Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read.
Start by marking “When Heaven and Earth Changed Places: A Vietnamese Woman's Journey from War to Peace” as Want to Read:
When Heaven and Earth Changed Places: A Vietnamese Woman's Journey from War to Peace
Enlarge cover
Rate this book
Clear rating
Open Preview

When Heaven and Earth Changed Places: A Vietnamese Woman's Journey from War to Peace

4.08  ·  Rating Details ·  2,226 Ratings  ·  223 Reviews
It is said that in war heaven and earth change places not once, but many times. When Heaven and Earth Changed Places is the haunting memoir of a girl on the verge of womanhood in a world turned upside down.

The youngest of six children in a close-knit Buddhist family, Le Ly Hayslip was twelve years old when U.S. helicopters landed in Ky La, her tiny village in central Vietn
Paperback, 400 pages
Published November 1st 1993 by Plume (first published April 29th 1989)
More Details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.

Reader Q&A

To ask other readers questions about When Heaven and Earth Changed Places, please sign up.

Be the first to ask a question about When Heaven and Earth Changed Places

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  Rating Details
Jul 26, 2007 Rebecca rated it it was amazing
This book is the closest I have ever come to understanding the horror of war. You are in the story and with her the whole time.
Dec 16, 2008 Eric_W rated it really liked it
Part of the problem reading history is that sometimes one tends to look at the overall picture; the strategic view, rather than the impact of an event on the individual Le Ly Hayslip has recounted her family's personal experiences during the Vietnam war from the perspective of those caught in the middle. Her story portrays the agony of the destruction of a centuries-old way of life and the ruination of a country. The village she lived in, Ky La, was just a tiny fanning village, one surely no one ...more
Aug 03, 2013 Kathy rated it really liked it
If you are planning a trip to Vietnam....this book is a must read. Author wrote her memoir in 1989, telling of her childhood during the Vietnam War. Family members served on different sides. Continues to her life as a young woman surviving in the war torn country....and then her escape to the United States. She returns to Vietnam in 1986, to visit family and to gather material for her book. How had life changed? Who do you trust. I thank Nancy B. for recommending this book. What will we find whe ...more
Oct 05, 2015 Amy rated it it was amazing
Shelves: non-fiction, memoir
This book is the closest I will ever get to understanding my father's childhood as a peasant in South Vietnam during the war that Americans know as the Vietnam War and the Vietnamese know as the American War.

I heard vaguer, child-censored versions of my dad's stories of the pressures of two sides (Viet Cong & Republican) in his village, and the euphemism of being taken away for "personal discussion" by the Viet Cong, but reading this memoir of a woman with different-yet-similar experiences d
Mar 19, 2009 Kay rated it it was amazing
We all know war is a bad thing, but reading this book really gives an insight as to how it damages the land over which its raged. The way community and life is ripped to pieces and the fabric of society unravels and is rewoven as something less appealing is well portrayed. To come through this and be able to share the story as well as attempt to rebuild and heal says a lot for the authoress.

The violence is never glorified, nor is the atrocities, but told in a way that taps into your emotions and
Michael Andersen-Andrade
Feb 22, 2014 Michael Andersen-Andrade rated it it was amazing
There are no winners or losers in war, just victims and survivors. Le Ly Hayslip brings the agony and hardship of the Vietnam War to life. I read this book in and around Da Nang, where much of the book takes place. Her book brought those streets and villages alive and populated them with the ghosts of her family and her people. Vietnam was forever altered by the war. While all sides contributed to the suffering, it is clear that the United States had no business in Vietnam and its rationalizatio ...more
Jan 02, 2010 ABC rated it really liked it
Shelves: teens-and-adults
This book was hard to read at times, so I put it down and took a break from torture, rape, and the horrible deaths contained in its pages. However, it is DEFINITELY worth reading to get one woman's viewpoint of the situation in Vietnam during the sixties. I like that she seems unbiased. She does not particulary seem to take the side of the North, or the South, or the Americans. (Although she did become American, and seems patriotic to both Viet Nam and the U.S.)

