Letters to Malcolm: Chiefly on Prayer
by
C.S. Lewis
C.S. Lewis meditates on many puzzling questions concerning the intimate dialogue between man and God. He goes on to consider the practical and metaphysical aspects of private prayer, such as when to pray and where; the content of prayer.
Hardcover, 124 pages
Published
1964
by Harcourt, Brace & World, Inc.
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,260)
Not Lewis at his best. The excuse could be made that, as a posthumous book, it may not have been quite ready for publication. The Discarded Image: An Introduction to Medieval and Renaissance Literature was also published after Lewis, but (despite being non-fiction) is just short of amazing.
The format is much like The Screwtape Letters: one side of an exchange of letters, this one supposedly with C. S. Lewis with an old friend Malcolm. Most, but not all, time references seem to date it to the las...more
The format is much like The Screwtape Letters: one side of an exchange of letters, this one supposedly with C. S. Lewis with an old friend Malcolm. Most, but not all, time references seem to date it to the las...more
A collection of letters that C.S. Lewis wrote to a friend called Malcolm (and I can't tell you who this Malcolm is because I have not bothered to research much beyond this) and the main topic of discussion is prayer, specifically private prayer. Lewis chooses not to speak about corporate prayer because in his words 'he knows very little about it'. It is a shame that in my edition we do not have Malcolm's letters because it would have been good to actually get both sides of the conversation, part...more
To fully appreciate this, one has to recognize what Jack is trying to do; or not trying to do. He is not trying to tell you what is correct or proper, or even what you should believe. He is only explaining what he tends to think regarding certain doctrines or aspects of the faith. This is in no way written to flaunt his beliefs as superior to others or even to name them as most right. I actually found myself disagreeing with a multitude of his ideas, not in a "kill-the-heretic" kind of way, more...more
This is not your traditional C.S. Lewis book. It's not really theological in the sense of his other writings like Mere Christianity or the Four Loves. And so, it is simply a collection of letters which Lewis writes to his friend Malcolm. In this exchange of friendly letters, I often felt like a third wheel, trying to listen to that secret language that is only known by such an intimate relationship.
Moreover, some of his conclusions are troubling, especially in regards to Purgatory and prayers fo...more
Moreover, some of his conclusions are troubling, especially in regards to Purgatory and prayers fo...more
After spending several hours of my life reading about the subject, I have come to the conclusion that Prayer is something better discussed than taught. In fact, I will go so far as to say that most "instructional" books on the topic may do the reader more harm than good. They either box the reader in with formulas, often on only one type of prayer, so that when the prayer is successful (whatever that means) a cult member is created, and when unsuccessful (which usually means they didn't get some...more
This was a tough read for me for some reason. It takes the form of a series of letters from Lewis to a close friend named Malcolm. As an Inklings fan, I spent a good part of the book wondering which of the Inklings Jack was writing to. I confess to being somewhat annoyed when I learned that Malcolm was an imaginary construct, devised to make the subjects Lewis was tackling easier for him to write about.
This bit of literary deception aside, "Malcolm" gives some great insights into prayer, includi...more
This bit of literary deception aside, "Malcolm" gives some great insights into prayer, includi...more
Mar 16, 2012
Timothy Darling
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
intelligent mature christians
I always come away from Professor Lewis the same way. It is often a chore. I cannot catch up, and I wonder where my education went wrong. If I were to write a book that said some of the things Lewis said, I would certainly be castigated as a heretic by my peers. Perhaps that is the advantage of being a literary theologian instead of clergy, what difference does it make if a critic is a heretic, as long as he isn't saying from the pulpit?
But, of course, Lewis isn't a heretic. He launches out from...more
But, of course, Lewis isn't a heretic. He launches out from...more
Spectacular and beautiful. CS Lewis' earlier books were very well written and (in my personal opinion) rather well argued. This is not an "argued" book, though; the subtitle "reflections" is a more apt description. That's not to say Lewis fails to present good arguments for his ideas, but the matter of the book is more of a 'search' than of a 'telling.' Especially towards the end, Lewis shows how much he has learned through his life on how to describe the beauty that we see beyond the physicalit...more
I read this at 3 different points in the last year, so my thoughts are a bit scattered.
