Cows, Pigs, Wars, and Witches: The Riddles of Culture
This book challenges those who argue that we can change the world by changing the way people think. Harris shows that no matter how bizarre a people's behavior may seem, it always stems from concrete social and economic conditions.
Paperback, 288 pages
Published
December 17th 1989
by Vintage
(first published December 1st 1974)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
2,035)
Why do Jews and Muslims refuse to eat pork? Why were thousands of witches burned at the stake during late medieval Europe? These and other riddles are explored by famous anthropologist Marvin Harris, and his conclusions are simple: people act within social and ecological contexts that make their actions meaningful. Put another way: cultural ideas and practices that seem strange to us may actually be vital and necessary to the people of those cultures.
Harris is especially good at explaining how s...more
Harris is especially good at explaining how s...more
Today, while lamenting the sidelining of fiction in favor of informational texts to the exclusion of just about anything else in English classes with a friend, I mentioned that no one had ever learned to love to read by reading a textbook. However, I had to immediately correct myself by adding "except for Cows, Pigs, Wars and Witches and The Day the Universe Changed: How Galileo's Telescope Changed the Truth."
I read Marvin Harris' scintillating book in 1978. Although an accessible paperback desi...more
I read Marvin Harris' scintillating book in 1978. Although an accessible paperback desi...more
May 23, 2011
ryeginald
rated it
4 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
anyone as fascinated with human behavior as I am
Shelves:
non-fiction,
favorites
Unexpectedly turned out to be one of the most though-provoking and fascinating cultural studies I've ever read. Everyone should have a few horizon-wideners on their book list -- this should be one of them.
Civilizations, even the most advanced among them, are invariably strewn with mythologies, folklore, and recherche taboo. While the contemporary United States would itself provide enough material for a multi-volume study of this kind, Marvin Harris focuses mostly on pre-scientific and pre-literate peoples to answer questions like: Why do Hindus not eat cows, while Jews avoid pork instead? How do you explain the concept of the Messiah? Why was the belief in witches in medieval Europe so prevalent,...more
Marvin Harris intends to apply scientific theory to some of the great cultural riddles of the world. Why do Hindus love cows? Why do Jews hate pigs? Unfortunately, like an evolutionary biologist trying to explain why humans have pinky toes, he comes across as making up just-so stories. The theories are plausible, but that doesn't make them accurate. The truth in a just-so story is always in what it tells us about the storyteller. In this case, he's a 1970s academic.
One more thing: Since I'm not...more
One more thing: Since I'm not...more
This book is required reading for my Political Science 101 class, and for once a professor has managed to select an interesting book.
This is an interesting look at some of the cultural riddles that tend to mystify Westerners - like Cow Love in India, Pig Hate in the Middle East, Cargo Cults, etc. Harris explains how these seemingly ridiculous (to us) behaviors are actually perfectly sensible and successful adaption strategies. A short and pleasant read, well researched and written. I highly rec...more
This is an interesting look at some of the cultural riddles that tend to mystify Westerners - like Cow Love in India, Pig Hate in the Middle East, Cargo Cults, etc. Harris explains how these seemingly ridiculous (to us) behaviors are actually perfectly sensible and successful adaption strategies. A short and pleasant read, well researched and written. I highly rec...more
Cows are inefficiently raised and devoured in the United States, while in India, people would rather go hungry than eat cow flesh. In the Jewish and Moslem tradition, pigs are unclean and cannot be consumed; while in others, gargantuan pig feasts are more holy than the Thanksgiving turkey. Is this just part of the inexplicable side of human nature, or are there understandable reasons for these cultural curiosities? Harris shows that these bizarre displays of cultural variety play an important an...more
I picked this up again last week and enjoyed it greatly. Harris does great job of describing the material bases for numerous cultural phenomena, beginning with the sacred cows of Hinduism, and moving on through the roots of the worship and hatred of pigs, messianic military leadership and Christianity, to witchcraft, anti-witch pogroms, and the counter-culture. Something I really enjoyed about Harris' voice in this book is the sense of barely contained anger that imbues it.
The main thing Harris...more
The main thing Harris...more
Una de las cosas buenas que tiene que Criptonomicón se publicase en 3 partes es que pude hacer un intermedio y leer este magnífico ensayo entre las partes 2 y 3.
Como ya he dicho, este libro me parece genial, y le doy 5 estrellas (de lo mejor que leí en 2005). Puedo decir que me transformó y que me hizo interesarme por la antropología y plantearme la historia y la imagen que tenemos de las distintas culturas de una forma completamente distinta a como veía el mundo antes de leer este libro.
Si de
...more
Este libro se escribió en 1974 y hay que leerlo teniendo eso en mente, ya que no descubre nada nuevo para quien se haya asomado ligeramente a los estudios antropológicos actuales. Es un pionero en las teorías de adaptación.
Teniendo eso en cuenta, Harris describe de forma amena (salvo algunos momentos del culto al cerdo y de los Potlatch que se me han hecho pesados y repetitivos)sus teorías, entonces muy novedosas, sobre el recurso de las sociedades a elementos sobrenaturales como elementos adapt...more
Teniendo eso en cuenta, Harris describe de forma amena (salvo algunos momentos del culto al cerdo y de los Potlatch que se me han hecho pesados y repetitivos)sus teorías, entonces muy novedosas, sobre el recurso de las sociedades a elementos sobrenaturales como elementos adapt...more
I enjoyed reading this book because I enjoy the study of societies and cultures. I found it the easiest read of any sociological book yet. It took me about 3 days to read it. It reads almost like a fiction book. He has some very interesting theories about why people do certain things in certain cultures. Actually it's pretty much one theory: They develop...or create...these cultural rules, deities, etc. to balance out the economic ecosystem of a society. It is a good theory but a somewhat oversi...more
Harris, an anthropologist, takes the most extreme forms of human behavior and belief and tries to explain them in practical terms, ecologically, historically, economically. Fascinating and insightful.
