145th out of 923 books
—
868 voters
The Case of the Missing Servant (Vish Puri #1)
by
Tarquin Hall (Goodreads Author)
Watch out Alexander McCall Smith! Here comes the first novel by the highly acclaimed writer Tarquin Hall in an entrancing new mystery series set in India.
The portly Vish Puri is India’s most accomplished detective, at least in his own estimation, and is also the hero of an irresistible new mystery series set in hot, dusty Delhi. Puri’s detective skills are old-fashioned in...more
The portly Vish Puri is India’s most accomplished detective, at least in his own estimation, and is also the hero of an irresistible new mystery series set in hot, dusty Delhi. Puri’s detective skills are old-fashioned in...more
Hardcover, 311 pages
Published
May 26th 2009
by McClelland & Stewart
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
Having heard so much about the book, I was eager to read the book. However, I was rather disappointed. To be fair, let us just say, it was nothing out of ordinary for me.
Vish Puri (pun on Hindi phrase for your wish comes true)is 51-year old Punjabi, pot-bellied private detective. (He is being India's Poirot.) But the book more reminded me of Mma Ramotswe for its sheer draggy quality.
However, don't get me wrong, my perspective is biased, since Delhi is home - this stereotyped peculiarity that Pu...more
Vish Puri (pun on Hindi phrase for your wish comes true)is 51-year old Punjabi, pot-bellied private detective. (He is being India's Poirot.) But the book more reminded me of Mma Ramotswe for its sheer draggy quality.
However, don't get me wrong, my perspective is biased, since Delhi is home - this stereotyped peculiarity that Pu...more
http://avadhutrecommends.wordpress.com/
Summary –
Vish Puri, founder of Most Private Investigators Ltd. undertakes to trace a maidservant known only as Mary in order to acquit her employer, a lawyer accused of murdering her and dumping her body.
Review –
Meet Vish Puri. He is portly, opinionated and Punjabi to the core. He loves his three square meals a day punctuated by chilly pakoras in between. You can underestimate him but only at your own peril. Inspired by Chanakya, world’s oldest spymaster, P...more
Summary –
Vish Puri, founder of Most Private Investigators Ltd. undertakes to trace a maidservant known only as Mary in order to acquit her employer, a lawyer accused of murdering her and dumping her body.
Review –
Meet Vish Puri. He is portly, opinionated and Punjabi to the core. He loves his three square meals a day punctuated by chilly pakoras in between. You can underestimate him but only at your own peril. Inspired by Chanakya, world’s oldest spymaster, P...more
A private detective in an exotic location- seems to be a trend. Yet again, the author isn't a native of India although he lives there now - Shades Of Alexander Smith McCall and his detective Mma Precious. But India is much more complex than Botswana and Vishi Puri is a more well rounded character.
Vish Puri makes his living as a private detective - mostly investigating prospective brides and grooms for the many arranged marriages. But there will be the big cases that come his way. Here he is deal...more
Vish Puri makes his living as a private detective - mostly investigating prospective brides and grooms for the many arranged marriages. But there will be the big cases that come his way. Here he is deal...more
Any fan of the Ladies No 1 Detective Agency (A McCall Smith) will find a new pleasure here. My mother recommended this author/series to me recently after reading The Case of the Deadly Butter Chicken, which is book 3. I like to try and read these in order if I can, so Missing Servant starts it off. Not only is there an interesting mystery to be solved by Vish Puri, private investigator; you will learn so much without being hit over the head with it about Punjabi (and Indian) life. In the way tha...more
I’ve found my new favourite detective. This time they are from India in the guise of portly, persistent and unmistakably Punjabi, private detective Vish Puri.
