22nd out of 415 books
—
623 voters
The Reluctant Heiress
by
Eva Ibbotson
Being an heiress in 1920s Austria with nothing but a broken-down castle to your name and nary a penny in your purse could be frustrating for anyone but the Princess Theresa-Maria of Pfaffenstein. ?Tessa,? however, is thrilled with her situation, as it allows her to concentrate on her love of the arts?and no one in the Viennese opera company need know that their delightful...more
Paperback, 368 pages
Published
April 30th 2009
by Speak
(first published 1982)
Friend Reviews
To see what your friends thought of this book,
please sign up.
Community Reviews
(showing
1-30
of
3,000)
Alright, I really like this author but enough is enough. I think I have read too many of her books in too short of time. Heck, I think I could write one of these books. Hmm, here goes. Impoverished adorable female heroine who, despite very bleak odds, is still the happiest, calmest, sweetest girl on the block. It doesn't matter that her parents hate her of she has no money, her beauty shines through the mess her life is in. Rich, tall, dashingly attractive man comes on the scene. Has all the mon...more
The summer before my senior year, I tore through Eva Ibbotson's quartet of standalone teen books (A Countess Below Stairs, The Morning Gift, A Song for Summer, and A Company of Swans) and thoroughly enjoyed them. When I came across this book a few months back in the bookstore, I was pleasantly surprised to find another Eva Ibbotson book, so I snatched it up.
Then I started reading and . . . it fell flat like music I'd already heard a thousand times before. I don't know why, but this book just was...more
Then I started reading and . . . it fell flat like music I'd already heard a thousand times before. I don't know why, but this book just was...more
Another joyous romp through Eva Ibbotson's world of love in the face of early 20th century post-war Europe, great art, and truly disarming heroines. Tessa (who just happens to be an Italian princess) has dedicated herself as a maid of all work in the service of opera. Guy (tycoon/former foster child & chaos creater) buys up her old palace in honor of his fiance. Said fiance turns out to be in love with herself. Which is actually a good thing because you know sooner or later Tessa & Guy a...more
I feel like I am in a Bad Book Rut, I need a good book asap to restore my faith in writers everywhere!!
Author Eva Ibbostson is 1-1. Her book "A countess below stairs" was wonderful, I thouroughly enjoyed reading it. This book, "The Reluctant Heiress' was a flop.
It took me about 200 pages of reading this one (or scanning it) to become half-way interested. The wording in this one is just too much. I know she was trying to write fitting to the time period, but I just really didn't like it. The char...more
Author Eva Ibbostson is 1-1. Her book "A countess below stairs" was wonderful, I thouroughly enjoyed reading it. This book, "The Reluctant Heiress' was a flop.
It took me about 200 pages of reading this one (or scanning it) to become half-way interested. The wording in this one is just too much. I know she was trying to write fitting to the time period, but I just really didn't like it. The char...more
While I have to saw that I found this a highly enjoyable book, I really felt that it drug on for way too long. Despite knowing how it would work out before I even opened the book, after finishing the first third, I honestly thought that the book should have ended. It's almost as if Ibbotson ended it and then decided that she wasn't quite finished with the characters and chose to change a couple of lines and then continue on for another couple hundred pages. Thus, while good, I've read better in...more
This was typical Eva Ibbotson fare: a story that's just predictable enough to make it feel cosy and well-loved without feeling boring or clichéd. I like her blend of simple storytelling mixed with delicious description, only in this case I found the description began to detract from the story. I can forgive a little exaggeration, but too much and I start to squirm. Oh, and Guy's eyes changing colour felt just a bit too much for me. And -- as with all Eva Ibbotson's books -- there were references...more
Eva Ibbotson is one of my favourite authors, and I think her books for teenagers/adults are utterly wonderful! Magic Flutes (also known as The Reluctant Heiress) was, in my opinion, gorgeous. It was almost like a fairytale, with the runaway, music-loving princess who then meets and falls in love with a rich, handsome man. Of course it wasn't that simple, and Tessa and Guy had to overcome many obstacles before they could be together.
