The Garden of Last Days
“So good, so damn compulsively readable, that I can hardly believe it.” —Stephen King, Entertainment Weekly
In his stunning follow-up to the #1 best-selling House of Sand and Fog, Andre Dubus draws us into the lives of three deeply flawed, driven people whose paths intersect on a September night in Florida. April, a stripper, has brought her daughter to work at the Puma Cl
...morePaperback, 544 pages
Published
June 1st 2009
by W. W. Norton & Company
(first published 2002)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
Jun 12, 2008
Mike
rated it
1 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
people who found "Crash" too complicated, and too short
Recommended to Mike by:
my own inner obsessive, demanding I read every 9/11 novel
To draw a quote from the book itself, this is one of those "And nothing happens by mistake" kind of narratives, every piss-poor choice by a character leading her or him down an overdetermined path toward melodramatic near- and actual tragedies (and some measure of cathartic redemption). Think "Crash," with a dollop of 9/11 thrown in to give the thing a bit more zeitgeistian heft.
I was able to take the hyperbole of plot in Dubus' last, big-selling _House of Sand and Fog_, because he does manage t...more
I was able to take the hyperbole of plot in Dubus' last, big-selling _House of Sand and Fog_, because he does manage t...more
I read this book cover to cover, which attests to its efficient prose despite its 500+ page length. Andre Dubus' trick is to advance the action of the loosely interlocking characters in cinematic mini-chapters, each time completely inhabiting the persona and neuroses of its subject.
Dubus is an accomplished observer and has clearly researched his Floridian subjects well. Especially fascinating are his antiheroes, a down-on-his-luck contractor and father trying to find a way to do right in all the...more
Dubus is an accomplished observer and has clearly researched his Floridian subjects well. Especially fascinating are his antiheroes, a down-on-his-luck contractor and father trying to find a way to do right in all the...more
Jun 12, 2008
Melissa Madrid
rated it
2 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
Those who like a good tale and don't care how well it is told
Recommended to Melissa by:
Powells
This book fits squarely into my category of a good idea poorly executed. The promise of the book lies in its gritty characters and the outward ripple into their lives from a point of chance intersection. And of course I was drawn by the clever concept of the chance intersection being taken from a footnote to the headlines of the biggest story of the young 21st Century.
But the execution is a big pile overwrought melodrama. My problem is that the prose is pedestrian and the story is drawn with a...more
But the execution is a big pile overwrought melodrama. My problem is that the prose is pedestrian and the story is drawn with a...more
Aug 10, 2009
Maureen
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
2009,
ultimate-favorites
Gripping me from the first page.
Dubus knows charctres so well,it is as if he grinds the human being down the original dust and then scattters that dust across the page.
The back jacket blurb for this novel does not do it justice. This not a book about "where were you September 10,2001?". This is a book about the choices we make everyday that keep us and everyone around us holding on to what is our reality,sometimes with the edges of our fingernails.
Does this book have a deeper human lesson to be...more
Dubus knows charctres so well,it is as if he grinds the human being down the original dust and then scattters that dust across the page.
The back jacket blurb for this novel does not do it justice. This not a book about "where were you September 10,2001?". This is a book about the choices we make everyday that keep us and everyone around us holding on to what is our reality,sometimes with the edges of our fingernails.
Does this book have a deeper human lesson to be...more
This is a gritty and graphic novel of the last days of one of the 9/11 highjackers and his chance meeting with April, an exotic dancer. Although the club scenes are filled with salacious details of the strip club life, the protagonist April retains her sense of self and has the reader hoping she will find her way.
For more about this book, see my review on amazon.com under the title and my reviewer's name, EGranfors.
For more about this book, see my review on amazon.com under the title and my reviewer's name, EGranfors.
My reading of this novel began so hopefully. At AWP a friend made me aware of the author's existence. He was there at AWP, and of course I had no idea who he was. I hate that. So I bought a book. And to be fair, I liked--maybe even loved--the first 50 or so pages.
Then the narrative began to fall apart. It's a multi-POV affair, which can be great. This one isn't. The attempt to imitate the Egyptian-sounding foreigner is corny but not cornier than the attempt to imitate the good old boy who's work...more
Then the narrative began to fall apart. It's a multi-POV affair, which can be great. This one isn't. The attempt to imitate the Egyptian-sounding foreigner is corny but not cornier than the attempt to imitate the good old boy who's work...more
Recommended by Stephen King as one of the best books of 2008, I picked this one up with high expectations.
King's made some great recommendations in the past and helped me discover the joys of reading Laura Lippman (for which I will be eternally grateful).
