Klezmer, Collector's Edition: Tales of the Wild East (Tales of the Wild West)
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Klezmer, Collector's Edition: Tales of the Wild East (Klezmer)

3.85 of 5 stars 3.85  ·  rating details  ·  296 ratings  ·  39 reviews
"Klezmer" tells a wild tale of love, friendship, survival, and the joy of making music in pre-World War II Eastern Europe. The Baron of My Backside is perfectly content as the leader of a traveling klezmer band, until his bandmates are brutally murdered. He sets out for Odessa alone, inconsolable even after he is joined by Chava, a beautiful girl with a voice like an angel...more
Hardcover, 144 pages
Published September 5th 2006 by First Second (first published November 1st 2005)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
This book is not yet featured on Listopia. Add this book to your favorite list »

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 456)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
There's a really great balance between lighthearted and dark in this book, but despite horrible things happening, the characters keep a... maybe not exactly "positive " outlook, but they don't dwell on these things. They keep moving forward, living however they have to. From reading the fairly extensive backmatter by Sfar (which is one of the best things about the book overall) I'd guess that this is meant as sort of a larger comment on the Jewish experience in Europe to some extent, in addition...more
Book #10 for 2014: This is a story about Jews pre-World War II in Eastern Europe. The story's sadness is masked by the watercolor and music. I enjoyed reading this musical graphic novel.

Favorite Lines:

And that I grow up with this worrisome thought: that humanist ideals and utopias of equality for all citizens are revocable at any time. (IX)

It's like the black person whose ancestors were slaves a very long time ago and who still feels the chains from time to time. Not out of paranoia. Not always...more
Snail in Danger (Sid) Nicolaides
Sep 11, 2012 Snail in Danger (Sid) Nicolaides marked it as maybe-read-sometime  ·  review of another edition
Recommended to Snail in Danger (Sid) by: saw it in a HPB
Shelves: comics
Nice art style, but whoa. Downer beginning.
Klezmer is a short graphic novel set in what Joann Sfar calls the "Wild East," Eastern Europe about a century ago. It tells of a disparate group of misfits who come together to form a klezmer band. One is the only survivor of an ambush of his musical troop, one a runaway bride, two of them are rabbinical students thrown out of their yeshiva, and the final is a gypsy. The group only gets together in the end when they all meet each other in Odessa, which launches a "to be continued" for the second...more
These characters--all itinerant musicians--live in a world that is openly hostile to them, yet also offers opportunities and a vagabond type of freedom. It's set in Eastern Europe in the nineteenth (?) century. Our lead characters are four Jews and one Gypsy. Both of those peoples were numerous and well established in the region, but definitely oppressed minorities.

There's something about the tragic religiosity of some Jewish traditions that really appeals to me. It doesn't avoid or whitewash t...more
The plot is totally pleasant, but the art annoys me enough to make me dock it a star. That is: the plot's not pleasant enough to overcome my habitual dislike of flowy, messy, free-spirited, blobby art, even if it is colorful. In the back, Sfar references Sempe, and although he says he's not trying to do that, it reminds me of his stuff and also of Saul Steinberg, who's acclaimed but really not my style. It makes me think of New Yorker covers I look immediately past and, sometimes, of long articl...more
Daniel Abdal-Hayy Moore
This is the Eastern European Jewish story, whereas the Rabbi's cat is the Algerian Jewish story (the author, Joann Sfar, has parents from both sides... and interestingly has said that the Algerian Jews are more attuned to God-talk and God-thought (surrounded by Muslims?) and the Eastern European Jews more to do with tradition and survival, not really surprising. But Sfar is a wonderful storyteller and brings his characters to life, with humor and serious pathos at the same time, along with these...more
Sep 27, 2007 Kelly rated it 3 of 5 stars  ·  review of another edition Recommends it for: Sfar fans and those interested in an amusing but historical account of Klezmer
This was a bit of a bizarre read, but enjoyable enough. I'm a huge fan of Sfar from his Vampire Loves, and so I enjoyed the art fairly well since I'm a fan. The story was pretty good, as we have a good mix of interesting characters and slightly odd scenarios. We get to follow a newly-formed Klezmer group in the early 20th century as they get to know each other and travel around playing their music. However, a lot of the references went over my head because I know (or knew) absolutely nothing abo...more
The style and tone of this comic was really fun, and Sfar's notes and impressions at the end on klezmer and modern day Judaism were great. Very much looking forward to grabbing the next volumes.
Thomas Andrikus
What an odd graphic novel!

The fact that numerous people die tragically in the story even in the first few pages may lead one to dismiss it as another tragic history of the Jewish people. However, soon enough, one would discover that Klezmer is beyond that.

The drawing is a bit of chaos, but I guess such is the author Joann Sfar's style.

Somehow, the story goes between the introduction of individual characters before finally converging at the point where they are to play together as a band.

Sfar yet again shows us people's cruelty and tenderness, their playfulness, craftiness, their hard edges. I am no longer surprised by his ability to dive into the human condition through his varied Jewish background; he's spoiled me on it and set the bar for most of the rest of what I read these days. All of the characters have a richness about them, a realness. I was intrigued that Yaacov had so much in him of the cat from "The Rabbi's Cat." I thought myself clever for noticing, and then Sfar p...more
"I believe God loves those moments when we do without him." --Joann Sfar.