I loved the 'minor' characters of this book. Martha Hodge was lo...more
I loved the 'minor' characters of this book. Martha Hodge was lo...more
Jul 01, 2012
Maninee
rated it
4 of 5 stars
·
review of another edition
Recommended to Maninee by:
Avisikta
Shelves:
romance
When I flipped through the book at the library the cover told me this was the story of beautiful dark eyed princess who has shrugged off her royal duties and taken up the life of theatre and how she meets and falls in love with a handsome and rich English businessman. For me atleast the story isn't so much about romance really. Atleast, not one of those heady romances where every other page is filled with detailed descriptions of the heroine's face. No, this was less of romance and more of, well...more
This book is virtually identical to Ibbotson's The Morning Gift in many ways, but I didn’t care. I always say, when you have a good story, stick with it! It was still enjoyable to me in the way all modern fairy tales are. Nevertheless, having just read The Morning Gift before this one, there were no surprises for me, except for the occasional change in syntax:
The Morning Gift: “What I’m going to do now, is kiss you.”
The Reluctant Heiress: “’I’m going to kiss you, you see,’ he explained.”
Yes, the...more
Guy Farne was abandoned as a baby and grew up first in an orphanage, then with a foster mother. When he fell in love with a young woman whose family threw him out for being penniless and nameless, he spent years amassing a vast fortune so he could eventually win her. His coup de grace was purchasing a magnificent, ancient Austrian castle from its bankrupt owners (just one of many Austrian and German castles for sale after WWI) and throwing a house party with the creme de la creme (such as it now...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
This book was exactly what I wanted at exactly the right time. I was suffering from a migraine yesterday when I started it, and this light and fluffy concoction was enough to distract me from my pain while still being light enough not to add to my strain.
This book is entirely predictable, but that's part of the reason you'll want to turn to it. As much as we readers know how the narrative will end, it's a delight getting there. The characters are lively and often filled with joy. Love of music f...more
This book is entirely predictable, but that's part of the reason you'll want to turn to it. As much as we readers know how the narrative will end, it's a delight getting there. The characters are lively and often filled with joy. Love of music f...more
Eva Ibbotson's usual lovely effort to raise the bar in the romance category, redeeming a typical fairy-tale plot with real people and real humor. Taking place in Austria just after World War I, we are swiftly introduced to two people obviously intended for each other: Guy, an English foundling turned self-made millionaire, and Tessa, an Austrian princess with a lineage that goes back to Charlemagne. But Guy is smitten with a snobbish fiancee and buys Tessa's castle to impress her, while Tessa is...more
Update: I finished... actually, I skipped a lot of the book. I just couldn't get into it. And it wasn't even the random big words (see earlier rant below). I just didn't really care about these characters. And there was so much in this book that didn't seem to fit quite right or that just felt like filler. I really doubt I'll ever read anything by Eva Ibbotson again.
Just a quick note... I'm only 40 pages in and I'm a bit annoyed with the author. "Vituperative" and "salubrious"? Really? She could...more
Just a quick note... I'm only 40 pages in and I'm a bit annoyed with the author. "Vituperative" and "salubrious"? Really? She could...more
If I had read this book before I read A Countess Below Stairs it would have been one of my favorite books. A beautiful story with such a great leading lady, and the opera...Debussy, Mozart, Puccini--love love love. I like the sacrifice of everything toward the greater good of music, and that Beethoven's button business-genius.
