Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “La tentación de San Antonio” as Want to Read:
La tentación de San Antonio
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

La tentación de San Antonio

3.8 of 5 stars 3.80  ·  rating details  ·  1,452 ratings  ·  49 reviews
Entre todos los libros de Flaubert, «La tentación de San Antonio» es el que mejor expresa la naturaleza profunda del escritor. Esta obra le acompañó toda su vida, pues hizo de ella tres versiones. El tema de la prueba de fuerza con el Diablo le obsesionó desde su juventud, y concibió la idea de escribir este drama filosófico, poema fantástico de personaje único y de múltip ...more
Paperback, Letras universales, 224 pages
Published 2004 by Catedra (first published 1874)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about La tentación de San Antonio, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about La tentación de San Antonio

This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Manny


At age 24, Flaubert saw Bruegel's painting, The Temptation of Saint Anthony, and decided he would turn it into a play. Like all his literary projects, he took it very seriously. He wanted to describe a 3rd century hermit sitting on a mountain-top in the Egyptian desert and being tempted by the Devil, and he spent most of the rest of his life writing and rewriting it; the final version came out nearly 30 years later, only a few years before his death.

The rest of this review is available elsewher
...more
Yann


Antoine est un anachorète égyptien des débuts du christianisme, dont la vie nous a été relaté par Anathase (Vie de saint Antoine). D'après cet auteur, il aurait été embêté par des démons venus pour le tenter d'abandonner sa rude et difficile retraite, en lui faisant miroiter tous les plaisirs qu'il abandonnait par sa décision. Il s'agissait de glorifier la résolution d'Antoine qui, loin d'accorder la moindre chance à ces fantômes, les chassait avec vigueur, raffermi par sa foi inébranlable.

Le su
...more
Mala
May 01, 2015 Mala rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Not for everyone
Recommended to Mala by: James Joyce
3.5 stars.
My head is still hurting! It's said that Flaubert had read nearly 1500 books for Bouvard and Pécuchet, I wouldn't be surprised if he read just as many for this one!
Hadrian
A vivid and terrifying fever dream, a spectacle of horrors and temptations. It's hard to believe this is the same Flaubert who wrote Madame Bovary.

It is based off of the Christian fable - the monk, Anthony, goes to the desert to meditate and pray, and the devil tempts him - and indeed, how the devil tempts him. All the obsessive desires of lust, of gluttony, and then the seductions of heresy and following false prophets, and then the submission to the vastness of the cosmos, the contradictions o
...more
Katelis Viglas
If one tries to read this novel when he is young, probably he will fail to see its significance. It is an excelent representation and dramatization of Saint Antoine's life. It is certain that Saint Athanasius, the first biographer of the famous Saint, wasn't so much informed and erudite as regards matters of heresis. Of cours it is about fantasy and fiction, but it is exactly beacause of writer's poetic licence and deep erudition that the person of Saint Antoine is enlightened; we can see it beh ...more
Justin Evans
This is a pretty damn weird book, in the best possible way. You always hear about Flaubert as a realist, Flaubert as wanting to write a novel about nothing, Flaubert as being obsessed with form and so on. Well, this was published 17 years after Madame Bovary, and is... not exactly a realist novel. It's more like a medieval passion play with historical people rather than personifications. First Antony is tempted by biblical characters (the Queen of Sheba, Nebuchadnezzar), then he confronted by he ...more
Kim
This book was interesting to me knowing that there really was a Saint Anthony who lived in the third century A.D. Anthony's parents were wealthy landowners and when they died all their wealth went to Anthony, and he was left with a sister to provide for. However, he decided to follow the words of Jesus, who had said: "If you want to be perfect, go, sell what you have and give to the poor, and you will have treasures in heaven; and come, follow Me", Matt. 19:21. He then gave away all his property ...more
Don
No pretense here of understanding the esoteric references or Flaubert's intent here at all. But that's the advantage of being a card-carrying philistine, no worries on that point. One can just sit back and enjoy the wild, hallucinatory imagery and the Lovecraft-vibe. This is supposed to be a prose-poem play and you have to wonder whether Flaubert owed a costumer some money or something because, if this was ever produced, it would be a full-employment for costumers program. I'd would so love to s ...more
Erik Graff
May 23, 2015 Erik Graff rated it 4 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Flaubert fans
Recommended to Erik by: Lajla Stousland
Shelves: literature
Having read about the excesses of the desert fathers and being long interested in literary representations of religious figures and the religious/mystical consciousness, I picked up my grandmother's old copy of Flaubert's The Temptation of Saint Anthony during a break from college and read it with some enjoyment. For his time, Flaubert was scandalous.

