16th out of 52 books
—
87 voters
How Beautiful the Ordinary: Twelve Stories of Identity
by
Michael Cart ,
Francesca Lia Block (Goodreads Author), David Levithan (Goodreads Author), Ron Koertge, Eric Shanower (Goodreads Author), Julie Anne Peters, Jennifer Finney Boylan (Goodreads Author), William Sleater
,
more…
A girl thought to be a boy steals her sister's skirt, while a boy thought to be a girl refuses to wear a cornflower blue dress. One boy's love of a soldier leads to the death of a stranger. The present takes a bittersweet journey into the past when a man revisits the summer school where he had "an accidental romance." And a forgotten mother writes a poignant letter to the...more
Hardcover, 350 pages
Published
October 6th 2009
by HarperTeen
(first published September 23rd 2009)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,760)
Anthologies are almost always a mixed bag. Especially anthologies by multiple writers. There's always at least a few stories that I just don't like, for whatever reason. How Beautiful the Ordinary is doing good to have only two stories that didn't resonate with me.
The subtitle (Twelve Stories of Identity) is a little cagey. What does that mean, exactly? Especially in a YA, where half the genre is about discovering who you really are. Here, though, it means sexual and gender identity. Yes, this i...more
The subtitle (Twelve Stories of Identity) is a little cagey. What does that mean, exactly? Especially in a YA, where half the genre is about discovering who you really are. Here, though, it means sexual and gender identity. Yes, this i...more
As many have noted, this would be a solid three stars without a couple of standout pieces. David Levithan's is probably my favorite. He writes with the absolute conviction that it gets better, to steal the recent catchphrase. He has the power to make you see the world as a better place without leaving you feeling disappointed when you finish reading. I have to say, I didn't like Margo Lanagan's story as much as I wanted to -- she's an amazing author and I love her books, but her story didn't rea...more
Feb 21, 2010
Henry
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Teens
Recommended to Henry by:
My English teacher
When I read How Beautiful The Ordinary: Twelve Stories Of Identity I thought it was great. I thought some of these stories were more for adult than teens like the story by David Levithan’s “A Word from the Nearly Distant Past,” in which Levithan recounts the experiences of generations past as they dealt with being in the closet, dealing with the AIDS crisis, and exhorts the younger generation to make sure that they live for future generations, as much as for themselves. This one was one of my f...more
Editor Michael Cart has collected twelve stories about LGBT youth identity in the form of short stories, graphic fiction, and verse, by well-known young-adult, and adult authors including Francesca Lia Block, Gregory Maguire, Jacqueline Woodson, Ariel Schrag, Emma Donoghue, and others.
There is something for everyone in this collection: stories of ghosts and girls trapped in walls serving as metaphors for transgendered teens trapped in the wrong body; handsome highway men and soldiers for a stab...more
There is something for everyone in this collection: stories of ghosts and girls trapped in walls serving as metaphors for transgendered teens trapped in the wrong body; handsome highway men and soldiers for a stab...more
The story from which the title of this collection comes is by David Levithan. It took me apart. Entirely. I think Levithan writes from the same place L'Engle wrote from- that calm and sure center where love lives, that place of hope untainted by delusion. He's rapidly becoming one of my favorites. I suspect this particular piece resonated so strongly with me because I can remember so clearly the time when all the beautiful boys were dying and we were powerless and afraid and fairly certain we we...more
Michael Cart has pulled together an interesting and fairly well-rounded sampling of lgbtq writings. The first 11 stories are fairly predictable and thoroughly enjoyable (or at least, if not whole-heartedly enjoyable to me, I can easily imagine that they would be enjoyable to others) but Gregory Maguire’s final story is a bit of a sore thumb.