But as for "Garden of Last Days," it was more of a miss than a hit. I enjoyed the story, but maybe my expectations were ratcheted up a bit too high after hearing King heap praise on the novel. It's a story with 9/11 firmly at the center, though...more
King's made some great recommendations in the past and helped me discover the joys of reading Laura Lippman (for which I will be eternally grateful).
But as for "Garden of Last Days," it was more of a miss than a hit. I enjoyed the story, but maybe my expectations were ratcheted up a bit too high after hearing King heap praise on the novel. It's a story with 9/11 firmly at the center, though...more
Well, I read all the other GoodReads reviews and don't have much to add. There are lots of sharp insights below.
In short, yes this was a book told from probably too many perspectives (I counted at least 9 distinct points of view), there was a bit of over-writing, and there is powerlessness/over-sexualization attached to some of the female characters. And the September 11th terrorist sub-plot borders on the ridiculous...but...I liked it.
I like a chunky book. I like a book with a strong sense of...more
In short, yes this was a book told from probably too many perspectives (I counted at least 9 distinct points of view), there was a bit of over-writing, and there is powerlessness/over-sexualization attached to some of the female characters. And the September 11th terrorist sub-plot borders on the ridiculous...but...I liked it.
I like a chunky book. I like a book with a strong sense of...more
The prose is a bit purple, the situations overheated, and the borderline fetishistic look into the mind of a 9/11 hijacker creeps towards the "what we hope they're thinking and are like," instead of what they may actually be like. The central plot, though, which I won't give away, is riveting, and based on the House of Sand and Fog I assumed the worst. I kept turning the pages and couldn't put it down, and found myself rooting for various characters, too.
That said, this is really just the House...more
That said, this is really just the House...more
I am so annoyed with myself for wasting the hours I spent to read this. I had to force myself to pick it up every day. I loved Dubus's first book so much that I kept hoping this would get better and some characters would appear who would be even the slightest bit appealing or meaningful. Never happened. And yes, I know life has a seamy side, but that does not make this novel any more appealing. It made me feel dirty.
But the reviewers loooooove it.
Amazon says that this book is 384 pages but my...more
But the reviewers loooooove it.
Amazon says that this book is 384 pages but my...more
I hadn't read this author before and when I was browsing some comments on this book on Amazon, it looked like most people enjoyed this but consider The House of Sand and Fog a better book. I first heard of this after Stephen King's glowing review in EW. It's an engrossing story about an exotic dancer named April who brings her 3-year-old daughter Franny to work one night when her regular babysitter is hospitalized. April had no other backup babysitters (I know how that feels). Two of the other m...more
"The Garden of Last Days" takes place within the final few days leading up to 9/11. The story follows a small cast of characters whose lives become interconnected during one long night in a strip club. Dubus delves into every thought, feeling, and action of each of these characters, superbly drawing the reader into an understanding of what motivates the choices made by these individuals. We certainly may not always condone these choices, but we do understand them. As the story unfolds, you truly...more
I taught this book in my course on 9/11 literature, though it has less (directly) to do with that infamous day than the other books in the course did. Yet 9/11 weighs heavily on the narrative. It takes place largely in and around a seedy Florida strip club (I realize there is at least one redundancy in that phrase). It's really a series of character studies. I've read everything by Andre and consider him a friend: he made a second visit to campus this semester at my request and visited two of my...more
Author Andre Dubus explores human relationships and motivation in this story that brings together 4 unlikely characters in the seamier side of life in south Florida: April, who works as a stripper to pay the bills and care for her young daughter Franny; Jean, April's landlady, babysits for Franny only to discover that the little girl gives her life a new purpose; AJ, a lonely young man estranged from his wife and a frequent customer to the strip club where April works; and April's rich foreign c...more
The main character of this book is April, a stripper in Sarasota FL. One night the person who does the regular babysitting for her takes ill, and she has to take her 4-year-old daughter to her club while she works. She puts her in the club's office with some videos and goes to do her job. That night one of the customers is a dumb redneck named AJ. AJ gets too frisky with one of the other dancers and gets thrown out, and his wrist broken at the same time. Another customer is Bassam, an Arab who i...more
This garden of flawed characters begins with a stripper bringing her 3-year-old daughter to work because her sitter is sick. This night at the club brings together many creepy people and their interactions are described in tawdry detail. One by one, new stereotypes are introduced. The night goes on, the book goes on. Even as a mere reader, I resented being stuck for so long with a bunch of strippers and their parasites in a dark, ugly club. It all seemed tedious to me.
