Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “Long Time Coming” as Want to Read:
Long Time Coming
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

Long Time Coming

3.72  ·  Rating Details ·  1,326 Ratings  ·  161 Reviews
Stephen Swan is amazed when he hears that the uncle he thought had been killed in the Blitz is actually alive. For nearly four decades, Eldritch Swan has been locked away in an Irish prison and now, at last, has been released. Shocked and suspicious, Stephen listens to the old man’s story and is caught up in a tale that begins at the dawn of World War II, when Eldritch wor ...more
Hardcover, 391 pages
Published February 8th 2010 by Bantam Press (first published November 20th 2009)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Jan 27, 2017 LadyJ71 rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: read-2017
I want to start out by saying this is my first Robert Goddard read and I was totally blown away by this book. The setting switches between 1940 and 1976 in Europe, primarily in London, Belgium, and Ireland. I like to look up facts about places and events mentioned and this book is loaded with those.

The story begins with an old man named Eldritch Swan being released from a prison in Ireland after 36 years. He shows up at the door of the only family he has left, his nephew Stephen and his sister-i
Read by David Rintoul. 11 Hrs 3 Mins

Description: Eldritch Swan is a dead man. Or at least that is what his nephew Stephen has always been told. Until one day Eldritch walks back into his life after 36 years in an Irish prison. He won't reveal any of the details of his incarceration, insisting only that he is innocent of any crime. His return should be of interest to no-one. But the visit of a solicitor with a mysterious request will take Eldritch and his sceptical nephew from sleepy seaside Paig
Dale Harcombe
Dec 30, 2014 Dale Harcombe rated it liked it
I used to read a lot of Robert Goddard books and enjoyed them immensely, so when my husband borrowed this from the library and enjoyed it I thought I would read it to before it went back. I got into it very quickly and enjoyed the mystery surrounding uncle Eldritch and why he had been imprisoned for so long as well as the mystery with the Picassos. The story is told from two time frames 1940, which is Eldritch's story and 1976 which follows his nephew Stephen Swan and then his interactions with ...more
Stephen Swan is surprised when his uncle Eldritch, whom he had thought was dead, is released from an Irish prison after 36 years. Eldritch refuses to tell anyone why he was imprisoned or why he's been unexpectedly released. It's not long before other people are trying to find Eldritch and soon Stephen finds himself drawn into a mystery that began in 1940.

We discover that just before WWII Eldritch returned to England from Belgium, where he worked for a Jewish diamond merchant and art collector.
Brenda H
Feb 11, 2017 Brenda H rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Stephen Swan's uncle Eldritch has suddenly shown up after 36 years in prison in Ireland. No one knows for sure why Eldritch was imprisoned and Eldritch isn't saying.

Then, one day a lawyer shows up on the doorstep with an offer for Eldritch - one he can't ignore. Suddenly Stephen finds himself in the middle of political intrigue, art theft and diamond smuggling...with a few murders thrown in.

Rating: 4 stars
May 11, 2011 F.R. rated it did not like it
There’s the kernel of a good book here: a roguish uncle returns from the dead and soon embroils his nephew in a mystery concerning a long ago art fraud and a very dubious part of English/Irish history. Ostensibly set in the seventies, it flashes back repeatedly to the forties with the two narratives intertwining. If done right – conjuring a good sense of time and place, while revealing its secrets judiciously – then this could be a nifty little suspense yarn.

Unfortunately, there’s no way I can p
Martin Fautley
Apr 25, 2011 Martin Fautley rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Hooray. A thriller finally written by someone who writes in sentences, speaks English, and keeps the plot moving without having to pretend it's the screenplay for an airhead action film! Or maybe I've read too much trash recently?

Nicely placed story set in 1970s and WW2, concerning characters, spy plots, smuggled diamonds, and forged pictures. Moves along with good level of detail, and doesn't assume the reader has the IQ of an Ant. Dirty dealings of Gov't in UK and Ireland, and complex sub- and
Dec 09, 2012 Andrew rated it it was amazing
What do you say? Robert Goddard is the master story teller, he paints a picture and takes you there, unravelling the story one layer at a time rather like the layers of an onion. He is one of my favourite authors and has never let me down, and this is one of his best stories. This book is filled with intrigue, betrayal, espionage, political machinations and a mystery element that is not revealed until the end. What more could you want? What are you waiting for? Read this book! You will not be di ...more
Nov 20, 2011 Ms.pegasus rated it really liked it
Recommends it for: anglophiles, mystery lovers,
Shelves: fiction, suspense
The elements of suspense are skillfully orchestrated in LONG TIME COMING. The contemporary (1976) narrative, seen primarily though the eyes of Stephen Swan alternate with the backstory occurring in 1940, primarily from the third-person observation of Stephen's uncle, Eldritch Swan, participant, among other things, in a forgery scam of priceless Picassos. This dual narrative allows the author to approach the problem of creating suspense from different angles. Stephen's dilemmas include a successi ...more
GS Nathan
Glad I checked out this book. The British have always had a lock on the stories about scoundrels who had moral lines they don't cross, dubious heroes, if you like that description, and Robert Goddard's story about Mr. Eldritch Swan falls in that category. Of course the counterpoint is his nephew, the real hero of the story. But in a story that switches between the 70's and the late 30's he manages to spin a very good yarn. Some parts, especially where a government secret service is too ready to ...more
Dec 21, 2014 Mark rated it liked it
This mystery spanning decades marginally kept me engaged through the first 3/4 of the book. In the end, I was rewarded with a good conclusion and would recommend this book to a patient reader.

