126th out of 391 books
—
177 voters
Lovecraft Unbound
by
Ellen Datlow (Goodreads Author) ,
Dale Bailey , Richard Bowes , Anna Tambour , Brian Evenson , Amanda Downum (Goodreads Author) , Joel Lane , Holly Phillips
,
more…
The stories are legendary, the characters unforgettable, the world horrible and disturbing. Howard Phillips Lovecraft may have been a writer for only a short time, but the creations he left behind after his death in 1937 have shaped modern horror more than any other author in the last two centuries: the shambling god Cthulhu, and the other deities of the Elder Things, the...more
Paperback, 421 pages
Published
October 1st 2009
by Dark Horse Comics
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,257)
This is a terribly-titled book, because most of these stories have little to nothing to do with HPL. Cthulhu isn't even mentioned at all! Wrap your head around that (if you can).
Also, even for an anthology, this seems particularly uneven. More on that below:
1. "The Crevasse" by Dale Bailey and Nathan Ballingrud
A dog-sled team in the Antarctic encounters evidence of a buried civilization under the ice. OR DO THEY?!? I really enjoyed this one, it did a great job of pulling off the creepy somethin...more
Also, even for an anthology, this seems particularly uneven. More on that below:
1. "The Crevasse" by Dale Bailey and Nathan Ballingrud
A dog-sled team in the Antarctic encounters evidence of a buried civilization under the ice. OR DO THEY?!? I really enjoyed this one, it did a great job of pulling off the creepy somethin...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
I have to admit that I'm a huge fan of reading works based on Lovecraft's or influenced by him and I tend to really enjoy Ellen Datlow as she draws typically wonderful pieces together from all over the place. This, in that regard, wasn't an exception to the rule. Nearly all of the stories were well done and the influence of HP could truly be found. Oddly for me the ones that I liked best (with the exception of Mongoose which took place in space) were set in Antarctica and Lovecraft's own Mountai...more
All short story anthologies are doomed to ups and downs; this is no exception. Lovecraft provides wide but often transparent (more often in theme than in mythos) and occasionally repetitive inspiration, especially in the stories written expressly for this collection, a problem exacerbated by post-story blurbs where authors provide two-penny insights into Lovecraft's work. But Datlow is an accomplished collator: the selection is broad, the variety of styles--sometimes ranging too far: there's a f...more
I really wanted to like this book, and I usually love Mythos stories by other writers. The Mythos is so badass that it's kind of hard to fuck it up. But these stories, mostly they had nothing at all to do with Lovecraft. I know that one of the stated aims of the editor in the introduction was to, you know, see how far they could go with Lovecraft, but after a certain point it just becomes supernatural fiction, and you get the feeling that this book was named Lovecraft Unbound to get it to sell....more
"ph'nglui mglw'nafh Cthulhu R'lyeh wgah'nagl fhtagn"
Now that that's out of the way, I admit it: H.P. Lovecraft isn't really my thing. It's not that his ideas aren't brilliant and genre-bending (not to mention a bit mind-breaking), but I've only ever been able to truly enjoy him when I consider his works in a historical context rather than as works of fiction, because otherwise I find his prose, well, purple. It is only by taking into account the era in which he was writing and the prevalent lite...more
Now that that's out of the way, I admit it: H.P. Lovecraft isn't really my thing. It's not that his ideas aren't brilliant and genre-bending (not to mention a bit mind-breaking), but I've only ever been able to truly enjoy him when I consider his works in a historical context rather than as works of fiction, because otherwise I find his prose, well, purple. It is only by taking into account the era in which he was writing and the prevalent lite...more
Once upon a time I wrote part of a dreadful H.P. Lovecraft pastiche. I mention this not because you care about the many pieces of fiction I've abandoned over the years, but to offer another small piece of evidence for the truth Ellen Datlow mentions in her introduction to this eminently enjoyable anthology: unimaginative Lovecraft imitations are everywhere. People treat his stories like a mathematical formula: strained antiquated prose plus unspeakable tentacled evil equals masterwork of horror....more
Edited by Ellen Datlow, whose collections generally more than fulfill their promise, here are 22 stories inspired by Lovecraft. Datlow sought stories inspired - thematically and possibly - by plot points in Lovecraft's mythos. She wanted variety: in tone, setting, point of view, time. Datlow had a preference for stories that made no use of the words 'eldritch' or 'ichor', and no mention of Cthulhu or his minions. And especially no tentacles. Having said that some tentacles did slip through but t...more
I'm neither a Lovecraft fan nor a horror fan, so possibly my opinion on this book is not of much value to anybody. However, I'm going to give it anyway.
