Miss Garnet's Angel
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating

Miss Garnet's Angel

3.67 of 5 stars 3.67  ·  rating details  ·  1,402 ratings  ·  200 reviews
After the death of her longtime friend and flatmate, retired British history teacher Julia Garnet does something completely out of character: She takes a six-month rental on a modest appartamento in Venice. An atheist, a Communist, and a virgin, Julia finds herself falling beneath the seductive spell of the city's intoxicating beauty and sensual religiosity. She befriends...more
Paperback, 352 pages
Published April 2nd 2002 by Plume (first published 2000)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
Othello by William ShakespeareThe Merchant of Venice by William ShakespeareDeath in Venice and Other Tales by Thomas MannThe City of Falling Angels by John BerendtIn the Company of the Courtesan by Sarah Dunant
Books Set in Venice
13th out of 186 books — 102 voters
One Hundred Years of Solitude by Gabriel Garcí­a MárquezThe Time Traveler's Wife by Audrey NiffeneggerThe House of the Spirits by Isabel AllendeLike Water for Chocolate by Laura EsquivelLove in the Time of Cholera by Gabriel Garcí­a Márquez
Favorite Magical Realist Novels
285th out of 654 books — 3,245 voters

More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 2,251)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Peg Lafrance
I found this book at a used bookstore in Peterborough, Ontario, Canada, while on vacation. I thought the subject - Venice, an English spinster, life changes - attractive. But the blurb reviews really recommended it to me. Penelope Fitzgerald, Joanna Trollope, and Anita Brookner all liked it. Atlantic Monthly mentioned similarities to Barbara Pym.

The book incorporates a story from the Apocrypha. It does it subtly, unfolding the biblical tale as the story of Miss Garnet's life blossoms. The chara...more
Jan 11, 2010 Marfita rated it 2 of 5 stars Recommends it for: fans of Dan Brown who suddenly realized what a lousy writer he is
I went into this with all my warning lights flashing: it's gonna be spiritual (and I'm not), "oh god, there's gonna be romance" (ew); and "she's gonna see angels, isn't she?" This was probably unfair to the author, but that hasn't stopped me before.
Miss Julia Garnet is a rather stupid woman who becomes fascinated by a story from the Apocrypha when she could be enjoying the endless art of Venice. She also has very bad "gay-dar." Vickers tries to interweave these two stories but as the outcome of...more
Delia O' Riordan
Julia Garnet is sixty years old, emotionally repressed, sexually inexperienced and has spent her life in almost sacrificial frugality. She is also the amazed heir to her former - even more frugal - housemate's legacy. Harriet seems to have had a secret: a genius for investment! Who knew? Certainly not Julia Garnet.

Both Julia and Harriet were dutifully pro-labour, even deriving a sense of moral superiority - or at least moral purity - from the connection. But beneath the austere surface, Julia Ga...more
Kathleen Dixon
A friend recommended Salley Vickers to me, and most especially this book. It’s often said that history repeats itself, and I have enjoyed a number of books where this is the theme, or where archetypal themes play out in people’s lives (I’m remembering Beauty, by Sheri Tepper).

Julia Garnet is a thoroughly straightlaced and cautious elderly woman who was a schoolteacher and is now very recently retired. Her flatmate, Harriet, dies 2 days after they both retired, and the elderly cat, that has lived...more
A friend recently said to me, "So many things are not worth talking about." He was referring to the quiet power of the understated, and the British have a tradition of novels about the still small voices, and the profound yet ordinary emotions, that sometimes get short shrift amid the fireworks of our soap-opera culture. From Jane Austen E.M Fortsre to Kazuo Ishiguro, these novels remind us of how interior and how subtle much of our emotional experience actually is. In writers like Barbara Pym,...more
Miss Garnet's Angel is the gentle story of Julia Garnet, a retired teacher, and her transformation in old age when she moves to Venice for six months following the death of her life-long friend. Out of her suburban English comfort zone, she allows people, paintings and the place itself to touch her soul for the first time. There's much to like, including Julia Garnet herself, and the Venice backdrop is atmospheric and evocative.

However, having read other Vickers' novels and thus armed with high...more
(3.5 stars) Miss Garnet, a recently retired English school teacher does one of the more impulsive things in her life by renting a flat in Venice after the unexpected death of her flat-mate, Harriet. She surprises herself by making friends and becoming intrigued by not only the architecture, but the churches, despite her long time involvement with communism. Her new companions include an American couple, her land lady and boy related to her, and two young people who are restoring a chapel near he...more
M.M. Bennetts
This review was originally published in The Christian Science Monitor.

Impelled into action by the unexpected passing of her closest and only friend, Harriet, the staid retired teacher, Miss Julia Garnet, lets her London flat and goes to Venice, renting a small apartment in the Campo Angelo Raffaele for six months. Thus opens Salley Vickers’ quiet, rich, benign and gentle novel, Miss Garnet’s Angel.