However, this is strikingly similar to A Countess Below Stairs and that book has a slightly more appealing hero, bigger climax moment with that great line that goes somethi...more
However, this is strikingly similar to A Countess Below Stairs and that book has a slightly more appealing hero, bigger climax moment with that great line that goes somethi...more
Nov 11, 2009
Nicole Catherine
rated it
3 of 5 stars
Recommends it for:
fluffy not-quite-squeaky-clean romance lovers
Shelves:
the-only-slightly-sketchy-shelf
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
I was so excited to find another Eva Ibbotson book! Awhile back I blew through A Song for Summer, A Countess Below Stairs, A Company of Swans, and The Morning Gift. When I surfaced again, I found myself really hoping the magic spell wouldn't end there. Happily there was one more sweet historical in store for me. THE RELUCTANT HEIRESS is a (retitled) re-issue of Ibbotson's Magic Flutes, which was originally published in 1982. It is set in the 1920s and revolves around the outrageously funny and t...more
As always, "The Reluctant Heiress" kept my not only my heart, but my emotional well-being on a roller coaster. Though it was not one of my favorite of Eva Ibbotson's works, for I was not groveling in painful tears and heartache as usual, it was none the less an enriching and enchanting piece of literature, starring as usual a humble, most-likable heroin, a man, this time battling with love's folly, and of course - conflict, at which Mrs. Ibbotson is distinguished in my opinion. Again, I was surp...more
How does one describe the novels of Eva Ibbotson? She has a way of blending outlandishly caricatured, eminently familiar hero and villain types with simple, earnest storytelling. Damning with faint praise, you say? No, no, for she does it so very well that, as a reader, you allow yourself to be swept away into her unabashedly modern fairy tale world. And her YA romance novels are nothing if not that. They don't contain the obvious trappings of fairy tales, for the characters are real people (eve...more
A republican princess of the people is charmed by a self-made orphan who buys her castle and shares her love of opera. This is the barest of summaries. A sweet, predictable book. I regret that I did not believe the relationship between Guy and Tessa, neither in its early stages, nor in its progression. Also I dislike that Ibbotson's bad-guy characters are so two-dimensional. Why do they have no redeeming qualities? Their shallow, self-absorption makes them the perfect fairy-tale foils (and utter...more
I know, I KNOW, that any time I pick up one of Eva Ibbotson's romances, I can't put it down. I KNOW THIS. And yet, last night when I got home after midnight, I STILL PICKED IT UP. Fortunately I could sleep in this morning.
The remarkable thing about this unbreakable grip Ibbotson's books have on me is that the main characters are the same from book to book, which you'd think would get boring. All the girls are young and full of loving, giving life, and all the guys are about 10 years older, hot-t...more
The remarkable thing about this unbreakable grip Ibbotson's books have on me is that the main characters are the same from book to book, which you'd think would get boring. All the girls are young and full of loving, giving life, and all the guys are about 10 years older, hot-t...more
I don't think whomever wrote the summary did the novel justice. The chance encounter that evidences Guy's kind and tender heart (his tendresse for his young love is further evidence). I read this as "Magic Flutes". Very sweet, tender denouement of Tessa's love and her feelings for Guy. It gradually sneaks up on her as she is trying to give her heart to the theater/Opera Company. The gift of the perfect performance of the Magic Flute at the Castle is one of the things that further brings Guy and...more
Eva Ibbotson writes fairytales. Or at least the two books I have read by her seem like fairytales. For reasons that will become clearer as the review progresses, I have decided to review both books together. I have spent almost a year immersed in the academics of fairytales (and yes, it is as fun as it sounds), deconstructing fairytales, finding out what they are saying under the shiny dresses and glass slippers and finding out that they are not as benign as they may be portrayed to be. On the s...more
I really enjoyed this book. I bought this and four other books by Eva Ibbotson. I decided to pick this one up to read a few days ago because it looked interesting. It didn't fail me. I really liked Tessa and I was rooting for her and Guy to get together. But of course in their way, they had Guy's fiancee, Nerine. I was originally annoyed by the author portraying stereotypical feminine things like wanting to look good and loving to shop as being shallow. But as I read, I found out that Nerine was...more
Eva Ibbotson's middle grade far outclasses her YA: it's more light-hearted in intent, which gives it both more fun and more emotional heft than this heavy-handed attempt at a romance. It's very sweet, but it lacks the impact and the creativity of, say, THE ISLAND OF THE AUNTS, not to mention its polished and easy prose. She has a hard time here with the maxim, "Show, don't tell," and instead prefers that less-beloved but no less common method, the infodump. Her books are very old-fashioned in a...more
I'm sure Eva Ibbotson is too precious by half for a lot of people, but I like her and she is very popular with a certain kind of teen girl. I've read two of her written-for-adults-but-recently-repackaged-for-teens books now, and while I liked A Countess Below Stairs better, this one is good too. To me, the main selling point is the voice of the narrarator, which is arch but kind to her characters.
