Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “In the Company of Secrets (Postcards from Pullman #1)” as Want to Read:
In the Company of Secrets (Postcards from Pullman #1)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

In the Company of Secrets (Postcards from Pullman #1)

3.79  ·  Rating Details ·  1,865 Ratings  ·  152 Reviews
The truth could cost her everything....
Olivia Mott didn't intend to lie. Somehow, it just happened. And wasn't it all Lady Charlotte's fault anyway?
Now Olivia's position as assistant chef at Pullman's elegant Hotel Florence is dependant upon her keeping her secrets. And sometimes lies have a way of leading to other lies. Should Olivia admit her real past and accept the c
Paperback, 381 pages
Published April 1st 2007 by Bethany House Publishers
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about In the Company of Secrets, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about In the Company of Secrets

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Oct 27, 2012 Nicole rated it it was amazing
Shelves: favorites
URGH!! This book was SO incredible! It totally captured by attention from page 1 and continued to grab me til the end. And now I'm so frustrated that I don't have books 2 & 3, Whispers Along the Rails & An Uncertain Dream.

Aside from an adult-level threat given in chapter one, In the Company of Secrets was SO clean! As I've mentioned in previous reviews, I so very much appreciate a wholesome, clean love story that doesn't go into unnecessary details.

Olivia Mott seeks to run from a nasty s
Noran Miss Pumkin
Sep 29, 2011 Noran Miss Pumkin rated it it was ok
Shelves: fiction, 2011
the plot was not intriguing. I actually find myself not liking Olivia-the lead of the story. She has many chances to come clean from her lies, with all in her life-but she does not, and the usual ramifications at the end of the book. You could see the ending after the first few chapters. I did like seeing the town of Pullman, nicely described. I had the delight of dining at the restored Hotel Florence a decade ago, being a birthday dinner with my brother Anthony. Snowy Feb. evening, just added t ...more
Jun 17, 2014 Jeffrey rated it it was ok
Shelves: could-not-finish
First, Let me clarify my rating as "did not finish" rather than "could not finish." The author is a fine writer and the plot was intriguing however, read on for my explanation for why I "did not finish."

Based on my perusals of reviews on, I steadfastly refuse to get drawn into another trilogy or series of books that require the reading of all the volumes for some sort of resolution! I put down Daughter's Inheritance by Tracie Peterson for that same reason. It is apparent that this
Jul 22, 2013 Ashley rated it it was ok
In the Company of Secrets (Postcards from Pullman Book #1) by Judith Miller has the potential to be a stellar book. There could be complex characters with an intricately woven plotline however, in the end, it collapses under the weight of the excessive moral lessons and faith-based guilt. The characters are one-dimensional, the story is predictable and overall it is just a very lackluster book. It was an average book until after Olivia Mott (the protagonist) takes a day trip with Mr. Samuel Howa ...more
Rachel Dixon
Sep 16, 2014 Rachel Dixon rated it it was ok
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Dec 17, 2012 Pegg rated it really liked it
Historically interesting look into the town of Pullman. George Pullman not only invented things like the Pullman railroad car, he also invented the "perfect" town. Smacking of socialism, it was seated just outside of Chicago.

As with so many social experiments meant to improve things for all mankind, with no saloons, no independent newspapers, strict codes to adhere to for the public good, etc., Pullman was far from perfect under the surface.

Into this town comes Olivia Mott. Newly escaped from a
May 14, 2013 Anita rated it liked it
I read this book in one day - snowing in Iowa in May.

I did not know about Pullman, Illinois. I hope to visit the town.

It is easier to tell the truth - one false statement leads to another. These girls have told so many lies they have to write a list to remember them all. Even though she had " 'fessed up " to her employer, when her boyfriend found the list there was damage to their relationship.

