The Faith Instinct: How Religion Evolved and Why It Endures
Noted science writer Nicholas Wade offers for the first time a convincing case based on a broad range of scientific evidence for the evolutionary basis of religion.
Hardcover, 320 pages
Published
November 12th 2009
by Penguin Press HC, The
(first published 2009)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
577)
Nicholas Wade makes the case that an instinct for faith became hardwired in humans, when it proved to be vital to the survival of early societies. He then goes on to build on this premise with an exploration of how religion binds people together - or, conversely keeps us separate from those who don't share our religion - and why this has shaped culture.
One of his most absorbing statements is that as humans began to live in larger and larger groups there was a greater and greater need to enforce...more
One of his most absorbing statements is that as humans began to live in larger and larger groups there was a greater and greater need to enforce...more
Jul 28, 2011
Rob Dewitte
added it
This comes on the heels of Wade's "Before the Dawn", which traced the evolution of human groups along mitochondrial DNA, which remains unmodified since modern humans left Africa thousands of years ago.
Wade's thesis, based in part on the fact that it is universal among human populations, is that on the whole, religion conferred an adaptive advantage to its believers, and thus is the result of evolution. He focuses his efforts on the concrete parts of religion that can be measured: religious beha...more
Wade's thesis, based in part on the fact that it is universal among human populations, is that on the whole, religion conferred an adaptive advantage to its believers, and thus is the result of evolution. He focuses his efforts on the concrete parts of religion that can be measured: religious beha...more
At the wedding I attended last weekend, I was a bit disappointed there was only one hymn because, despite being nonreligious and a terrible singer, I love hymns. Why, though? What itch is scratched by hymn-singing that isn't scratched by karaoke or listening to an Orlando di Lassus CD? In this book, Nicholas Wade talks about the purposes and methods of religion from an evolutionary point of view and concludes that the most fundamental ingredients of religion are singing and dancing together. Bec...more
Now this is a fascinating concept: that religion evolved because it helped people survive. The author claims that religion grew because it helped societies band together and gave them the glue that was a necessary to bind them to each other, and helped them to create rules which would serve the group's interest.
I had been thinking that it was religions which led to warring, killing and cruelty to others. But this book turned that thought upside down and let me see it from a different angle. The...more
I had been thinking that it was religions which led to warring, killing and cruelty to others. But this book turned that thought upside down and let me see it from a different angle. The...more
The first half of the book, describing how and why religions evolved, was fascinating, engaging, and well-researched, with contradictory theories presented, and his reasons for preferring one over the other well-explained. The second half, describing his conclusions, was vastly less so. He dismissed studies backed up by evidence without either refuting those studies or providing evidence for his own counter theories. He also blatantly contradicted himself--for example, earlier in the book, he st...more
Dec 20, 2011
Mouldy Squid
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
students of religion and history, readers interested in religion and society
Shelves:
religion-and-occult
A fascinating exposition of a theory sure to stir controversy. Nicholas Wade carefully and convincingly puts forth the hypothesis that religion, far from being a delusion, or "mental illness" as Dawkins claims, is actually an evolutionary adaptation that selects at the group level. Wade argues that the ubiquitousness of religion, which must pre-date all civilization and perhaps language, could only have survived the crucible of Darwin if it conferred some advantage to the ancestors of human bein...more
It's an important book and a good read, though more broad and speculative than it is scientific. The thesis described in the title, that religion in the human individual and society is the result of natural selection, is barely discussed before Wade moves on to support a different claim, that shared religion the the glue that binds the individuals in a society. But both topics are interesting and Wade brings a lot of reading and thought to bear on each subject, so I was happy with the book.
Among...more
Among...more
The Faith Instinct is not a bad book, but it may not be what you're expecting. It certainly wasn't what I was expecting.
Based on the title, "How Religion Evolved and Why It Endures" I was expecting some pretty hard scientific data. Brain imaging, scientific experiments, and psychological case studies, however, are not to be found in this book. Instead, author Nicholas Wade approaches the question of religion not from a scientific or psychological perspective, but an historical one.
