79th out of 186 books
—
273 voters
Flawed Dogs: The Shocking Raid on Westminster
Pulitzer Prize-winning Berkeley Breathed's first illustrated novel! Sam the Lion is actually a priceless dachshund, bred to be a show dog. More important, he is Heidy?s best friend?and she needs one like never before. Living with her reclusive uncle is hard, but Sam has a way of making her feel soft and whole. Until the day Sam is framed by the jealous poodle Cassius, and...more
Hardcover, 216 pages
Published
September 17th 2009
by Philomel
(first published November 15th 2008)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,176)
This is the story of Sam, a pedigreed dachshund with a rare Duuglitz tuft. Meant to be a show dog, he soon escapes the clutches of the overbearing Mrs. Nutbush and elects to follow an orphan named Heidy who is going to live with her uncle. But when Sam steals the attention away from the champion standard poodle Cassius, Cassius will get his revenge. What ensues is a wild and wacky adventure as the flawed dogs decide to claim what is rightfully theirs.
This book read just like an animated feature...more
This book read just like an animated feature...more
I'm glad my friends recommended this book to me. I almost always avoid animal stories, especially those about dogs, because it seems that they always involve tragedy, death, abuse, etc. and I just can't deal with that. My friends assured me that everything would "be OK" in this story, and they were right! Yes, the story made reference to a few horrible situations, but I thought Breathed did a great job of getting us out of those situations almost as immediately as they were brought up. That way,...more
If it weren’t for the writing, I might have enjoyed Flawed Dogs The Novel by Berkeley Breathed. Its message, like that of Breathed’s picture book, is one everyone should read. But where the picture book conveys this message through cute illustrations and whimsical verse, the novel warps this message through bitter heroes, violent storyline, and a writing style that is sometimes painful to read.
Parts of the plot work. Sam the Lion, a dachshund featured in the picture book, escapes from a show dog...more
Parts of the plot work. Sam the Lion, a dachshund featured in the picture book, escapes from a show dog...more
Feb 27, 2011
Miss Pippi the Librarian
added it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
adolescent-audio-adventures
The idea of Flawed Dogs is very catchy. Who doesn't want to see an underdog succeed? The adorable dachshund on the cover with a ladle for a leg peaked my curiosity. I am sad to say that the story didn't meet my expectations. The storyline jumped between scenes quickly. Many times I hit rewind to repeat sections of the novel. Johnny Heller read very well. Sadly, Berkeley Breathed wrote a choppy novel that has a time setting of three years (view spoiler)...more
Allow me to set a scene for you, review reader. Picture a comfy couch covered in snuggly blankets where a reader is perched with two miniature dachshunds ready to read a book featuring another wiener dog. Picture the reader clutching the two dogs close as she reads the opening scene. Sam (the book's main character) has laid his long, broken, little body on the floor of a dog fighting ring. That, my friends, is how I read this book. I had to hope that Sam was going to make it and we were all goin...more
Flawed Dogs by Berkeley Breathed
A fairy tale illustrating that everyone or every dog should have it’s day. That regardless of size, shape or breed overweening ambition can corrupt and unconditional love can console. A perfect dachshund becomes flawed, despondent, abandoned and maligned. He conquers all and returns in triumph. It is a story of acceptance and redemption.
You may not recall Opus the penguin or Billy and the Boingers but Berkeley Breathed has been around for quite awhile. I admit to...more
A fairy tale illustrating that everyone or every dog should have it’s day. That regardless of size, shape or breed overweening ambition can corrupt and unconditional love can console. A perfect dachshund becomes flawed, despondent, abandoned and maligned. He conquers all and returns in triumph. It is a story of acceptance and redemption.
You may not recall Opus the penguin or Billy and the Boingers but Berkeley Breathed has been around for quite awhile. I admit to...more
I loved this book. Having said that, it must be pointed out that at times it's pretty dark and violent. So I shelved it with middle school and high school. I also think the themes would be better understood by that age group rather than younger kids, even though reviews peg it younger. I just don't agree with them. I agree with other reviewers that the language level is higher than the reviewers' views.