Summary: Eldritch swan is released Dom an Irish prison after 35 years. He contacts his nephew Stephen, and together they try to uncover proof that because of paintings were forged 35 years ago. Why was Eldritch in prison? Conditions of his release don't allow him to say, however Oldrich claims that he did
Nov 22, 2010 Lara rated it liked it
Shelves: 2010
I always look forward to a new Robert Goddard, though don't think I would persist if his earliest ones hadn't been so good. This one vaguely mixes anglo-irish politics with an art scam. I liked how the story moved back to the 1940's and then to the 70's. Usual Goddard convoluted plotting, but I did read another book in the middle so not quite unputdownable as I have found some earlier ones.
Feb 13, 2017 Carol rated it it was amazing
Long Time Coming by Robert Goddard
4.5 stars

From The Book:
Stephen Swan is amazed when he hears that the uncle he thought had been killed in the Blitz is actually alive. For nearly four decades, Eldritch Swan has been locked away in an Irish prison and now, at last, has been released. Shocked and suspicious, Stephen listens to the old man’s story and is caught up in a tale that begins at the dawn of World War II, when Eldritch worked for an Antwerp diamond dealer with a trove of Picassos—highly va
Jan 18, 2011 Mbm rated it liked it
I've read a few of Goddard's novels but none of the earlier ones more cherished by his devotees.The majority of them have been readable and entertaining,although one or two have been awful.This I found to be pleasantly diverting at least.

Goddard is very good at whisking his reader around the map book.You're shuttled around provincial Britain,continental Europe and even further afield in his work at regular intervals.At times this lends a paradoxical cosiness to proceedings,at others an annoying
Robert Intriago
The book is divided into two subplots. The first one takes place in 1976 and it involves the theft of a blue period Picasso art collection. The story is interesting but the author relies on several forced subterfuges to construct the plot. Characters appear out of the blue to fill gaps in the story. These mysterious appearances force you to backtrack to the beginning of the book to find where you first heard the name before.
The other subplot deals with 1940. It has some very interesting historic
Aug 31, 2012 Susan rated it liked it
Geologist Stephen Swan comes home to find an uncle that he was told died during the Blitz, but has just been just released after 36 years in an Irish prison for an unspecified crime. The uncle is hired to prove the truth about the ownership of a trove of Picassos stolen at the outbreak of WWII and enlists Stephen to help. He predictably falls in love with Rachael Banner, the somewhat obsessed granddaughter of the man from whom the paintings were stolen. The plot is complex and revealed in layers ...more
Apr 19, 2010 Trish rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: fiction
I have loved Goddard's writing from day one and have all his books on my shelves. I considered him a great secret, since he was never promoted, but his books would show up on my local bookstores shelves, only one copy, even of a new title. This time, however, we got more than one copy, and it turns out to have been the worst of the lot. The characters missed by a long shot--not realistic in the slightest, nor particularly likeable, any of them, except the old black valet at the end. No, don't go ...more
Joe Stamber
Aug 05, 2012 Joe Stamber rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Shelves: read-2012
While on holiday in Cyprus I discovered a "library" of books that people had left for others to enjoy. I dutifully left Ken Follett's Code To Zero there after finishing it and was delighted to find this fairly new Robert Goddard book. As usual, Goddard delivers an enjoyable and easily readable mystery that jumps between time zones and locations with spanners thrown into the works at regular intervals. The Irish troubles are woven brilliantly into the narrative as Goddard produces another excelle ...more
Linda Schwartz
Jun 04, 2010 Linda Schwartz rated it it was amazing
I always hate it when I get more than 50% through a Robert Goddard book because I know the end is getting closer. Fantastic writer with complex plotting, yet not complicated or difficult to follow. This plot moves back and forth from the early days of WWII to the mid-1970s and involves a question of a mysterious imprisonment and stolen/forge Picassos. Goddard is a gem, as usual.
Deborah O'Regan
Dec 02, 2016 Deborah O'Regan rated it it was amazing
This is the first book I have ever read by Robert Goddard and I really enjoyed it. I liked the way it went back and forth in time from 1976 to 14940. It also gave me food for thought on Irelands position on neutrality during WW2.
Jan 06, 2011 CLM rated it really liked it
Shelves: suspense, uk, 21st-century
This started off a little slow but like all Goddard pulls in the reader, fascinates and confuses her, then reveals every carefully thought out thread at the end...
Diane Macaluso
Apr 06, 2011 Diane Macaluso rated it liked it
I slogged my way through this one. I thought of just returning it, but found that I wanted to know how it ended. I'm thinking I might have enjoyed it more some other time! Oh, well!
The book is called Long Time Coming, I assume "Made To Be Broken" is the British title or there are gremlins on Goodreads.
Monica Wies
Na zijn ontslag besluit Stephen Swan zijn moeder in Engeland te bezoeken.
Tot zijn verbazing ontmoet hij daar zijn oom Eldritch, die, zoals hij en zijn moeder dachten, al 36 jaar dood zou zijn. Gestorven tijdens de Blitzkrieg.
In plaats daarvan heeft hij 36 jaar in een Ierse gevangenis gezeten. Waarom wil hij niet vertellen.
Wel vraagt hij Stephen om hulp bij zijn onderzoek naar vervalste Picasso's en naar de familie die daardoor van erfenis is beroofd.
Het verhaal speelt zich deels af in 1940 en de
Oct 11, 2016 Margaret rated it did not like it  ·  review of another edition
I have loved reading books by this author but not this novel, I struggled to read more than half of the story, I found it lengthy, boring and confusing. It is rare for me to give up on a book but this one managed to defeat me by not holding my interest.
Bryan Higgs
Dec 15, 2012 Bryan Higgs rated it it was amazing
By my count, this is number 21 on my quest to read all of Robert Goddard's books, in chronological order by publish date.