If you live in a country where vi
Tammy Stathelson
Apr 09, 2015 Tammy Stathelson rated it it was amazing
This is actually the first book I think I have ever read about the Vietnam War. It certainly gives a different perspective than that of an American GI. I have always believed this war was simply about the spread of communism and how we, the American People, had to stop it at all cost. Those were some pretty high costs and I don't think we accomplished much of anything except the loss of life on both the American and Vietnamese sides.
Megan Sharma
Jul 22, 2007 Megan Sharma rated it it was amazing  ·  review of another edition
Recommends it for: everyone!
This is the truly amazing story of a woman who grew up in central vietnam during the war and eventually found her way to America. Excellently written, terrifying and extremely poignant, it's hard to believe that anyone could go through so much and still have any faith in the human spirit. Seriously--it's sounds like depressing subject matter, but this is a must read.
Feb 17, 2017 Alisa rated it liked it
I have mixed feelings about this book. It literally took me years to read---because it didn't grab my attention and beg to be read every day. After visiting Vietnam, I wanted to understand the war from a local's perspective, and I think this book achieves this exactly. The author grows up in a central village that is torn between the Viet Cong and Republican (the side the US was on) forces--and they have to feign allegiance to both of them at different times, in order to survive. I believe it ga ...more
Jim Drewery
Dec 22, 2013 Jim Drewery rated it it was amazing
The author does a splendid job of revealing to the reader the horrors of war and how the untold casualties of any war are inevitably not just those who serve in combat, but the millions of innocent people whose lives are forever uprooted and irrevocably altered by the hell on earth that is war. She shows clearly how war is very much like a terrible disease which devours the humanity from its participants and shows no mercy to any innocent which has the misfortune to end up in its path. Through ...more
Megan Brizzell
Mar 19, 2013 Megan Brizzell rated it it was amazing
For my research paper on Vietnam I chose to read the book "When Heaven and Earth Changed Places: A Vietnamese Woman's Journey from War to Peace". Though at times the book was extremely graphic, I enjoyed it thoroughly.

The narrator, Le Ly, is the youngest of six children born to peasant farmers in Ka Ly, a town on the central coast of Vietnam. Since she is the sixth child, her name actually means "sixth child" so her parents would know who she is. She has a close relationship with her parents, w
Nov 14, 2016 Alba rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
It was a very fascinated read. I felt bad for her through her whole journey and was glad when it was over. It gave me anther insight of the war.
Jan 03, 2017 Lisa rated it really liked it
This is rather humorous. I read this book 22 years ago while we lived in Singapore. Maybe I will read it again as I have had it in Goodreads as "to read." This was the first book I ever read on the Vietnam War. I was in Elementary school and Junior High and even High School during the war. I did not understand much at that time but I remember each night when my father watched the CBS Evening news, Walter Cronkite would share how many Americans died that day. For me the war became personal when m ...more
Sep 28, 2016 Laurelle rated it it was amazing
This is one of my favourite books. I bought a badly printed version off a beggar child in a Vietnamese bar because I felt sorry for him. I didn't expect to devour it! I have lots of books in storage but this one always comes with me when I move.
David P
Nov 29, 2012 David P rated it really liked it
A remarkable, fascinating autobiography by a Vietnamese woman. Le Ly was a peasant girl in a rice-paddy village near Danang, and she lived precariously throughout the Vietnam war. It is all there--Viet-Cong terror, escape to the city, life on the fringes of the US army, also poverty, temptation, violent death and rape, as well as insights into Vietnam's culture, centering on Buddhist traditions and warm extended families.

It is strong stuff, made just a bit more palatable by the way Le Ly inter
Le Ly writes two intersecting stories: One is of her time growing up in war-torn Vietnam (she was born in 1949) with her large family. She gives us a taste of what a farm girl in Vietnam's life is like, the struggles she had to endure time and time again, and the lust of man throughout it all. The second is of her visit back to her family in Vietnam in 1986, after being in the US since 1970.

I have read a bunch of books written by people who were children or teens in wars in Asian countries, but
The Literary Bystander
Nov 28, 2011 The Literary Bystander marked it as will-come-back-to-someday
Shelves: owned-books
Okay I am just going to put this as DNF because it has been on my currently reading list for way too long and considering how many other books I've zoomed past while this stayed the same for so long, yeah... it's probably saying something.

