Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “The Brothers Story” as Want to Read:
The Brothers Story
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

The Brothers Story

3.11 of 5 stars 3.11  ·  rating details  ·  46 ratings  ·  20 reviews
Teenage twins Kit and Christy have grown up amid grinding poverty in their Essex village. As Christy has been “simple” from birth, Kit is literally his brother’s keeper. But the latest hardships visited upon their country home by the Great Frost of 1683–84 bring Kit to frustration and despair, and he abandons Christy to make his way to London, seeking to better himself. Th ...more
Hardcover, 288 pages
Published November 10th 2009 by Farrar, Straus and Giroux (BYR)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Brothers Story, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Brothers Story

The Way of Shadows by Brent WeeksAssassin's Apprentice by Robin HobbThe Black Prism by Brent WeeksThe Magician's Apprentice by Trudi CanavanThe Burning Bridge by John Flanagan
36th out of 69 books — 54 voters
Watership Down by Richard AdamsDune by Frank HerbertPride and Prejudice by Jane AustenThe Curious Case of Benjamin Button by F. Scott FitzgeraldThe Amber Spyglass by Philip Pullman
In a Brown Mood
274th out of 457 books — 54 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 133)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Eva Mitnick
Although the jacket art depicts a lad who looks like a 70s California Boy, this novel about a teen who leaves his "simple" twin brother behind in their impoverished village to seek a better life in London plunged me right into the desperately cold winter of 1683. I sensed no anachronisms - even Kit's mindset and attitude (about sex and women, about religion, about a person's rightful station, about fairness) were clearly far from modern. There has always been a place in my heart for stories abou ...more
THe plot is great but I felt there was a gratuitous sexual act in the book. It bugs me when it is in the story and does nothing to further the plot. Sexual acts used poorly do not make edgy teen literature; they make poor books. Set during the coldest winter on record in London, the protagonist is likable, except the icky act. I felt for him, and his twin. I liked the overall plot, just not a few incidences that are wasteful.
Fianlly, a book with a perfect, clean-cut, satisfying ending!

This book was a lovely, heartwarming and humbling story, and I highly recommend it to anyone who is interested in history, who wants an escape from their everyday life, or who wants to be made appreciative of the life that they already have. It tugged my heartstrings throughout, but also left me with tears in my eyes - I'm still thinking about the characters days after I've finished. Fantastic. A real portrayal of life in the 17th cent
This was a good book, but had some more mature parts (I wouldn't let teens read it). But it seems to portray life as it would have been in England back in those days. Kind of enlightening, and a good read.
Katherine Sturtevant is the author of my favorite YA novel, A True and Faithful Narrative. That book also takes place in Restoration London, but it's about the daughter of a bookseller who wants to be a writer, which is naturally going to be a situation more modern readers can identify with, as opposed to this book, which is about a lower-class boy who wishes to better himself. He's not a sophisticated thinker. I empathized with him but didn't necessarily identify with him.

But what I love, love,
Books and Literature for Teens
The winter of 1683, the coldest winter ever recorded in England, has taken an terrible tole on Kit and his poor family. Kit dreams of going to London to find a job, but the only thing holding him back is his twin brother, Christy, who was born "simple". Since Kit has always looked after his brother and has never been separated, Kit isn't sure if Christy will survive without him. Frustrated and determined to better himself, in the end, Kit decides to abandon Christy in Essex and flee to the city. ...more
Margo Tanenbaum
Katherine Sturtevant's third novel for young people returns to 17th century England, this time to the winter of 1683-84, known as "The Great Frost," considered the worst frost for which we have historical records. The Thames froze solid, two feet thick, as well as the surrounding seas, rendering commerce very difficult. In this historical context, Sturtevant spins the captivating story of two twin teenage boys, Kit and Christy. Identical in appearance, Christy has been simple since birth, and Ki ...more
Dec 05, 2012 Ed added it
Sturtevant, Katherine. (2009). The Brothers Story. New York: Farrar, Straus, and Giroux. 275 pp. ISBN 978-0-374-30992-3 (Hardcover); $16.99.