Although even the terroris...more
Although even the terroris...more
Dubus III, Andre. THE GARDEN OF LAST DAYS. (2008). ***. It’s tough to follow an act like, “The House of Sand and Fog.” But you have to judge a book on its own merits. This one has a few, but could have been a lot tighter than it was. It’s the story of the clash of cultures and the clash within cultures. It’s the story of people making the wrong decisions and building on them. The action centers around the Puma Club for Men, where all of the characters meet and then depart. April – Spring at the...more
Jan 26, 2009
Linda
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
current-novels,
current-events-social-history
It took me a while to see that April, the single-mom, stripper who is the main character of the story, is culpable for her choices. And, I don't know that she ever quite blames herself for her troubles. But, she has her own version of the American dream!
There are many supporting characters in this story and Dubus gives attention and sympathy to each of them. Remember the Joan Baez song with it's refrain: There but poor fortune go you go I. I identified with so many of them, especially the older...more
There are many supporting characters in this story and Dubus gives attention and sympathy to each of them. Remember the Joan Baez song with it's refrain: There but poor fortune go you go I. I identified with so many of them, especially the older...more
A JON AND HIS MA BOOK CLUB SELECTION
Al Bundy knew the score: It's all happening at the nudie bar.
Andre Dubus III goes to a Florida "gentlemen's" club for the follow-up to "House of Sand and Fog," his Oprah-beloved best-seller of middle-brow misery. Like "Sand and Fog," "The Garden of Last Days" is full of self-pitying, self-made victims digging themselves ever deeper into self-inflicted predicaments.
Up on the stage of the Puma Club dances April, aka Spring, a divorced mother shaking her ya-yas t...more
Al Bundy knew the score: It's all happening at the nudie bar.
Andre Dubus III goes to a Florida "gentlemen's" club for the follow-up to "House of Sand and Fog," his Oprah-beloved best-seller of middle-brow misery. Like "Sand and Fog," "The Garden of Last Days" is full of self-pitying, self-made victims digging themselves ever deeper into self-inflicted predicaments.
Up on the stage of the Puma Club dances April, aka Spring, a divorced mother shaking her ya-yas t...more
Actually, I listened to the audio of this book, which I believe was over ten hours.
I was incredibly impressed with the House of Sand and Fog, which led me to this book. A number of reviewers have remarked that it's a difficult book to get into, but I didn't find that with the audio edition.
Dubus is a master at juggling the stories of his characters, and the unpredictable ways lives collide. I also admire the fact that in this book, as well as in Sand and Fog, he contrasts cultures, broadening...more
I was incredibly impressed with the House of Sand and Fog, which led me to this book. A number of reviewers have remarked that it's a difficult book to get into, but I didn't find that with the audio edition.
Dubus is a master at juggling the stories of his characters, and the unpredictable ways lives collide. I also admire the fact that in this book, as well as in Sand and Fog, he contrasts cultures, broadening...more
I did not enjoy reading this book. For my taste, there were too many characters, there was a tense change for one of the characters, there was too much redundancy in the story, and there were too many pages. Given the plot points, I expected more urgency in the story, but I didn't catch that feeling while reading. I put this book down more than once, only to pick it up again because I made a pledge to myself to read all of the library book club books, even if I couldn't attend the book club.
Esse...more
Esse...more
I have to admit to a personal bias for this author. He taught one of my creative writing classes at Emerson and he is one of those few professors that stay with you. When you can still recall lectures from over twenty years ago, you know he was doing something right.
Anyway to get back to the book, like the House of Sand and Fog, this novel reads like a train wreck, the suspense building as you plummet down a long hill, knowing that when the ride ends it will result in disaster.
Unlike the House o...more
Anyway to get back to the book, like the House of Sand and Fog, this novel reads like a train wreck, the suspense building as you plummet down a long hill, knowing that when the ride ends it will result in disaster.
Unlike the House o...more
“And it was her smile the men liked because she was always smiling and it never looked phony.” (39) “she began to wonder if she’d find any help or comfort or meaning in this world at all before she was dust no one would remember or speak of or even think about in passing while reaching for the butter or unlocking the door.” (52) “Tired of working so hard for nothing but bad feelings in return.” (121) “God was for the weak, that’s what she really thought. It was for people who can’t face that we’...more
Oct 23, 2011
Suzanne Moore
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
thriller,
nominations-to-sort
When April's babysitter falls ill without notice, she is forced to take her young daughter to work with her. April works as a stripper at the Puma Club for men ... not the ideal place for a young child. Leaving her baby with the owner's wife in the office, April is a nervous wreck, (although her professionalism won't allow her to show it) as she entertains a foreigner in the VIP room.