Lewis delves into the psychology, theology and practice of prayer. He is honest about its "irksome"ness. He deals not only with personal prayer but our interaction with the supernatural, generally. How do we take delight in God, in the sunshine? How do we do good things (like prayer) when sin weighs us down and they feel like duty, instead?
This book is famous for Lewis' purgatory error. He says it's a necessit...more
Lewis delves into the psychology, theology and practice of prayer. He is honest about its "irksome"ness. He deals not only with personal prayer but our interaction with the supernatural, generally. How do we take delight in God, in the sunshine? How do we do good things (like prayer) when sin weighs us down and they feel like duty, instead?
This book is famous for Lewis' purgatory error. He says it's a necessit...more
Short review: Such a good short book. Collections of letters can be so good or so bad. This is on the good side. We only read Lewis' letters (Malcolm's are not presented) but the flow is still natural. It is an intimate portrait and one where we can see Lewis working out ideas, not just showing us the final product. I will read this again. It is too rich to not pick up again. I listened to it, so I will pick it up on paper or kindle later. As ridiculous as it often is, the Kindle version is more...more
Written Screwtape-style with only one side of the correspondence presented. This is a profound inquiry into what constitutes worship and prayer. My favorite line, frequently quoted, is a caution to the church's haste to "relevant" and attractive to outsiders, "It looks as if they believed people can lured to go to church by incessant brightenings, lengthenings, abridgements, simplifications amd complications of the service."
The debate is whether there really was a "Malcolm" or is he a device of...more
The debate is whether there really was a "Malcolm" or is he a device of...more
I listened to this on audiobook and so there were frequent interruptions. Nevertheless, out of the 15 CS Lewis books I've read, this is probably my least favorite. The book primarily consists of speculations and musing on prayer with very few conclusions. I certainly differer from Lewis on praying for the dead and the existence of purgatory both of which he referenced but chose not to defend.
As anything written by Lewis does, the book contains flashes of brilliance and a heap of great one-liners...more
As anything written by Lewis does, the book contains flashes of brilliance and a heap of great one-liners...more
I love CS Lewis. But not this book. Perhaps it was the first chapter. I simply found myself disagreeing with him so often regarding my experience of worship and prayer, that it hard to read the rest of the book with an open mind. I was looking for points of disagreement, not revelation. So it's probably my error in reading, rather than his in writing. Or perhaps it's because any book on prayer written as a dialogue with another person is doomed to fail. Learning the art of sculpture from the con...more
What I found so interesting about Letters to Malcolm is that Lewis wrote this fictional exchange between himself and his friend as a way of avoiding writing a book on prayer, which he’d been urged to do but felt vastly unqualified to do. It was a thought provoking exchange, and for me, not a quick read. As per usual when I read Lewis, I needed to read, step back, and chew on it for a few days before I could move on.
According to www.cslewis.org, “Letters to Malcolm was the final book Lewis wrote,...more
According to www.cslewis.org, “Letters to Malcolm was the final book Lewis wrote,...more
Unsurprisingly (but always astonishingly), C.S. Lewis's "Letters to Malcolm" is a life-altering look at our prayer lives. Though Lewis does admit that the book is "exaggerated," even almost a "lie," because of its treatment of prayer so separate from the rest of daily life, the book (written in the form of correspondence between Lewis and his friend) achieves its purpose: it provokes deep thought, intense prayer and serious introspection. It also encourages a lovely view of everyday miracles; th...more
This book is not one of the books that C.S. Lewis is widely known for writing, and it is likely due to the fact that this book is unlike most of C.S. Lewis' other books: It is technically a work of fiction, but feels like an anthology of disconnected letters that muse on the theology of the church and of prayer. A cursory glance of some of the other reviewers tells me that many people seem to have expected the work to be a sort of theology of prayer, only to find that it is nothing more than an...more
I am very, very curious about this one. I have so many questions and confusions about prayer, with the result being that I don't feel very good at it and I hate volunteering/being volunteered to pray...
