Blank-133x176
The Vinland Sagas: The...
 
by
Anonymous
Rate this book
Clear rating

The Vinland Sagas: The Icelandic Sagas About The First Documented Voyages Across The North Atlantic, The Saga Of The Greenlanders And Eirik The Red's Saga

by
3.84 of 5 stars 3.84  ·  rating details  ·  551 ratings  ·  46 reviews
One of the most arresting stories in the history of exploration, these two Icelandic sagas tell of the discovery of America by Norsemen five centuries before Christopher Columbus. Together, the direct, forceful twelfth-century Graenlendinga Saga and the more polished and scholarly Eirik's Saga, written some hundred years later, recount how Eirik the Red founded an Icelandi...more
Published November 19th 2008 (first published 1390)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about The Vinland Sagas, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about The Vinland Sagas

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,218)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Siria
I read this in a slim little Penguin Classics edition which brings together The Saga of the Greenlanders and Eirik the Red's Saga (both together are about 50 pages long), together with some good introductory material and lots of informative appendices. Because it's so well-contextualised, I think this would be a very good edition to use in an undergrad classroom—the maps in particular are really excellent, though some of the introductory material is perhaps slightly out of date/not as certain as...more
Pete daPixie
I'm being generous here, giving this 3 stars. This Penquin Classic only reads for around 100 pages. The first 50ish contains Magnus Magnusson's Introduction, and that was the best part of the book. Magnus writes of the two Vinland Saga's, their dates, their origins and the contemporary histories of Norway, Iceland, Greenland and the British Isles. He also includes the archaeological discoveries that back up the saga stories.
So...in 985, as Forkbeard was cuninge in Denmark, the year perhaps Cnut...more
Grant
Jul 01, 2008 Grant rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: History geeks
An amazing insight into how people lived 1000 years ago. Whilst sometimes the structure of the stories can be a bit clunky, I found these two sagas a riveting read. Given that most of the old Norse sagas are written accounts of stories that were orally passed down through the generations, it is a testimony to Icelandic culture that such stories are remembered with any detail at all. According to my history buff friends this is the easiest to read of all of the sagas.
With an interesting introduct...more
dead letter office
kickass stories of the norse settlement of north america circa 1000. the best thing about these sagas (they don't have quite the poetry of, say, Egil's) is their blending of historical fact with myth. the norse landing in newfoundland around this time is archaeologically supported, but plenty of magic and violence and weirdness crept into the account by the time it was set down in the Vinland Sagas 200 years or so after the fact. i imagine (without really knowing) that this is the earliest known...more
Ape
These are particularly short sagas, in fact more of the book is dedicated to the introduction and notes than the sagas themselves. They both cover the same ground, that being the settlement of Greenland and the discovery of Vinland (North America). I find it fascinating to cover that these stories are over 1000 years old, originally from the oral traditional and then written down in medieval Iceland. These are the history of a people, but also of individuals - as well as the big stuff, there's p...more
David Sarkies
I have long heard the rumours that the vikings had discovered North America long before Christopher Columbus sailed across the Atlantic but I had always assumed that it was little more than a single expedition of which nothing more came of it. However, this little book, which contains two Viking texts: Eirik's Saga and the Graenlendinga Saga says otherwise. Both of these texts tell the same story, however there are a few differences (in that Eirik's Saga seems to be more of a text telling how C...more
Michelle
I was drawn to this book for two main reasons: 1) because I have a triple dose of Scandinavian blood (Swedish, Norwegian, Danish); and 2) because I love ancient and medieval history. I was not disappointed. The language is not necessarily incredibly beautiful or well-phrased, and it is, of course, a translation--I can't speak any of those languages, and certainly not Old Icelandic. However, certain passages struck me as being particularly "Minnesotan"--and perhaps because Minnesotans are, by and...more
Andrew
The two sagas in question are very short, and the introductory matter is probably no longer up to date (the translation is 40-50 years old). That said, since Magnus Magnusson did the translation, I was willing to give it a whirl. The Graenland Saga (the early and shorter one) was totally loony fun -- I think its freewheeling "anything goes" mentality was a benefit, not -- in the eyes of the introduction -- a hindrance. The later saga (Eirik's Saga) was much less entertaining. It was longer, more...more
russell barnes
Ohhhh, get me reading Icelandic sagas from one thousand years ago. One. Thousand. Years. Ago.

