135th out of 1,123 books
—
1,900 voters
The Iowa Baseball Confederacy
Bearing W.P. Kinsella's trademark combination of "sweet-natured prose and a richly imagined world" (Philadelphia Inquirer), The Iowa Baseball Confederacy tells the story of Gideon Clark, a man on a quest. He is out to prove to the world that the indomitable Chicago Cubs traveled to Iowa in the summer of 1908 for an exhibition game against an amateur league, the Iowa Baseba...more
Paperback, 310 pages
Published
March 14th 2003
by Mariner Books
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
1,249)
I just reread this book, wondering whether or not this time, if I paid very careful attention, I'd come to understand what really happened. Forlorn hope!
I guess that W.P. Kinsella is best known for Shoeless Joe, on which the movie Field of Dreams was based. If you know that film, the blend of baseball nostalgia with magical realism in Iowa Baseball Confederacy will feel familiar, in a good way.
Here, the neighbors consider our protagonist eccentric because of his obsession with the titular small-...more
I guess that W.P. Kinsella is best known for Shoeless Joe, on which the movie Field of Dreams was based. If you know that film, the blend of baseball nostalgia with magical realism in Iowa Baseball Confederacy will feel familiar, in a good way.
Here, the neighbors consider our protagonist eccentric because of his obsession with the titular small-...more
The Iowa Baseball Confederacy was about baseball and took place in Iowa, both pros in my world. However, it also involved a lot of magic and science fiction bullshit, which is a definite con.
The story follows a man whose father has passed on a bunch of information about this supposed baseball league that existed and beat the 1908 Chicago Cubs (one of the best baseball teams in history). The problem is that no one but this man and his father believe it exists. The son ends up losing his wife and...more
The story follows a man whose father has passed on a bunch of information about this supposed baseball league that existed and beat the 1908 Chicago Cubs (one of the best baseball teams in history). The problem is that no one but this man and his father believe it exists. The son ends up losing his wife and...more
Apr 07, 2011
Henrik Brameus
rated it
5 of 5 stars
Recommended to Henrik by:
Claes Brameus
Shelves:
favorites
W.P Kinsella is not your normal author. He's Canadian, and likes to write about baseball. But it's baseball with a twist. As a metaphor for life, and with some magic woven into it. If you think "Field of Dreams" you are close. It was based on another of his books.
The Iowa Baseball Confederacy is my favorite of the Kinsella books I've read. It has a deep and intricate weave of characters and events. At the same time it has some quirky episodes that will pop into your head when you least expect it...more
The Iowa Baseball Confederacy is my favorite of the Kinsella books I've read. It has a deep and intricate weave of characters and events. At the same time it has some quirky episodes that will pop into your head when you least expect it...more
This is a delightful little book, one of the most enjoyable I have read in quite some time. Gideon Clarke has spent his entire life, as did his father before him, trying to prove the existence of the Iowa Baseball Confederacy, a baseball league that existed in 1908. He knows all of the facts and statistics concerning the players and the league, including the knowledge that the Chicago Cubs played the Confereracy All-Stars in an exhibition game that was played in the pouring rain, and lasted for...more
My apologies for the false promises I made when I said that I would be able to turn more of my focus to this blog. There are extenuating circumstances, I assure you.
Regardless, here I am.
Now, for those of you not even remotely familiar with the genre of fantasy baseball fiction (and I mean fantasy in the literary genre sense of the word, not the fantasy sports sense of the word), W.P. Kinsella is the man who wrote the novel Shoeless Joe--which one of my favorite sports films Field of Dreams was...more
Regardless, here I am.
Now, for those of you not even remotely familiar with the genre of fantasy baseball fiction (and I mean fantasy in the literary genre sense of the word, not the fantasy sports sense of the word), W.P. Kinsella is the man who wrote the novel Shoeless Joe--which one of my favorite sports films Field of Dreams was...more
Baseball lends itself to obsession. From young boys spending every dime of their allowance money on trading cards to grown men spending every spare moment crunching numbers in a pursuit of the perfect metric, the game's hold runs deep.
Gideon Clarke's fixation is more specific than most. Convinced that the Chicago Cubs visited his hometown in 1908 for an epic exhibition game against a collection of all-stars from a competent but relatively obscure circuit known as the Iowa Baseball Confederacy, h...more
Gideon Clarke's fixation is more specific than most. Convinced that the Chicago Cubs visited his hometown in 1908 for an epic exhibition game against a collection of all-stars from a competent but relatively obscure circuit known as the Iowa Baseball Confederacy, h...more
Holy cats, where to start? The "I'm not albino, I'm just really pale and have shoulder-length white hair and blue eyes!" protagonist? The grating "My special divine knowledge is right but everyone thinks I'm crazy!" plot? The utter flatness of the female characters, all of whom are either sex objects or sexless mother figures? The actual mystical Indian whose "power vision" is of a game of baseball? I would like to believe that Gideon Clarke is a parody, but Kinsella is so damn earnest that ther...more
I purchased this book based on the movie Field of Dreams. So, it's not exactly what the movie was based on - that was Shoeless Joe. I couldn't afford Shoeless Joe, so I bought this one instead. Same author AND it's about baseball... so, it'll drive me to tears and reduce me to some quivering emotional mass. So, not really... however, the book does offer up some magical realism in slow pitch softball form. The depiction of a 2,000 inning game are glorious... it truly is a game that has not change...more
This is the first book of Kinsella's work I have read. Being that I am a big baseball fan, and that "Field of Dreams" (based on Kinsella's novel "Shoeless Joe") is one of my favorite movies, it's kind of sad that it took me so long to get around to this.
