Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “After the Fire, a Still Small Voice” as Want to Read:
After the Fire, a Still Small Voice
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

After the Fire, a Still Small Voice

3.58 of 5 stars 3.58  ·  rating details  ·  709 ratings  ·  134 reviews
Set in the haunting landscape of eastern Australia, this is a stunningly accomplished debut novel about the inescapable past: the ineffable ties of family, the wars fought by fathers and sons, and what goes unsaid.

After the departure of the woman he loves, Frank drives out to a shack by the ocean that he had last visited as a teenager. There, among the sugarcane and sand d
Hardcover, 304 pages
Published August 25th 2009 by Pantheon
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about After the Fire, a Still Small Voice, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about After the Fire, a Still Small Voice

The Book Thief by Markus ZusakJasper Jones by Craig SilveyPlebs by Jim GoforthThe Light Between Oceans by M.L. StedmanThe Forgotten Garden by Kate Morton
Australian recent fiction
78th out of 103 books — 52 voters
Wild by Cheryl StrayedWhere'd You Go, Bernadette by Maria SempleDare Me by Megan AbbottThe Goldfinch by Donna TarttBird by Bird by Anne Lamott
Binders Recommend
114th out of 139 books — 23 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 1,837)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Richard Reviles Censorship Always in All Ways
Women can be sexist pigs, too. Only thing is, it's okay when they're nasty, dismissive, judgmental about men. Don't believe me? Read AFTER THE FIRE, A STILL SMALL VOICE.

A thoroughly unpleasant book.
While I was reading ‘After The Fire…’, I came across this quote:

“Remember, there are two kinds of light: the steady blue flame at the heart of darkness and the false, desperate sunshine of the cheery countenance.”(1)

I’m fairly certain Evie Wyld wrote this book by the light of that steady blue flame, and not in the sunshine. It’s fairly unrelenting. I would say it’s part claustrophobia, part introspection, but mostly violence. Lots of different shades of violence.

It’s certainly an ambitious boo
Violet wells
Strange choice of subject matter for a first time young female novelist. Evie Wyld has chosen to write a novel about male worlds as rudimentary and imminently violent as the landscapes in which her novel is set. Clearly a choice that took her way outside all her comfort zones. I’m not convinced it was the right choice as, for me, she never quite appeared in command of her characters or her story. The story alternates between a father and a son. Except the father is always shown younger than the ...more
David Hebblethwaite
I’ve been meaning to read this book ever since I came across Evie Wyld’s excellent short story ‘Menzies Meat’ in the summer. In the intervening months, After the Fire, a Still Small Voice has won the John Llewellyn Rhys Prize, and received near-unanimous praise – now here’s some more.

What’s particularly striking about the novel, looking back on it as a whole, is how quiet it is; it’s probably the quietest book I’ve read all year. Its tone is quiet, its theme is quietness – the things that aren’t
Luke Devenish
There's some exquisite writing here. I envy Evie Wyld's clean, unvarnished style. Beautifully composed, with startling, vivid imagery in so many places. This book has bold ambitions, which I really liked it for. Parallel stories, separated by forty years, of a father and son - the father being younger than the son for much of the narrative. Each of the journeys is quite compelling, although Leon, the father's, story initially held me more. I really enjoyed the sections about his childhood in the ...more
May 27, 2011 Lisa rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Lisa by: Kim from Reading Matters
A most impressive debut by a very talented writer.
Evie Wyld identifies herself as English, but there is an Australian sensibility about this novel that derives from her long acquaintance with this country. It’s not just the superb evocation of our landscape, it’s also Wyld’s familiarity with the way Aussie blokes bottle up their emotions as if to let them loose is to fail a test of male identity. This is a novel about the intergenerational damage done by war, explored from that curious Australi
This was an impulse pick - I chose it for the title, and because it's set in Australia. What an incredible find! It' a first novel, described by the author herself as a "romantic thriller about men not talking". The story moves back and forth between father and son. This is a construction that in my opinion can be very confusing and interrupting, but here it really does serve to illustrate a generational legacy of sorrow and isolation. I was riveted.

