The Invention of the Jewish People
A historical tour de force that demolishes the myths and taboos that have surrounded Jewish and Israeli history, The Invention of the Jewish People offers a new account of both that demands to be read and reckoned with. Was there really a forced exile in the first century, at the hands of the Romans? Should we regard the Jewish people, throughout two millennia, as both a d...more
Hardcover, 432 pages
Published
October 1st 2009
by Verso
(first published September 3rd 2008)
There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!
sign in »
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is currently not featured on any Listopia lists.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
286)
Как сa измислени еврейската и другите нации по света – “Изобретяването на еврейския народ” от проф. Шломо Занд
http://www.knigolandia.info/2011/05/blog...
Да напишеш такава книга е безкрайно трудно. Още повече ако се числиш към еврейския народ, въобразил си уникалност и самовнушена богоизбраност. И готов на всичко, за да превърне в несъмнена истина хардкор фентъзито “Стар Завет”, без подбор на средства и методи. Не, това не е антисемитизъм, както ще има вряскания до небето. То...more
http://www.knigolandia.info/2011/05/blog...
Да напишеш такава книга е безкрайно трудно. Още повече ако се числиш към еврейския народ, въобразил си уникалност и самовнушена богоизбраност. И готов на всичко, за да превърне в несъмнена истина хардкор фентъзито “Стар Завет”, без подбор на средства и методи. Не, това не е антисемитизъм, както ще има вряскания до небето. То...more
Steve Cran
added it
Forget about everything you may have learned in Hebrew school, this book is a myth buster. It is common knowledge that according to the Bible the Jewish people started with Abrahamin Mesopotamia and then went to Egypt to be slave and then was redeemed. After wandering the desert for forty years under the leadership of Moses they came to Canaan where Joshua the brilliant military commander drove out the Canaanites in a lightning fast victory. King David and his son Solomon would form man empire ...more
The Invention of the Jewish People by Shlomo Sand
"The Invention of the Jewish People" is an interesting yet controversial scholarly book about Jewish history through the eyes of leading historian Shlomo Sand. What makes this book controversial is the fact that the author denies such a thing as a Jewish "race" that were descendents of the first exiles with everything that it entails. This 344-page book is composed of the following five major chapters: 1. Making Na...more
"The Invention of the Jewish People" is an interesting yet controversial scholarly book about Jewish history through the eyes of leading historian Shlomo Sand. What makes this book controversial is the fact that the author denies such a thing as a Jewish "race" that were descendents of the first exiles with everything that it entails. This 344-page book is composed of the following five major chapters: 1. Making Na...more
Even though it is a detailed academic study, it is a pleasure to read. The language is crisp (some of the plaudits here must go to the translator). But what I found particularly enjoyable was the progressive building of the argument, citing source after source, evaluating them as adding (or not) to the tower of knowledge he constructs.
What is a 'nation'? Is there (was there ever?) a Jewish nation? The constuction of myths cast as history, such as the invention of the exile of the Jews.The...more
What is a 'nation'? Is there (was there ever?) a Jewish nation? The constuction of myths cast as history, such as the invention of the exile of the Jews.The...more
I have written reviews of many books here. If there is one above all the rest that I would like others to read it would be this one.
Regardless of the country you call home, it rests on a foundation of myths, stories of the distant past that unite the citizenry. Israel is no exception, yet the story of the historical Jews is one that more people in the United States are familiar with that that of any other people.
Shlomo Sand begins his book discussing definitions - what ar...more
Regardless of the country you call home, it rests on a foundation of myths, stories of the distant past that unite the citizenry. Israel is no exception, yet the story of the historical Jews is one that more people in the United States are familiar with that that of any other people.
Shlomo Sand begins his book discussing definitions - what ar...more
While Shlomo Sand’s “Invention of the Jewish People” has attracted endless accolades from partisans with an axe to grind – though not always exactly the same axe as the author – any close scrutiny reveals the book to be little more than a collection of strawmen arguments forming a feeble foundation for a weak argument. Time and again, Sand rails against a scholarly consensus which seems to exist only in his mind and ignores the considerable primary source evidence that undermines his case.