*enter diatribe*
Maguire’s story is good, really good…it just doesn’t meld with the other selections. Told from the POV of a 40 year old father, flashing back...more
*enter diatribe*
Maguire’s story is good, really good…it just doesn’t meld with the other selections. Told from the POV of a 40 year old father, flashing back...more
I enjoyed the variety within this collection, unified nonetheless by the theme of gendered and sexual identity. The anthology includes stories of love, loss and betrayal, as well as specifically LGBT experience. Few are traditional short stories; there are two comic book stories, one novella and several use unusual voice or experiment with narration in some way. The stories are a mixture of realism and fantasy, and cover different time periods as well as a wide range of LGBT experience: male/mal...more
A girl thought to be a boy steals her sister's skirt, while a boy thought to be a girl refuses to wear a cornflower blue dress. One boy's love of a soldier leads to the death of a stranger. The present takes a bittersweet journey into the past when a man revisits the summer school where he had "an accidental romance." And a forgotten mother writes a poignant letter to the teenage daughter she hasn't seen for fourteen years.
Poised between the past and the future are the stories of now. In nontrad...more
Poised between the past and the future are the stories of now. In nontrad...more
This is a collection of short stories about identity for GLBT teens, though I'm not sure it's entirely aimed at YAs. Gregory Maguire's story in particular is definitely more of an adult story; it's set in both the past and the present, and tells the story of a key incident in a teen's life, and how it continues to affect him as a 40-something father. While I appreciated the viewpoint, being a 40-something myself, I'm not sure any YA would understand (or want to understand) how life works sometim...more
Twelve stories, all exploring different aspects of LGBT life and identity. I definitely enjoyed some stories more than others, but each was enjoyable it its own way. "A World from the Nearly Distant Past" nearly made me cry. I loved how the ghosts of the past watched the present and future and cheered them on from the side. "Happily Ever After" was a nicely drawn comic that had a great resolution that is left open for many different avenues. "A Dark Red Love Knot," while excellent writing and be...more
I had no idea this was an LGBT book when I picked it up - I was looking for a book of short stories to read for book club and the title and subtitle (twelve stories of identity) drew me in. I think the ambiguous cover and title might make it more appealing to teens who might not want it immediately visible what they are reading.
The stories represented a wide variety of experiences, emotions, and styles. There were one or two that just didn't click with me, but in an anthology that's not bad. And...more
The stories represented a wide variety of experiences, emotions, and styles. There were one or two that just didn't click with me, but in an anthology that's not bad. And...more
There isn't much to say about this book or a lot I really want to say to be honest, so this will be shorter than my other reviews.
I liked what this book was all about, I really did. The title jumped out at me and so did the subject matter. What didn't really capture me was a lot of the stories. I had my 2 favourites and then I skimmed over the other stories because their beginnings just did grab me like the couple I liked.
It seems that nowadays the subject of being an outcast, whether gay, strai...more
I liked what this book was all about, I really did. The title jumped out at me and so did the subject matter. What didn't really capture me was a lot of the stories. I had my 2 favourites and then I skimmed over the other stories because their beginnings just did grab me like the couple I liked.
It seems that nowadays the subject of being an outcast, whether gay, strai...more
I picked this up after reading Margo Lanagan's post about her story (http://amongamidwhile.blogspot.com/20...), because I've loved "The Highwayman" ever since reading it in a grade-school literature book. And I did think "A Dark Red Love Knot" quite wonderful. I'm a little put off by the collection as a whole, though. The cover promises "stories of identity" and the flap details "distinctively modern views of love, sexuality, and gender identification." Keep going and in the introduction you lea...more
This collection of GLTBQ-themed short stories definitely skews toward older teen readers in style as well as content. And the content ranges all over, including the darkly disturbing (Lanagan, big surprise) and the honestly explicit (Peters). Most of the stories are about older young adults--Donoghue's and Maguire's stories are even written from an older adult perspective. I enjoyed the mixed format (comics by Schrag and Shanower), and was pleased to see several stories featuring trans character...more
These twelve stories represent a variety of genres (prose, poetry, letter, instant messaging/e-mail, and graphic formats). Award-winning authors David Levithan, Jacqueline Woodson, Gregory Maguire, William Sleator, Francesca Lia Block, and Julie Anne Peters all contribute to this mostly moving, sometimes stunning collection, which includes two stories that explore gender identity and expression exclusively. One of my favorite pieces is Margo Lanagan’s “A Dark Red Love Knot,” which retells Alfred...more
Well, other than the fact that the introduction kept saying lesbian, gay, and trangender, thus excluding bi, pan, and otherwise queer identified people, and the borderline transphobia and cissexism in two of the stories, this anthology was okay. It felt very GL(t) to me, with 6 books about gay males, 3 about lesbians, 2 about trans* guys and 1 about a trans* girl. David Levithan's story was fairly good, and a good reminder to younger queer people about older members of the community did before t...more
I enjoyed most of the stories in the collection. Many were very touching and I cried several times, but I withheld one star because there were definitely some pieces that seemed overly lengthy or which simply didn't hold my attention as much as others. The various narrative forms were interesting and added variety. David Levithan's piece, in particular, was beautiful.