The Case of the Missing Servant is our first introduction to this ‘Indian Poriot.’ An established detective, with an web of contracts and employees, Puri is very much a conductor and ring master, though even he has problems with an interfering mother. As an introduction it works well. Hall gives us several threads to follow. Not only do we...more
The Case of the Missing Servant is our first introduction to this ‘Indian Poriot.’ An established detective, with an web of contracts and employees, Puri is very much a conductor and ring master, though even he has problems with an interfering mother. As an introduction it works well. Hall gives us several threads to follow. Not only do we...more
The good - this is a fun read. It's funny and I can pick up some info on Indian culture and politics.
The bad - I think that authors writing of a culture that is not their own, have a responsibility to present at least some of the characters of that culture in a respectful way. Tarquin Hall does not do that. My understanding is that he has lived in India a long time but he is not Indian and all his characters are. At least one of them should be presented as if he were a real person with real feel...more
The bad - I think that authors writing of a culture that is not their own, have a responsibility to present at least some of the characters of that culture in a respectful way. Tarquin Hall does not do that. My understanding is that he has lived in India a long time but he is not Indian and all his characters are. At least one of them should be presented as if he were a real person with real feel...more
Mar 06, 2012
Doreen
added it
This is the debut appearance of the Punjabi detective, Vish Puri, founder of Delhi's Most Private Investigators, Inc.
A maidservant has gone missing, and a crusading layer has been accused of killing her. Puri sets out to prove the attorney's innocence. (Other more minor cases are also investigated.)
Puri is called the Punjabi Sherlock Holmes and, although he shares similarities with a number of fictional detectives, he has a charm all his own. He is clever and resourceful but with enough eccentri...more
A maidservant has gone missing, and a crusading layer has been accused of killing her. Puri sets out to prove the attorney's innocence. (Other more minor cases are also investigated.)
Puri is called the Punjabi Sherlock Holmes and, although he shares similarities with a number of fictional detectives, he has a charm all his own. He is clever and resourceful but with enough eccentri...more
There was a popular song during my youth by a band called 10cc. The chorus of this song was, "I'm not in love/so don't forget it/it's just a silly phase I'm goin' through...." India, books Indian in setting and theme, Indian food *dripdrool*, Hindu theology, henna tattoos, all objects of fascination for me and much of the American culture just now. Fairly soon, I understand we're to get our first Tatas on these shores. (Go Google "Tata.")
So what's a weentsy-teentsy little shoestring publishing h...more
So what's a weentsy-teentsy little shoestring publishing h...more
Ah, India. How I long to see you and breath your diesel fumes and eat your greasy pakoras. Mr. Hall's first book about India's Most Private Investigator is another fun read that immerses the reader in India's current swirling hodge-podge of confliting cultures and lifestyles. Hall has created an interesting assortement of characters and a lively, multifaceted plotline. I especially enjoyed the comic, intermission-like interlude where Vish Puri, always calm and collected, has to face his greatest...more
Apr 17, 2011
Tze-Wen
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
crime-and-mystery,
india
After a week of emotionally charged books, I was ready to read something less serious, and it was right there and then that the colorful cover of Hall's novel beckoned to me. Spring has announced itself in the past few weeks, heating up my living room and forcing me to open up the curtain-less windows to a cacophony of happy chatting terrace loungers, soaking in the sun. When I closed my eyes, there were certainly moments that I could believe myself to be in dusty, crowded Delhi. If only I had a...more
I loved this book and hope there are many more to come - Vish Puri is a great hero! "Chubby" to his loving wife Rumpi, "Mummy-ji" and wonderfully mixed bag of friends and associates, he calls himself India's Most Private Investigator and his ego (rightfully) equals Poirot himself. Puri carefully records all of his cases at completion, as he is sure future generations will want to study his methods and even has the title picked out for his future memoirs: "Confidentiality Is My Watchword".
Puri is...more
Puri is...more
Private Investigator Vish Puri is also the managing director of ‘Most Private Investigators Ltd. A well respected and honest public litigator has been accused of killing Mary, his maidservant. Vish must also investigate a second case involving a potential bridegroom.
