9th out of 17 books
—
16 voters
A Death in Vienna (Liebermann Papers #1)
by
Frank Tallis
In 1902, elegant Vienna is the city of the new century, the center of discoveries in everything from the writing of music to the workings of the human mind. But now a brutal homicide has stunned its citizens and appears to have bridged the gap between science and the supernatural. Two very different sleuths from opposite ends of the spectrum will need to combine their tale...more
Paperback, 471 pages
Published
May 8th 2007
by Random House Trade Paperbacks
(first published 2005)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,506)
It's refreshing to read of a time in history when guys got together to play and sing Schubert lieder for fun! This is the pastime of Dr. Max Lieberman, psychoanalyst, and his detective friend, Oskar Rheinhardt...they are good musicians too, one can tell by their chosen repertoire and the way they talk about music. Truly skilled amateurs are a thing of the past...
A beautiful blond medium has been mysteriously murdered and Rheinhardt must discover not only the perpetrator but how the murder was ac...more
A beautiful blond medium has been mysteriously murdered and Rheinhardt must discover not only the perpetrator but how the murder was ac...more
It would sound snarky if I said, "This is a novel about a man who uses psychoanalysis to fight crime," but, well, it is. The story centers on two characters working together to solve a puzzling murder: Oskar Rheinhardt, a detective in the Viennese police force (and a gentile), and Max Liebermann, a young Jewish physician who treats hysterics and has an active interest in the new ideas of Freud (who makes a couple of brief appearances).
At first, I found the novel somewhat difficult going. The des...more
At first, I found the novel somewhat difficult going. The des...more
May 29, 2008
E
rated it
3 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
history buffs, Freud fans, mystery readers
Shelves:
mystery-detective-fiction,
historical-fiction
I enjoyed this detective novel set in Freud's Vienna. Main characters are Detective Rheinhardt and psychologist Dr. Max Liebermann, both on the forward edge of innovations in their fields. The psychologist applies "talk therapy," hypnotism and dream analysis to unravel clues, working with the detective and his sidekick. Freud has a cameo and is presented with respectful humor. Most interesting is the setting of the book in turn-of-the-19th-century Vienna, including its growing anti-Semitism, wit...more
The murder mystery is not *that* interesting but the setting is wonderful. Really. It has some of my favourite things mixed in an historical murder mystery. So it has birth of psychoanalysis lit (Freud, Vienna 1902), the hero is a young Jewish Doctor, a fan of Professor Freud. We have Vienna, 1902, music (Beethoven, Mahler, Strauss, Chopin) both our hero and his counter part in the police are music lovers. We have Vienna, 1902, and the 14th Secession exhibition, dedicated to Beethoven. Klimt, Kl...more
Mar 04, 2009
Tony
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
fiction-crime-detection
Tallis, Frank. A DEATH IN VIENNA. (2005). ****. This was the first novel in what is now a series by this author featuring Dr. Liebermann (not to be confused with Kaminski’s Liebermann) as the psychologist/sleuth in an unusual murder in turn-of-the-century Vienna. Don’t confuse the title with Daniel Silva’s novel of the same name, either. They are very different books. This period in Vienna saw the emergence of the city, under Franz Joseph, into the modern age. The city was becoming electrified....more
With a few exceptions, I am not a fan of historical mysteries or books set outside the U. S.
This is not just a mystery. It is more complex than that. Tallis weaves several story lines throughout the book. At first they seem to have no bearing on the main plot, but as the novel progresses, several slowly weave into that mystery while others only peripherally relate and a few are unresolved by the end, providing an inducement for the reader to pick up the next book in the series.
Tallis does an exc...more
This is not just a mystery. It is more complex than that. Tallis weaves several story lines throughout the book. At first they seem to have no bearing on the main plot, but as the novel progresses, several slowly weave into that mystery while others only peripherally relate and a few are unresolved by the end, providing an inducement for the reader to pick up the next book in the series.
Tallis does an exc...more
OK, I have to say I just finished a Jo Nesbo novel before this one, so I was on a whirlwind of suspense and not quite ready for a slow-moving, old-fashioned Victorian novel. But I could have adjusted if this book had been better.