Meanwhile an over zealous patron is thrown out for getting too close to one of the dancers. As things progress B...more
Meanwhile an over zealous patron is thrown out for getting too close to one of the dancers. As things progress B...more
This book was good in some parts, and lacking in others. The whole writing style was odd and somewhat superfluous for the narrative that it was, but the way the narrative changed well made it a good narrative. The way the writer changed his writing for each character was a good idea, and could have been something great, but it wasn’t executed well enough.
Each character had a certain narrative niche, a small quirk that made the character, and for most of them, this small niche was all the chara...more
Each character had a certain narrative niche, a small quirk that made the character, and for most of them, this small niche was all the chara...more
The Garden of Last Days tantilized - Florida and strippers... and then it became much, much more. Andre Dubus has a descriptive style of writing that tugs you along as the characters develop and you are entwined in their lives and what shapes those lives. Mr. Dubus peels back the suductiveness of the "gentlemans club" and lays it bare in front of us. He turns the lights up bright enough to see the threadbare and beer soaked carpeting - literally.
Regardless of your culture or background we all lo...more
Regardless of your culture or background we all lo...more
So far this is my favorite book in recent history (as far as modern literature goes).
I could not put this book down from page one. Andre Dubus is a genius, and his writing is thought-provoking, powerful and emotional - a literary trifecta.
If you haven't read this book, I highly recommend it - you won't be disappointed.
Some books end up being a waste of time (especially when you have a short amount of free time to begin with)...but not this one. I gladly gave up many hours of sleep so I could fin...more
I could not put this book down from page one. Andre Dubus is a genius, and his writing is thought-provoking, powerful and emotional - a literary trifecta.
If you haven't read this book, I highly recommend it - you won't be disappointed.
Some books end up being a waste of time (especially when you have a short amount of free time to begin with)...but not this one. I gladly gave up many hours of sleep so I could fin...more
The Garden of Last Days is a perfect literary example of masterful storytelling. It doesn't matter that the book is lengthier than average at over 530 pages because you won't notice it or feel overwhelmed; you'll simply enjoy the reading experience.
Andre Dubus III opens The Garden of Last Days on a lazy Florida afternoon and we are introduced to April and Franny; a single young woman who works for a strip club and her three-year old daughter. April's usual babysitter, Jean, is in the hospital, a...more
Andre Dubus III opens The Garden of Last Days on a lazy Florida afternoon and we are introduced to April and Franny; a single young woman who works for a strip club and her three-year old daughter. April's usual babysitter, Jean, is in the hospital, a...more
The author does an amazing job describing a story during the 3 or 4 days leading up to 9/11 in this fictional, uniquely captivating novel. I was pleasantly surprised to find out at the end from Dubus' epilogue that quite a lot was actually true with respect to Bassam, one of the hijackers, and his partners. Adds a different perspective, the angle he worked is refreshing. Written from the viewpoint of the various main characters, I could hardly put the book down, despite it being consistently sad...more
Novelists keep being drawn to the events of September 11, 2001, hoping to confine the heinous imponderables of that day into the shapings of fiction. Writers as various as Jay McInerney (The Good Life), Jonathan Safran Foer (Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close) and John Updike (Terrorist) have made their attempts at it.
It’s hardly surprising that Andre Dubus III should join them with his new novel, The Garden of Last Days. Even before 9/11, in his 1999 novel House of Sand and Fog, he gave us a s...more
It’s hardly surprising that Andre Dubus III should join them with his new novel, The Garden of Last Days. Even before 9/11, in his 1999 novel House of Sand and Fog, he gave us a s...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| A disturbing walk in the garden | 1 | 54 | Nov 17, 2008 06:52pm |
Andre Dubus III is the author of Townie, The Garden of Last Days, and House of Sand and Fog (an Oprah Book Club pick and a finalist for the National Book Award). His father, Andre Dubus, was a noted short story writer. Andre Dubus III lives with his family north of Boston.
More about Andre Dubus III...
Share This Book
1 trivia question
More quizzes & trivia...
“But even in September, Thursday was a big money night, seven to eight hundred take-home, and that's what April concentrated on as she drove, Franny's chin starting to loll against her chest—April made herself think of that fat roll of tens and twenties she'd have at closing, how she'd fold it into the front pocket of her jeans then go to the house mom's office off the dressing room and give Tina a hundred before she found Franny in her pj's on Tina's brown vinyl couch, and she'd try not to think of the walls above Tina's desk covered with dancers' schedules and audition Polaroids of naked women, some of them under postcards from girls who came and went.”
—
1 person liked it
More quotes…

Loading...
view all 12 comments