The notion of imperfection being a desired quantity is a well known theme in many novels. Brea...more
The notion of imperfection being a desired quantity is a well known theme in many novels. Brea...more
Sam once had it all. He was a perfect purebred with an elusive tuft of hair that entranced show judges. But more importantly, he had the love of his owner, Heidy. But Sam's winning ways and his bond with young Heidy drive Cassius, the pompous poodle of the housekeeper, to plan his demise. Sam lives, but he's now flawed...and even worse, separated from Heidy. He undergoes unspeakable horrors for three years, meeting an interesting band of misfit dogs along the way. With these "underdogs," Sam set...more
Flawed Dogs is by far the best new book I’ve read all year.
On a recent trip from one U.S. coast to the other, I spent all six take-offs and all six landings with my nose buried in the pages of one book or another, trying to concentrate on the words instead of the terror. Thanks to inclement weather that caused me to miss my last connecting flight, I had to stay over in Denver. On standby the next day, I found Flawed Dogs in the airport bookstore. It was the only one of the books I read during th...more
On a recent trip from one U.S. coast to the other, I spent all six take-offs and all six landings with my nose buried in the pages of one book or another, trying to concentrate on the words instead of the terror. Thanks to inclement weather that caused me to miss my last connecting flight, I had to stay over in Denver. On standby the next day, I found Flawed Dogs in the airport bookstore. It was the only one of the books I read during th...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Nov 03, 2012
Lexie
rated it
1 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
younger children
Shelves:
reviews-written,
read-a-long-time-ago
I read Flawed Dogs a couple years ago. I bought it, in fact, at a book fair because everyone was saying how amazing it looked. But, in fact, I hated it.
SUMMARY A group of dogs with flaws (hence the title) set out to show the world that they're better than pedigreed dogs.
COVER Okay, the cover is what gives it its one star. It's the best thing about this book. And I'm not even a huge fan of it.
PLOT The plot was a bit dull, and I remember that I put down the book to even go do my HOMEWORK.
CHARACT...more
SUMMARY A group of dogs with flaws (hence the title) set out to show the world that they're better than pedigreed dogs.
COVER Okay, the cover is what gives it its one star. It's the best thing about this book. And I'm not even a huge fan of it.
PLOT The plot was a bit dull, and I remember that I put down the book to even go do my HOMEWORK.
CHARACT...more
You’ve heard the saying “Don’t judge a book by its cover”...well that certainly applies to this book. Why? The cover gives the prospective reader the impression that the “read” will be a delightful romp with man’s best friend, but Flawed Dogs is anything but that.
Being a huge animal lover myself, I bought this book hoping to be entertained, and I was not. The first chapter has Sam, the main dog (character) and dachshund, being placed in the ring to fight a pit bull. When he realizes why he has...more
Being a huge animal lover myself, I bought this book hoping to be entertained, and I was not. The first chapter has Sam, the main dog (character) and dachshund, being placed in the ring to fight a pit bull. When he realizes why he has...more
I'm not the kind of mom who troubles herself too deeply about the contents of books or movies. My kids aren't watching the Saw series, but if they enjoy the Nightmare Before Christmas or find Futurama funny, so be it. We began reading Flawed Dogs to our five-year-old, and after the first few disturbing chapters I had to read ahead to make sure that this was a book we could finish reading to him.
This book broke my heart several times. I knew this was going to be a problem when the book opened in...more
This book broke my heart several times. I knew this was going to be a problem when the book opened in...more
Sam the Lion, a unique daschund, finds himself in the arms and heart of Heidy, quickly adopted into her family and loved. Loved, by everyone that is, but Cassius the prize-winning poodle who sets out to destroy Sam and remove him from the household.
The story that follows is sad and does not always show the best of human nature. As a children's book, a parent will have decide how honestly they wish to show the possible life of a stray dog to their children. Having rescued all of our mammalian pet...more
The story that follows is sad and does not always show the best of human nature. As a children's book, a parent will have decide how honestly they wish to show the possible life of a stray dog to their children. Having rescued all of our mammalian pet...more
I guess I was taking too long to read this one aloud: my son read 6 chapters (24 - 30) one night and, after I read one more, he finished it himself. We had gotten to the "really hard to put down" point and it seems that affects him much more than it does me.