Vish’s character is perfect except he has an immense fear of flying. Luckily for Vish, he has a team of operatives that support him, especially his Mommy who conducts her own investigation.
There are actually three mysteries in the st...more
Vish’s character is perfect except he has an immense fear of flying. Luckily for Vish, he has a team of operatives that support him, especially his Mommy who conducts her own investigation.
There are actually three mysteries in the st...more
First Sentence: Vish Puri, founder and managing director of Most Private Investigators Ltd., sat alone in a room in a guesthouse in Defense Colony, south elhi, devouring a dozen green chili pakoras* from a greasy takeout box.
Private Investigator Vish Puri has his hands full. An honest and respected public litigator has been accused of murdering his maidservant. The police say they have witnesses of him dumping the body. Puri must prove the man’s innocence and find the real killer. A second case...more
Private Investigator Vish Puri has his hands full. An honest and respected public litigator has been accused of murdering his maidservant. The police say they have witnesses of him dumping the body. Puri must prove the man’s innocence and find the real killer. A second case...more
I honestly chose this book because of the cover! I was at the library and saw it on a display table, and loved the design of the front cover. The description of the book was appealing, and I plowed through it with delight over the course of a couple of days.
The skilled, likeable and slightly pompous main character, a detective in India, was such an engaging protagonist, and I loved reading about the culture, the inside jokes, the slang and colloquialisms of the area. The author helpfully includ...more
The skilled, likeable and slightly pompous main character, a detective in India, was such an engaging protagonist, and I loved reading about the culture, the inside jokes, the slang and colloquialisms of the area. The author helpfully includ...more
Delightful, even if Vish Puri is a pompous, sexist ass sometimes.
Set in contemporary Delhi, Puri is hired to find out what happened to a missing servant girl whom his client is accused of killing. One subplot has him investigating the prospective groom of his client's daughter, and the other has his mother investigating who is responsible for shooting at him.
All the plots were satisfying, the characterization deft, and there was plenty of dry humor, too. Bonus points for the extensive glossary...more
Set in contemporary Delhi, Puri is hired to find out what happened to a missing servant girl whom his client is accused of killing. One subplot has him investigating the prospective groom of his client's daughter, and the other has his mother investigating who is responsible for shooting at him.
All the plots were satisfying, the characterization deft, and there was plenty of dry humor, too. Bonus points for the extensive glossary...more
Aug 02, 2010
Kathleen Hagen
added it
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
2010-audio-books,
2010-mysteries
The Case of the Missing Servant, by Tarquin Hall, A-minus, narrated by Sam Bastor, produced by BBC-audio books America, downloaded from audible.com.
The publisher’s note says it as well as I could:
Meet Vish Puri, India's most private investigator. Portly, persistent and unmistakably Punjabi, he cuts a determined swathe through modern India's swindlers,
cheats and murderers. In hot and dusty Delhi, Puri's main work comes from screening prospective marriage partners, a job once the preserve of aunti...more
The publisher’s note says it as well as I could:
Meet Vish Puri, India's most private investigator. Portly, persistent and unmistakably Punjabi, he cuts a determined swathe through modern India's swindlers,
cheats and murderers. In hot and dusty Delhi, Puri's main work comes from screening prospective marriage partners, a job once the preserve of aunti...more
The Case of the Missing Servant (Simon & Schuster 2009) introduces Vish Puri, the portly Punjabi founder of Most Private Investigators Ltd., a detective agency in Delhi, India. Puri’s current case is the disappearance of a maid named Mary from the household of Ajay Kasliwal, a lawyer who targets corrupt government officials. A rumor is circulating that Kasliwal killed the maid after getting her pregnant, and Kasliwal is convince the smear campaign is retribution for his campaign against corr...more
Imagine Sherlock Holmes in modern-day India, and you've got a good feel for what this book is like. The Case of the Missing Servant is written in such a way that it was as if I was listening to the characters voices speaking (in English of course) with Indian accents. I was very impressed by this writing which was so easy to read, yet captured the grammatical idiosyncrasies of Indians speaking English.