Actually this a brilliantly easy-reading saga beyond the fact THE Magnus "I've started so I've finished" Magnusson, translated it. Strangely enough, when you read the blurb you think this is going to be some middle-English drag-a-thon, more struggle than fun read, admittedly one that features Vikings.

*However* once you get beyond the introduction (which is longer than both sagas combined), essentially wh...more
Jeremiah Carlson
I learned a lot from this book and I found it semi-entertaining too. The introduction is very very overwritten and I would personally just skip it, or read it after the story like most. But it doesn't really ruin much of the stories contained fortunately. Introduction was well written though.

The sagas are okay, but the most fun parts are speculating for yourself what certain things in them mean, and having your own conclusions on this under-read story of history. Though there is enough strange h...more
John Nebauer
This is a pair of fascinating accounts of the Viking voyages to North America some 400-odd years before Columbus' voyages. Interesting in their own right, they are helped with an excellent introduction by translators Magnus Mangusson. Comprising about 1/3 of this slim volume, it puts the voyages into a broad context which adds greatly to the experience. It gives a brief account of the settlement of Iceland and the beginnings of the doomed Norse outposts on Greenland.

While the translations move t...more
David
I read some Norse sagas in college and do enjoy the quasi-historical, quasi-fictitious nature of the genre. One thing about it, though--sagas do not work well as a quick or fragmented read. It takes a lot of time and investment in this literature first to get all the names straight and also to unravel the history from the fiction. For some sagas many versions (or fragments thereof) abound, written at different times by people with different motives. But it's fun now and then to dive into this so...more
Xavier
I know a lot of people will disagree with me on this, but I found the prose to be quick and lively, as one would expect of an oral history. This is especially true in the first, more sober account. I know there are genealogies now and then, but they're really not that bad. The story of Eric the Red's discovery and settlement of Greenland is interesting, and his children's discovery and attempted settlement of America is fascinating. The embellishments seem for the most part rather obvious, espec...more
Pamela Lloyd
Jun 10, 2008 Pamela Lloyd rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Everyone
I've only just started reading the introduction, but already I feel this should be required reading for elementary or middle school history classes. (It would be great to have it tied to an English or social studies class on the Norse myths.)

Update: Having finished reading the introduction and both sagas, I feel even more strongly that this work needs to be far better known. Our children are still taught, by and large, that Columbus discovered America. Even discounting the fact that this contine...more
Justin Evans
And then some stuff happened, and then some other stuff happened, and then some more stuff happened, and here's a list of names that you'll never remember, and then some stuff happened. Okay, it ain't a work of beauty. I daresay that if these chronicles related the discovery of Gersey nobody would bother translating it, let alone read it. But it is pretty cool that some random viking types found the North American continent. And these 'sagas' are short, so you can read them pretty quick, and get...more
Nancy
It took me over a year to read the 50 pages of this book. I bought it after visiting Lanse aux Meadows and I was inspired to hear Viking tales in their own words. Due to the unfortunate practice they had of naming everyone Thorsomething it was hard to keep everyone straight. But once you got past the family tree at the beginning of each story it would finally get interesting. Vikings are not big on explaining motivation so why someone would up and kill half of her party is left to the reader's i...more
Tyler
The Vinland Sagas are two very short (compared to Egil's or Njal's or some of the others) Sagas that tell about the earliest white explorers to arrive in North America. The Vinland saga is actually an excerpt from a larger work about some Norweigan King so it doesn't fit the usual setup afforded most of the sagas. The Saga of Erik the Red talks more about Greenland and a teensy bit about Vinland.

I really enjoyed these sagas but I wish they were longer and had more details. Its amazing to think a...more
Electric Landlady
Fascinating, especially having read The Far Traveler: Voyages of a Viking Woman earlier this year and then visited L'Anse aux Meadows. The sagas themselves are quite short - 50 pages total - but the book is also full of information, footnotes, maps, family trees and a glossary. It makes for an absorbing read especially if you're at all interested in the Vikings and/or Newfoundland and/or early voyages to the Americas.
Rebecca
So this read exactly like a history book. I am not sure why they keep calling it a SAGA. Seriously, it reads like this, "Then Erik sailed here and he called it this. He then got in a fight and left for here. It looked like this and they called it this. He died." The end. I am not saying it was bad reading, just 7th grade history boring except that I am now an adult and can see the value better reading. I would suggest this to others who like history and who wish to be better informed.
P.S. The in...more
Skut L
I enjoyed the translation, laughing out loud a time or two which I had not expected, due to the terseness of events and the way certain things were described; clearly some things that were taken for granted hundreds of years ago when this was first scrawled down have not translated with age.