I really like how this story played out. I liked that we start in the middle of the story and then are rewound to the very beginning. I like the strange characters -- humans and canines -- that lurk in this book. It does have some dark parts...more
I really like how this story played out. I liked that we start in the middle of the story and then are rewound to the very beginning. I like the strange characters -- humans and canines -- that lurk in this book. It does have some dark parts...more
Actually a 3.5. I was expecting more from this little book as I love all of Berke Breathed's creations. I think what was lacking was character development in this fairly predictable story of dogs-done-wrong seeking revenge and finding themselves on the way. I didn't care about the characters as much as I should have in a kid's book. Still, it had it's wonderful moments of genius, such as the mad escape from the life of a show dog that Sam makes using an electric airport cart as his getaway vehic...more
This is the first of the 15 Sunshine State Young Reader Award (SSYRA) books that I've read for this year, and it's a great one. This is the story of a very rare variation purebred dachshund who is doublecrossed by a vengeful poodle intent of winning all dog shows. This sends him from his happy home to a nightmarish three years in a research lab. Upon escaping the lab, badly scarred and missing a leg, he seeks other "flawed" dogs to join him in taking over the Westminster Dog Show and gaining his...more
I liked this book but the vocabulary is a little high for 3-5 grades.
Pulitzer Prize-winning Berkeley Breathed's first illustrated novel!
Sam the Lion is actually a priceless dachshund, bred to be a show dog. More important, he is Heidy's best friend—and she needs one like never before. Living with her reclusive uncle is hard, but Sam has a way of making her feel soft and whole. Until the day Sam is framed by the jealous poodle Cassius, and is cast out by Heidy's uncle, alone on the wild streets,...more
Pulitzer Prize-winning Berkeley Breathed's first illustrated novel!
Sam the Lion is actually a priceless dachshund, bred to be a show dog. More important, he is Heidy's best friend—and she needs one like never before. Living with her reclusive uncle is hard, but Sam has a way of making her feel soft and whole. Until the day Sam is framed by the jealous poodle Cassius, and is cast out by Heidy's uncle, alone on the wild streets,...more
Oh my. Well, anyone familiar with Berkeley Breathed would likely already know his skills as a storyteller. Flawed Dogs just reinforces this knowledge. Anyone with a love of dogs, an animal story, or a just a good story with a wicked sense of humor and a huge sense of heart will enjoy this brief but worthwhile book. Highly cinematic in its telling, I fully expect to see a movie crafted from it in the future, but I will be content with the book and its marvelous pictures.
My only caveat in this cas...more
My only caveat in this cas...more
Jul 28, 2011
Robert Starner
added it
What a delightfully fun entertaining read. Only wished all illustrations were in color. Breathed is much better in color. Though there are dark overtones within the story, Breathed skirts some of the very scary stuff with implied courtesy and acknowledgement and admission of just how scary the subject matter can be. Enjoy tremendously the terrific sense of humor expressed by Sam the Beagle in his communications and throughout the book's illustrations as well. A great and valuable lesson in taugh...more
I agree with another reviewer that this book can't be judged by it's cover. In fact, after reading it I can say that it hardly belongs on the shelves among other pre-teen books. With topics as gruesome as dog fighting, maiming & mutilation, and the mention of selling dogs to laboratories where the horrors they experience should only be left to the nightmares of children, it is certainly not an appropriate read for impressionable minds.
Dog-lovers and animal-lovers in general will find it dif...more
Dog-lovers and animal-lovers in general will find it dif...more
I really love Bloom County. This book just sat wrong with me for some reason. I heard Berk Breathed speak, and he said that he believes that kids' books should take one into the valley of hard emotions so that one can climb out again. I agree that kids don't need to be coddled or shielded from negative emotions. But this book started off with a dachshund being flung into a fighting dog pit and lying down to die in despair. I've got a soft spot for animals, and I had a hard time with that one. I...more
This was a book I very much wanted to like. I've been a Berkeley Breathed fan since Bloom County's first days and a book written (and illustrated!) by him should have such potential.
