Intervention (Jack Stapleton & Laurie Montgomery #9)
by
Robin Cook
New York Times-bestselling author Robin Cook returns with another ripped-from-the-headlines medical thriller, where DNA science, biotechnology, and religion collide.
I t's been more than thirty years since New York City medical examiner Jack Stapleton's college graduation and almost as long since he'd been in touch with former classmates Shawn Doherty and Kevin Murray. Once...more
I t's been more than thirty years since New York City medical examiner Jack Stapleton's college graduation and almost as long since he'd been in touch with former classmates Shawn Doherty and Kevin Murray. Once...more
Hardcover, 448 pages
Published
August 4th 2009
by Putnam Adult
There is a good chance some of your friends read this book. Sign in to see!
sign in »
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
This book is currently not featured on any Listopia lists.
Add this book to your favorite list »
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,379)
Deborah Bobo
added it
Intervention begins with two seemingly barely connected stories. Jack Stapleton works for the city morgue in New York City. Shawn Doherty is a renowned biblical archeologist who is visiting the Middle East with his wife when he discovers a codex that sheds light on the burial of the Virgin Mary. The story flips back and forth between Jack’s work and difficult personal life (he has an infant with neuroblastoma) and Shawn’s discovery and quest for the ossuary that allegedly holds the bones of the ...more
You would have had to pry this book out of my cold, dead hands. I would have saved it from a burning house to finish it. I last read a Robin Cook novel in the '80s. Now, I will read every one, but this will be my last review, just like I'm not writing a review of all the Ludlums or Stephen Kings I've read. Everyone's read them and everyone says the same things, right? But this was SO-O-O-O-O GOOD. The protagonists are a Medical Examiner who tries to occupy his mind with an investigation and expo...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Not having read a Cook novel before and having some liking for novels that include science or medicine in them, I found at the end that I could only award "Intervention" one star. Yes, could say in a word, disappointed.
The novel begins well with the story of Jack Stapleton in New York and his work as a M.E., his homelife concerning the dire illness of his infant son, and on to his investigations into deaths that involve alternate medicine.
I felt that the novel was ...more
The novel begins well with the story of Jack Stapleton in New York and his work as a M.E., his homelife concerning the dire illness of his infant son, and on to his investigations into deaths that involve alternate medicine.
I felt that the novel was ...more
Don't "they" still tell writers to write what they know? Dr. Robin Cook is excellent at plaques and sudden death from toxic creatures. He is out of his element here. It could be a good story, or even a good movie, but it would need a serious rewrite. While I don't like his work, Dan Brown did it better.
Three roommates from Amherst College have done well: Archbishop of New York, Chief Medical Examiner for the City of New York and archaeologist as head of the department of N...more
Three roommates from Amherst College have done well: Archbishop of New York, Chief Medical Examiner for the City of New York and archaeologist as head of the department of N...more
Intervention starts out like a typical Robin Cook medical thriller, but never quite makes it there. The little medical thriller that is in the book quickly gets shoved aside in favor of Cook trying his hand at writing a Dan Brown type thriller. Cook's faux Brown plot line, which involves an ossuary supposedly containing the bones of the Virgin Mary, long buried beneath Saint Peter's and excavated in the middle of the night by a renegade and ambitious archeologist, is, like many of Robin Cook's p...more
3 for idea; 2 for execution; 1 for ending; , September 22, 2009
First things first -- this is NOT a medical thriller. This is a combination of anti-alternative medicine rant and a diatribe against Christian zealotry -- or, even worse, a conspiracy story of mediocre proportion.
There are two things going on in this novel: the original plot line of Jack investigating an untimely death caused by chiropractic cervical manipulation (producing VAD) and his subsequent out of co...more
First things first -- this is NOT a medical thriller. This is a combination of anti-alternative medicine rant and a diatribe against Christian zealotry -- or, even worse, a conspiracy story of mediocre proportion.
There are two things going on in this novel: the original plot line of Jack investigating an untimely death caused by chiropractic cervical manipulation (producing VAD) and his subsequent out of co...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Alicia
rated it
Intervention, my first (and possibly last!) Robin Cook novel, was dull, redundant and unoriginal. I didn't care for any of the characters - Shawn and Sana, in particular, were an irritating couple, and Shawn's casually sexist and demeaning treatment of his wife was gross. They seemed more like acquaintances who barely knew each other or colleagues forced to work together on a project than husband and wife who had known each other for several years. The dialogue was incredibly stiff and unnatu...more
Pathetic! I'm a fan of Robin Cook but this was beyond the pale. The writing was ghastly and the plots absurd. I can't imagine what happened to the Dr. Cook I loved. Clearly he wanted to rant(using Jack) against alternative medicine and he did a stellar. if sophomoric, job. Sort of amusing that Jack kept running into intelligent, powerful people who use and love various kinds of alternative treatment.(Perhaps the book should have been titled "Vendetta"). Therefore, Jack decides he re...more
One of the few authors who has managed to grab my attention and keep me indulged is Robin Cook. Having read almost all his other works, it was an easy choice for me to pick Intervention at Landmark, Spencer’s Plaza, where I had been recently. (My love affair with Landmark demands a separate post altogether. I just can’t resist buying books at Landmark, something that I can do at Crossword for some reason).
