5th out of 35 books
—
7 voters
When Helping Hurts: How to Alleviate Poverty Without Hurting the Poor . . . and Yourself
Churches and individual Christians typically have faulty assumptions about the causes of poverty, resulting in the use of strategies that do considerable harm to poor people and themselves. Don't let this happen to you, your ministry or ministries you help fund! A must read for anyone who works with the poor or in missions, When Helping Hurts provides foundational concepts...more
Paperback, 232 pages
Published
July 1st 2009
by Moody Publishers
(first published June 24th 2009)
There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!
sign in »
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,246)
This is an absolute must-read for those who are engaging in the current trend toward missional poverty alleviation efforts. Corbett begins with a Biblically based understanding on broken relationships derived from the fall and their radiating effects to all the various relationships that make up our social structures. He marries this Biblical understanding to scholarly research on social work, highlighting especially potential misconceptions or matters of ignorance in the common practices of pov...more
Steve Corbett and Brian Fikkert have done a great service for the Church in their book When Helping Hurts: Alleviating Poverty Without Hurting the Poor. . .and Yourself.
One of the major premises of the book is that “until we can embrace our mutual brokenness, our work with low-income people is likely to do far more harm than good.” Their central point is, ” One of the biggest problems in many poverty-alleviation efforts is that their design and implementation exacerbates the poverty of being of...more
One of the major premises of the book is that “until we can embrace our mutual brokenness, our work with low-income people is likely to do far more harm than good.” Their central point is, ” One of the biggest problems in many poverty-alleviation efforts is that their design and implementation exacerbates the poverty of being of...more
A very good book, though it really was a slap in my face and it is messing up my world. His chapter on why short term mission trips are typically more harmful then good, was really unsettling (Especially since my job is to host short term mission teams), I disagree with them on some points, but in other ways they made quite a point. The authors explained how misguided helping hurts the poor which brought to mind the countless times I've been ignorantly employing the very methods they condemn, ca...more
This book is a helpful book for determining a biblical framework for engaging in ministry to the materially poor with a humble attitude. The book does a great job of pointing out how the local church should be engaged in meeting the needs of the poor as the Bible makes it clear the local church is to do. I like the relationship focus of the book. The poor are not to be helped financially without regard to the spiritual condition of their lives, and any help should take a true relational appro...more
Our help to needy people should come in three stages: relief, rehabilitation, and development. Hurricane victims need relief—right away. But we can hurt others–and ourselves—if we insist on doling out relief when what they need is (personal) rehabilitation and (community) development. It's easier, in a way, to just give money to buy relief. But the personal work it takes to go on to further stages is daunting, not least because as regenerated people we know that a needy persons truest needs are ...more
Susie
added it
This book is an excellent read for people no matter where they may be serving. If you heart is burdened to do something to help people who live all around us it's important to read this book first. We need to stop and consider what this author has said before we throw money around thinking that we're helping. We may actually be hurting, and I don't think any of us want to do that! We need to understand that "Poverty is the result of relationships that do not work, that are not just, that ar...more
I'd recently read The Hole in our Gospel, and thought it a compelling call to action. This book, recommended to me by a friend, is a plan of action. Well, not a plan perhaps, but a set of guidelines and considerations on how to help effectively. Basically, it about how not to make things worse by throwing money around and attempting to rescue those who do not need *you* to rescue them. It focuses on the need of both rich and poor for the true Savior to rescue them, and how to effectively min...more
The last commenter, although respectful, missed the point of the book - and what others spoke to as well. The book's purpose is not to avoid hurting yourself, but to consider what you do so as not to hurt those Christ calls us to help. I've checked out White Man's Burden from the library, under a friend's recommendation. It's proving to be a bit more difficult to slog through. But Brian Fikkert addresses the same realm of issues in a far more simple and clear way. When Helping Hurts confirm...more
This book is a wonderful introduction to the complexities of compassion ministry. Fikkert shows how the modern American church can sometimes push itself into places of physical need with an overconfidence and paternalism that doesn't respect the dignity of those being helped. As a result, the wealthy receive a sense of accomplishment... while the cycles of physical poverty are actually exacerbated by our efforts.
So how can we help the poor without hurting them? Fikkert offers practical...more
So how can we help the poor without hurting them? Fikkert offers practical...more
I read this book in connection with my church job. One of the co-authors came and spoke to the congregation. All too often, well-meaning people try to help the poor but in a way that backfires and actually perpetuates poverty.