Not that I think Lewis will clear up all of my misconceptions with this book, but I'd really love to get some clarification here. What exactly is prayer? Why should we do it? If we're praying for God's will to happen, why in the world should we pray anyway? Can God's will be thwarted? When I ask f...more
Not that I think Lewis will clear up all of my misconceptions with this book, but I'd really love to get some clarification here. What exactly is prayer? Why should we do it? If we're praying for God's will to happen, why in the world should we pray anyway? Can God's will be thwarted? When I ask f...more
Jul 26, 2008
Richard Piet
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
non-fiction,
religion
Prayer is relational. It is a conversation between two people. Letters to Malcolm is a conversation about prayer. C. S. Lewis uses the premise of two friends corresponding between one and another as a basis to discuss prayer with his readers. In a friendly, familiar style, the letters explore how and when to pray. It is as if the reader is eavesdropping on a friendship. Through this style, Lewis lays out his opinion on what he thinks are God’s expectations on us while we pray. He moves from sim...more
Some quotes I liked:
"A clergyman once said to me that a railway compartment, if one has it to oneself, is an extremely good place to pray in 'because there is just the right amount of distraction.'" (p. 18)
"Have we any reason to suppose that total self-knowledge, if it were given to us, would be for our good? Children and fools, we are told, should never look at half-done work; and we are not yet, I trust, even half-done. You and I wouldn't, at all stages, think it wise to tell a pupil exactly w...more
"A clergyman once said to me that a railway compartment, if one has it to oneself, is an extremely good place to pray in 'because there is just the right amount of distraction.'" (p. 18)
"Have we any reason to suppose that total self-knowledge, if it were given to us, would be for our good? Children and fools, we are told, should never look at half-done work; and we are not yet, I trust, even half-done. You and I wouldn't, at all stages, think it wise to tell a pupil exactly w...more
I have read and re-read this book, and I love something new in it each time.
A few marked lines, starting at the beginning, so weighted toward the literal beginning of the book:
Nothing makes an absent friend so present as a disagreement.
The perfect church service would be one we were almost unaware of; our attention would have been on God.
Any tendency to a passionate preference for one type of service must be regarded simply as temptation.
To forgive for the moment is not difficult. But to go on...more
A few marked lines, starting at the beginning, so weighted toward the literal beginning of the book:
Nothing makes an absent friend so present as a disagreement.
The perfect church service would be one we were almost unaware of; our attention would have been on God.
Any tendency to a passionate preference for one type of service must be regarded simply as temptation.
To forgive for the moment is not difficult. But to go on...more
Nov 13, 2012
Sally
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
theology-ministry-church,
non-fiction
Started this a while ago, but just finished today. This book's thoughts, for me, fall into three categories: "Yes! You said that so well!" or "Mmmm, not sure about that!" or "Huh?! Maybe I'll understand this on my next reading of it." Overall, I highly recommend this book as an instrument to clarify one's own thoughts about prayer. Lewis covers many aspects of it, including who we pray for, the difficulties of prayer, methods of prayer, etc.
I'm only one chapter into it and I already have laughed out loud and nodded my head at his apt points. Lewis is a gifted theologian and I am glad that this book is the topic of our Sunday school class.
Just finished this book and all I have to say is WOW. It is a VERY dense theological book. Many times I had to go back and re-read a few chapters just to catch some of what Lewis was saying. This book is a keeper, if only for the fact that when I read it again, I'm going to catch more of what I mis...more
Just finished this book and all I have to say is WOW. It is a VERY dense theological book. Many times I had to go back and re-read a few chapters just to catch some of what Lewis was saying. This book is a keeper, if only for the fact that when I read it again, I'm going to catch more of what I mis...more
Thought provoking but I presume a fictional correspondence between Lewis and a certain Malcom. The two do not agree on how prayer works or how it is supposed to be done. Not even on the outcome or anything at all.