It's not the case, like Little Dorrit where I couldn't finish because it was just mind-numbingly uninteresting for me to continue. I think I'm just in some reading slump/being a major procrastinator and overall lazy bum. We can all crucify me later.

I will proba
Kelly Lynn Thomas
Reading for my Vietnam Travel Seminar. I would recommend this for anyone who's read a little bit of literature about the Vietnam war from the U.S. perspective, as this book gives you the Vietnamese perspective.

The first 90 pages or so go a bit slow as she sets up the culture and establishes what it means to be a poor village farmer in Vietnam. And then horrible things start to happen, and don't stop happening until the end. The author's village, Ky La, is forced to declare loyalty to one side d
Dec 02, 2014 Shannon rated it it was amazing
In the epilogue to this book--a tale of seemingly unending devastation; a book recounting one woman's experience with the total warping and decimation of the entire country of Vietnam, in which each page seems to offer a fresh perspective on horror and the fresh ripping-apart of ancient cultural bonds and loving families by both "sides" as it were, of the war--the author, Le Ly Hayslip, offers these simple paragraphs:

"In this book, I have tried to show how we peasants survived--and still survive
Oct 16, 2013 Rob rated it it was amazing
This book is a very moving account of what it was like for many Vietnamese who lived in the war zone of South Vietnam.

While this is the very moving account of Le Ly Hayslip's life, it could probable be retold buy any number of women who have lived in the war zones of Iraq or Afghanistan, or any other half dozen countries around the world.

While many events took place in Ms Hayslip's life (and certainly any number could have been the source of great personal devastation to someone of lessor inner
Billy Marino
Nov 08, 2013 Billy Marino rated it it was amazing
This book was both hard to put down and sometimes hard to keep reading. It is great for anyone who is interested in learning about the Vietnam War, and for those who just want to read a gripping personal story of a woman suffering through countless hardships but managing to be a compassionate and understanding person. I read this book as part of a class on the Vietnam War, and found it to be a great component to view the war from the the eyes of those it was supposedly being fought for. Le Ly Ha ...more
Kathy Piselli
Feb 09, 2016 Kathy Piselli rated it really liked it  ·  review of another edition
Hayslip's philosophical autobiography and call to action was published in 1989, but the final events took place in 1986, the year free-market reformists came to power, ushering in a wave of capitalism. Today, the country continues to seesaw in search of a balance of the values of socialism and those of capitalism. Knowing this in 2016, it was interesting to read about the inception of that wave. But even better was the autobiography of a Vietnamese peasant who lived through the French and later ...more
Sep 18, 2016 Katie rated it liked it
Heartbreaking and difficult to read for long periods of time. The fact that Le Ly lived and was able to escape to America during the Vietnam War is nothing short of a miracle. She had a sad, difficult life in Vietnam, violated and brutalized as a child by the Republican Army, the Viet Cong, and later, American soldiers.

Le Ly presents her story in two alternating timelines: the first begins with her birth and leads to her eventual escape, and the second begins with her return to Vietnam to reconn
Jul 12, 2014 Adna rated it liked it
I found an old summary/review of this book when I read it as a school assignment:

After Le Ly Hayslip's brother Bon went North she began to pay more attention to her father, and they became closer and closer. She found out about new, loving side of him, and very protective and strong person. Because of his honesty, his empathy, and his openness to people, he understood life deeply. He was the more understanding parent.

"... even as a parent, my father was more lenient than our mother, and we som
Apr 20, 2010 Jileen rated it really liked it
Definitely a book that keeps you turning pages. And just when you think it can't get any worse... it does.

My father fought in the Vietnam war and never really talked about it. He did have tons of slides (you know, the old slide/projector shows before VCRs...) It was very interesting to me to learn about this foreign country that I saw so many slides of. Their culture, the beliefs, the ideals that were important to Vietnamese families and their ancestors. Fascinating!