The authors distinguish between "relief" and "development". Relief is appropriate after a natural disaster, for example, when food, clean water, medical care, and shelter are the immediate needs. But for long-term poverty, development--...more
The authors distinguish between "relief" and "development". Relief is appropriate after a natural disaster, for example, when food, clean water, medical care, and shelter are the immediate needs. But for long-term poverty, development--...more
I'm about a year behind everyone else reading this. But that's ok, I've read plenty else that, I think, provides a good context for understanding where this book is coming from, and where it could be going. This book points out some relevant questions, but answers them from a very arrogant point of view (while affirming non-arrogance) and does little to provide motivation other than selfish reasoning. Don't help the poor the wrong way or you'll hurt yourself and waste your time.
Ther...more
Ther...more
This book was a helpful reminder of things that many authors have previously said ("give a man a fish...teach a man to fish..."); but it didn't break any new ground.
But there was a general tone, especially in the Forward and the Preface, towards Marxism.
In the Forward, Dr. John Perkins calls for the need for "social justice." That has become code word not for justice and mercy for the poor, but the call for the government to redistribute wealth.
...more
But there was a general tone, especially in the Forward and the Preface, towards Marxism.
In the Forward, Dr. John Perkins calls for the need for "social justice." That has become code word not for justice and mercy for the poor, but the call for the government to redistribute wealth.
...more
There is so much brokenness in this world. Even here in America, we can see that things are not as they should be. Marriages end. Children are abused. Crimes go unpunished and the innocent often suffer. Babies are aborted by the millions.
When we leave our borders, this brokenness becomes even more magnified as we encounter billions of people living in abject poverty, without access to the basic needs for human survival. Every day, people die by the thousands due to starvation and pre...more
When we leave our borders, this brokenness becomes even more magnified as we encounter billions of people living in abject poverty, without access to the basic needs for human survival. Every day, people die by the thousands due to starvation and pre...more
A very good a very important book. It puts such good words and thoughts to a very important part of what it means to walk in justice as a follower of the Lord. I highly suggest this to every single Christian. We are called to walk in justice and to do it in a way that is effective and glorifying to God. I think that I'm going to start suggesting this book to anyone that wants to pursue short term trips in Tanzania, because it is that important. The authors present very biblical and very practica...more
I would highly encourage any Christian who desires to obey the Bible’s call for Christians to love and care for the poor (Jeremiah 22:3; James 1:27 et. al.) to read this book. The book looks at how evangelicals should help the poor from an uncommon and fresh perspective. The book is almost like a seminar with practical--and sometimes overloading and overwhelming practicality.
The gist of the book is this, “”Until we embrace our mutual brokenness, our work with low-income people is lik...more
The gist of the book is this, “”Until we embrace our mutual brokenness, our work with low-income people is lik...more
Fikkert and Corbett have produced a well written and very accessible book for those interested in thoughtfully engaging poverty. I've read the book twice; each time it has re-shaped my understanding of what it means to draw near to the vulnerable in our society in the name of the Jesus.
I have a clearer understanding of what poverty actually is (in contrast to how my background and culture have defined it) and I have a greater sense of what it means to seek renewal in both our local an...more
I have a clearer understanding of what poverty actually is (in contrast to how my background and culture have defined it) and I have a greater sense of what it means to seek renewal in both our local an...more
I chose this book for two of my classes this fall, Christ and the City & The Theology of Poverty, because it addresses a very important issue in Christian missions and community development work: the tendency of do-gooders to leave the ones they are helping in a less empowered state than when they got involved with them. The authors have a great deal of experience consulting with Christian organizations overseas seeking to help the poor, and make an important distinction between relief, rehabili...more
Very deep, thought-provoking book taking a look at the huge picture on poverty and strategies on how to help those in poverty. Written on a very high level, which made it all the more exciting to read. I still need to process and consider the presented philosophies, as they would represent huge changes in every ministry with which I work. Definitely challenging in that it presents foundational, systemic changes. I am still deciding on whether I buy into it all or not, but I would have to exa...more
A necessary and well-written book about the gap between intentions and effects in our attempts to alleviate poverty. The authors lay out a convincing argument, developing strong principles and then referring back to them appropriately rather than just giving their own opinions. To put it bluntly, many of us (as individuals, organizations, and governments) have spent a lot of money and time on good intentions that have actually made poverty even worse.
I was grateful for Part 1, focusi...more
I was grateful for Part 1, focusi...more
This book equipped more than it inspired. I didn't get all the warm fuzzies & ah-ha moments as I did with 'The Hole in Our Gospel,' but it was still foundational. I appreciated its attention to both individual & systemic issues.