I was expecting a medical thriller again in some other form, probably something l...more
I was expecting a medical thriller again in some other form, probably something l...more
I think I understand why this book is rated so poorly. I have to justify why i'm throwing 4 stars on something that was actually pretty Boring.
This was my first Robin Cook book. As must as I do enjoy a bit of science/medicine or religion in my fiction, this one was certainly a hodge podge of faith vs facts that I think played out well with the three main characters (who by the way not one is named Keith despite the backcover synopsis).
The only way to get through this no...more
This was my first Robin Cook book. As must as I do enjoy a bit of science/medicine or religion in my fiction, this one was certainly a hodge podge of faith vs facts that I think played out well with the three main characters (who by the way not one is named Keith despite the backcover synopsis).
The only way to get through this no...more
I usually like a Robin Cook novel, but this one was bad writing. Why did I finish it? - probably to see how he would end it AND the ending was disappointing and unbelievable. It's called a mystery thriller - where was the mystery and where was the thrill? - they were missing. He usually writes medical thrillers but this time he strayed into Dan Brown territory and does it badly. This is about three college roommates who connect when Shawn (archaeologist) and his wife Sana (DNA expert) discov...more
This book centers around three college buddies, Jack Stapleton, Shawn Doherty and Kevin Murray who all go in very different career paths once they graduate, but are all brought together after 20+ years. A dig beneath Saint Peter's bascillica unearths an ancient relic that promises to change people's views on science and the Catholic religion. The college friends work together to determine the authenticity of the artifact and what they should do with it. Their work takes a tragic turn in the en...more
The book begins with two separate storylines, one of which is abruptly abandoned midway through the book. The remaining storyline is somewhat thought-provoking, and the tension builds nicely. At last, I am drawn into the novel. What will the characters do? How will they prove their suspicions? How will the church respond? I want to know. Apparently, the writer doesn't have the answers, either. Instead, he pens a few pages which cause the plot to suddenly vanish into thin air. Imagine a ...more
New York City ME's Jack and Laurie Stapleton are consumed by the cancer, neuroblastoma that has attacked their young son. While Laurie is on leave, staying home to take care of their ill son, Jack escapes from the sorrow and the frustration of a very cranky, always crying child at work. He receives a phone call to have lunch with his college buddy who is now the Bishop of the Archdiocese of NY. During lunch, the Bishop tells Jack that their other buddy, who is an archeologist has made a spect...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
The plot was ok, but the author seemed determined to include all the research he undertook for the book, easily adding 100 pages that didn't need to be there. The author should have spent far more time developing the Stapleton's dilemma with their newborn's illness and medical science's frustration with these sorts of cancer. The last 100 pages were a bit improbable as was the neatly tied up divine intervention at the end.
I like Robin Cook and his books are usually a nice blend of m...more
I like Robin Cook and his books are usually a nice blend of m...more
I was very dissatisfied with both the subplot and resolution of this latest addition to Robin Cook's series featuring Dr. Jack Stapleton, New York City forensic pathologist. When Dr. Stapleton discovers a death due to a rupture of blood vessels caused by a chiropractor, he decides to investigate just how many deaths can be linked to alternative medicine and its practitioners. He describes some of these practices making the case that they do harm.
On the other hand, the subplot concer...more
On the other hand, the subplot concer...more
I'm kind of forcing myself to finish this one. I like most of Robin Cook's books, although I think he spells things out a bit too much, whereas a better novelist trusts that the reader can infer the mindset and the emotions of the characters without wasting an additional 2 or 3 sentences. This almost seems like two separate books; one that was a medical thriller (the alternative medicine storyline) but was tossed aside to make way for the Dan Brown-esque religious conspiracy. I'm disappointed...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
I've been a die-hard lover of Robin Cook for about ten years now and I was excited to find out there was a new Jack Stapleton novel out. I love Jack and was excited to see what kind of trouble he was going to get himself into.
Turns out, not much.
I love Cook because he's generally a straightforward author who hooks you into the main thread of the plot within the first hundred pages. I got half way through the book before the real plot kicked in and, even then, it wasn't ex...more
Turns out, not much.