So here's what I liked about this book: Nice historical details, particularly about Freud's personality (which I assume are true, since the author is a psychologist) and the art nouveau innovations (which I looked up on Wikipedia and was quite impressed). Also, the writ...more
So here's what I liked about this book: Nice historical details, particularly about Freud's personality (which I assume are true, since the author is a psychologist) and the art nouveau innovations (which I looked up on Wikipedia and was quite impressed). Also, the writ...more
Nov 16, 2011
Marfita
rated it
2 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommends it for:
people too timid for Caleb Carr
Shelves:
mysteries,
period-mystery
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Jan 22, 2011
Monica Carter
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
international-thrillers
A Death in Vienna by Brit writer Frank Tallis is a thriller that is palatable, meant for those who like their thrillers civilized and steeped in intellect. It’s a polite whodunit with an added mystery of how’dtheydunit and filled with all the hat-tipping and decorum that has fallen tragically by the wayside in today’s society. A historical thriller set in turn-of-the-century Vienna, this is a novel that takes the marks of that era and place--Freud and Mozart--and uses them as a backdrop for a ca...more
You can tell that this is a first novel, especially in the way the author sticks to short scenes, but the character and milieu are promising; I'll read the sequels. The protagonist is Max Liebermann, a Vienna psychiatrist circa 1902; he spends his evenings smoking cigars and playing the piano to accompany his friend, baritone and Detective Inspector Oskar Rheinhardt. Naturally Rheinhardt ends up with a murder that he can't solve without drawing on Liebermann's expertise. A famous medium has been...more
I Love this book so much!!! Penyakit mental memang selalu menarik ya? Latar belakang sebagai pemicu awal dari penyakit itu yang lebih menarik tepatnya.
Adalah Dr. Max Libermann yang seorang psikiater muda yang digambarkan ganteng ini dalam buku dikisahkan hidup di sekitar awal abad 21an kurasa, mengingat setting kuno tempat, gaya berpakaian, gaya hidup dan kendaraan yang serba kuno. Tapi disini menariknya, karena aku selalu penasaran pada kehidupan sosial, gaya hidup dan cara berpikir kaum purit...more
Adalah Dr. Max Libermann yang seorang psikiater muda yang digambarkan ganteng ini dalam buku dikisahkan hidup di sekitar awal abad 21an kurasa, mengingat setting kuno tempat, gaya berpakaian, gaya hidup dan kendaraan yang serba kuno. Tapi disini menariknya, karena aku selalu penasaran pada kehidupan sosial, gaya hidup dan cara berpikir kaum purit...more
There’s lots to like about A Death in Vienna (also published as Mortal Mischief). The plot is cleverly conceived and well executed, with a couple of substantial subplots that add, rather than detract, from the story. The locked room element of the story is well realised and Tallis does a good job of keeping various suspects in the frame. The characterisation is nicely executed with respect to all the principle and secondary characters, with Rheinhardt and Liebermann being nice, complementary foi...more
It's 1902, Oskar Rheinhardt is investigating the murder of the beautiful medium, Frualine Charlotte Lowenstein in Vienna, Austria. The victim has been found shot in the heart in a room locked from the inside with what appears to be a suicide note, no weapon or secret means of egress are found. Rheihardt enlists the help of his good friend, Max Lieberman, who is a doctor of psychoanalysis. The medium's regular customers become an interesting circle of suspects.
Frank Tallis has done a nice job of...more
Frank Tallis has done a nice job of...more
Mar 06, 2013
Briansmom
rated it
5 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
historical-fiction,
mystery-thriller
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Jul 04, 2012
Dawn
rated it
3 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Shelves:
mystery-modern-twentieth
Max Liebermann is a disciple of Sigmund Freud and is a doctor in the new field of psychoanalysis. Set in Vienna in the early 1900s where science and art are hotly debated topics and the benefits of psychology are viewed with scepticism and electric therapy is in prevalent use.