All sin is forgiven, but there are still consequences. you cannot put the egg back in the shell - no
Feb 07, 2009 Stacia rated it liked it
This book was what I was looking for. Something that is an easy read, with some history and a little romance thrown in. I enjoyed the story, but I often think that author's overplay guilt. I also think that Fred's responses and reaction to certain things were a little over the top as well... who wants to date a guy that is suspicious of your feelings from the outset, before ever having a reason to distrust you? Overall, I enjoyed it and would recommend it to others who enjoy historical Christian ...more
May 17, 2012 Reianna rated it did not like it
This book was awful. It was intolerably slow, the plot almost non existent till the end. There was zero character development, and I felt no connection to any of the characters whatsoever. Everything is exaggerated from a small offense to something life ending-ly horrible. The writing style is stiff, and in no way enjoyable. 0 stars.
Lindsey (Books for Christian Girls)
So, the book starts out with Olivia running away from a chef who's trying to make her his mistress.
Yeah, so, uh, I didn't get passed that.
Amber Schamel
Jan 18, 2017 Amber Schamel rated it really liked it
Shelves: on-my-kindle-tbr
The story was interesting, though not as suspenseful as I expected.

The ending is a cliff hanger, so beware. It is the first of a series, and apparently you must read the whole series to find out what happens. :)
I do want to read the rest of the series, so that is a good sign.

I enjoyed the way that Judith takes both Mr. Howard and Fred's POV, because it leaves you wondering which one will win out in the end.
Lyndee S. Pitiak
Enjoyable read, but...

This was an enjoyable read but I was not satisfied with the ending. This is the first of a series so it left a cliff hanger. I don't like it when this happens. I prefer to have an ending to a book, even one in a series.
Jan 08, 2017 Fran rated it really liked it
I didn't particularly like the character of Olivia, but the plot made up for that.
May 03, 2016 Lisa rated it it was ok
Maybe 2.5 if you really want it to be.

Quick summary: Set in the 1890s, ITCoS introduces Olivia Mott as a maid in the kitchen of Lord and Lady Spencer in London, England. The chef there gives her an ultimatum: become his mistress or lose her job. When she confides in a fellow maid in the household, that maid tells her Spencers' daughter, Charlotte, her plight, and a plan is hatched...they'll flee to America, where Olivia's cousin lives and can perhaps find her a job. As it turns out, Lady Charlot
Sep 30, 2008 Cali rated it really liked it
Recommends it for: anybody
Recommended to Cali by: my mother- in- law

Sir Walter Scott said, “O what a tangled web we weave, when first we practice to deceive!” Within her book, In the Company of Secrets, Judith Miller constructs this kind of “tangled web.”

Olivia Mott is a helper in the kitchen of an earl and his wife in London, England. When she is advanced upon by the chef, she decides it is time to leave. The earl’s daughter has the perfect idea for both of them to escape, but her plan requires many lies.

The two women end up in Pu
Jan 02, 2009 Becky rated it liked it
Miller, Judith. 2007. Postcards from Pullman: In the Company of Secrets. Bethany House. 382 pages.

Run! Faster! Hurry!

Historical fiction. Set in 1892.

Wanting to escape the advances of a malicious Chef Mallard, Olivia Mott, a mere scullery maid, finds herself tangled up in an ever-growing web of lies when she accepts help from Lady Charlotte Spencer, the daughter of the Count and Countess of Lanshire. Lady Charlotte temporarily rescues the young woman with culinary aspirations, but it comes with a
In the Company of Secrets had all the makings of a book that I would enjoy: a historical setting, an interesting synopsis and characters I would imagine to be strong willed and determined. Unfortunately this first book in the Postcards from Pullman series missed the mark.