Vish Puri is an intelligent private investigator who is famous for solving crimes, yet also doe...more
Vish Puri is an intelligent private investigator who is famous for solving crimes, yet also doe...more
Need an exotic change of pace from mysteries set in Victorian London or Nowheresville, America? Has your favorite heroine been eating too many cheeseburgers? A trip to India is just the cure! Tarquin Hall emerses the reader into the rich culture and vibrant personalities in a modern day murder mystery - India style.
The lead character runs a detective agency with stylistic nods to Agatha Cristie and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. The humor is often tongue-in-cheek, poking at the inevitable bureaucracy,...more
The lead character runs a detective agency with stylistic nods to Agatha Cristie and Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. The humor is often tongue-in-cheek, poking at the inevitable bureaucracy,...more
I picked this up with great hopes after reading To the Elephant Graveyard, but I'm afraid it didn't live up to my expectation. Vish Puri is more like Hercule Poirot than he is like Sherlock Holmes, and this first book in what is apparently going to be a series picks up on his career when he has already solved a good many mysteries. He is surrounded by a large cast of helpful family members and skillful employees, and he has already established a large collection of informers and people in high p...more
Jun 24, 2009
Richard
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
Mystery lovers; people who like strong characters, excellent dialogue and exotic settings.
Recommended to Richard by:
I read a review.
I see why Vish Puri can proclaim himself "India's most private investigator" and the reason he has won so many awards: his handling of this case is brilliant. But then, he would not hesitate to tell you all his cases are solved the same way.
The story reads much like an account by John Mortimer about Rumpole of the Bailey.
I found the account of India by Mr. Hall, who lives part time in Delhi, fascinating. If his descriptions are true, you can easily see what many of their problems are. In fact, t...more
The story reads much like an account by John Mortimer about Rumpole of the Bailey.
I found the account of India by Mr. Hall, who lives part time in Delhi, fascinating. If his descriptions are true, you can easily see what many of their problems are. In fact, t...more
I came across the second of the novels in this series, 'The Case of the Man who Died Laughing' about a year ago and enjoyed it so much that I immediately downloaded the eBook of this, the first in the series, but put it aside as a treat to be enjoyed later.
The book has all the features I enjoyed about 'The Man who Died Laughing' - likeable and well-drawn main characters and a vivid description of middle class life in modern India. The main plot is more convincing than that of 'The Man Who Died L...more
Warning: prepare plenty of snack foods before reading. This book will make you desperately hungry, as our hero Vish Puri loves to eat - so much so that his family & close friends affectionately call him Chubby! Puri is a private investigator with a storied past and, currently, a set of difficult mysteries to solve. A friend's maid has gone missing, and the friend is suspected of her murder - then Puri is shot at while tending his prized chilis on his own rooftop! All the while he is also dea...more
Sep 22, 2011
Marfita
rated it
3 of 5 stars
Recommended to Marfita by:
Goodreads automatic recommendation engine
Shelves:
mysteries
Reading about Vish Puri's huge ego in the beginning made me think I wasn't going to like this book, but by the end I was up late, heart racing, and my eyes goggling away as the Indian private detective races to save his client from ignominious murder charges. Puri is part Hercule Poirot and part "Goodness Gracious Me." He's plump, has mustaches, and is probably speaking with some cute accent. The dialog and narration are larded with vocabulary from various Indian languages/dialects. All my years...more
I've loaded my shelves with a lot of Indian detective fiction lately. There's Ray's entire set of Feluda stories with a lot of other novels. This one by Tarquin Hall was recommended by someone on Twitter and as it turns out, it isn't a bad book. I wanted to give it 2.5 stars but can't do that on Goodreads.