...more
...more
The book makes the point that there really wasn't a diaspora and that the majority of European Jews really do not have Semitic genes because most of the Jews in Europe historically were converts. Hence, the author says that Israel was founded on a sham, and that there should be steps taken to include Palestinians as rightful residents of Israel along with the present Jewish population. The book is extremely well documented though tedious for me to read at times because of that. Maps would hav...more
This book caused a lot of controversy in Israel and elsewhere for stating the obvious: that contemporary Jews are probably not the descendants of the ancient Israelites, but are instead gentiles from various parts of the world whose ancestors had converted to Judaism at some point. Sand supports this argument with plenty of citations, relying mostly on Hebrew sources, astonishingly enough, the cultural importance of which (as the book shows) has largely been systematically diminished in global ...more
Shlomo Sand, a professor of history at Tel Aviv University, writes about the genesis of the idea "Jewish People." His main goal is to demonstrate that this idea, contrary to its inherent myth of being timeless, originated with the rise of nationalism in the 19th Century, at the same time that other national ideas such as "German People," "Italian People," and so on were being developed.
Sand makes additional controversial claims based on his historical re...more
Sand makes additional controversial claims based on his historical re...more
J'ai trouvé très intéressant la manière d'aborder la question de la nation : un retour aux significations et aux évolutions étymologiques de la nation, de même que leurs appréhension dans le contexte historique qui prédétermine bien souvent l'orientation de la définition. De manière concise, les termes de race, peuple, ethnies sont envisagés avec l'idée de nation, ses relations avec la religion, l'État mais aussi les intellectuels, et le corps professoral.
« La naissance de la nation...more
« La naissance de la nation...more
This book is worth reading no matter your politics. Sand is a decent writer and shares lots of interesting information. I'm skeptical in general of claims of the past as inspirations for ethnonationalism and so I agree with Sand's broad anti-nationalist pov despite not knowing enough about Jewish history to comment on that aspect of his book. I wish that he would have made a better historical and theoretical distinction between "nation" and "nation-state." He often uses t...more
بثينة العيسى
rated it
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Arabs, Palestinians, and especially Jews
What a book!
This book exposes how fragile and vulnerable is the state of Israel, mainly because it is relying on biblical myths to construct its Zionist ideology and Jewish identity, rather than on actual history proven by archeological and biological research.
It is said that this book is another nail in the coffin of Zionism and I couldn't agree more. Unless the state of Israel starts acknowledging it's moral Schizophrenia and political hypocrisy, and it's discriminatory/ rac...more
This book exposes how fragile and vulnerable is the state of Israel, mainly because it is relying on biblical myths to construct its Zionist ideology and Jewish identity, rather than on actual history proven by archeological and biological research.
It is said that this book is another nail in the coffin of Zionism and I couldn't agree more. Unless the state of Israel starts acknowledging it's moral Schizophrenia and political hypocrisy, and it's discriminatory/ rac...more
This is a really excellent and brilliantly original book written about the origins of the 'Jewish people'. Shlomo Sand, who is an Israeli historian, shows that in fact European Jews were converts to the religion rather than being descendents of a Jewish 'race'. By the same token, he maintains and that the original Jews who stayed in their country of origin eventually converted to Islam and are today's or many Jews wish to hear though I gather it was a best seller in Israel. As a 'Jew' in name, b...more
Professor Sand, who teaches film history and modern political French history, opines that the Jewish people is a construct invented some time in the 19th century. This book is his argument in support of his opinion. It's also, if unwittingly, Sand's argument in favor of writing about what one knows. Presumably, Sand knows film history and modern French political history. What this book makes clear is that Sand does NOT know ancient or medieval history, or Jewish history. The professor also seems...more
Mike Bauldree
is currently reading it
Just started this book so do not yet have a strong opinion.
I do find this quote from the NYTimes review interesting:
"Professor Sand accuses Zionist historians from the 19th century onward — the very same scholars on whose work he bases his case — of hiding the truth and creating a myth of shared roots to strengthen their nationalist agenda. He explains that he has uncovered no new information, but has “organized the knowledge differently.” In other words, he is doing...more
I do find this quote from the NYTimes review interesting:
"Professor Sand accuses Zionist historians from the 19th century onward — the very same scholars on whose work he bases his case — of hiding the truth and creating a myth of shared roots to strengthen their nationalist agenda. He explains that he has uncovered no new information, but has “organized the knowledge differently.” In other words, he is doing...more
Very interesting book. Sand describes Jewish History as cultural or religious instead of racial or genetic. He thus undermines the claims of Zionists that they have a direct link to Israel. It turns out that Jews, like Frenchmen, Scotts, Germans, etc, etc, have an invented, mythical history. The history of the spread of the Jewish religion described here is complex and occurs on different fronts; through conversion by persuasion, convenience, political expediency and force.