The chapter on Cargo cults made me extremely interested in the following chapter on messianism; cargo isn't just LIKE messianism, it is a form of it. Unfortunately, my trust in him was shaken when I found his research on messiah theology and history to be completely shoddy. For example, he writes th...more
The chapter on Cargo cults made me extremely interested in the following chapter on messianism; cargo isn't just LIKE messianism, it is a form of it. Unfortunately, my trust in him was shaken when I found his research on messiah theology and history to be completely shoddy. For example, he writes th...more
Mar 22, 2012
Fox
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
2012,
history,
native-american,
non-fiction,
own,
philosophy,
politics,
religion,
sociology,
science,
anthropology
What an entertaining book. While I don't agree with all of Marvin Harris' conclusions, I can say that the scientific way that he approaches problems typically viewed only in a just-so light was both informative and fascinating. His precise evaluation of each question was both thorough and scientific and offers much to anyone fascinated in anthropological (or even political) theory.
While the author is very much the product of the time in which the book was written (the 1970's) the methods that ma...more
While the author is very much the product of the time in which the book was written (the 1970's) the methods that ma...more
The first couple of chapters were mild-blowingly good. I thought Harris' explanations of foods that are taboo or vaunted and how those roles are not only logical, but dictated by the socioenvironmental setting in which they originate fascinating. He treats cultural norms as almost the results of Darwinian processes, which is a fascinating and really revolutionary approach. I was awed both by his treatment of rules that are second nature to me, like Jewish dietary laws, as well as those that were...more
Cultural materialism, the theory named and used by Marvin Harris is probably my favorite theoretical mechanism within Anthropology. I first encountered in as an undergraduate and have since then fallen to its whims. This book, turns out does not do a very good job explaining or introducing this theory. Instead, this book, as it was written, is a very basic introduction to the world of Marvin Harris and his arguments on the existence of four major concepts within cultural materialism: cows, pigs,...more
This is a fascinating book about anthropology. The book literally is about cows, pigs, wars, and witches, but what this plain title can't convey is how this book is packed with riveting explanations of the mysteries of cultural attitudes toward these four things, or how profoundly relevant solving these mysteries are for understanding our own culture.
Why do Indians worship cows? Many Indians don't even know, but after reading this book's explanation, you'll understand all the historical and econ...more
Why do Indians worship cows? Many Indians don't even know, but after reading this book's explanation, you'll understand all the historical and econ...more
At the end of the book, Harris writes that he likes to "de-mystify the world's mysteries," and that is precisely what he sets out to do and what I love about this book.
While other books by Harris might be more educational on a "world history" scale, this book investigates cultural-religious institutions and beliefs that are certainly relevant and educational. Harris doesn't really care what people and cultures believe, but instead he tries to explain why they believe what they do. He does this f...more
While other books by Harris might be more educational on a "world history" scale, this book investigates cultural-religious institutions and beliefs that are certainly relevant and educational. Harris doesn't really care what people and cultures believe, but instead he tries to explain why they believe what they do. He does this f...more
Harris attempts to solve an interesting series of anthropological puzzles including witches, food superstitions, primitive warfare and whether or not the historical Jesus was a militant rather than a prince of peace. I recommend the book with two provisos. The validity of the research on the Yanomamo people cited in the savage male chapter has since been strongly questioned and his comments on our counter-culture now seem quite dated.
I had just moved to Eugene when I bought this book at the University Bookstore. I had moved into a house, with my three cats and not much else. I didn't own a bed or even a lamp, but I had money to go buy books, and this was one of the first ones I bought. So I sat in the backyard during daylight hours and read . . .this was a great little book, full of fascinating facts about different foods in different cultures - like a trivia book about food around the world, but well written. This is also a...more
Harris is an "Anthropologist" and uses judgmental words such as bizarre and maniacal in the same sentence. My problem with the book is not the inferences made about certain practices, but the way in which they are discussed. It saddens me to see someone supposedly dedicated to the study of culture discuss in such a negative manner.
This book explores human behaviour and how seemingly bizarre practices may stem from social and economic conditions. Harris explores interesting behaviour such as burning withers, ‘Cargo Cult’ and other social phenomena. This book is thought provoking and fascinating, read it and make up your own mind on social theory.
Oct 03, 2010
Sonia Lowrie
added it
this is one of my favorite books of all times, i bought it and loaned it so someone and i had to buy a new copy, and i loaned this one too and now i have to buy another copy. It really breaks down all the mythes of religions and witchcrafts. Highly recommended.
My favorite chapters were the final chapters dealing with witches and messiahs. It is important to remember the lengths the ruling classes have underwent throughout history to pit the proletariat classes against each other and, as a result, take the attention away from aristocratic and ruling classes. It is a good way to reflect on how this is happening today.
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
American anthropologist Marvin Harris was born in Brooklyn, New York. A prolific writer, he was highly influential in the development of cultural materialism. In his work he combined Karl Marx's emphasis on the forces of production with Malthus's insights on the impact of demographic factors on other parts of the sociocultural system. Labeling demographic and production factors as infrastructure,...more
More about Marvin Harris...
Share This Book
“Counter-culture celebrates the supposedly natural life of primitive peoples. Its members wear beads, headbands, body paint, and colorful tattered clothing; they yearn to be a tribe. They seem to believe that tribal peoples are nonmaterialistic, spontaneous, and reverently in touch with occult sources of enchantment...”
—
1 person liked it
More quotes…

Loading...










view all 3 comments