This book is a small miracle, one of the best I've read in a while. It's beautifully written, subtle and powerful. It has bones and meat and blood and guts and heart and soul, not to mention a world-weary liver. Lines like this made me gasp: "A strand of hair caught in the corner of her mouth and how appalling it was that he would not be the one who was allowed to free it." The flicker of hope at the end is fragile but real. A writer to watch.
Jeanette  "Astute Crabbist"
Quite an ambitious debut novel for this Australian writer. I like her prose style and her ability to create a sense of atmosphere in the story.
Remember that old saying about the sins of the fathers being visited upon the children? I think this story shows how the wounds of the fathers are passed down to the sons through the generations.

The story is set in Australia. Chapters alternate between Frank and his father Leon, although the story covers three generations, including Leon's father as wel
Bonnie Brody
This is, by far, one of the best books I have read this year. It is written in a poetic, character driven narrative by an author who appears much wiser than her years.

The story is a multi-generational dynamic of men in a family - men who have gone to war, are prone to violence and find it hard to use words to discuss their feelings. Instead of words they use alcohol, violence and avoidance.

Leon's father is a baker in Australia who signs on to fight in the Korean War. When he returns he is not th
It must have been towards then end of last year that I first spotted After the Fire, a Still Small Voice, cover turned out on the new books shelf in the library. Such an intriguing title. Such a beautiful cover. I had to pick it up and find out more. I was intrigued and yet I didn’t bring the book home. I wasn’t sure that it was the book for me.

But then I read so much praise for both book and author that I began to wonder if I had made a mistake. And so the next time it appeared on the shelves I
I really wanted to like this book. I don't know - I don't have the greatest track record with Australia-set books. I think they lose something for me, as Australian's probably the only English dialect that I have actual trouble with. But I loved this book's title. But it didn't translated over to the love of the book. I still liked it, the prose made sure of that (and was easy to handle to an Australia-ignorant like me), but I didn't love it.

The problem is the father-son relationship as depicted
Zachary Bush
I ran across an Advanced Reader's/Reviewer's Edition of this book for $1.00 outside of The Strand and was initially taken with the title. Thought, what could I lose? ...nothing. This debut novel was hauntingly stunning; an absolute pleasure to read. Wylde's got guts. She has command of character conflict, detail, pacing, and dialogue. She knows how to lure the reader in ( shockingly believable through male perspectives), grab him by the throat and hold on until she's ready to let go. She had me. ...more
Partly to try and offset the impact of some reviews I just don't understand, I'm going to review this book now.

It's. Really. Friggin. Good.

Honestly, if you like books that take you away from yourself, if you enjoy Peter Carey, Tim Winton, John McGahern, Richard Powers, books where landscape and place are another character, where human beings live the same messy lives we all do then please give this book a try. The last fifty pages had me completely compelled, turning pages as quickly as I coul
In a word, awful. This has to have been one of the worst books I have ever read. I kept reading, thinking there would be some huge climax or reveal at the end, and it was nothing. How this book has a 4.0 rating is beyond me, although only 16 people have read it at this point. They must be really deep. A shallow person like myself, I can hardly wait to move on to something with a plot or at least a point.
Shivanee Ramlochan
Excerpted from the full review:

"Frank Collard turns to the wild, and his grandparents’ rustic outpost in the swamplands, when an abusively disastrous relationship shatters his heart. Lonely, he gradually inches away from being corralled by the teeming landscape that surrounds his shack, to becoming a part of it, blending gracelessly and gruffly into the local milieu. Though he adapts the semblance of a normal life, rooted in work and earnest, albeit thorny, social interaction, he shares little o
Present day... Frank has left Sydney for small-town Queensland.
A generation ago... Leon leaves Sydney after being conscripted to fight in Vietnam.

After the Fire tells the story of these two men. Chapter 1 Frank, Chapter 2 Leon, Chapter 3 Frank, Chapter 4 Leon, Chapter 5 Frank.... oh, you get the drift. The format is reassuringly consistent.

Let me start with the good stuff, the reasons I've given this book 3 stars. First and foremost, the writing is beautiful - there's a good reason that this ha
Frank has returned to his childhood playground, a beach cottage near Queensland, to sort out his life after a devastating breakup, a relationship that inevitably ended when he became physically violent with his girlfriend. He loathes what he did, and runs to hide in a place that he thinks will comfort him. Once there, memories begin to eat at him, becoming so real that he turns his head and alerts to their arrival.