Tarquin's detective Vish Puri is a Delhi based punjabi detective who takes his job as seriously as he takes his chicken frankie. Tarquin has sketched Vish Puri's adventures in a bumbling, delh...more
Tarquin's detective Vish Puri is a Delhi based punjabi detective who takes his job as seriously as he takes his chicken frankie. Tarquin has sketched Vish Puri's adventures in a bumbling, delh...more
Now and again I find I like cosy type novels, they hit the spot on a busy or stressful week when other kinds of books seem to be hard going. Novels like those by Alexander McCall Smith – although it is a while since I read one, the Marriage Bureau books and the Agatha Raisin series – to name but a few. So when this novel came my way recently at a bookcrossing meet up – I was anxious to give it a go – as it looked like something I would love. I should have loved it – it has all the ingredients of...more
There is no escaping the inevitable comparisons with Precious Ramotswe and her #1 Ladies Detective Agency...Hall gives you the provincal tradition and ways of the Indian culture in much the same way that McCall brings you African culture.
Vish Puri is the gentleman PI with his crew of undercover partners - FaceCream, TubeLight and Flush...and the interfering Mummy. Puri works within a changing Indian Culture - the changing face of the caste system sets limits on the questions and avenues that can...more
Vish Puri is the gentleman PI with his crew of undercover partners - FaceCream, TubeLight and Flush...and the interfering Mummy. Puri works within a changing Indian Culture - the changing face of the caste system sets limits on the questions and avenues that can...more
You need a mystery? You do not want to tax your gray cells much? But enjoy reading and think some at the same time? The reading moves at a pace you can cope up with and not tire you?
Ok, this is the book for you. I could finish reading it in three sessions spread over 3 days, two fairly long sessions in flight. Can not say it's a literary pleasure but an enjoyable read.
Had I not known the author's name I would have thought it's written by an Indian. Tarquin Hall has really gone into details and s...more
Ok, this is the book for you. I could finish reading it in three sessions spread over 3 days, two fairly long sessions in flight. Can not say it's a literary pleasure but an enjoyable read.
Had I not known the author's name I would have thought it's written by an Indian. Tarquin Hall has really gone into details and s...more
As others have mentioned, this book is similar in some ways to the books in the No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency series, but I thought that this one was more gritty than those, too. For me this was a combination of the above mentioned series and the Cetin Ikmen series by Barbara Nadel (just not so sexed up, and less violent). This is a series that I could see myself reading more of when I'm in the mood for a mystery that's more hard-boiled than anything in the No. 1 Ladies Detective Agency books, b...more
The Case of the Missing Servant
Author: Tarquin Hall
Publisher: Random House
Price: Rs. 430/-
Let me make myself very clear at the outset. I have never been a fan of who-dun-it novels by Indian Authors. The only one that I have liked in recent times was Krishnna’s Konfession & that too I attribute to the fact that it was chick-lit cum mystery novel. My last attempt at Indian thriller (though I must accept it wasmore of a love story) was “My Friend Sancho” by Amit Verma. The book though listed Ma...more
Author: Tarquin Hall
Publisher: Random House
Price: Rs. 430/-
Let me make myself very clear at the outset. I have never been a fan of who-dun-it novels by Indian Authors. The only one that I have liked in recent times was Krishnna’s Konfession & that too I attribute to the fact that it was chick-lit cum mystery novel. My last attempt at Indian thriller (though I must accept it wasmore of a love story) was “My Friend Sancho” by Amit Verma. The book though listed Ma...more
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Discussion | 3 | 45 | Jan 30, 2013 10:35am |
Tarquin Hall is a British author and journalist who has lived and worked throughout South Asia, the Middle East and Africa. He is the author of The Case of the Missing Servant, dozens of articles, and three works of non-fiction, including the highly acclaimed Salaam Brick Lane, an account of a year spent above a Bangladeshi sweat shop in London’s notorious East End. He is married to Indian-born jo...more
More about Tarquin Hall...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...




























Jul 14, 2012 06:01pm
updated Aug 22, 2012 11:54pm