Where it becomes interesting though is in both their struggles with prayer and when one of the two has quite grief to deal with. Then the differences are laid aside comfort is given to the other
Where it becomes interesting though is in both their struggles with prayer and when one of the two has quite grief to deal with. Then the differences are laid aside comfort is given to the other
Consistent with Lewis' other writings, this book is replete with wit and charm and sharp logical arguments. In form epistolary, comprising one-half of a written dialogue written sometime after Joy Davidman's death, this book gives an intimate view of Lewis' personal thoughts and perspectives on prayer and a variety of other topics. Enjoyable and lucid, if books on prayer are your cup of tea.
Presenting his thoughts in the form of personal letters, Lewis makes use of a warm, simple style that allows him to deal with some rather thorny theological issues in a manner that even a casual reader would not find off-putting. Although I never agree with Lewis 100% in all areas, he never fails to spark my spiritual imagination with his decidedly Romantic literary approach.
Apr 27, 2010
Amelia, the pragmatic idealist
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
religion-theology,
required-reading
Favorite quote: "Joy is the serious business of Heaven"
:)
This one is in letter format, kind of like THE SCREWTAPE LETTERS, only this book isn't written by a chief demon. Actually it's written to an imaginary person named Malcolm and in it, Lewis focuses on different Christian aspects of prayer. I liked it...better than THE FOUR LOVES anyway
:)
This one is in letter format, kind of like THE SCREWTAPE LETTERS, only this book isn't written by a chief demon. Actually it's written to an imaginary person named Malcolm and in it, Lewis focuses on different Christian aspects of prayer. I liked it...better than THE FOUR LOVES anyway
Jan 03, 2013
Tim Woody
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
practical,
theological
"I am often praying for others when I should be doing things for them. It's so much easier to pray for a bore than to go and see him." -C.S Lewis
This collection of letters to C.S. Lewis's friend Malcolm provided reflection on ideas of prayer in a way only C.S Lewis can do. His wit, and anecdotes always give just the right angle that leaves you with a glimmer of his mind. This book is an enjoyable read! Exhorting you to pray more and enjoy God in it. He also writes about how he sees himself appro...more
This collection of letters to C.S. Lewis's friend Malcolm provided reflection on ideas of prayer in a way only C.S Lewis can do. His wit, and anecdotes always give just the right angle that leaves you with a glimmer of his mind. This book is an enjoyable read! Exhorting you to pray more and enjoy God in it. He also writes about how he sees himself appro...more
Strange as it is to say, this is probably my least favorite of Lewis' "theological" books. There are chapters of it that were breathtakingly wonderful, but others weren't quite as incredible as one would expect. Of course, Lewis was merely writing about prayer, and a lot of other things, as a correspondence between himself and a fictitious person named Malcolm, so he is not attempting to teach, in an authoritative sense, about prayer. Other people, and many notable Lewis scholars, absolutely lov...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
CLIVE STAPLES LEWIS (1898–1963) was one of the intellectual giants of the twentieth century and arguably one of the most influential writers of his day. He was a Fellow and Tutor in English Literature at Oxford University until 1954, when he was unanimously elected to the Chair of Medieval and Renaissance Literature at Cambridge University, a position he held until his retirement. He wrote more th...more
More about C.S. Lewis...
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“Relying on God has to begin all over again every day as if nothing had yet been done.”
—
340 people liked it
“Some people feel guilty about their anxieties and regard them as a defect of faith. I don't agree at all. They are afflictions, not sins. Like all afflictions, they are, if we can so take them, our share in the Passion of Christ”
—
50 people liked it
More quotes…


