This one is the best I've read of his for some time. The plot is complex (with, of course, the required hallmark plot twists of a Goddard book), set in interesting and historic times, with chapters moving backwards and forwards between 1976 and 1940. The author does an outstanding job of slowly peeling off the layers of the onion of the plot, and I, at least, did not guess wha
Oct 29, 2013 Sheri rated it it was ok
Shelves: wwii
This was good for what it is. Meaning, of course that it is just a "candy book". There is nothing really profound here, there are no points of wisdom; it is simply a fairly compelling mystery novel and easy page turner.

I did not find the plot particularly surprising or suspenseful and the characters were rather thin, but it kept me entertained. I was most annoyed with Rachel's character. First, I did not understand her reasoning behind the bitterness of having grown up poor-ish because of the t
Maryann MJS1228
Dear Robert Goddard, where did it all go wrong? We met in South Africa and you kept me company on the long flight home. Then we'd meet up once a year for whirlwind of historically informed adventure. It was great until without warning my sure bet was Found Wanting. But anyone can have a bad day, or a bad book, so I was back for more with Long Time Coming with nary a reservation.

I'm sorry to report that this book is the equivalent of having your date to the opera show up wearing a clown suit. It
Feb 25, 2015 Janebbooks rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: art and mystery lovers

A TROVE OF PICASSO' janebbooks
A Review of LONG TIME COMING by Robert Goddard

What could be better than a stolen trove of Picasso paintings and a bit of Irish history? Robert Goddard's latest publication LONG TIME COMING has both. It's a spellbinding novel!

The time is 1976. Eldrich Swan is released from a Irish prison after 36 years imprisonment. He returns to England and is recruited to recover the Picasso's, currently the property of an American tycoon and in exhibition at the Royal Acade
Feb 08, 2017 Eadie rated it it was amazing
Shelves: read-2017
Robert Goddard is the master of complex plots with lots of twists and turns, surprise endings and plenty of interesting history mixed in. This book takes us to England, Ireland and Belgium. The chapters switch back and forth from 1940 to 1976. Eldritch Swan was in an Irish prison for 36 years and his nephew, Stephen Swan, has been asked to help Eldritch repair the wrongs from the past which include forged Picassos, IRA terrorists and lots of secrets. It's a tale of revenge, redemption and justic ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Interrogation of Gabriel James
  • Rogue Island (Liam Mulligan, #1)
  • Dead Spy Running (Legoland Trilogy, #1)
  • Playing With Bones (Joe Plantagenet, #2)
  • Morse's Greatest Mystery and Other Stories
  • The Necropolis Railway (Jim Stringer, #1)
  • Alfred Hitchcock's Solve-Them-Yourself Mysteries
  • Far North (Fire & Ice, #2)
  • Dood van een soldaat
  • Queen of the Mersey
  • Dead Tomorrow (Roy Grace, #5)
  • Beams Falling
  • The Haunted
  • The Silver Locomotive Mystery (Detective Inspector Robert Colbeck, #6)
  • The Holocaust: The Fate of European Jewry, 1932-1945 (Studies in Jewish History)
  • Deloume Road
  • Murder In The Green (Libby Serjeant Murder Mysteries)
  • Our Lady of Pain (Mark Tartaglia, #2)
In a writing career spanning more than twenty years, Robert Goddard's novels have been described in many different ways - mystery, thriller, crime, even historical romance. He is the master of the plot twist, a compelling and engrossing storyteller and one of the best known advocates for the traditional virtues of pace, plot and narrative drive.
More about Robert Goddard...

Share This Book