The notes were extremely informative and the annotations very meticulous. It still boggles me how many people are unaware that the first Europeans to visit North America arrived hundreds of years before Colu...more
María of Spain
Another fantastic translation by the great Magnus Magnusson.
The intro itself is worth getting this particular volume. Well researched, well laid out, a pleasure to read.
The two sagas are themselves some of the best saga reading I've ever done. Brief but so revealing!
I recommend reading them first, then Landnámabók and Íslendingabók, for background, then whatever else one wants to read: Njáls saga and others.
Umut
Genelde Vikingler barbar,yağma yapıp insanları zevk için öldüren vahşiler olarak tasfir edilir ve bu şekilde anlatılırdı fakat bu kitapla beraber aslında Vikinglerin Amerika kıtasını ilk keşfeden,denizcilik hakkında muazzam bilgilere sahip kaşifler oldukları görülüyor.
Böylece Amerika'nın fake kaşifi Christoph Colomb'un da Vikinglerin Ingilizlere verdiği bilgileri kullanarak Amerikaya gittiği anlaşılmıştır
Nicholas George Setford
One story but two different Sagas told differently! Great!
The Vikings - who cannot be in awe of this set of peoples who through force were to wield such an influence within the power structures of most of Europe! If their social and community talents had been been as acute as their seafaring skills and their bravery America might well have had another name!
Kailey Willmore
Placing the descriptions of Helluland, Markland and Vinland onto a modern map is a fun exercise, but this was a straightforward documentation of a voyage. In true twenty something fashion I am more drawn to the sagas of mythical stories and revenge.
treus
Informative and sometimes humorous account of Viking excursions into North America. The high point is the fighting between Vikings and Indians.

Be sure not to pass over the introduction, as it gives a useful background to the saga.
Dawn Paris
I think the intro was almost as long as each of the sagas, but it was good to get the comparison of the two up front. As for the sagas themselves, I think I prefer the older Graelendinga Saga better than the more polished Eirik's Saga.
Dana McCallum
I read this right after reading The Sea Road and I think these two books make wonderful companions. Read The Sea Road for an engaging dramatic retelling of the events, then read The Vinland Sagas for the historical background.
Luis P Castelo
Son sagas, a sonoridade e as fórmulas empregadas gáñanme. A tradución sabe conservar a esencia, o ritmo e a sonoridade, así como a capacidade de evocación, porén, non estou moi dacordo con algunhas das escollas ortográficas...
Lorina Stephens
A comprehensive introduction to the two Vinland Sagas: the Graenlendinga Saga and Erik's Saga, as well as updated archelogical information. Well organized. Well presented.
mattson
the world's first written example of racist slang... unipeds on the african coast... and america before columbus' greatgreatgreatgreatgreatgreatgrandparents were born.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 40 41 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Hrafnkel's Saga and Other Icelandic Stories
  • Seven Viking Romances
  • King Harald's Saga
  • Viking Age Iceland
  • A History of the Vikings
  • Gods and Myths of Northern Europe
  • The Vikings
  • Norse Mythology: A Guide to the Gods, Heroes, Rituals, and Beliefs
  • Vikings: The North Atlantic Saga
  • The Race for Timbuktu: In Search of Africa's City of Gold
  • The Penguin Historical Atlas of the Vikings
  • Adventures in the Unknown Interior of America
  • The Four Voyages: Being His Own Log-Book, Letters and Dispatches with Connecting Narratives
  • A Brief History of the Vikings: The Last Pagans or the First Modern Europeans?
  • The Anglo-Saxons
  • From Asgard to Valhalla: The Remarkable History of the Norse Myths
  • The Travels of Sir John Mandeville
  • The Darkest Jungle: The True Story of the Darien Expedition and America's Ill-Fated Race to Connect the Seas
Books can be attributed to "Anonymous" for several reasons:

* They are officially published under that name
* They are traditional stories not attributed to a specific author
* They are religious texts not generally attributed to a specific author

Books whose authorship is merely uncertain should be attributed to Unknown.
More about Anonymous...
Holy Bible: King James Version The Arabian Nights: Tales from a Thousand and One Nights The Epic of Gilgamesh Holy Bible: New International Version The Bhagavad Gita

Share This Book