Oskar Rheinhardt is a detective with a loving wife and children. When a so called medium is found murdered in her apartment with the door locked from the inside, rumours are rife with tales of the supernatural. With politic...more
Oskar Rheinhardt is a detective with a loving wife and children. When a so called medium is found murdered in her apartment with the door locked from the inside, rumours are rife with tales of the supernatural. With politic...more
Psychoanalyst Dr. Liebermann helps his detective friend solve a baffling murder. The level of detail about early 19th century Vienna was interesting and the main character was pretty likable. The only thing I didn't like was the shoe-horned in growing romance between him and his English patient despite having just proposed to his girlfriend. The poor fiance is kind of immature and loves talking about fashion and gossip (she seems really sweet, though) but the English girl is all about Science an...more
Sad to say that the best observation about this is that it proved a diversion from the big pile of seriously pointy-headed other things I have to read/work on at the moment – but still the evocation of turn-of-the-20th-century Vienna seemed plausible, and I kept seeing the places where the action was: streets I've walked, buildings I've viewed/visited, locations experienced, and so forth. Alas, setting the climax on the Riesenrad was oh-so-3rd-Man clichéd – surely we can have moments of Viennese...more
I've been reading a lot of period mysteries about Berlin and Vienna lately, and someone said she liked this, so I tried it. I knew immediately it wasn't for me, for two reasons. First, it has a Sherlock Holmes character, and I have no patience for Sherlock Holmes characters other than Nero Wolfe. Second, it's got real people in it (Sigmund Freud, in this case) and I'm not usually crazy about that, either. But I gave it 50 pages. Then I gave it 100 pages. Then I finished it and ordered the second...more
I thoroughly enjoyed this murder mystery, most especially because it was a period story set in early 19th century Vienna. With the music, art, culture -- and yummy pastries -- thrown in, it was exquisite. And maybe because I was really buying the period setting, I could totally visualize the events happening in black and white. As if! While the goal, of course, was to find out who did it, in this case, more interesting was how it was done. And I am happy to walk away from this book with all the...more
Max Lieberman is a psychologist and student of Freud who assists his friend Rheinhardt in the Homicide unit with psychological insights that combine psychology with the deductive and observation skills of Sherlock Holmes. I love the series and its vivid portrayal of late 19th century Vienna. It is the heydey of the arts and culture and Vienna is a city alive with brilliant minds, great musicians and lively arts. Meanwhile, under the surface, the roots of fascism are slowly spreading. The story i...more
A leisurely murder mystery set in fin-de-siecle Vienna, with the likes of Freud and Mahler making walk-ons. It is too long and the solution to the murder is hardly convincing, yet I stuck with it. Why? Its fine evocation of the city of cafes and whipped cream during the early days of psychoanalysis, with its cranks and crackpots, anti-semites and charlatans, and nervous, intelligent women on the cusp of independence. Tallis has done his research (maybe he shows it off a little too much) and know...more
A Woman is murdered in the early 20th century of Vienna. There is no bullet found and the door of the room where the murder takes place is locked from the inside. Dr. Lieberman is called by his detective friend to help solve the case. I thought the setting was interesting. I liked the references to Sigmund Freud. The mystery did not grab my attention, however. I thought there were too many mini-plots that were really not pertinent to the story. I wondered if they were intentional to make the boo...more
Wasn't exactly fast-paced, but the author's tendency to leave you hanging at the end of the chapter and pick up a totally different plot thread in the next had me really turning pages. I very much enjoyed the detailed descriptions of turn-of-the-century Vienna, one of my favorite literary settings. I felt like the author's attempts to work in descriptions of the main character's personal life a little brittle and one dimensional, although it seemed to work better with other characters. Got a chu...more
The beginning of an excellent series set in early 20th century Vienna. Young psychoanalyst Max Liebermann is Freud's student, a talented musician, a middling fencer, a coffeehouse regular, and best friend of a police detective, Oskar Rheinhardt. The hub of culture, science, and political ferment, 1903 Vienna is itself a character in these books. It is the stage on which the personal, intellectual, and historical intersect with well-plotted solutions to puzzling crimes. Each volume illuminates th...more
The first in a series of mysteries set in the decadent world of Vienna at the turn of the century. The main character is Max Lieberman, one of the new practioners of psychoanalysis trained by Sigmund Freud. His good friend is Oskar Reinhart, an detective with the Viennese police whose secret joy is singing. To be honest, I enjoyed the book because I read it while staying in Vienna. I walked to each location while I listened to the music discussed in the novel on my IPod and ate the same traditio...more
Maybe 3 and a half, but probably 4 stars for me. It's a good book. Slow and a little faster for a good bit of the book, but I never could quite put it down. It dealt with the period in Vienna rather going from the greater imperial age to what then was more modern, but still quite stilted with social distinctions and rituals connected that might rival the class system in India. Music and the arts were at a high point. Freud and some of the modern psychology forerunners were part of this era at th...more
Max Lieberman is a very retiring character, a practicing psychologist.His good friend is Oskar Reinhardt, a Viennese police detective.
