Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “But Not for Long” as Want to Read:
But Not for Long
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

But Not for Long

2.75 of 5 stars 2.75  ·  rating details  ·  169 ratings  ·  50 reviews
Hard-shelled, career-minded Greta is the newest and least likely member of a sustainable foods cooperative house in Madison, Wisconsin. Shortly after she joins Karin and Hal in their stately residence near campus, the husband Greta left appears on their porch, drunk, and the reason for her sudden appearance becomes clear. Yet the house members already have plenty to occupy ...more
Hardcover, 336 pages
Published October 13th 2009 by Thomas Dunne Books
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about But Not for Long, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about But Not for Long

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 423)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
I am always awestruck when somebody is able to write a book about absolutely NOTHING and it's still a very good rarely happens anymore.
This is one of those books though.
With very few words Wildgen shares a story about the lives of four people over the span of a few days. The entire book takes place during an extended black out, which even intensifies the languid tone of the book.
Sounds boring. And actually, it is boring.
Yet, I came to know the characters and wanted to know what became
A curious book about liberal do-gooders on the edge of the apocalypse. As a liberal do-gooder who is worried about being on the edge of the apocalypse, this is right up my alley. The best part of this book is the way it represents disaster in our lives: something we notice around the edges of our everyday existence, worry about when we get a spare minute, but ultimately am less concerned with then our own personal issues. Wildgen poses a question here that we need to consider: can all of our goo ...more
I really enjoyed this quirky book about a group of people that live in a coop on Madison's near east side. It could go along and be a perfectly good book about interesting people, but an added plot twist is a power outage that lasts for three days. In that time period you get to know the people that live in the coop and follow them to work. I was surprised at how much I enjoyed the characters and how they dealt with perversity and people around them. Michelle Wildgen is the presenting author at ...more
The story takes place in Madison again, there's been gasoline shortages, power failures...sounds like it could be a pretty modern day story. The power goes out again and instead of it coming back on in a few hours, it's out for 3 days+ in the story.

After reading You're Not You, I was expecting a lot more. I didn't really care about any of the characters and their problems. There's too many unanswered questions when the book ends and it seems unfinished. I didn't like it.
Anne Marie
This book was pleasant until the last page. The ending BLOWS. It was one of those abrupt endings that makes you feel as if a few pages were torn out of the back of the book. I think the author was trying to carry some symbolism through the book and have it culminate with a realization at the end. It did not work. At. All.
I was a little distracted by the fact that this book is set in Madison since I live in Madison, but that's not Michelle Wildgen's fault -- she lives in Madison, too. Distraction aside, I thought the characters were well drawn and the writing is VERY good. I'm looking forward to reading her other novel.
This book was ok. It took me a long time to get into it and then after I did, the book ended and I felt like I was exactly where I was when I started. It appears that they are making a movie out of this book and I'm very confused how that will work. Not something that I'd recommend.

Life Goes On As Society Falls Apart

I review Michelle Wildgen's "But Not For Long" today, Sunday, December 20th, in The News & Observer.

I couldn't finish this one and I'm not sure why. As a Madison native, I really wanted to like it. I think I had a hard time getting to know the characters.
I loved her first book You're Not You, and so far this one is just as wonderful.

Michelle Wildgen is a Madison author. The book has all the familiar streets, lakes and places. This brought more interest to the book for me. The story also brings in the long standing Eastside vs. Westside living debate that has long been a subject of conversation in Madison. The storyline follows three people living in a co-op during a prolonged power outage. Karin is the youngest in the house. She write for a dairy journal. Greta recently moved in the co-op after leaving her alcoholic husband
This is one of those books that's probably better than my rating indicates. I admired it but it didn't really work for me. It's set in Madison, Wisconsin, over a period of just two days, with what seems to be a very promising premise. There are lots of apocalyptic novels that start after some vague event has resulted in primitive conditions for the novel's characters. This is a more likely premise. After a vaguely ominous opening scene that hovers in the background of the novel, the power goes o ...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
The main characters of the book are the members of a housing co-op focused on sustainable food. This is the sort of person I frequently meet in life (I live in Berkeley), but rarely in literature, so I liked that. Characterization is Wildgen's strong point: Hal, Greta and Karin are complex and convincing, and there are some keen insights into relationships. There's also some gorgeous prose, together with a few clunky patches. Plot is less skillfully handled; there are some very slow sections, es ...more
The writing is very strong.

The book is very, very dark.

And, there were some plain old weird parts:
"Greta felt the work of her throat in great detail: it's glottal effort, the pulse of muscle, the wet contractions, like a python's, trying to ease the burden along. She felt the ragged edges of the crust against her flesh" (219).

And, that is just two sentences of 9 paragraphs of choking on a piece of bread and gentle receiving the Heimlich maneuver. Perhaps it was a bit too much information for
Anji Beane
I won this book as a goodreads first reads. I was excited to read it and I thought I'd really like it. I didn't. I felt like I was waiting for something to happen, and then the book was done and I didn't know what it was about at all. I was disappointed in the lack of a story. Things that seemed like they were part of a story that was supposed to happen never ended up amounting to anything, which was frustrating and confusing, as I felt like it could have been a decent book if any of the loose ...more
The way a city works stops working. The way relationships work within this malfunctioning city is why I rated this book amazing. Place and people mirror each other. They patch up as similarly as they fall apart. Something strong holds it together, basic necessities and unspoken essentials of human spirit.
Unfortunately mediocre. I had high hopes. I'm always endeared to any of Wildgen's writing because she sets her novels in my city. I recognize the street names, the neighborhood descriptions, and love how the farmer's market is basically a character in each of her novels (accurate, for Madisonians). But this book rang hollow for me. It had its moments, but the characterization was flat. I appreciated the concept - no "real" conflict and resolution, vague sense of apocalyptic foreboding churning t ...more
The first thing that stood out to me about this book was the importance of its Madison setting. The name-dropping of streets, bars, and nearby towns might annoy, unless you live (or have lived) in Madison (in which case, you might enjoy it even more!). Set in the near future, it explores the possible implications of an energy crisis. But really it's about the people, most of whom are roommates at a sustainable-foods co-op. Although the plot only covers a few days, you'll learn histories and memo ...more
I received a copy of But Not for Long through’s FirstReads giveaway program. The last book I won through the program was A Girl Named Mister by Nikki Grimes and I wasn't so impressed, so I was hoping for a breath of fresh air with this one.