Everyone who is concerned about the conflicted land of Palestine should read this book. It is not always an easy read, but this makes the nuggets of historical investigation even more surprising and revelatory when they appear. We need more books like this which show the way towards a sensible debate on the Middle East and how a people - the Palestinians - are being persecuted on the basis of a false claim that others have a stronger entitlement to the land that is theirs.
Sally Rosalina
marked it as to-read
For now I can only put the book on my wish-listed. But some references point out that it reveals no Exodus but Jews converting to Islam. If Jews converted to Islam then it means the Palestinians are the Chosen People. Also see this: http://inventionofthejewishpeople.com/
ala'
is currently reading it
طويلا انتظرت أن أحصل على هذا الكتاب ، يقال ان شلومو ساند هو ذاته جندي الزنابق البيضاء الذي كتب عنه درويش ، عموما ، في الصفحات الاولى :)
نعود برأي ما :))
نعود برأي ما :))
This was a difficult read for someone that isn't a trained historian. The author has a confusing (for me) way of writing and coupled with the history jargon made it hard for me to understand. He did bring up some interesting points about my assumptions of the history of the Jews. It did give me new avenues to investigate in the Jewish-Palestinian subject.
Comment le peuple juif fut inventé
J'ai lu ce livre il y a quelques temps. Je l'ai beaucoup aimé. On y apprend beaucoup, mais surtout, on y trouve une autre manière de voir l'histoire, peut-être même plus plausible.
Shlomo Sand a du avoir beaucoup de courage pour écire ce livre.
Je suis tombée aujourd'hui sur cet article. J'ai eu envie de le partager avec vous, en espérant vous donner envie de lire le livre.
Une fois que l'on a dépassé le chapitre rela...more
J'ai lu ce livre il y a quelques temps. Je l'ai beaucoup aimé. On y apprend beaucoup, mais surtout, on y trouve une autre manière de voir l'histoire, peut-être même plus plausible.
Shlomo Sand a du avoir beaucoup de courage pour écire ce livre.
Je suis tombée aujourd'hui sur cet article. J'ai eu envie de le partager avec vous, en espérant vous donner envie de lire le livre.
Une fois que l'on a dépassé le chapitre rela...more
Clear and concise analysis of the idea of a Jewish state. The author is well researched and nd relies on empirical data for his analysis.
It is a book which documents a surprising revision of the history of the those who follow the Jewish religion.
Israilil Jewish Realization they are wrong, and that we can defeat them in the the thought morally
Un livre documenté, courageux et fourmillant d'idées . En dénoncant l'histoire officielle qui a créé un état ethnique et religieux en refusant l'héritage culturelle de ses communautés - du Yiddishland au Yemen et des royaumes berbères aux khazars-, en rappelant les ascendances judééennes des palestiniens d'aujourd'hui, il ouvre aussi un espace de reflexion pour un devenir commun aux deux peuples qui se disputent la terre d'Israel. Un historien brillant à lire absolument.
recommended by my Aussie friend Andrew
A discussion about the formation of identity, and complications that arise in heterogeneous nations related to these created identities.
Fascinating and informative, a must read for those interested in the situation in Israel/Palestine today.
Eileen
added it
I didn't manage to read this book to the end, as it was on loan from another library - extremely interesting, but not a light read. Many interesting facts which I never thought about before.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
He is professor of history at Tel Aviv University and author of the controversial book The Invention of the Jewish People (Verso Books, 2009). His main areas of teaching are nationalism, film as history and French intellectual history .
Sand was born to Polish Jewish survivors of the Holocaust. His parents had Communist and anti-imperialist views and refused to receive compensations fr...more
More about Shlomo Sand...
Sand was born to Polish Jewish survivors of the Holocaust. His parents had Communist and anti-imperialist views and refused to receive compensations fr...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“Dans chaque démocratie libérale s'est élaboré un imaginaire de citoyenneté au sein duquel la projection dans l'avenir est devenue plus significative que le poids du passé. Cet imaginaire s'est traduit par des normes juridiques, et a même pénétré par la suite à l'intérieur du système éducatif étatique.[...] La souffrance du passé justifie le prix exigé de la part des citoyens dans le présent. L'héroïsme des temps qui s'éloignent promet un avenir rayonnant pour l'individu, du moins sûrement pour la nation. L'idée nationale est devenue, avec l'aide des historiens, une idéologie optimiste par nature. De là, notamment, vient son succès.”
—
1 person liked it
More quotes…

Loading...






view all 5 comments






