Some familiarity with early Church history allows for a greater appreciation of this text.
Courtney
Trippy! Dizzying amounts of obscure references and Biblical names/stories/themes - Flaubert was a mad genius, and besides the nearly indescribable excellence of his writing, this work (play? novel?) is humbling in its encapsulation of one man's obsession with learning.
Kristel
Saint Anthony or Anthony the Great was a Christian saint from Egypt. Flaubert desired to write an epic of spiritual torment that might equal Goethe’s Faust (German literature). The author spent a large portion of his life writing this story that is written in the form of play script. The work’s form influenced the development of modernist play-texts, notable the “Circe” section of Joyce’s Ulysses. The novel might also be called a prose poem. The work is a fictionalized story of the inner life of ...more
Matthew
Beautifully conveyed, and more shocking than À Rebours.

"Antony meets all his enemies one after another. He recognises people whom he had forgotten. Before killing them, he outrages them. He rips them open, cuts their throats, knocks them down, drags the old men by their beards, runs over children, and beats those who are wounded … The blood gushes up to the ceiling, falls back on the linen clothes that line the walls, streams from the trunks of decapitated corpses, fills the aqueducts, and rolls
...more
Thomas
A voluptuous meditation on the dark underside of asceticism by a master of literary realism. Apparently Flaubert worked on this off and on throughout his life after his friends initially told him he should throw it in the fire. I'm glad he didn't, though it's easy to see why they cautioned restraint in his future endeavors. James Joyce, no admirer of restraint, was so touched by it that he modeled the Circe episode of Ulysses on it.

Lafcadio Hearn's translation is so lyrical that I was sure he w
...more
Craig
Encyclopedic, nightmarish, orgiastic, and beautiful. Flaubert's less than sane genius flaunts mad visions and buffets of esoteric delights across the pages. Similar to Bouvard and Pecuchet, this work is expansive in its breadth of knowledge, a book about books. Different in its themes and topic and how Flaubert creates and plays with the structure.
Greg
Flaubert’s retelling of the temptation of St. Antony is an unexpected, strange, wonderful dramatic prose poem. I do not know of many other examples of dramatic prose poems of historical religious fiction. It is as if Flaubert strove to combine all possible genres into one.

The work itself centers around St. Antony, the 3rd century desert follow who was the subject of St. Athanasius hagiography, which is one of the foundational post-biblical texts of western theology. Flaubert starts by roughly sk
...more
Antti
Äärirealistista proosaa, hurmahenkisyyttä ja kreikkalaista draamaperinnettä tarjoava kirja, joka ei yritä ollenkaan yhdistellä kirjoitustapojaan, vaan käyttää aina kutakin kun paras vaikutus saadaan.

Flaubertin omana mielikirjanaan se on kiinnostava avainromaani, ja kuvaakin myös kirjailijan omaa luomistuskaa.

Perfektionistin kirja vie lukijaa mukanaan ilman mitään hidasteita.

Dermatologia kiinnostanee, että 200-luvulla Egyptin aavikolla eläneen pyhimyksen yhtä ihovitsausta, erysipelasta, kutsut
...more
Nathan Rostron
Aug 08, 2007 Nathan Rostron marked it as shelved-indefinitely  ·  review of another edition
I have this awesome illustrated copy with naked ladies and stuff. I'm sure it was Flaubert's intention, the randy sot.
Catachresis
Fabulous prose, pure lexical honey studded with diamonds.
Fabio
Pure exuberance of thought. The act of writing taken to a most indulgent yet polished and insightful end.

It's no surprise that this book was revered by minds like Wilde's and Freud's. Its a work of genius, of expansive, list-making, encyclopedic, overwhelming genius.

Replete with references that dwarf even the most exotic catalogues of heresy, and not unlike the best paintings on the subject (Bosch, Michelangelo,
Rops, Brueghel, and Dalí all turned their eye to this abyss), the book is more a m
...more
Mohammed
I kept hearing about Gustave Flaubert through discussion by critics of his famous novel 'Madame Bovary'. So I did my research on the author and one book caught my attention, his last novel, which he considered his masterpiece. Temptations of Saint Anthony, which concerned a famous Christian Egyptian, saint who faced supernatural visions from the Devil to tear apart his faith. 19th century literature in concerning belief in God has always been one of my favorite subjects so when I saw the novel i ...more
Greg Morrison
"It was yet again the Devil, and in his double guise: the spirit of fornication and the spirit of destruction."

The closet drama - a play never meant to be performed - is dead. Our conventions, which masquerade as the only way for the world to reach paper, dictate a subdued prose. Show, don't tell. Details, details, details. Write what you know. Authenticity. Is it especially surprising that we're coming through a memoir boom?