I think there is something to be found in each story and I would recommend this collection, especially to anyone else struggling w...more
I think there is something to be found in each story and I would recommend this collection, especially to anyone else struggling w...more
I really enjoyed the short stories in here. Out of the twelve stories I didn't like four, so there's that. That's the thing with picking up a book with multiple authors. You'll read one short story and LOVE it and then the next one makes you want to stop reading the entire book.
I'm really glad I read the book though. It's a great way to find the writing style of new authors so you can check out the other books they have done. For example, I loved David Levithan's story, but I love all his books...more
I'm really glad I read the book though. It's a great way to find the writing style of new authors so you can check out the other books they have done. For example, I loved David Levithan's story, but I love all his books...more
Apr 04, 2012
Sarah
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Shelves:
queer-people-themes-studies,
young-adult,
anthologies,
romance-major-theme,
angst-angst-angst,
china-japan-southeast-asia,
crap-parents,
creepy,
i-cried,
issues-with-this,
made-me-think,
multiple-perspectives,
north-america-about-or-setting,
our-world-special-powers,
protagonist-i-want-to-slap,
quickie,
plothole-what-plothole,
politically-socially-aware,
realistic-or-contemporary-fiction,
shield-your-eyes-kids,
where-are-your-parents
I had varying feelings about each of the stories.
A world from the nearly distant past: David Levithan - 5 Stars
I cried. Just read it; it's good.
Happily Ever After: Eric Shanower - 2.5 Stars
My life as a dog: Ron Koertge - 3.5 Stars
Trev: Jacqueline Woodson - 3 Stars
My Virtual World: Francesca Lia Block - 3 Stars
A Dark Red Love-Knot: Margo Lanagan - 0 Stars
Ohhh, this one made me angry. I don't know whether it's because I love The Highwayman (original Noyes poem on which this story is based- for a...more
A world from the nearly distant past: David Levithan - 5 Stars
I cried. Just read it; it's good.
Happily Ever After: Eric Shanower - 2.5 Stars
My life as a dog: Ron Koertge - 3.5 Stars
Trev: Jacqueline Woodson - 3 Stars
My Virtual World: Francesca Lia Block - 3 Stars
A Dark Red Love-Knot: Margo Lanagan - 0 Stars
Ohhh, this one made me angry. I don't know whether it's because I love The Highwayman (original Noyes poem on which this story is based- for a...more
I thought my impression was: a somewhat uneven collection. But I'm pretty sure the problem is not with the book, but with me being a long way from 17. Not all stories resonate across ages.