Olivia’s charade would have gone a lot smoother had she been a good liar. However before I reached the half way mark, I was getting pretty annoyed with her. I didn’t feel as if the reader got a sense of who she was beyond all t
Heather Rae
Nov 28, 2013 Heather Rae rated it it was ok
This was a cute, easy read. I was a little disappointed that the story didn't end with the book. I didn't realize it is part of a three book series, all with the same female character. Olivia is an somewhat interesting character, but her infatuation with Fred was ridiculous. I did NOT like him, though I tried to. He lives with his mother, he pouts over everything and oh, he has a temper? How nice. I much preferred Mr. Howard over Fred. At least he seemed to have a kind heart and the courage to p ...more
Jun 07, 2014 June rated it liked it
An engaging read of a young naive woman who wishes to be a chef. Her dream is realized but not as she expects. The story, written in the third person, is a realistic and relatable look of what happens when one seeks to reach your dream and how life can intervene. Olivia is immature at the outset and slowly gets wise. There are some hard lessons which she learns and it is written without being preachy. The story develops at a slower pace than I would like but it is a series. The plot is though so ...more
Jul 11, 2013 Susan rated it liked it
Shelves: fiction
Olivia worked in the kitchen for a Lord in England. When the chef threatened that she would be his mistress or she would be fired, Olivia and Lady Charolette decided to go to American to the city of Pullman. Olivia finds out that Lady Charlette is pregnant by an American. Upon arriving, a fake letter from Lady Charloette's mother gained Olivia a job in the hotel kitchen. One lie led to another and another with a tangled web being made. Two men showed interest in her which only serves to confuse ...more
Betty Ost-Everley
Jul 06, 2013 Betty Ost-Everley rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
"What a wicked web we weave when first we practice to deceive." In this first book of the Postcards of Pullman series, we find that Olivia Mott learned this lesson the hard way, suffering some unintended ramifications. Along the way, Olivia comes to understand the gift of forgiveness from her Savior, as well as the unforgiving nature of humans. Judith McCoy Miller introduces us to the very orchestrated lives of the residents of Pullman, Illinois at the turn of the century, and how George Pullman ...more
P S Karr
Sep 05, 2014 P S Karr rated it really liked it
Shelves: drama
Olivia Mott wants to be a chef. She works in the kitchens of an Earl but does not enjoy the lascivious advances of the chef. She runs off to America with the truant daughter of the Earl, Lady Charlotte, and they end up in Pullman. Olivia is happy because her cousin Al lives there. Charlotte plans to meet her beau Randolph Morgan and is planning her wedding. But their world comes crashing down when they learn Randolph is a married man. Now Charlotte is in a delicate condition and poses as a widow ...more
Shilo Quetchenbach
Jul 09, 2013 Shilo Quetchenbach rated it did not like it
I kept hoping this would get better. But it didn't. The hazards of reading something based on the cover, I suppose. I was hoping for something steampunk-y. Instead, I got a slow moving story about a servant who escapes London with the daughter of her employers (the Earl and his wife) and travels to a company town in Illinois. Her lady is looking for the father of her child. The story is promising. The execution was less than I had hoped. The writing was ponderous and stilted. The main character, ...more
Margaret Metz
Oct 18, 2012 Margaret Metz rated it liked it
Well, I love historical fiction and truly enjoyed all the descriptions and the food talked about in the book. I wasn't totally sold on the romance -- I actually thought Fred was a bad guy in the beginning of the book because of his temper and constant tirade against her boss (I mean Pullman - and we never meet him). I had some trouble "bonding" with Olivia as well. I'm not sure why that is -- her choices, the interaction with other characters . . . I don't really know why.

It's a matter of choice
Mar 24, 2015 Kate rated it liked it
3.5 egh.

The cover doesn't fit the book.

/Where did this train come from????/

3.5 rating

The book focused less on romance than I was expecting, but as a series, it was to be.... expected.

Instead, the book focuses on struggles and overcoming them and poor choices (quick fixes) and their consequences, both important topics. Who hasn't had these on there mind late at night?