There are twenty stories in this book. I abandoned fourteen for being either boring (you have to get my attention with human desires; life-or-death adventures on the ice don't cut it), amateurish (starting way too early, thunking into the dreaded past perfect for a nice long slog through the backstory, awkwardly lurching from emotion to emotion),...more
There are twenty stories in this book. I abandoned fourteen for being either boring (you have to get my attention with human desires; life-or-death adventures on the ice don't cut it), amateurish (starting way too early, thunking into the dreaded past perfect for a nice long slog through the backstory, awkwardly lurching from emotion to emotion),...more
Not being a big Lovecraft fan, I can't really say why I picked this up -- but I was pleasantly surprised with it. The quality of the writing is consistently good, with the stories being inspired by Lovecraft, rather than imitations of his work.
My favourite story was Mongoose, by Sarah Monette & Elizabeth Bear -- it was suspenseful, but had a lovely charm to it, with engaging characters.
Sadly, the weakest for me was In The Black Mill, by Michael Chabon. I really expected to love this one, but...more
My favourite story was Mongoose, by Sarah Monette & Elizabeth Bear -- it was suspenseful, but had a lovely charm to it, with engaging characters.
Sadly, the weakest for me was In The Black Mill, by Michael Chabon. I really expected to love this one, but...more
Usually when I tackle a short story collections there will be at least one or two duds from my point of view, but while there were a few here that I didn't like as much as others they were all rather inventive and there wasn't a one that I felt like saying "Why did they include THAT in here?" over.
My without-a-doubt favourite is Mongoose. It's pretty much straight-out sci-fi with a Lovecraft bent, I can honestly say I was sad when it finished. Looking up Elizabeth Bear and Sarah Monette's work I...more
My without-a-doubt favourite is Mongoose. It's pretty much straight-out sci-fi with a Lovecraft bent, I can honestly say I was sad when it finished. Looking up Elizabeth Bear and Sarah Monette's work I...more
I am rating this one at 3.5, the highest rating I've given an Ellen Datlow collection so far. Having just finished four other books she's edited, I have to say that this one has a wider range of good stories than the previous four volumes of The Best Horror of the Year do individually. It's still a mixed bag though, with some stories much better than the rest, some following under the category of "good and I'd probably look for more by their authors," and some that just didn't do it for me. In s...more
I thought about rating this one 4 stars, because of a number of really fine stories. However, there are at least a 100 pages wasted on pretty lame material. I think when you get to a 100, the sin for an anthology becomes unforgivable. I have notes for the individual stories, but I left them elsewhere. Maybe I'll put them up later. In the mean time, the good stuff:
The Crevasse, by Dale Bailey and Nathan Ballingrud
Cold Water Survival, by Holly Phillips
Houses under the Sea, by Caitlan Kiernan (Best...more
The Crevasse, by Dale Bailey and Nathan Ballingrud
Cold Water Survival, by Holly Phillips
Houses under the Sea, by Caitlan Kiernan (Best...more
I thought these short stories would be a little more Lovecraft mythos themed, but the editor says they tried to stay away from Cthulu and tentacles, which I suppose is fair. A lot of stories are terrific anyway, though most of them seem to be in the second half of the book, which is a good buy because of its length alone. I recommend "Leng" by Laidlaw, "In the Black Mill" by Chabon, "Commencement" by Joyce Carol Oates, and "Mongoose" by Monette and Bear.