There, Venice–la Serenissima–city of bridges, barges, campaniles, Renaissance art and palaces, of b...more
This is a surprising book.... A story of personal growth late in life and an awakening to spirtiual things in an unexpected way. Miss Garnet, a devote communist, enters the scene as a strict, stern and rather miserly old school marm, one who has never left anything to chance & who has always been caustic and cynical from the sound of it. She uncharacteristically goes to Venice after her life long housemate dies and here she discovers in herself unexpected capacity to see things anew, to make...more
Part travel log, part fiction, part bible story, interwoven so beautifully. Miss Garnet coming of age as a spinster in Venice, very touching but not sappy and although it's about someone finding her faith one is not hit over the head with the religious aspect of the book. One I will surely read again.
Prim, English spinster travels to Venice where she loses her preconceptions and finds her angel. I liked it a lot and find it hard to top this review http://us.penguingroup.com/static/rgu...
At last a wonderful book. Loved this, the story of the awakening of a retired spinster, who travels to Venice, and becomes fascinated with the angel Raphael. A story with many layers.
Aimee Habibullah
To be frank, I didn't like this book. The author writes patronisingly about elderly, single, retired women teachers and their feelings, emotions and experiences. You wouldn't have thought that Julia had had anything to do with young people the way the author makes her talk and interact with the twins. The story of Tobias and the angel is a separate one on its own and by interlacing it with the novel the device slows down the narrative.I almost gave up reading this novel but persevered out of a m...more
Retired spinster Julia Garnet has been an uninspiring history teacher and lives a narrow life in an Ealing flat with her friend Harriet. When Harriet dies, the unexpected void causes Miss Garnet to suddenly decide to live in Venice for several months. The move leads to Miss Garnet meeting new people and realising that she has been blind to people and opportunities. The interwoven parallel apocryphal story of Tobias and the Angel Raphael share the theme of overcoming blindness and accepting chang...more
Miss Julia Garnet, spinster and virgin, travels to Venice after the death of her friend Harriet. She discovers more than solace there, something more akin to an awakening. It’s a beautiful premise and is artfully executed, and Venice is the ideal, sumptuous setting for this intriguing mix of stories that Julia’s tale entwines with – my favourite character is the wise and delightful Monsignore Giuseppe, whose presence brings a kindness and affability to the story which I really loved, but while s...more
Sep 16, 2012 Norah rated it 4 of 5 stars Recommends it for: Sue Brown
There is something very old-fashioned and reassuring about Sally Vickers' novel Miss Garnet's Angel. The themes, self-discovery and redemption have the air of a bygone age, despite the novel being set in contemporary Venice in a world of holiday apartment lets and Pizza Express-funded restoration works. Julia Garnet is a middle-aged woman who has been practising economies of the spirit for years. Hers is a closed-in world, dusty with Marx's theories and when her friend and flatmate of 30 years d...more
There were some moments of greatness in this book, a tale of an British history teacher who goes to Venice for six months after her long term housemate dies suddenly. That Julia is a spinster, atheist, virgin, and Communist doesn't make much of a difference as Venice seduces her. She falls in love for the first time in her life (and no, it doesn't end like that, meets a pair of art restorers and a fair number of locals. But her real fascination is with the Archangel Raphael and the story of Tobi...more
This is a delightful story of an english schoolteacher (history) who retires on the same day as her housemate and then is devasted by her sudden death a few months later. Julia Garnet then decides to spend some months in Venice and the story takes off. She rediscovers an old master painting of Tobias and the Angel (and dog) which is based on the book of Tobit (you need an apochrypha if you are protestant though jewish, catholic and orthodox bibles include it).

Julia's story is intermingled with S...more
This review originally appeared at www.readinasinglesitting.com

For someone whose background involves copious amounts of Jungian psychoanalysis, it's no surprise that Salley Vickers in her work so frequently touches on notions of the development of self, and on individual narrative journeys in order to reach a greater sense of consciousness and agency. While Vickers has in some of her work, such as the tremendously eruditeThe Other Side of You (see our review),done this by means of the presentati...more
Good read...may change the rating. This sucked me in right away, the best part of the beginning is the main character's unfamiliarity with new experiences and her newfound enjoyment of other people and life.The characters are all created well, but the main lady Miss Garnet is complex and honest. She has freed herself from her old life in England and her adventures in Venice, its art and religion has started to shift her mind to question everything about herself. Her notes in her journal as she t...more
Miss Garnet's Angel is a book of luminous beauty which I have known and loved for 12 years, and which always reminds me how to see goodness beyond the immediately obvious. The book's heroine visits Venice for her first time, late in life, and discovers not just the treasures and beauties of the city but something deeper and more real within herself than she has ever known before. It is not too fanciful to say that in Venice, Julia Garnet discovers her soul.

But there is more to it than that. Ther...more
Jacquelynn Luben
At first sight, the latest book circle read - Miss Garnet’s Angel by Salley Vickers seems comparable with another book we read, Miss Pettigrew lives for a day, another story of an elderly or middle aged lady whose life we hope is going to be transformed.