For a rundown on the book, I use the review from Publishers Weekly via Amazon.Com:
For a rundown on the book, I use the review from Publishers Weekly via Amazon.Com:
On the day he met his true love, a carnival performer named Darling Maudie, Matthew Clarke was literally struck by lightning and magically imbued with the knowledg...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Lets see. Where to begin...
There are levels of suspending reality which separate some works of fiction from others. There is the level of Harry Potter, in which we have to believe that magic exists, there is the level of Chronicles of Narnia in which we have to believe in portals to other worlds, and there are pretty simple suspensions of reality like Forrest Gump, in which we have to believe that one "special" man could accomplish all of those incredible things.
Then there is the complete suspe...more
There are levels of suspending reality which separate some works of fiction from others. There is the level of Harry Potter, in which we have to believe that magic exists, there is the level of Chronicles of Narnia in which we have to believe in portals to other worlds, and there are pretty simple suspensions of reality like Forrest Gump, in which we have to believe that one "special" man could accomplish all of those incredible things.
Then there is the complete suspe...more
Sometimes suspension of belief can ruin a story. Not so in this case. This is the Kinsella book that should have been made into a movie. I found myself caught up in a world where baseball as myth and religion melds into an almost believable formula. This book more than any other I have read, finally taught me why I love baseball so much. A game could go on forever. The romanticism about the game touched me deeply and I found myself believing that pro baseball could be great again.
The story extended the boundaries of reality in a dreamlike way that gave even the most unbelievable situations and characters a footing in reality. The story could have been better if it hadn't taken on so many fantastical elements from page 222 through the end. Also, the author seemed to be making attempts at allegory throughout the book, but he didn't make them obvious enough for me to understand much of it. Even still, the abstracted reality presented in this story was good enough for four s...more
I loved Shoeless Joe and when this one appeared on our staff favorites shelf, I grabbed it. It is a strangely compelling story of a baseball game that "never" happened, but was really a titanic battle of wills. It goes even farther out there than Shoeless Joe and not quite as heartwarming, but still a really good read!
It took me a long time to warm up to this story - at first it just seemed creepy and sad. I was also disappointed to discover that it was straight-up magical fantasy, though I wouldn't have minded had I known that going in. I enjoyed the baseball parts. I was utterly confused by the ending - not a clue what that was.
I am not a big sports fan, or of books about them, but I really enjoyed this book. It had a lot of the feeling like 'Field of Dreams' but not exactly the same story. There was some weird stuff at the end, which was a bit disconnected (for me) from the rest of the story, but still overall an enjoyable read.
I haven't read this book in many years, so I was surprised by some of the things I didn't remember about The Iowa Baseball Confederacy. In some ways I was disappointed that it wasn't as I remembered but I was greatly surprised by other things in the book. I forgot how strong the magical realism is throughout the book. Also the way that Kinsella weaves baseball, religion, and mysticism together and was very excellent. They all go together when one looks right down it.
I still think Shoeless Joe is...more
I still think Shoeless Joe is...more
The overly sentimental writing and the unfortunate use of magic as a central plot device in a more or less believable story really bother me about Kinsella's writing. The Iowa Baseball Confederacy is a great example of Kinsella killing a great idea by going just a little too far with the spiritual/magical/time travel business.
This book just seemed like a haphazard assembly of half-baked story ideas that could have been interesting on their own if developed properly.
On a semi-related side note,...more
This book just seemed like a haphazard assembly of half-baked story ideas that could have been interesting on their own if developed properly.
On a semi-related side note,...more
What a fun book! Also a bit confusing, however. I really loved all of the baseball + time travel + historical figures (Teddy Roosevelt, Leonardo da Vinci). But some of the other characters, such as Sunny, bothered me, and I didn't get the thing about Sarah getting stuck. The ending kind of lost me. Still, left me feeling pretty happy with it.
About a baseball game only two men remember anything about (including the stats, scores and players), but which was never recorded in written history... Great story.
Baseball, magic, and mysticism keep this from being anything like an ordinary story. There were things I loved about it - the analogies that were as thick as heat lightening in an Iowa summer, the easy flow between the real and the unreal - but in the end there just wasn't enough of a narrative drive to keep me completely engaged. My favorite parts involved the women in Gideon's life, and for me there just weren't enough of those sections to outweigh the rest. In the interest of fairness, I must...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
William Patrick Kinsella, OC, OBC is a Canadian novelist and short story writer. His work has often concerned baseball and Canada's First Nations and other Canadian issues.
William Patrick Kinsella was born to John Matthew Kinsella and Olive Kinsella in Edmonton, Alberta. Kinsella was raised until he was 10 years-old at a homestead near Darwell, Alberta, 60 km west of the city, home-schooled by his...more
More about W.P. Kinsella...
William Patrick Kinsella was born to John Matthew Kinsella and Olive Kinsella in Edmonton, Alberta. Kinsella was raised until he was 10 years-old at a homestead near Darwell, Alberta, 60 km west of the city, home-schooled by his...more
Share This Book
No trivia or quizzes yet. Add some now »

Loading...



