From the other Lovecraft spinoff mythos I'...more
From the other Lovecraft spinoff mythos I'...more
I love shorts stories in general but this batch was really good. These are all Lovecraft inspired stories by different authors, there are some seriously creepy, fatalistic tales in here. I really loved Mongoose in particular, loved the Alice references. I definitely reccommend this book. I think this is a good book to read if you find Lovecraft himself difficult, I think this gives you a good idea of the feel of his writing without bogging you down in heavy, musty descriptions, strange tongue-tw...more
I love the horror genre, especially in short story form, to which I think it’s ideally suited, but I’m not as well read in the classics as I’d like. I haven’t read any Lovecraft stories until recently: when I checked out this book, I checked out a book of Lovecraft stories to read first, so I could experience what I’d heard about his writing style and his themes firsthand. I read (more like skimmed, to be honest) five stories before giving up entirely. I hate to admit it, but even though I find...more
A compilation of novels is difficult enough to keep interesting, but to try to compile authors where Lovecraft is the common inspiration is near impossible. The aim of Datlow is not to create a collection of stories based on Lovecraft's body of work, but more inspired by the same. This does create a very unbalanced collection. Some of the author's are clearly better than others and it seems as if they have all decided to use the same blueprint when they tackled the task.
Most of the short stories...more
Most of the short stories...more
I was disappointed with this collection, but then that was partly my fault as my expectations were askew. If I'm honest I didn’t read the introduction until I’d read all of the tales. (It sounds perverse, but I never read introductions until I’ve finished reading the rest of the book. Primarily because, if you have a piece of classic fiction you’ve never encountered before, the introduction is often quite happy to ruin the entire plot). And the thing is, the introduction does make it entirely cl...more
Another excellent anthology of horror from legendary editor Ellen Datlow. Here she has collected 20 tales influenced by Howard Phillips Lovecraft, best known for his "Cthulhu Mythos" stories from the first three decades of the 20th Century. This anthology is just what I like to see from new Lovecraftian fiction, that is, these stories are new.
Lovecraft is one of those authors who are famous, not just for their own work, but for pastiche. Too often Lovecraftian fiction is but pale imitation of th...more
Lovecraft is one of those authors who are famous, not just for their own work, but for pastiche. Too often Lovecraftian fiction is but pale imitation of th...more
This is not a collection of Mythos stories, or even stories necessarily set in Lovecraft's world. It seems the idea was to collect stories inspired by the tone in much of Lovecraft's work. Bleak hopelessness, psychological strain, that sort of thing. Oh, there are indeed things recognizable as Old Ones, but none of the familiar ones. So if you're a fan of Lovecraft, you're likely to enjoy the style the authors were aiming for, but feel somewhat mislead with what you get. Be forewarned.
Anthologie...more
Anthologie...more
Datlow, with the possible exception of Gardener Dozois, is probably one of the best SF/Horror editors ever so I was pretty much assured this comp was going to have some solid gold in it. I was not disappointed.
This is one of the best, if not the best, Lovecraft collection I've ever read (barring those by HPL himself), featuring a variety of styles and approaches. By being flexible in her selection of 'Lovecraftian' material, she was able to include some excellent gems that might have otherwise b...more
This is one of the best, if not the best, Lovecraft collection I've ever read (barring those by HPL himself), featuring a variety of styles and approaches. By being flexible in her selection of 'Lovecraftian' material, she was able to include some excellent gems that might have otherwise b...more
I am fairly wary when it comes to Lovecraftian stories by other authors. Either they are really good, or really bad. And usually they are really bad.
I have to say though that Lovecraft Unbound was an enjoyable read. The editor set out to have authors write stories that were Lovecraftian in their ideas, not in their monsters/characters/etc. Sure, some of them still have a tentacle or two, but for the most part, we are left with a very unique feeling after each story, one that we encounter when we...more
I have to say though that Lovecraft Unbound was an enjoyable read. The editor set out to have authors write stories that were Lovecraftian in their ideas, not in their monsters/characters/etc. Sure, some of them still have a tentacle or two, but for the most part, we are left with a very unique feeling after each story, one that we encounter when we...more
My new favorite story "Mongoose" is in this anthology, so I thought I'd read the whole thing. Disappointingly, the theme is Lovecraft without tentacles or reference to anything Lovecraft. I like tentacles, and the world "eldritch," and Deep Ones, and all the other disallowed items. (A few did sneak in, but not as many as I'd like.) The stories are solid but to me they were horror stories, not Cthulhu Mythos for the most part.