In this way, i...more
Based on the title, "How Religion Evolved and Why It Endures" I was expecting some pretty hard scientific data. Brain imaging, scientific experiments, and psychological case studies, however, are not to be found in this book. Instead, author Nicholas Wade approaches the question of religion not from a scientific or psychological perspective, but an historical one.
In this way, i...more
Wade presents the idea that religion evolved biologically and culturally as an adaptive aspect of humanity. This book has many critics on both sides of the debate. Religious fundamentalists find his assertion that religion is a product of natural laws unsettling, while many non-theists find his assertion that religion is essentially an adaptive trait misleading. Religion is obviously not the product of a single genetic trait, and Wade fully acknowledges this; however, he does argue that a comple...more
The author wanders awkwardly from biology to sociology to history. The chapter on "The Tree of Religion" is especially interesting and reveals some interesting points about the development of Islam, previously unknown to me. I think I agree with the author that we are sadly stuck with religion. His observations on the relationship of dancing and music with belief hit close to home. I recently had to endure a Springsteen concert. It really didn't have that much to do with the music. It was all ab...more
The first half of this book was interesting. The author reviews the evidence for the evolution of morality and religion. He gives an interesting and believable argument in favor of group selection in evolution under special circumstances. Group selection is very controversial in biology. He makes a good case for it. After that, however, things start to go awry. After his discussion of the evolution of morality, he then goes on to say that religion is the source of all morality in society. Furthe...more
I think I will be thinking about this book for a long time. Much to chew on. The author's thesis is that religion has evolved as humans have evolved, and that essentially religion has helped to ensure the survival of societies through regulating reproduction, inspiring warriors to defend territory, creating social cohesion, etc. The author states at the beginning that the book can be offensive to both atheists and believers, though it is intended to offend neither. Atheists might be offended bec...more
Mr. Wade brings a number of interesting new theories and recent discovers to light in the first portion The Faith Instinct.
The connection between belief, group selection, and ritual in primitive hunter-gatherer societies is compelling and fascinating. However, a number of insights about how the socioeconomic pressures of growing communities and the supplanting of community beliefs with hierarchical religion may have decreased the value of supernatural beliefs on both group and individual levels...more
The connection between belief, group selection, and ritual in primitive hunter-gatherer societies is compelling and fascinating. However, a number of insights about how the socioeconomic pressures of growing communities and the supplanting of community beliefs with hierarchical religion may have decreased the value of supernatural beliefs on both group and individual levels...more
There is a conciliatory tactic in the trenches of the science versus religion debate that tries to separate the responsibilities of the former from the latter. Despite its attempts to stay out of religion, though, science can’t. It has a job to do: it has to explain religion. Religion is a human behaviour, and humans are part of the physical universe. Therefore, science should have room for an explanation of religion as an emergent phenomenon. Historically, religion has tended to be the domain o...more
I really liked this book, despite its flaws, the main two being:
1) It's somewhat redundant, almost as if he really wrote each chapter to stand on its own, and
2) As others have mentioned, he does tend to do a bit of glossing when talking about violence inspired by religion (which is not to say that the theory that, evolutionarily speaking, religion has been more helpful than hurtful when it comes to passing on genes is incorrect), and then when he DOES talk about violence in religion, he mostly f...more
1) It's somewhat redundant, almost as if he really wrote each chapter to stand on its own, and
2) As others have mentioned, he does tend to do a bit of glossing when talking about violence inspired by religion (which is not to say that the theory that, evolutionarily speaking, religion has been more helpful than hurtful when it comes to passing on genes is incorrect), and then when he DOES talk about violence in religion, he mostly f...more
Jan 27, 2012
Terence
rated it
3 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
People interested in religion & evolution
Recommended to Terence by:
Library New Book shelf
In The Faith Instinct, Nicholas Wade argues that religion is a gene-based adaptation that allowed those groups that had it to survive where those without perished, “religion” being defined as “a system of emotionally binding beliefs and practices in which a society implicitly negotiates through prayer and sacrifice with supernatural agents, securing from them commands that compel members, through fear of divine punishment, to subordinate their interests to the common good.” (p. 15) Religion deve...more
i think people in general spend so much time actively engaged WITHIN their religion that they never really develop an appreciation for the HOW's, WHY's, and WHERE's of their religion, or for religion as a whole.