Oskar is called into investigating a closed room setting. The victim was a "seer" and the suicide is suggested to be a murder by demonic means.
The investigation continues as Max deals with a supervisor insistent on using electro therapy instead of the "talking" therapy. The "talking" therapy is a new practice extended by Sigmund Freud,a Jewish doctor.
Both topics,...more
Oskar is called into investigating a closed room setting. The victim was a "seer" and the suicide is suggested to be a murder by demonic means.
The investigation continues as Max deals with a supervisor insistent on using electro therapy instead of the "talking" therapy. The "talking" therapy is a new practice extended by Sigmund Freud,a Jewish doctor.
Both topics,...more
An intriguing time (around the turn of the century) and place (Vienna) with a Freud-following psychologist pairing up with a detective to solve the murder of a medium. The subtlest and best modulated aspect of this piece, however, wasn't the mystery but the love interest. The psychologist/doctor (Liebermann?) becomes engaged to a lively, pretty woman, a friend of the family but Liebermann finds himself increasingly attracted to one of his patients, an English woman who wants to study medicine. N...more
This book was enjoyable to read, and I read it quickly about a month ago. When it came time to discuss it at a book group though I found I had to go back to it and re read parts because I had forgotten most of it. I prefer to read books that stay with me for years and don't mind struggling through them if they are dense rather than reading a book that I forget as soon as I put it down. Some in my bookgroup found that there were too many characters and subplots but did find it an interesting peri...more
I'm happy to have stumbled on this book at the library. I'm even happier to know that it's the first in a series and I can look forward to catching up. The author, Frank Tallis, is a clinical psychologist and brings his knowledge of psychotherapy and specialty in obsessive behavior to his writing. The book is set in turn-of-the-century Vienna. Psychoanalysis and talk therapy are in their infancy. One of the two main characters is Dr. Liebermann, who is refusing to treat a "hysterical" patient wi...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Aka F.R. Tallis.
Dr. Frank Tallis is a writer and clinical psychologist. He has held lecturing posts in clinical psychology and neuroscience at the Institute of Psychiatry and King's College, London. He has written self help manuals (How to Stop Worrying, Understanding Obsessions and Compulsions) non-fiction for the general reader (Changing Minds, Hidden Minds, Love Sick), academic text books and o...more
More about Frank Tallis...
Dr. Frank Tallis is a writer and clinical psychologist. He has held lecturing posts in clinical psychology and neuroscience at the Institute of Psychiatry and King's College, London. He has written self help manuals (How to Stop Worrying, Understanding Obsessions and Compulsions) non-fiction for the general reader (Changing Minds, Hidden Minds, Love Sick), academic text books and o...more
Share This Book
1 trivia question
More quizzes & trivia...
“We must remember that possession of physical beauty can easily weaken the moral faculty.”
—
7 people liked it
“It is my opinion that the isolated mind loses its purchase on reality all too easily and becomes prone to fantasy.”
—
7 people liked it
More quotes…

Loading...





view 1 comment



