It was good to find that Berkeley Breathed's book-length writing was as good as some of his more prose-heavy Bloom County comic strips. The problem, however, was that Sam's story seemed a bit cobbled together. There were many strong scenes but the transitions seemed to me missing for me. There were stretches of story...more
It was good to find that Berkeley Breathed's book-length writing was as good as some of his more prose-heavy Bloom County comic strips. The problem, however, was that Sam's story seemed a bit cobbled together. There were many strong scenes but the transitions seemed to me missing for me. There were stretches of story...more
So, you won't often see me give 5 stars, especially not to a juvenile novel, but this one deserved it. Berkeley Breathed's "Flawed Dogs: The Novel" was fantastic! Based on his picture book, "Flawed Dogs: The Year-End Leftovers at the Piddleton Last Chance Dog Pound," the book follows Sam the Lion as he becomes a flawed dog and then learns that heart matters more than those flaws. It's a must read for dog lovers, but will bring a smile to your heart, regardless.
"Sam watched his commandos meet th...more
"Sam watched his commandos meet th...more
I am still reading this book but so far it's pretty good. It's a bit jumpy and its not in chronological order most of the time but the story line is good. The author is also author of opus and many other books and cartoons. The book is about a dog named Sam who is a very rare breed of dachshund called the duuglitz tuft dachshund who finds a girl named Heidi and comes with her to her uncles dog ranch where a poodle named Cassius lives. Soon after Sam arriving Cassius gets jealous of him and the a...more
The cover art caught my attention and when I realized it was written by Berkeley Breathed, creator of Bloom County, I had to give it a try. It looked like it would be a fun book to read out loud to my 7-yr-old son who likes dogs. Well, not so much. The vocabulary is above his level and the story gets really dark-the dog goes through some pretty horrific experiences. But some of Breathed's typical offbeat humor is still there including the funniest lines I have read in a long time:
"...giving the...more
"...giving the...more
Sam the Lion is a dachshund that is a show dog, living only to make his owner happy. Heidy is an orphan who is sent to live with her Uncle Hamish. Heidy and Sam are very happy living with one another under Uncle Hamishes care. Then one day the house keepers poodle decides to frame Sam for misbehavior and he is sent away. He is sent to a pound for unadopted dogs and is very unhappy with his situation and decides to break out. Then he finds himself in even a greater predicament. This is a fun and...more
There are two things you need to keep in mind about me:
1) I'm not really a dog person.
2) I'm not really into Berkeley Breathed.
Neither of these things are especially surprising if you know me, but the reality is that these two issues probably impacted my ability to enjoy this book. It follows a dog and his pretty terrible struggle that brings him from a family to a dogfighting ring and back again, and it really felt uneven and strange and uncomfortable. Kids books are great when they are strange...more
1) I'm not really a dog person.
2) I'm not really into Berkeley Breathed.
Neither of these things are especially surprising if you know me, but the reality is that these two issues probably impacted my ability to enjoy this book. It follows a dog and his pretty terrible struggle that brings him from a family to a dogfighting ring and back again, and it really felt uneven and strange and uncomfortable. Kids books are great when they are strange...more
One of my favorite pictures books to use with my students is Flawed Dogs by Berkely Breathed. The pictures alone are worthy of a fun writing assignment. Well, he has followed that up with a novel that includes all the funny yet flawed characters from that book. This book is kind of like a prequel to the picture book and explains how they arrived at the last chance dog pound where that book takes place. It is a very sweet, sometimes sad, look at the life of a dachshund named Sam the Lion. Might m...more
I read this to my 3rd grade class and while there were lots of high level words they begged me and reminded me to read every day. The pictures were funny and really added to the story as well. There is a few things such as language and topics that I didn't read or skipped over but they didn't notice. It is appropriate for 4th-5th grade to read independent though. It had just about everything in this story: drama, comedy, and the sad parts too. At the suspense parts the kids would even go da-da-d...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Guy Berkeley "Berke" Breathed is an American cartoonist, children's book author/illustrator, director, and screenwriter, best known for Bloom County, a 1980s cartoon-comic strip which dealt with socio-political issues as seen through the eyes of highly exaggerated characters (e.g. Bill the Cat and Opus the Penguin) and humorous analogies.
More about Berkeley Breathed...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“Neither knew it at the time, but a line had been crossed that could not be uncrossed- a running leap over a chasm of ignorance and misunderstanding between species and worlds...and a baby step taken into life's endless possibilities for wonder and joy and surprise that could no more be reversed than one's first taste of chocolate.
A dog kiss.”
—
4 people liked it
More quotes…
A dog kiss.”

Loading...










view 1 comment


