Another reason to adore Joann Sfar is his _Klezmer: Book One: Tales of the Wild East_. With light, quick hand and wit Sfar paints the tale of a ragged band of musicians and Yeshiva dropouts who sing folk songs as they travel from village to village. Their destination: Odessa, where an exotic, wealthy woman hires them to play at her mansion. Another set of hilarious, splotchy drawings illuminate the pages of _Klezmer_. The b...more
This is probably the best written, most involving book by Joann Sfar (though one could probably never call his books "involving" as their appeal usually lies in their utterly laid back, relaxed attitude) but it doesn't matter. The man has such a glorious way about his art that most of his books will rate highly with me. Still it doesn't hurt that he's a great writer of comics. This one is probably a 3 star one from me. Not as great as The Rabbi's Cat or as fun as Dungeon, but still, it is a) abo...more
The Ashkenazi flip side of The Rabbi's Cat. The visual style is a little looser (maybe intentionally Chagallesque) and the plot is sort of a "Seven Samurai" homage. I can imagine this book (with the cartoon full-frontal nudity) titillating Sam in 10 years. So, Sam Of The Future, I hereby consign this to the bookshelf for you to discover in years to come. You're welcome.

Now go listen to some klezmer music.
Mikael Kuoppala
Joann Sfar has delved into his North African heritage in the acclaimed series “The Rabbi’s Cat,” so it’s only natural for him to do the same with his Eastern European roots. Klezmer dives into the history of the region, offering a road trip kind of story structure with many different colourful characters. The feel is very much like that in “The Rabbi’s Cat,” but Klezmer does have its own distinctive flavour.
sweet pea
this book features an appealing cast of outcasts who haphazardly band together to form a band. the story is excellent and evokes an eastern europe long gone. the illustrations are fairly inchoate and often feature improbably bright colors. which keeps things interesting. the book just ends. which is fairly cruel as the rest of the series hasn't been translated into english yet.
Another fun book from Sfar -- can this guy slow down? Prolific -- and good -- two things that I think are very hard to accomplish. The only disappointing thing about this book is that it's the first in a series -- I thought it was a stand-alone story and then it's "to be continued". Not a bad thing, unless you're not expecting it going in.
A promising start to a new series. I liked the story, although it's more of a launch pad for the rest of the series, but actually preferred the Q&As with Safar at the end of the book. Also, I didn't like the style of illustrations (semi-abstract watercolours) as much as the illustrations in The Rabbi's Cat.
French graphic novelist Joann Sfar's story about ragtag outsiders who join to form a klezmer band is a joy. The art and story are very loose and flowing. His comments at the end are especially interesting about what klezmer and being Jewish mean today (to him, of course).
Urocze, zarówno rysunki jak i opowieść, byłoby więcej gwiazdek, ale język naprawdę nieciekawy - choć zakładam, że to wada polskiego tłumaczenia (co zresztą nie byłoby nowością, wydaje mi się, że może trochę lepiej, ale nadal średnio wyglądało od tej strony "Persepolis")
Eh. I was hoping for something more like Fiddler on the Roof, I suppose. Klezmer being the Jewish musical tradition. But I didn't like the characters, and hated the drawing style, it's all squiggles that you can hardly make out. Not my thing.
Mike Short
Sfar is always good. Doesn't dissapoint here. The art is pretty, very rough/sketchy in quick watercolor washes. works ok for this. The storytelling is solid 4 stars for the writing, 2 for the art. Looking forward to the next one
I love Joann Sfar. This is a great graphic story about Klezmer music by an amazing Ashkenazi and Sephardic Jewish artist. There is an interesting interview in the back where he also talks about his identity and politics--all good stuff!
Eric Orchard
Every time I read a book by Sfar I'm just blown away by his versatility, storytelling skills and drawing that seems to leap from the page. This comic is wonderful, I can't recommend it highly enough.
Beautiful, moving, and totally interesting. I enjoyed both the graphic novel part and the wee little essays at the back. My only complaint is that Parts 2 and 3 haven't been translated into English yet!
I like Sfar's depiction of 19th century Eastern Europe as some sort of wild land of outlaws and gun-toting klezmer musicians. However, I find his loose, scribbly drawing style to be too messy and simplistic.
Loosely drawn volume has two parallel stories - both are compelling, and the art is beautiful. Keep in mind this is book one, though... can't wait for the next installment!
With each piece I read I become a bigger fan of Joann Sfar. I love his stories, and I particularly liked the water coloring in Klezmer. Can't wait to read book two.
James Cradock
Good book. Loved the illustrations. I don't know if Sfar's text was translated (he's French), but I couldn't tell. Recommended.

Fantastic! The art is reminiscent of Quentin Blake and the story is dark and funny and illuminated.
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 15 16 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Glacial Period
  • Garage Band
  • The Property
  • Moomin, Vol. 2
  • Town Boy
  • To the Heart of the Storm
  • Dawn Land
  • Same Difference & Other Stories
  • A.L.I.E.E.E.N.: Archives of Lost Issues and Earthly Editions of Extraterrestrial Novelties
  • The Arctic Marauder
  • Sloth
  • Journey Into Mohawk Country
  • A Child's Life and Other Stories
  • Les Quantités négligeables (Le combat ordinaire, #2)
  • The Wrong Place
  • Salamander Dream
  • The Golem's Mighty Swing
Joann Sfar (born August 28, 1971 in Nice) is a French comics artist, comic book creator, and film director.

Sfar is considered one of the most important artists of the new wave of Franco-Belgian comics. Many of his comics were published by L'Association which was founded in 1990 by Jean-Christophe Menu and six other artists. He also worked together with many of the new movement's main artists, e.g....more
More about Joann Sfar...
The Rabbi's Cat Le Petit Prince The Professor's Daughter Vampire Loves (Grand Vampire, #1-4) The Rabbi's Cat 2

Share This Book

“I believe God loves those moments when we do without him.” 4 likes
More quotes…