this is an incredibly fascinating look at the origins and evolution of religion from the religions of nomadic tribes to the three monotheisms of today's civilizations.
as reportage, it's stellar, and wade makes this stuff compelling through a variety of histories, anecdotes, and distillat...more
this is an incredibly fascinating look at the origins and evolution of religion from the religions of nomadic tribes to the three monotheisms of today's civilizations.
as reportage, it's stellar, and wade makes this stuff compelling through a variety of histories, anecdotes, and distillat...more
Wile I personally do not 100% resonate with all of the conclusions Wade makes in this book. ( I am currently pretty far out on the Dawkinsiean atheist tip and am subsequently more
skeptical and hostile towards religion than Wade ) I did thoroughly enjoy this book and I also learned a lot. If anything, this book has brought me back to a more rational, balanced, less hostile view of religion and it's apparently necessary role in human culture. Great stuff.
skeptical and hostile towards religion than Wade ) I did thoroughly enjoy this book and I also learned a lot. If anything, this book has brought me back to a more rational, balanced, less hostile view of religion and it's apparently necessary role in human culture. Great stuff.
Fascinating book on a biological/evolutionary understanding approach to the development of religion and its role in human life. This book is not for everyone; clearly, there are those who will view it as heretical in its approach. Nonetheless, it offers some interesting insights on the role that religion can play in communal and individual life.
I confess, theories that attempt to align the evolution of the human genome with any type of belief or behavior are usually unconvincing. In this regard Wade does no better than others I have recently read, and I remain a skeptic.
Having said that, what I did find of use was his in-depth exploration of archaic hunter-gatherer proto-religions, such as the Dreamtime of the Australian Aborigines. Due to their geographic isolation, it has been possible to go back 15,000 years to study the earliest fo...more
Having said that, what I did find of use was his in-depth exploration of archaic hunter-gatherer proto-religions, such as the Dreamtime of the Australian Aborigines. Due to their geographic isolation, it has been possible to go back 15,000 years to study the earliest fo...more
The perfect (for me) follow up to "Dancing in the Streets" by Barbara Ehrenreich. This book returns to the natural inclination of humans to spiritual activities. It references the attraction of Music and dancing as expressions of spirit. It doesn't say that a sermon or dogma help us feel connected to our community. It says shared rituals like music or movement create "collective effervescence"...this is what I love... it is that feeling of being more alive! If this is actually an evolutionary ad...more
The first half of the book was about group evolution and how we could have evolved with a disposition towards religion because it is good for the group. I thought this sectioned went on for a bit too long. Or maybe that's only because I've already read more than my share of books about evolution.
I did really enjoy the chapter on Religion and the Nation though. This chapter talked about how religion is declining in most of the world, but not in the US and why that might be the case. It also talke...more
I did really enjoy the chapter on Religion and the Nation though. This chapter talked about how religion is declining in most of the world, but not in the US and why that might be the case. It also talke...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Nicholas Wade is a British-born scientific reporter, editor and author who currently writes for the Science Times section of The New York Times. Wade was born in Aylesbury, England and educated at Eton College and King's College, Cambridge. Wade has been a correspondent, based in Washington, and deputy editor, based in London, of the journal Nature. He also reported from Washington for the journal...more
More about Nicholas Wade...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...



























updated May 10, 2012 09:19am