I have felt so badly for the
David Cupples
Apr 05, 2013 David Cupples rated it it was amazing
Another book I read in Vietnam around the time of the Millennium (or shortly thereafter). It is of course the basis for the Oliver Stone movie Heaven and Earth and the author, Le Ly Hayslip, the model for the film's main character. How cool that Stone one way or the other stumbled up Hayslip's book and decided to turn it into a movie. How cool also to read a book about Vietnam written by a Vietnamese. In my recollection she took pains to be even-handed when it came to dishing against both sides, ...more
Samuel Burt
Oct 25, 2010 Samuel Burt rated it really liked it

When heaven and earth changes is an emotional roller coaster of former Viet-Cong member Le Ly Hayslip. The book is split between present and past memories in her life, telling you about her memories then crossing over to present time telling of her risky visit back to her hometown. This memoir has a large amount of emotion as this young girl grows up in a dark world surrounded by the Vietnamese-American war, knowing nothing else.The reader is also informed with the tactics the North and South
William Graney
Aug 26, 2008 William Graney rated it really liked it
Like Sorrows of War this was another fascinating look into the lives of the Vietnamese during the 1960’s & 70’s. In this book we even get a bit of a glimpse into French occupation in the 50’s.
The perspective of Le Ly is filed with both emotion and a stiff upper lip. She shows a lot of grit and inner strength during episodes of extreme trauma and her saga is both inspiring and sad on many levels.
My only complaint is that at times I felt she tended to ramble and give numerous examples that m
karl levy
Jun 10, 2016 karl levy rated it really liked it
This book was written by Le Ly Haylsip who lived near Danang in Southern Vietnam as a child. She was part of the Viet Cong and is an wonderful insight into the Vietnamese perspective as the American perspective has many many books written about it. the book was chosen by Oliver Stone to make the third film in his trology, 'Heaven and Earth', teh first two films being 'Platoon' and 'Fourth of July'. hayslip eventually made it to America after marrying an American Serviceman and eventaull;y return ...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
  • The Sacred Willow: Four Generations in the Life of a Vietnamese Family
  • A Vietcong Memoir: An Inside Account of the Vietnam War and Its Aftermath
  • Patriots: The Vietnam War Remembered from All Sides
  • Last Night I Dreamed of Peace: The Diary of Dang Thuy Tram
  • Stay Alive, My Son
  • Catfish and Mandala: A Two-Wheeled Voyage Through the Landscape and Memory of Vietnam
  • The Princeton Dictionary of Buddhism
  • The Unwanted: A Memoir of Childhood
  • The Humanistic Tradition: Prehistory to the Early Modern World (The Humanistic Tradition, #1)
  • Home Before Morning
  • Dalai Lama, My Son: A Mother's Autobiography
  • Perfume Dreams: Reflections on the Vietnamese Diaspora
  • Novel Without a Name
  • The Killing Zone: My Life in the Vietnam War
  • The Girl in the Picture: The Story of Kim Phuc, the Photograph, and the Vietnam War
  • A Dragon Apparent: Travels in Cambodia, Laos & Vietnam
  • From the Land of Green Ghosts: A Burmese Odyssey
  • The Alhambra
Le Ly Hayslip is a Vietnamese-American memoirist and humanitarian. She was born in Ky La, now Xa Hao Qui, a small town in central Vietnam just south of Da Nang. She was the sixth and youngest child born to farmers. American helicopters landed in her village when she was 12 years old. At the age of 14, she endured torture in a South Vietnamese government prison for "revolutionary sympathies". She f ...more
More about Le Ly Hayslip...

Share This Book

“For you see, the face of destiny or luck or god that gives us war also gives us other kinds of pain: the loss of health and youth; the loss of loved ones or of love; the fear that we will end our days alone. Some people suffer in peace the way others suffer in war. The special gift of that suffering, I have learned, is how to be strong while we are weak, how to be brave when we are afraid, how to be wise in the midst of confusion, and how to let go of that which we can no longer hold. In this way, anger can teach us forgiveness, hate can teach us love, and war can teach us peace.” 16 likes
“The past, for everyone, is full of missed chances, surviving to understand them, if not set them straight, is one of the things that makes the next breath worth taking.” 11 likes
More quotes…