Notes from Underground; The Grand Inquisitor
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Notes from Underground; The Grand Inquisitor

4.19 of 5 stars 4.19  ·  rating details  ·  554 ratings  ·  36 reviews
Dostoevsky's NOTES FROM THE UNDERGROUND is a psychological study of the deepest darkest skeletons in the closet of the human mind. The first novel from Dostoevsky's mature "second period" works, divided in two parts, presents an unnamed protagonist, a twisted angry student, and his worldview. It is one proud man's cry for help and perverse rejection of the world around him...more
Kindle Edition
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about Notes from Underground; The Grand Inquisitor, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about Notes from Underground; The Grand Inquisitor

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 965)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Josh Karaczewski
If this was published today, "The Asshole" might be an appropriate title for its mercurial, unpleasant, unreliable narrator. Ever wonder why that guy in the office is so mean, and always revels in bringing everybody down? This book will give you some insight into what might be going on in that asshole's head. It may not help you to sympathize with him, but it could turn some of your annoyance to pity.

A demanding read that will require you to reread sections for understanding (I certainly had to)...more
Jim Elkins
Why revisit "Notes from Underground" now? First, because the psychology of the first part, in particular, is so complex that it continues to evade readers. I know I did not understand much of what the narrator was proposing when I first read “Notes from Underground” in high school or college, and I was curious how much sense it could make to me now. In particular I wondered if it could be a model for psychological complexity in contemporary fiction.

Second, it is interesting to consider a book as...more
Jonathan
Dostoevsky is a master at uncovering the depths of humanity. He does not hold back, but goes at it (humanity) with every bit of strength and affection he has (or had). To him humanity is not something to be looked down upon nor to be exalted to the place of glory.

He is satiric, playful, dark, despairing, hopeful, and everything in between. He captures life as it is and not as what some may hope it is or despair of.

Notes from Underground is an insightful and enjoyable read. He castigates those...more
Bill Viall
This is one of the true seminal books in my life, which completely altered my course. It's a remarkable work, that is a rather chilling literary prologue to the Terrible Twentieth.
Chrissie
Mostly, I just like that I read Notes from the Underground while actually underground.

Solid subway reading--easy to read in short chunks without losing the thread.
Sam Haughton
The most concise (read: shortest) display of Dostoevsky's mastery of character, mood, theme, and satire. 115 pages of pure brilliance.
Dasha Smirnova
The very essence of his philosophy and understanding of human nature.
Evelyn
Grumpy (but oh so eloquent) Russian literature doesn't exactly fit in with the usual genres of summer reading I'd go for, but I'm so glad I've finally gotten around to reading this. The bulk of this combined book is the short novel Notes From The Underground; a scathing and thoroughly miserable satire based around the memoirs of Dostoyevsky's famed anti-hero protagonist. His 'Underground Man' is the epitome of misanthropy, and has chosen to isolate himself from the rest of 19th century Russian s...more
aPriL purrs 'n hisses
Although I am a little amused at the intense emo of it all (actually Crime and Punishment shocked me especially because that was the first FD novel I read and my understanding was it was fictional autobiography and the mad wanting to run away from his human nature and all the self hatred and disgust at ordinary people, so much like being a teenager today, but by aping the supposed Superman Napoleon seemed so incredibly delusional but yet true to certain teenage boys). This novel I understand pre...more
Jeanette
"Of course, I cannot break through a wall by battering my head against it if I really do not have the strength to break through it, but I am not going to resign myself to it simply because it is a stone wall and I am not strong enough.
As though such a stone wall really were a consolation and really did contain some word of conciliation, if only because it is as true as two times two makes four. Oh, absurdity of absurdities! How much better it is to understand it all, to be conscious of it all,...more
Greg Thompson
From the beginning, Dostoevsky sucks readers into a character who seeks to justify himself with a faulty logic driven by menacing bitterness. The first half of the book is an overwhelming philosophical "writing" by the narrator. It is difficult to understand, yet what the simultaneously sucks the reader in and disgusts the reader is the bitterness driving this man. He is a complex entity, full of brokenness and loneliness, yet it is his hatred that permeates in the reader, almost infecting the r...more
john Adams
Notes From the Underground by Fyodor Dostoevsky

I don't get. Maybe it's me? Maybe I am over it? But this book, to me, was basically one man's journey into self-obsessed indulgence. Maybe that's all there is to“existentialism.” The question I have that makes me wonder if I don't get it is simply—why? Why does he have to be an self-obsessed asshole? Why can't he be a Buddhist? If the philosophy argues that all that matters is your subjectivity (granted self-obsessed asshole fits perfectly) why can'...more
John E. Branch Jr.
If you really want to be an existential anti-hero—which may not be very popular in this bright and hopeful 21st century but was an acceptable inclination for disaffected American teens in the 60s and 70s—you will have to live up to the standards set by Dostoyevsky's Underground Man.