It seems immediately like a feel-good book, and in fact, initially, things go rather too swimmingly for Miss Garnet. She seems to make friends so easily in Venice, one begins to wonder why she couldn’t manage it so well in the UK.

Perhaps this is...more
Philip Dickinson
Miss Garnet's Angel began promisingly. The bereavement of a close friend and the move to Venice seemed like the start of something very exotic. I've been to Venice and read up on some of it's history so I was keen to see what strangeness Salley Vickers would brew up. Dark intrigue and who knows what. The descriptions took me back to that fantastic city and I was always eager to see where Julia would wander next.

I liked the way Salley put Julia's life together and built up a picture of what thos...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it, click here.
I enjoyed this partly because it was a re-read. I'm such a lazy, speed-read-for-the-plot reader that a second read allows me to enjoy the structure and ideas more. Here, the interweaving of the Tobias and Angel Raphael story reinforced the ideas about 'blindness' and coming to enjoy life - it also slowed the pace nicely, gave our cautious heroine another dimension, and took us out of an occasionally claustrophobic Venice.

I'm always asking for maps in books. This has a map of Venice. But I'm sti...more
Andy Kabanoff
Beautifully written multi-layered novel tracing a retired woman English teacher going to spend six months in Venice and having her life and her ideas transformed by meetings with people and with the art and history and the atmosphere of the city. In some ways I saw it as a much more subtle attempt at what Fowles does so incredibly well in The Magus – except that I could not fully identify with the protagonist . . . The story – Tobit in the Apocrypha – works very well, enriching the narrative.
Natalie Saar
I read this just before I myself went to Venice, and loved it. Sally Vickers seems to effortlessly and seamlessly integrate threads of plots from the past and present... Simply moving and beautifully written. Julia Garnet, the protaganist, is elderly, shy and intoverted - a reserved person who represents an unprominent sector of society seldom visited in literature. As a person with introvert tendencies myself, I found the slow and gradual progress of such a character's spiritual awakening and m...more
I loved this book. The main attraction for me was its setting - Venice. It is somewhere I have always wanted to visit, and Salley Vickers' descriptions have made me want to go there even more.
The story concerns Julia Garnet, a retired school teacher who is somewhat set in her ways. She has shared her home with her friend Harriet for many years, and when Harriet dies, Julia finds herself at a loss. She makes an unusually spontaneous decision to rent out her house and go and live in Venice for a f...more
I found this book while on holiday in Venice, and since the whole story takes place in the mythical Lion City, I picked it up without knowing anything about its author - apparently quite a popular writer in her native Great Britain. Good choice. Miss Garnet's Angel is a delightful, charming, often touching novel which reminded me sometimes of the E.M.Forster's novels taking place in Italy, or of the delectable Enchanted April. In this sense, there's something very British about this book, and th...more
This was a very unusual book. Vickers obviously has a love of myths, legends and Biblical stories. This book unravels the story of the Archangel Raphael. It is extremely well researched and is based on the book of Tobias from the Apocrypha. This story is unravelled by Miss Garnet, an elderly Briton who travels to Venice after the death of her friend. Through the people she meets, the beauty of Venice and the experiences she has, she learns for the first time about beauty, love and generosity. Ho...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 75 76 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • Eve Green
  • Summer Bird Cage, the
  • A Stopover in Venice
  • Stone Virgin
  • As It Is In Heaven
  • Archipelago
  • The Bay of Noon
  • Day
  • Venice
  • The Dark Heart of Italy
  • Stone in a Landslide
  • The Mark Of The Angel
  • The Pleasing Hour
  • Rector's Wife
  • Crampton Hodnet
  • Painting and Experience in Fifteenth-Century Italy: A Primer in the Social History of Pictorial Style (Oxford Paperbacks)
  • Left Bank
  • Various Pets Alive and Dead
Salley Vickers was born in Liverpool, the home of her mother, and grew up as the child of parents in the British Communist Party. She won a state scholarship to St Paul’s Girl’s School and went on to read English at Newnham College Cambridge.

She has worked, variously, as a cleaner, a dancer, an artist’s model, a teacher of children with special needs, a university teacher of literature, and a psy...more
More about Salley Vickers...
The Other Side of You Mr Golightly's Holiday Instances of the Number 3 The Cleaner of Chartres Where Three Roads Meet: The Myth of Oedipus (Canongate Myths)

Share This Book

“Then it was she saw him again. On the upper reaches of the scaffolding, a sheerness of presence, no more. It was as if he took the space from the air about him and against the darkness was etched, like the brightness which seeps through a door ajar, hinting at nameless, fathomless brilliances beyond, the slightest margin of light. Impossible to look too closely, but some way below, beneath where the long feet might have rested, she made out the girl's huddled shape, her arms folded over her head like some small broken-winged, storm-tossed bird.” 1 likes
More quotes…