In the coldest winter in England’s history, Kit and Christy are desperately scratching to eat, stay warm, and survive. His younger brother, Michael, has already died and his mother has sent him begging. Surviving for Kit may be a bit easier than for his twin brother Christy. Christy is developmentally disabled and we are in Essex in the year of our Lord, 168
England, 1683 brought the most brutal winter people had seen in a very long time. Kit, 15 and his twin Christy were cold, hungry, and poor living in Essex. Their father and sister died from the fever, and their 3 year-old brother, Michael is deathly ill. Christy is 'simple' and his mother wishes he would have died instead of other family members. Kit is his only champion. When Michael dies, the mother employs herself at a neighbor's farm, leaving the twins in the care and servitude of a despicab ...more
Mar 16, 2012 Sue added it
Another good example of why I really like reading historical fiction is this book. This story takes place in what is still believed the coldest winter in England's history - 1683-84. The main character, 15-year-old Kit, leaves his dreadful life in a small village in Essex, to better himself in London. He leaves behind his mother and twin brother, Christy, who is "simple."
The enormous struggle of the poor and the wretched treatment they received, is powerfully presented, and again, the reason I
Dekevion Gause
this book was set in old time London, with a poor dialect to it. Set during the hardest frost period on record, two twin boys (Kit & Christy) are struggling to survive. Both of there real names are Christian, because there mom thought one of them was going to die from pneumonia. In a act of desperation, Kit leaves to London to try to make it on his own. Although the realism of the times, back then are interesting and the truthfulness of author gives the characters are pretty good, the second ...more
Set in old time London during the hardest frost on record, twin boys, Kit & Christy are struggling to survive. In a act of desperation, Kit flees to London to try to make it on his own. Although the gritty realism of the times back then are interesting and the honesty the author gives the characters are refreshing, the second half of the book was a very big disappointment to me. The author decided to focus on Kit's hormones and the sexuality of the book was out of line for a teenage book. I ...more
Sturtevant really made the coldest winter ever recorded in England seem real. I really enjoyed the contrast between the two brothers. I also enjoyed the subtle input of religion in the novel, like the coat of many colors. I'm a little irked at the sexual scenes, but I do not know why. It does not seem right in this historical fiction. I understand that Kit is a teenager and this is set in the late 1600's, but it seemed out of place, like a badly placed comic relief.

Overall, this novel will be o
Don't know if I can fairly review this book. I didn't make it passed the first couple of chapters. I was already struggling with the hormonal issues discussed. I kept thinking, "I bet this is just going to get worse." So, I looked up a couple of reviews here. Yep. It was just going to get worse. I don't have time to waste that. There are so many good books out there that tell a story with teenage boys (or girls) as the protagonist that don't have sex in them; I'll just skip this one.
Very similar to Avi's "Cross of lead" series in its realistic, detailed description of an English peasant's life (tho set 200 years later). It won't pull in reluctant readers, but is very well done.
Maureen E
Set in 1680′s England, this is the story of twin brothers, Kit and Christy. Kit must care for Christy although he resents it. An interesting historical fiction. [Nov. 2010]
It was so slow in the beginning that I just wanted to stop reading it, but more into the book it got better. I wouldn't recommend anyone to this book, but it was an ok book.
Okay so I pretty much just STOPPED reading this. It's too....blah. I just can't read it anymore. And I've NEVER done this to a book. This is the first time.
England in the 1600's...developmental disabilities, poverty, "frost fair", social class, coming of age...
Horrible cover and didn't really feel anything towards the characters.
Anna Cuneo
Anna Cuneo marked it as to-read
Aug 23, 2015
Heidi marked it as to-read
Jul 27, 2015
Juliana Jordan
Juliana Jordan marked it as to-read
Jun 30, 2015
Angelia marked it as to-read
Jun 18, 2015
Cindy is currently reading it
May 05, 2015
Tori added it
Mar 28, 2015
Dragonr marked it as to-read
Dec 25, 2014
Ma.elayka B.
Ma.elayka B. marked it as to-read
Dec 22, 2014
« previous 1 3 4 5 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
A True and Faithful Narrative At the Sign of the Star Mistress Moderately Fair Our Sisters' London: Feminist Walking Tours Our Sisters' London: Nineteen Feminist Walks

Share This Book