And if you're looking for a good biting way to ridicule the cult of celebrities, pop stars, film actors, and the like, try fitting all that to the Grand Inquisitor's scheme of things, in which man requires to be led b...more
April
The chapter that the publisher cut and never made it into the book was what put this book on the all time greats in history. Its purpose was to convince the reader that the freedom to choose is worth the awful risks involved (he admits that most people will abuse it), and that Christ is the only answer when agency goes awry. Unfortunately the publisher completely altered the message of the book by cutting out the ending. I wonder what Dostoevsky's reaction was to that. I'm sure he knew that the...more
John
All I read here was notes from underground, I didn't bother with the other one. It's funny, I started reading this after finding it on my shelf where it has been since freshman year of college, when I never really read it, just skimmed it. And once I started it again, I had the exact same reaction I remember having in college. Maybe it's just this translation, but it is really hard to stay with this. Not that it isn't interesting, but my mind tends to wander and I have to force myself back to it...more
Tristan Williams
Imagine if Holden Caulfield were Russian, didn't have a family, and was a bit more off his rocker. That's Notes from Underground. The Grand Inquisitor is just a damn good excerpt from Brothers Karamazov.
Erik
Dostoevsky is such a brainiac. It's amazing to see such a mind in action. I don't know if his intent is lost in translation, but you kind of see how humans don't think like this anymore. He's just so extrapolated in his existentialist whims. The first few lines "I am a spiteful man" sucked me in, but I felt it was misleading. This book was so DRY to me. And well...that's Dostoevesky. But I felt Crime and Punishment was just an incomparably better work than Notes or the Grand Inquisitor. Haven't...more
Gary Godefroy
Compelling, thought provoking, but a chore to read. In Part 1 of 2 parts there is not a single person's name mentioned, not even the narrator. It's a self analysis of his hyper-sensitivity, hyper-insecurity, self-absorption, and self-loathing, In Part 2 his antisocial behavior is displayed in a thoroughly dysfunctional meeting with 4 childhood acquaintances and later a prostitute.
Cristal Wright
Very philosophical. The main character gives you a lot to think about. While this character has many similarities to Dostoevsky's other character in Crime and Punishment, Raskolnikov, this novel has more depth for thinking and brings the reader onto his level in order to understand the turmoil he endures by just being himself.
h
i read this book really spread out timewise because i had a hard time really getting into it, although i really enjoy dostoyevsky. intriguing and heady but not exactly a page-turner.
Philip Burnett
Read this on an attempted thru-hike of the wind rivers. When we were stuck in the tent it offered really good comic and philosophical relief to all three party members.
Jason
Oct 22, 2007 Jason is currently reading it  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: any and everyone who thinks.
i have yet to get all the way through this one. many a false start has prolonged the completion of this read. talk to ya'll later... i gotta get reading. :o/
TaleofGenji
Jan 05, 2013 TaleofGenji marked it as to-read  ·  review of another edition
I registered a book at BookCrossing.com!
http://www.BookCrossing.com/journal/11624884
Ciara
I don't know what it is -- I just can't get into the Russian classics. I thought maybe a shorter version would help, but, well, no.
Jake Gonnella
A tough book to get in to, but one that presents some great points and raw truths. Definitely worth a second or third read.
Danielle
Not my favourite of his books but still a definitive work. I am usually not so turned off by FD's characters.
Peter Holst
Notes from the Underground could be my favorite of Dost if only cuz its condensed, gets in the mind.
Paul
Only read Notes from the Underground and it was pretty incredible and surprisingly not dated all that much
Manda Keeton
Highlights humanity's absurd tendency to be despicable and irrational regardless of moral constraints.
Anna
I have read this a number of times and am always able to mine something new from the experience.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 32 33 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Brothers Karamazov (Landmarks of World Literature)
  • Cranford and Cousin Phillis
  • The Uncommercial Traveller
  • The Moneychangers
  • The Forged Coupon
  • Prisoners of Our Thoughts: Viktor Frankl's Principles for Discovering Meaning in Life and Work
  • Stray Birds
  • Parables and Paradoxes
  • Fyodor Dostoyevsky's Crime and Punishment (Monarch Notes)
  • Rigadoon
  • A Great Idea at the Time: The Rise, Fall, and Curious Afterlife of the Great Books
  • The Philosophy of Friedrich Nietzsche
  • Existentialism
  • The Silenced Majority: Stories of Uprisings, Occupations, Resistance, and Hope
  • Writing Degree Zero
  • Next Episode
  • Normal Accidents: Living with High-Risk Technologies
  • Seven Who Were Hanged
3137322
Fyodor Mikhaylovich Dostoyevsky (Russian: Фёдор Михайлович Достоевский), sometimes transliterated Dostoevsky, was a Russian novelist, journalist, and short-story writer whose psychological penetration into the human soul had a profound influence on the 20th century novel.

Dostoevsky was the second son of a former army doctor. He was educated at home and at a private school. Shortly after the death...more
More about Fyodor Dostoyevsky...
Crime and Punishment The Brothers Karamazov The Idiot Notes from Underground Demons

Share This Book

“Bana bunların imkansız olduğunu, bu derece kötü, bu derece aptal olamayacağımı söyleyecekler, biliyorum; hatta Liza'yı sevmememin, hiç olmazsa aşkını takdir etmememin mümkün olmadığını da ilave edeceklerdir muhtemelen. Halbuki neden imkansız olsun? İlkin sevmek elimden gelmezdi, çünkü bence sevmek, manevi üstünlük kurmak, zorbalık etmek anlamına gelir. Ömrüm boyunca başka türlü düşünmedim; hatta şimdi bile bazen sevginin sevdiğimizin bize gönül rızasıyla bağışladığı, kendine zorbalık etme hakkından ibaret olduğunu düşünüyorum. Yeraltı hayallerimde bile aşkı nefretle başlayan ve manevi zaferimle biten bir mücadeleden başka şekilde kuramıyordum, ama dize getirdiğim varlığı ne yapacağımı hiç bilemedim. Kadını canlandıran, onu uçurumun dibine kadar yuvarlanmaktan koruyarak yeniden doğmasını sağlayan biricik kuvvetin aşk olduğunu biliyorum, ama manevi varlığım o derece bozulmuştu ve "canlı hayattan" o kadar uzaklaşmıştım ki, demin bana "dokunaklı sözler" dinlemeye geldiğini sanıp kızı rezil etmeye kalkmamın da, dokunaklı sözler dinlemeye değil, bana olan sevgisi yüzünden geldiğini anlayamamamın da garipsenecek yanı yok bence.” 1 likes
More quotes…