I found it hard to get into the book (Olivia's feet hurt after a long day a handful or more times) but by the end feel anxious to
Feb 12, 2015 Patsy rated it it was amazing
Shelves: history
This is a Christian romance historical fiction novel. Olivia is a young woman with a dream of becoming a chef. She goes to work for an earl in England, the Earl' s daughter talks Olivia into going to America to meet her cousin in Pullman, Illinois to find a job as a chef. The book is interesting with a web of tangled lies and then more lies. Olivia was trying to protect her friend as well as follow her own dreams but she ended up hurting a lot of people including herself. A well written book wit ...more
Barb Nifong
Jun 01, 2014 Barb Nifong rated it it was amazing
What a tangled web we weave. Olivia didn't mean to lie, but as often happens one lie leads to another. It was all Lady Charlotte's fault. She was protecting Lady Charlotte. Olivia had plenty of opportunities to tell the truth and recant her untruths. She seemed to be of weak character, unable to stand up for she wanted, and was often led by circumstances. We are all given choices each day. The thing is which way will we choose? Right or wrong? Easy way out or the right and moral way? We also nee ...more
Trudy E
Oct 14, 2014 Trudy E rated it really liked it
Oh, what a tangled web we weave..... When Olivia can no longer stay in her current job, she tries to figure out a way to join her cousin in America. The daughter of her employer decides that she would like to go as well and paves the way for Olivia to go as her companion. Though it appears all is on the up-and-up, Olivia finds herself blackmailed in order for Lady Charlotte's agenda to move forward. One lie leads to many others and the burden of keeping it all straight becomes nearly unbearable. ...more
Dianne Sidebottom
Dec 11, 2013 Dianne Sidebottom rated it really liked it
The title of the book does give you the story line that gets tangled up in a web. The proper way to interact with people in this era gets me in a dither and so glad I don't have to learn. The gossip that follows people around I guess is no different today. Work ethics have changed and employers don't own you along with wages and hours. Charlotte's neglect of her baby maybe also true to her class background and Olivia having lost her mother early in her life had the love to bestow on the baby. I ...more
Carrie Bray
Oct 10, 2013 Carrie Bray rated it really liked it
Okay so this book was going great them bam it ended. It drives me crazy when a book ends without an ending know what I mean!? So I get all of my books a free or very discounted rates so I was pleasantly surprised to get a good book even if was a partial book. Not much character growth....yet. Very descriptive scenery but not overly dull. No obvious typos or at least none that I remember. The other two books have been added to my amazon wish list in the hopes they go free or very cheap but I don' ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
Sinopsis en Español // Synopsis in Spanish 1 1 Jan 22, 2015 09:42AM  
  • Daughter of the Loom (Bells of Lowell, #1)
  • The Heart of Thornton Creek (Queensland Chronicles #1)
  • Lily (Song of the River #1)
  • Distant Dreams (Ribbons of Steel, #1)
  • An Untamed Land (Red River of the North, #1)
  • Waiting for Summer's Return (Heart of the Prairie #1)
  • Gentleman of Her Dreams (Ladies of Distinction, #0.5)
  • The Maiden of Mayfair (Tales of London #1)
  • All in Good Time (The Gilded Legacy, #2)
  • Paradise Valley (Daughters of Caleb Bender, #1)
  • The Solitary Envoy (Heirs of Acadia, #1)
  • Angels Watching Over Me (Shenandoah Sisters, #1)
  • A Most Unsuitable Match
  • Into the Whirlwind
  • Lanterns and Lace (Texas Legacy #2)
  • Paper Roses (Texas Dreams, #1)
  • Heiress (Daughters of Fortune, #1)
Judith McCoy Miller is an award-winning author whose avid research and love for history are reflected in her bestselling novels. Judy and her husband make their home in Topeka, Kansas.
More about Judith McCoy Miller...

Other Books in the Series

Postcards from Pullman (3 books)
  • Whispers Along the Rails (Postcards from Pullman #2)
  • An Uncertain Dream (Postcards from Pullman #3)

Share This Book