I love Cook because he's generally a straightforward author who hooks you into the main thread of the plot within the first hundred pages. I got half way through the book before the real plot kicked in and, even then, it wasn't ex...more
I was tempted to give this 4 stars since it held my interest....but the quality of the writing just isn't there. Cook interweaves 3 stories....one of a couple with a sick baby, one about the husband of that couple who is a ME trying to debunk alternative medicine, and a third about an archeologist who thinks he's discovered Mary's bones and can debunk the whole Catholic Church and their Assumption thing. All 3 stories get tied in the end. The 3rd story reminds me of DaVinci code a bit...some ...more
One of the worse books I've read in a long time. Entire plot was an unbelievable tying together of three former roommates but gets lost in Cook's rant against alternative medicine and Christianity. Premise sounded very intriging/exciting and I forced myself to finish it as I thought Cook, who I've really enjoyed reading before, would somehow emerge and tie to story together but it never happened. From the ridiculous descriptions of books located in a chiropractor's office to (SPOILER ALERT) blow...more
Anne Marie
added it
So much potential in the first half. I'm only giving 3 stars due to the interesting and potentially controversial topics Cook gets us to begin thinking about. It all gets sketchy, patchy and increasingly rushed towards the end of the book, though, leading me to believe that meeting the publishing deadline/contract became much more important than fully exploring so many interesting threads. If I likened this to a real live exchange, I'd say to the author "thanks for starting a stimulating...more
I really liked the beginning of this book when the main character, Jack, was exploring the world of alternative medicine through his medical examiner eyes. I expected the book to highlight a struggle for Jack over whether to treat his ailing infant with alternative therapies. I was disappointed when the second story line came into focus and the first came to a sudden halt. Although the dig at the Vatican and discovery of Christianity changing artifacts was ok, it felt like Robin Cook was tryi...more
I was quite disappointed with this Cook. He usually tells a thought provoking tale regarding abuse or misuse in the medical field. I usually struggle happily through the medical jargon. However, this was barely medical at all, with the exception of attacking the alternative medicine realm. So the book is a historical/theological story aka Davinci Code in which Mary's (Jesus' mother's) bones have been discovered in present day and the potential societal and especially Catholic Church ramification...more
I've always liked Dr. Robin Cook, and his medical novels. This one was newly mention on Amazon's Kimble list so I downloaded it yesterday. It's a tale of three college classmates and their interaction in regard to an ancient ossuary which one believes contains the bones of Mary, mother of Jesus. He is a renowned archeologist. One is Archbishop of New York whose faith believes in the bodily ascension of the Virgin into heaven. The third works as a medical examiner and becomes the go-between....more
I have read many books by Cook and so had no hesitation to buy this one. It started out interesting if somewhat different than most of his books, but as I read and neared the end I couldn't believe that there would be any way to bring this story to an end that would make sense.
It felt like Cook was fulfilling a contract with a publisher and so just threw together a book that really made no sense. Don't think I'll buy anymore of his works. Will wait for the library to get new ones ...more
It felt like Cook was fulfilling a contract with a publisher and so just threw together a book that really made no sense. Don't think I'll buy anymore of his works. Will wait for the library to get new ones ...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Dr. Robin Cook (born May 4, 1940 in New York City, New York) is an American doctor / novelist who writes about medicine and topics affecting public health.
He is best known for being the author who combined medical writing with the thriller genre of writing. Several of his books have been bestsellers on the "New York Times" Bestseller List. Several of his books have also been ...more
More about Robin Cook...
He is best known for being the author who combined medical writing with the thriller genre of writing. Several of his books have been bestsellers on the "New York Times" Bestseller List. Several of his books have also been ...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »
“Natural,my ass! The worst poison known to man comes from a tree frog in South America. You cannot imagine how small an amount would be necessary to kill you.and it's natural.Calling something NATURAL is a MEANINGLESS MARKETING PLOY."
"All right,calm down! Maybe I like alternative medicine because it's been in use for more than six thousand years.After all that time,they have to know what they're doing."
"You mean the wacky idea that somehow in the distant past people had more scientific wisdom than they do today?That's both crazy and counterintuitive.Six thousand years ago people thought thunder was a bunch of gods moving around furniture."
-Conversation btw Dr.Jack Stapleton and Vinnie”
—
1 person liked it
More quotes…
"All right,calm down! Maybe I like alternative medicine because it's been in use for more than six thousand years.After all that time,they have to know what they're doing."
"You mean the wacky idea that somehow in the distant past people had more scientific wisdom than they do today?That's both crazy and counterintuitive.Six thousand years ago people thought thunder was a bunch of gods moving around furniture."
-Conversation btw Dr.Jack Stapleton and Vinnie”

Loading...


view all 3 comments


