One-sentence review: After finishing this book five months ago, I realize that I still don't know what the point was and why I was supposed to care about the characters portrayed.
Jacquelynn Fritz
This book got good reviews and was the reason I got it from the library, but I don't understand the hype. Its the story of three housemates who live in Madison co-op during a black out. Hal helps run a food pantry. Karin works for a dairy magazine. Gerta, who has left her drunk husband, works as a college fund raiser. The story takes place over a couple of days during the black. The three are in crisis, but there isn't enough there to care about the characters. The book ends without a conclusion ...more
Some extremely beautiful passages, and I very much agree with the reviewer who commented on the writer's ability to illuminate the awkward moments and relationships that abound in the world. Overall, for me, there was too much too much. I was able to notice too easily when there was a flow; which meant that for me there often wasn't a flow. Part of it is because it is set in Madison, where I live, so I get too caught up on that and am not able to dive in the way I do, usually, with a setting tha ...more
Cathy Lenahan
But Not for Long is an incredibly interesting story, one that couldn't be more timely. This is a character driven novel--all of them round, layered and believable--but there is also a dark, almost apocalyptic veil over the narrative. This is a world that feels just one click away from our own. To her writerly credit, Wildgen shows great restraint and exactitude in this book, which suits her story. A taut, wonderfully written, satisfying read that will keep you thinking about it long after you pu ...more
This book sounded so good that even while slogging through the first few chapters I kept hoping it would get better as I went along - but it never did. The book follows three house-mates, Hal, Karin and Greta, over 3 days of an unexplained power outage in Madison, Wisconsin. The writing is stiff and odd and the characters are not relatable or lovable at all. Overall, it was a waste of time and I wish I had quit reading it earlier rather than making myself finish it.
I could not get through this book. It was so close to home, based in a Madison neighborhood in which I lived for many years. Yet the differences between the book and the real world bothered me. Like the cover art. Since when does Madison have mountains? Or when has Madison had a power outage for days and days? Or why perpetuate the eastside/westside rivalry? Or why should I care about these sad people? I wanted to like this book but just couldn't.
I a reading this a second time. But Not for Long is a strange novel about permanently left wing college graduates living in co-operatives of various sorts dealing with a collapse of the economy and the power grid in Wisconsin. My first pass through this struck me as having good characters but a plodding plot. My second run through it finds it much more interesting, which probably says I wasn't paying enough attention the first time.
Odd premise, so fun. I liked it while I was reading it, but really hated the ending.

The writing was awesome though, as illustrated in this quote:

"Hal had lived with Karin for nearly a year, had watched her head out for her run each morning of the week, and somehow had never equated that discipline with practical physical strength. He wanted to get her a brandy and a towel, a giant breakfast, and watch her move furniture."
Apr 23, 2010 Carol added it
Michelle Wildgen will be this year's Book Club Cafe author on May 26. Let me know if you need tickets!

This futuristic and rather unsettling novel is set in Madison, and even mentions Monroe Street several times. The novel's small range of motion is intentional but also somewhat disturbing. Well worth reading for Wildgen's masterful skill at catching the small nuances of character, dialogue and setting.
Although it's set in the city where I live, which I found somewhat distracting, the characters were flawed in interesting ways. I was left somewhat lost by the ending, which I kind of like. There were places where the writing was terrific, and places where it was not that good.

It's an interesting story, in which Madison and the surrounding areas have a several day blackout. Life just gets weird.
Freyja Vanadis
Wow. What a strange tale. I thought it was very well-written, but I couldn't stand any of the characters, especially Hal. I'm glad I read Ms. Wildgen's other book, You're Not You, before I read this one because if I had read this one first, I'd never have bothered to read You're Not You, which I loved.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 14 15 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Americans in Space
  • A Year of Cats and Dogs
  • 21 Erased
  • The Great Bay: Chronicles of the Collapse
  • Water Ghosts
  • The Season of Second Chances
  • Ready to Fall
  • Radio Iris
  • Paradise
  • Jarrettsville
  • Far Bright Star
  • Buffalo Lockjaw
  • Splintered Icon
  • The Dewey Decimal System
  • A Wrinkle in the Skin
  • What We All Long For
  • Wastelands II: More Stories of the Apocalypse
  • Domestic Affairs
Michelle Wildgen is a writer, editor, and teacher in Madison, Wisconsin. In addition to being an executive editor at the literary journal Tin House, Michelle is the author of the novels Bread and Butter: A Novel (forthcoming from Doubleday), But Not For Long and You’re Not You (both available in paperback from Picador), and the editor of an anthology, Food & Booze: A Tin House Literary Feast ( ...more
More about Michelle Wildgen...
You're Not You Bread and Butter Food and Booze: A Tin House Literary Feast Qualcosa di buono: Due donne. Una grande amicizia. Un nuovo inizio. You're Not You: Jij bent mij

Share This Book