As a 37 year old then: David Levithan's story was brilliant: heartrending and joyous; classic and iconic and new and different and everyone should read it. Eric Shanower's comic was very well done, but...I think you have to love the storytelling tropes of comic books to appreciate it, and I don't. I love Ron Ko...more
As a 37 year old then: David Levithan's story was brilliant: heartrending and joyous; classic and iconic and new and different and everyone should read it. Eric Shanower's comic was very well done, but...I think you have to love the storytelling tropes of comic books to appreciate it, and I don't. I love Ron Ko...more
Truly enjoyable collection. I'd read works by David Levithan, Jacqueline Woodson, Ariel Schrag, Jennifer Finney Boylan, and Gregory Maquire in the past, so had fairly high expectations. I wasn't disappointed. What was most impressive and enjoyable was the variety of stories present - graphic story, poetry, prose, short form and long, comedy and tragedy, realistic fiction, fantasy, biography, and complex main characters who, amidst their other identity markers, identify as gay, lesbian, or transg...more
Ages 14+ (sex, sex, and sex)
I adore, I adore, I adore. Of course, that may just be the afterglow of Gregory Maguire's modern homage to Brokeback Mountain. But even without that, this is a well rounded collection of what it means to be gay, lesbian, or transgender from a series of great authors. (Julie Ann Peters, your offering was almost PWP, I never expected!) As of this note, Margo Lanagan's is the only story I haven't read, but her style has never suited me. For gay folks, straight folks, and...more
I adore, I adore, I adore. Of course, that may just be the afterglow of Gregory Maguire's modern homage to Brokeback Mountain. But even without that, this is a well rounded collection of what it means to be gay, lesbian, or transgender from a series of great authors. (Julie Ann Peters, your offering was almost PWP, I never expected!) As of this note, Margo Lanagan's is the only story I haven't read, but her style has never suited me. For gay folks, straight folks, and...more
With the Trax commuting I do, I find that I really like having short story collections on my Kindle. The stories here were OK. The bulk of the book was about a 3 star for me, not standing out one way or another. Until I got to the last story by Maguire. I'm generally not a fan of Maguire's writing, but I loved this story. The juxtaposition of present/third person with past/first person was done quite well. The way the story slowly filled itself in and revealed itself was wonderful. And the emoti...more
Not every story in it is a five-star for me, but I think most of them would be for somebody. I'd have loved to have read this as a teen when I was looking for representations of myself and of the people I hoped to love someday. And as far as covering plenty of different LGBTQ topics, this anthology works. Parents and straight kids may not get it, but I absolutely believe it will hit the spot for young people who need it.
i chose to read 3 stories from this collection. the book features stories (fiction) from twelve popular authors on being glbtq. i read stories by: david levithan, francesca lia block, and julie anne peters. i've read more than one book by each before. although i love david's writing normally, i just couldn't get into his story. i'm still confused as to what it's about. block's story is told through blog entries and emails, and tells the story of a girl who has always identified as straight falli...more
oh my god how did i not add this book to goodreads before? it was fucking awesome. Also, normally I feel pretty indifferent about David Levithan, but the first story by him was AMAZING. and Julie Ann Peters rocked as well. And Gregory Maguire surprised me -- I don't usually like him either. Great great great great. Although I don't know why I'm surprised; Michael Cart always does awesome anthologies.
I really enjoyed some of the stories in this collection, and others I felt were lacking luster or excitement. Some of the stories felt forced, being written solely on the crutch of "this needs to be LGBT related" and forgetting the art of story and prose.
I didn't hate this book, I think it's fantastic that the collection exists, I just wish some of the stories had been better.
I didn't hate this book, I think it's fantastic that the collection exists, I just wish some of the stories had been better.
A really solid group of authors, I overall really enjoyed this collection. In particular, the opening piece by David Levithan was really wonderful, some of his best writing I've seen. And I LOVED Gregory Maguire's story, which is the last one and the longest one, taking up almost a quarter of the book. So good.
A collection of gay, lesbian and transgender short stories aimed at teens, but with crossover adult appeal. David Levithan, Jennifer Flynn Boyle, Jacqueline Woodson, Fransesca Lia Block, and William Sleator are some of the authors featured in this collection. Worth reading just for the closing story from Gregory Maguire, about a gay, Iranian-American man looking back at a college romance as he travels across the United States to visit his alma mater.
Other highlights included the story from Will...more
Other highlights included the story from Will...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Former Director of the Beverly Hills (CA) Public Library and a Past President of the Young Adult Library Services Association, Michael Cart is a nationally recognized expert in children's and young adult literature. Now a columnist and reviewer for ALA's Booklist magazine, he is the author or editor of eight books, including From Romance to Realism, a critical history of YA literature; MY FATHER'S...more
More about Michael Cart...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“Ignorance isn't bliss. Bliss is knowing the full meaning of what you have been given.”
—
6 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...











view all 7 comments

