He can’t relate to his new violent streak, and tries to analyze what has happened
Our Library Mornington
If you enjoy literary Australian fiction, then give this one a try. It is an impressive debut novel from author, Evie Wyld, who tackles the subject of father and son relationships. This compelling story centres upon a rundown shack in the sugar cane regions of Eastern Australia. Frank, his father and his grandfather have each retreated separately to the shack at some point in their lives. The building has been a haven for the men from the Korean and Vietnam Wars. Now Frank has retreated from the ...more
Alice Meloy
I can't believe a story this good and this well-written didn't make it to the Man Booker long list. Two apparently separate story lines gradually converge in a tough and gritty tale of the legacies of war in an Australian family. Leon's father never recovered from his Korean War experience, presaging Leon's own struggles after fighting in the Vietnam War. In an alternating story line that takes place in the very recent past, Frank attempts to find himself and start a new life in his grandparents ...more
Debut author Wyld's After the Fire, a Still Small Voice is a quietly raging novel, full of hurt that lasts across generations. It is also intensely beautiful to read, with vivid descriptions that help to create a tone of isolation despite the numerous characters. Set in Australia, the novel follows two Collard men: Leon (the father) and Frank (the son) as each tries to reconcile his existence in the face of some form of abandonment. Frank is deeply affected by the actions and experiences of his ...more
I got so tired of the descriptive language in this book (particularly about the drunken binges, violence and urination) that I literally missed the glimmer of hope at the end of it. Thank heaven for book club. The writing itself is good, and the author uses symbolism deftly and without hitting you over the head with its meaning. Occasionally I found that she used it too subtly and I was left wondering about her meaning. It's often described as a "quiet" book, and I found it more unsettling than ...more
I picked this up because I recognised the author's name from a list of best young authors, and based on this book, she is certainly one to watch. (She has also inspired fans of this book to write some rather beautiful reviews!)

I feel rather mean only giving it 3 stars, but I think that's because I didn't ever really get truly emotionally involved in the story so couldn't quite give it 4 (my fault - because of outside factors distracting me I should have gone for something lighter and saved this
I did not like this book. Too many times, the smell of urine was mentioned, and soon it was all I could think about. Nobody likes that smell, so constantly mentioning it is irritating and moot. I do not recommend this book. Turgenev is Turgenev, and this is not.
This one falls kind of squarely in the "good enough" category for me. As a reading experience it had enough action to pull you steadily forward through the book and some moments of brilliance, especially in description. It was an impressively male book to have been written by a woman- all of the main characters are male, their major conflicts revolve around the very male occupations of war and violence and all of that was executed believably enough that I think the book would read identically if ...more
I learned that I enjoy reading very well written books set in Australia.

I learned what it was like for Australian soldiers in the Vietnam War.

I learned that it's a nice feeling when you don't want a book to end.

What dates did you read the novel? From Dept.22 to Sept.25
b. What do you think the overall theme, or universal message, of the novel is? Why?
Its about love stories because there is a price to be paid for love and this novel takes us on this journey.
c. Choose a significant quote from the novel and describe its significance.
"Remember there are two kinds of light:the steady blue flame at the heart of darkness and the false, desperate sunshine of the cherry countenance. This could mean you have t
I was surprised to see the number of negative reviews this has received on here. My guess is that people were expecting or desiring something upbeat and heartwarming but disappointed when they got something that was not. This book treads into dark subjects: war, abuse, family dysfunction, to name a few. I understand that these are challenging topics, but I feel more readers would appreciate this novel if they were more willing to step out of their comfort zone or realize their discomfort is the ...more
loved this very Australian book about two different men, their trials and tribulations and a special place
Steve lovell
Women. Will they ever be understood by the male of the species? They're mysterious, beguiling creatures – so easy to love, with most of my gender in complete inadequacy when coming to grips with their feminine psyche – with this only adding to their allure. I am permanently in thrall of the women in my world. I find them easier to talk to than most men as they have endless topics of conversation, not just footy, cricket and when at a loss, the weather. I love being in their company. My own speci ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 61 62 next »
topics  posts  views  last activity   
THE LISTS: Novel Updates 11 24 Dec 01, 2011 07:11PM  
  • The Great World
  • Snapped
  • Little Gods
  • Fireflies
  • Cropper's Cabin
  • The Favorites
  • Lying With the Dead
  • Alexandra, Gone
  • Hunter's Moon
  • The Body of Jonah Boyd
  • Almost Dead
  • Samurai (Simon St George #2)
  • The Book Of Fathers
  • An Unfinished Score
  • Carpentaria
  • Shadows in the Twilight
  • Riders in the Chariot
  • The Professor of Truth

Share This Book