The basic formula in these books is that a young woman loses her job as a princess/member of the ari...more
The basic formula in these books is that a young woman loses her job as a princess/member of the ari...more
If you've read and enjoyed Eva Ibbotsen's other recently republished historical romances, this one is just the same and perfectly charming. The plot is extremely similar to that of The Countess Below Stairs, but the supporting cast is distinct enough that it's still quite enjoyable to read.
All of Ibbotsen's heroines are roughly the same type: whisper-thin urchins with huge eyes and mischevious grins whose pure-hearted joy at life and art makes them glow from within. Her heroes, by and large, ar...more
All of Ibbotsen's heroines are roughly the same type: whisper-thin urchins with huge eyes and mischevious grins whose pure-hearted joy at life and art makes them glow from within. Her heroes, by and large, ar...more
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers. To view it,
click here.
Originally posted at http://shelversanon.blogspot.com
This is such a strange book. Do you know how a cat will tip its head and jerkily poke an unfamiliar object? That's how I feel starting this review.
The writing style was... weird. I don't know if it was a "I was written in the 80's and we did things differently then" kind of weird or what, because I'm not an expert on the evolution of writing styles. Maybe it was an Austrian type of style (the story is set in Austria, and I'm willing to wager t...more
This is such a strange book. Do you know how a cat will tip its head and jerkily poke an unfamiliar object? That's how I feel starting this review.
The writing style was... weird. I don't know if it was a "I was written in the 80's and we did things differently then" kind of weird or what, because I'm not an expert on the evolution of writing styles. Maybe it was an Austrian type of style (the story is set in Austria, and I'm willing to wager t...more
There are no discussion topics on this book yet.
Be the first to start one »
Eva Ibbotson (born Maria Charlotte Michelle Wiesner, 1925, Vienna, Austria) was a British novelist specializing in romance and children's fantasy. Eva Ibbotson was born in Vienna, Austria, in 1925. When Hitler came into power, Ibbotson's family moved to England. She attended Bedford College, graduating in 1945; Cambridge University from 1946-47; and the University of Durham, from which she graduat...more
More about Eva Ibbotson...
Share This Book
5 trivia questions
1 quiz
More quizzes & trivia...
1 quiz
“I must go-- the aunts will be worried. Guy, I don't know if we will meet again, but--" Her voice broke and she tried again. "Sometimes, when you're alone and you look up at--" Once more, she had to stop. Then she managed, "If I cannot be anything else... could I be your Star Sister? Could I at least be that?"
Guy dug his nails into his palms. Everything in him rose in protest at the fey, romantic conceit. He did not want her in the heavens, linked to him by some celestial whimsy, but here and now in the flesh and after the death of the flesh, her hand in his as they rose from graves like these when the last trump sounded.
"Yes," he managed to say. "You can be my Star Sister. You can at least be that.”
—
14 people liked it
Guy dug his nails into his palms. Everything in him rose in protest at the fey, romantic conceit. He did not want her in the heavens, linked to him by some celestial whimsy, but here and now in the flesh and after the death of the flesh, her hand in his as they rose from graves like these when the last trump sounded.
"Yes," he managed to say. "You can be my Star Sister. You can at least be that.”
“She took a deep breath, inhaling the night air scented with hay, honeysuckle and the rich waters of the lake, listened to the music and laughter coming from the theatre, tilted her head to the the stars. She had never seen them so brilliant and clear. Cassiopeia, Orion, the great girdle of the Milky Way-and her own birth sign, Gemini. With such staggering beauty in the world, how could anyone not rejoice?
It seemed however, that 'anyone' could. For at once came the age-old cry of lovers since time began. 'What are the stars if i am not gazing at them with him? What is beauty except something we share?”
—
10 people liked it
More quotes…
It seemed however, that 'anyone' could. For at once came the age-old cry of lovers since time began. 'What are the stars if i am not gazing at them with him? What is beauty except something we share?”

Loading...











































Apr 08, 2009 06:31pm
Apr 09, 2009 11:10am
Jan 11, 2013 06:10am