With "Lovecraft Unbound", Datlow seeks to assemble authors to channel Lovecraft without regurgitating a bunch of Cthulhu-mythos characters. Across twenty short stories, there are only a handful of direct Lovecraft references and for the most part, the collection is the stronger for the works that pay homage to Lovecraft without ripping him off.
As with any anthology, some stories ("The Crevasse", Marya Nox") are better than others ("Machines of Concrete Light and Dark", "Catch Hell"); others ("Ho...more
As with any anthology, some stories ("The Crevasse", Marya Nox") are better than others ("Machines of Concrete Light and Dark", "Catch Hell"); others ("Ho...more
I think Lovecraft often gets a bad rap. People read that he influenced the modern greats, everyone form authors like Stephen King and Clive Barker, to movie makers like John Carpenter and Wes Craven, and then dive into his books expecting the same fare. He wrote for a different era. His mind-bending, first person surrealistic approach to a creeping, nameless horror stunned and fascinated huge segments of early century America. The America that read, that is, which wasn't nearly what it is today....more
The stories in this book are overall very much in his style. I think I would like these stories, and indeed Lovecraft's own works, more if there were more explanation to them. I really enjoyed most of them, but as I said, there were times that I wished that there was more detail. Part of the mystery in the stories is the unknown, but instead of being spooked, sometimes I was just plain confused....several times I went back and reread passages just to be sure I didn't miss anything. Overall thoug...more
These kind of books are always a bit scary: Sometimes the contributors who take the basic ideas of a well-loved author for an anthology can get it so completely wrong.
But I've heard so many good things about this, plus Ellen Datlow was also the editor of the very impressive Alien Sex, that I am going to give it a go.
But I've heard so many good things about this, plus Ellen Datlow was also the editor of the very impressive Alien Sex, that I am going to give it a go.
Some fantastic stuff in here, some not-so-good. I really liked that is isn't full of the usual Lovecraft pastiches -- the book is very deliberately NOT a collection of those. My favorite is probably "Mongoose," which was an absolute blast, full of references not just to HPL but many others, notably Lewis Carroll.
A really disappointing book - most of the tales trail off without any real ending. I realize that they were going for a post-modern, "hip" take on Cthulhu Mythos - Cthulhu stories that never directly invoke Lovecraftian mainstays, but it results (mostly)in a naval-gazing, magical-realism-with-a-little-gore-added-in muddle.
A wonderful collection of new Mythos tales, the greatest strength of which is it's foregoing of tentacles and ichor in favor of the broader Lovecraftian themes of cosmic dread and deep time. Worth reading just for Kaitlyn Kiernan's "Houses Under The Sea", but theres a remarkable variety of fine stories here.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Ellen Datlow has been an award-winning editor of short science fiction, fantasy, and horror for over twentyfive years.
She is editor of the Best Horror of the Year and has edited or co-edited a large number of award-winning original anthologies. Her most recent are Supernatural Noir, Naked City, Blood and Other Cravings, The Beastly Bride, Teeth, Trolls Eye View, and After (the last three with Ter...more
More about Ellen Datlow...
She is editor of the Best Horror of the Year and has edited or co-edited a large number of award-winning original anthologies. Her most recent are Supernatural Noir, Naked City, Blood and Other Cravings, The Beastly Bride, Teeth, Trolls Eye View, and After (the last three with Ter...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“Terrible and ancient and scarred with the endless cold of space, the terrible and ancient things glistened with frozen moisture and colors played across the surface of the skin, colors that were never meant to be seen on earth.”
—
3 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...


























Jul 01, 2010 10:57am
Jul 03, 2010 04:42am