mind with the voice of a compassionate and empathetic clinician.
Most of his books that I've read are case studies based on different brain disorders. This book is a bit different. It's really 3 shorter pieces, all dealing with deafness that he wrote over a period of about 10 years. The first third is a New York Time Book Review piece that he wrote, the second is more of a paper expanding on the first third and the last section is a...more
Most of his books that I've read are case studies based on different brain disorders. This book is a bit different. It's really 3 shorter pieces, all dealing with deafness that he wrote over a period of about 10 years. The first third is a New York Time Book Review piece that he wrote, the second is more of a paper expanding on the first third and the last section is a...more
Seeing Voices is a collection of three essays, each addressing a different aspect of the deaf experience. The first is introductory and historical, blending anecdotes about notorious deaf individuals with the author's commentary. This portion of the book is sometimes impossible to read because Sacks refuses to write in a straight line. The sentences are overwrought, criss-crossing between unrelated ideas separated by copious quantities of commas. The content, while fascinating, is obscured by it...more
Rewelacyjna książka, napisana w zupełnie inny sposób niż pozostałe książki autorstwa O. Sacksa, w których opisuje on przypadki swoich pacjentów. Analizuje w niej problem społeczności głochoniemych, przedstawia historię ich walki o prawa (bunt w uczelni Gallaudet w 1988). Przedstawia również teorie dotyczące rozwoju języka migowego, jego analizę ligwistyczną. W przeciwieństwie do pozostałych książek, w których analizuje schodzenia swoich pacjentów z punktu widzenia neurologa (choć nie brak w nich...more
Seeing Voices was originally published in 1989. That was a big in-between year for the deaf. In 1988 Gallaudet students successfully pushed for a deaf president of the university. And in 1990, the Americans with Disabilities Act would be signed into law.
As for me, in 1989 I was three years old. I had not yet been diagnosed with my own hearing loss. I had no idea who Oliver Sacks was, what "deafness" means, where Gallaudet is, or what American Sign Language is. Two years later my worried parents...more
As for me, in 1989 I was three years old. I had not yet been diagnosed with my own hearing loss. I had no idea who Oliver Sacks was, what "deafness" means, where Gallaudet is, or what American Sign Language is. Two years later my worried parents...more
This was not my favorite Oliver Sacks book; my favorite is his memoir "Uncle Tungsten" which I really enjoyed. This book about the deaf and sign language seemed slow and repetitive especially with the copious footnotes but I did gain a much better understanding of sign language. It is a language in its own right with structure, grammar and nuances just like a verbal language. It gave me a much greater appreciation of the importance of sign language and why some deaf people do not envy those that...more
This is a fascinating and richly detailed book, as with all of Oliver Sacks's work. I like the way he combines psychology, neuroscience, and anthropology to create a truly nuanced and empathetic portrayal of his subjects. However, this book (published in 1989) is very outdated and a lot has changed since then in the fields of linguistics and disability rights, so I would not recommend this book to someone who is new to d/Deaf culture and the issues faced by the community. It was originally inten...more
Never met a Sacks I didn't like - this one is no exception, although I really wish the extensive notes had been footnoted and not crammed at the end like an unusually important epilogue. Quite a bit here that I knew about (had a few friends, Deaf and hearing both, who were part of the Deaf community growing up), but much that I didn't. One interesting/heartbreaking bit? How Sign was initially adopted and then abandoned until recently. Best stuff? The examination of the linguistics and neurology...more
Vendo Vozes é um livro por um lado datado. Foi escrito nos anos 80 e revisado nos anos 90. Um período pré internet que fica evidente ao longo da leitura. São três livros em um e acabam se repetindo um pouco. Diferente de outros livros do mesmo autor, Vendo Vozes tem em alguns momentos uma estrutura de ensaio sobre a importância da linguagem no desenvolvimento da inteligência e do indivíduo. Claro que ele não se restringe à lingua falada, mas principalmente pelo estudo de casos de surdez ele expl...more
The subtitle of this book is: "A journey into the world of the deaf". Written in three parts at different points in Sacks' exposure and familiarity with deaf culture, it's filled with the perfect mixture of his pure human curiosity and his neurological expertise. It feels as if the reader is meant to learn along with Sacks as he explores the topic. He writes about the history of the treatment and education of deaf people, explaining how the non-deaf world's view of deafness and sign language has...more
Jan 18, 2008
Jenny
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
pregant ladies, folks with no idea about deaf studies
Recommended to Jenny by:
Laurel
I wish Oliver Sacks were my grandfather and I could go to him at his rocker in front of a roaring fire and have him tell stories of people and their brains. This book works somewhat as a story even though its more of a science and history text because Sacks puts a lot of the dry factual stuff in endnote form (and believe me, the endnotes take up half the book. I was tempted to razor the spine so I wouldn't have to flip back and forth all the time) and in the body text he tells stories of people...more
This book is about the language of the deaf... I'd have to describe the book as very interesting content, but not so interesting to read. Til I got Chapter 3, and it became more readable. This was about the students at Gallaudet organizing to effect the selection of a deaf president. The book conveys the deaf community as a community of its own, with its own language and culture, and the trials it has gone through over time. Also the learning of language by those who don't hear, and the universa...more
Interesting, finally understand more about deaf and why my sister is like she is. I remember going with her as a child to the deaf and blind center in Dallas and telling the lady she needed her hands to talk. I must have been about four. Something so obvious to a four year old was thought to be not the best way by the educators. This book should be read by all educators. Please don't think you know everything, it is important to keep an open mind.