Flaubert defies realism, and instead has stage directions like:

"On the
...more
Benjamin
Delicious lists, fascinating philosophies, nightmarish visions, and hallucinatory images. Flaubert writes a novel (which almost reads like a play) that describes in detail the dreams that Anthony has during a single trying night. Flaubert's writing is not so much poetic as precise (which I am led to believe was his goal in writing). He culls names and images from history, myth, legend, religion, and science to concoct scenes and characters who confront Anthony and challenge his faith. There are ...more
Nathan Marone
One Goodreads review called this book a "fever dream". That's about right to me. The parade of heretics, mythological figures, and pagan gods can be overwhelming at times. I admit that I eventually tired of flipping back to the glossary to figure out the historical context of a character that would deliver one line. Still, Flaubert's book is the type of nightmare that only a dedicated mystic could have. It is among the finest apocalyptic works I can think of.
Larry
Very strange book, and certainly not for everyone, but right up my alley. A compendium of early Christian myth and yet another sui generis masterpiece from the astounding Flaubert who invented at least three different *kinds* of fiction (not including this artifact which seems to have only influenced poets; novelists have not followed, unless there's a whole body of fiction I'm tragically unaware of).
Czarny Pies
Nov 13, 2014 Czarny Pies rated it 2 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: Graduate students in French lit
Recommended to Czarny by: Mme. Rathe one of my undergraduate French lit profs. I never made it to the next level.
Shelves: french-lit
I find it rather strange that Gustave Flaubert's Madame Bovary and Salambo are on the Papal Index (L'Index librorum prohibitorum) of books prohibited to Catholics but that this work is not. The Temptation of Saint Anthony did not deserve to have been omitted from the Index. Indeed it deserves a special place of honour.

This loopy work reads like the script from Monty Python's Life of Bryan. Indeed it is a truly savage parody of the monastic vocation as Saint Anthony is shown to suffer in the most
...more
Andrei Turcu
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
Elena
It was so surprising for me to find out a surrealist Flaubert, instead of the dry and cool realism he displayed in Madame Bovary.
This enchanted me and made me think that Salvador Dali had for sure read this before painting his famous Temptation of Saint Anthony, as his vision was so similar - I kept it in my mind while I was reading Flaubert - more even than the Bruegel version, that I have just found out (reading Manny's review) that was the one that inspired Flaubert. Which made me think furth
...more
Francesco D'Isa
Perché il diavolo è così convincente? Perché ha ragione. E anche se non persuade S. Antonio il dubbio resta, a giudicare dal monologo finale. Notevoli le comparsate degli dei, soprattutto il Budda arrabbiato: “Gli uomini, gli animali, gli Dei [...] le miriadi di miriadi di stelle, tutto sta per morire; e fino a nuove nascite, la fiamma danzerà sulle rovine dei mondi distrutti!”
Trama: Nonostante tutto il diavolo non convince Antonio.
Reperibilità: Difficile, ma nel Mammut c’è.
Voto: 94 su 100.
Esteban Gordon
"The freedom of the deep forests once intoxicated me; the odours of the wild beasts and the exhalations of the marshes made me as one drunk with joy. But the women whose maternity I protected now bring dead children into the world. The moon trembles with the incantations of witches. Desires of violence, of immensity, seize me, fill me. I wish to drink poisons, -- to lose myself in vapours, in dreams!" And so dies the goddess Diana. Come hermit... and tempt thyself with madness, poetry, genius.
T.P. Williams
I can't say that I particularly cared for this book. I understood it represented author's effort to portray soul-searching/temptation on different levels - psychological, religious, ethical, etc. - but there was almost no transition between scenes and dialogue sections made it seem like it couldn't make up its mind if it wanted to be a play or a novel. I don't think it helped that the translation I read is from 1904 and the English was archaic.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Castle Richmond
  • Born in Exile
  • Pierre et Jean
  • The Monastery
  • Là-Bas (Down There)
  • Marius the Epicurean
  • Virgin Soil
  • Albigenses
  • The Absentee
  • The Vice Consul (Pantheon Modern Writers Original)
  • Thaïs
  • Le neveu de Rameau
  • Fantômas (Fantômas, #1)
  • Locus Solus
  • Lost Illusions (La Comédie Humaine)
  • Mademoiselle de Maupin
  • Les Chants de Maldoror
  • Hell
1461
Gustave Flaubert (December 12, 1821 – May 8, 1880) is counted among the greatest Western novelists. He was born in Rouen, Seine-Maritime, in the Haute-Normandie Region of France.

Flaubert's curious modes of composition favored and were emphasized by these peculiarities. He worked in sullen solitude, sometimes occupying a week in the completion of one page, never satisfied with what he had composed,
...more
More about Gustave Flaubert...
Madame Bovary Sentimental Education Three Tales Salammbô Bouvard and Pecuchet

Share This Book

“And he beholds the moon; like a rounded fragment of ice filled with motionless light.” 28 likes
“Le monde est l'œuvre d'un Dieu en délire.” 0 likes
More quotes…