It went from conceptual to practical. I'm glad to own it, because it'll be one I reference in the future.
Idea highlights, worth exploring further:
-Our fundamental beliefs about the cause of poverty will impact our attempt to alleviate it. If...more
It went from conceptual to practical. I'm glad to own it, because it'll be one I reference in the future.
Idea highlights, worth exploring further:
-Our fundamental beliefs about the cause of poverty will impact our attempt to alleviate it. If...more
This is a must-read for every church interested in charity or relief work whether at home or abroad. In the very least, it should be in every church's reference library for easy consultation before such projects, especially short term mission trips, are planned. However, this is more of a manual than a book you read cover to cover. Without a specific project in mind, it can become a bit tough to wade through. In addition, while not a liability per se, the author's Presbyterianism is a bit strong...more
Very good book, with the exception of chapter 8. That one was a brick, but the rest of the book is much needed.
This is a very helpful book. The Church needs to put mercy ministry to the poor at the forefront of its agenda (because Jesus did!), and this book provides sound wisdom from Scripture, economics, and practical experience.
What I found most interesting is the chapter on how short-term missions trips can actually do a great deal of harm. The chapter had several good insights on how to do short-term missions better.
The authors are both part of the Chalmers Center for Econo...more
What I found most interesting is the chapter on how short-term missions trips can actually do a great deal of harm. The chapter had several good insights on how to do short-term missions better.
The authors are both part of the Chalmers Center for Econo...more
A helpful, readable introduction to thinking carefully about how to approach poverty alleviation. The authors contend that many of the standard ways of "doing ministry" are actually harmful to the poor (increasing their shame and dependency) and to ourselves (building god complexes). Poverty alleviation should work with the goal to restore people in their relationships with themselves, others, God and creation so that they are able to glorify God by working and supporting themselves an...more
This book completely rocked my world. As Christians, we often think that we help people by giving them a handout or providing financial help. The authors help us think differently about helping, and think critically about what KIND of help people need. Rather that trying to treat a symptom, they ask us to consider addressing the cause. I came away realizing that to effect change, a long-term commitment is required.
If you are a leader in a church, or someone who has a heart to help ...more
If you are a leader in a church, or someone who has a heart to help ...more
While much of When Helping Hurts seems founded on good principles (differentiating between relief and development, empowering self-support instead of perpetuating dependency, elevating beneficiaries to decision-maker status in programs, and so forth), there's something about it that rubs me the wrong way—in nuance, I think. I want to agree with many of the book's points, but I find myself suspicious of them at the same time. I think it has something to do with the the implications of withhol...more
This book is truly is about how we can do more harm than good when we try to help. It approaches this from a Biblical perspective, however, the truths and applications are universal. It challenged me, made me think of my past and how I'm sure I've hurt when I thought I was really helping. How I still do the same. Made me rethink how I currently help homeless people. It was an encouragement as well. It freed me in many ways to. If you plan on ever helping someone of any race, creed, income l...more
This was an excellent resource in learning how to work toward poverty alleviation without causing damage to the people or cultures one is trying to help. The first section has a lot of useful background information, and the introduction and reflection questions enhance. It stresses looking for the positive things (assets) that those in poverty have so that one's approach empowers rather than develops dependency. It also looks a little at the psychology of poverty and how simply supplying mate...more
When Helping Hurts is a helpful and necessary book that I'd recommend to others interested in the best practices of mercy ministry and community development from a Christian perspective. Coming out of a reformed worldview of creation, fall, and redemption, the authors see the purpose of mercy ministries as restoring people to right relationships with God, one another, creation and having a healthy and biblical view of themselves. They have many years of experience and research to share and gre...more
It's rare that a book entirely changes the way I think about a ministry of the Church. That probably says as much about me as it does about the books I read or the power of books in general. However, this is just such a book. It is fantastic.
The foundational idea in When Helping Hurts is that poverty is not just something experienced by the economically disadvantaged. Because of the Fall, we are all poor, as sin has damaged each of the "four foundational relationships"—...more
The foundational idea in When Helping Hurts is that poverty is not just something experienced by the economically disadvantaged. Because of the Fall, we are all poor, as sin has damaged each of the "four foundational relationships"—...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Community Development Specialist for the Chalmers Center for Economic Development and an Assistant Professor in the Department of Economics and Community Development at Covenant College.
More about Steve Corbett...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...
















view 2 comments


