I really enjoy Oliver Sacks' books. His writing style is informative and engaging. His enthusiasm for learning always shines throughout his books. This book was less effective than some of his other books because it's three essays about deafness joined in one book. There was repetition within some of the essays. Still, I learned a lot about sign language and how it came about. I found the book really interesting.
Really fascinating to read someone as brilliant as Sacks discover the Deaf community. Probably better for someone who knows very little about Deaf culture and would be really great for an intro ASL class. Sacks spends a good deal of time writing about how ASL really is its own language and this can get a bit redundant if you're already familiar with the Deaf culture.
I have read some of his other books and I did not like this one as much. It was by no means bad but his style seems a lot dryer than in his other books. Like in his other books, the topic is interesting but it seems like he does not explain it as well as he has other topics in his other books. Also, a good portion of the book is his notes and sources which makes the book seem much longer than it actually is.
Fascinating information about how pre-lingual deafness differs from those who learned a spoken language before they lost their ability to hear. The connections of language to thought, the mis-assumptions of hearing people and the impact of using sign language has on the brain are wrapped together in a free-flowing, almost stream of consciousness. There were some bits that were technical enough so that I would like to re-read them. Most, however, was very understandable by the amateur.
Jun 15, 2007
Eoin
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
people with language or minds
Shelves:
nonfiction
Not done yet, so this is a temp. The subject is facinating (to me) and important (to everyone) and Sacks has that greatly excited tone of his that makes you think, probably rightly, that everything about the human mind is so *facinating*. The difficulty with this book is formating. In the edition I'm reading, there are footnotes (I love me the foot-notes, don't get it twisted) that take up as much as half the page, often running into the feet of subsequent pages. So lots of tangents and flipping...more
Wonderful and interesting book about the deaf community. I had much to think about and lots to bring up to discussion. However, the there were so many footnotes that they themselves could have been another book. He should have just added them to the book and made it that much better. Overall it was so interesting.
Jul 13, 2012
Heather
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
nonfiction-or-memoir,
own-fl
Not as memorable for me as The Man Who Mistook His Wife for a Hat & Other Clinical Tales but not much would be.
A clear, well-written book about the culture and linguistics of the deaf. It's a little dated having been published in the late 80's but for a nonfiction book about deaf culture, it is flawless. I even cried at the end when he discusses the "Deaf President Now" campaign at Gallaudet. My hat's off to Oliver Sacks.
Fascinating insights into the world of the deaf... you begin to appreciate the intricacies of sign language. I have learned it is truely a language; not just a pictorial pantomime of symbols, but a complex 3D movie of idiosyncratic edits, expressions, and points of view that is not bound or restricted emotionally in any way... it has equal access to as many expressions as spoken language... nay I have learned that sign can do more than spoken language. I have also learned that without language w...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Oliver Wolf Sacks, CBE (born July 9, 1933, London), is a British neurologist residing in the United States, who has written popular books about his patients, the most famous of which is Awakenings, which was adapted into a film of the same name starring Robin Williams and Robert De Niro.
Sacks was the youngest of four children born to a prosperous North London Jewish couple: Sam, a physician, and E...more
More about Oliver Sacks...
Sacks was the youngest of four children born to a prosperous North London Jewish couple: Sam, a physician, and E...more
Share This Book
1 trivia question
More quizzes & trivia...
“We speak not only to tell other people what we think, but to tell ourselves what we think. Speech is a part of thought.”
—
26 people liked it
“And language, (...) is not just another faculty or skill, it is what makes thought possible, what seperates thought from nonthought, what seperates the human from the non human.”
—
1 person liked it
More quotes…

Loading...






































Jan 02, 2012 07:27pm