The Judgment of Paris: The Revolutionary Decade that Gave the World Impressionism

The Judgment of Paris: The Revolutionary Decade that Gave the World Impressionism

3.86 of 5 stars 3.86  ·  rating details  ·  2,902 ratings  ·  158 reviews
While the Civil War raged in America, another revolution took shape across the Atlantic, in the studios of Paris: The artists who would make Impressionism the most popular art form in history were showing their first paintings amidst scorn and derision from the French artistic establishment. Indeed, no artistic movement has ever been quite so controversial. The drama of it...more
Paperback, 464 pages
Published November 28th 2006 by Walker & Company (first published January 10th 2006)
more details... edit details

Friend Reviews

To see what your friends thought of this book, please sign up.
The Shock of the New by Robert HughesThe Judgment of Paris by Ross KingThe Man Who Made Vermeers by Jonathan LopezMichelangelo, the Sistine Chapel by Stefano ZuffiThe Power of Art by Simon Schama
Best Art and Art History Books
2nd out of 137 books — 101 voters
Les Misérables by Victor HugoA Moveable Feast by Ernest HemingwayA Tale of Two Cities by Charles DickensMy Life in France by Julia ChildThe Count of Monte Cristo by Alexandre Dumas
Books About Paris
44th out of 268 books — 285 voters


More lists with this book...

Community Reviews

(showing 1-30 of 3,000)
filter  |  sort: default (?)  |  rating details
Dvora
I very much enjoyed this history of the beginnings of Impressionism in France. It was well written, fairly well illustrated (there is always the internet for looking up more of the paintings mentioned, but I hate getting up from my reading to do that), and the subject matter and people involved were fascinating to me. Thanks AC and the Artist Lovers group on GR for drawing my attention to this book, which I doubt I ever would have heard of otherwise.

I wanted to add that after reading this, I am...more
Kathleen
1. I listened to half on my way home from Ohio, and now I'm going to actually READ the second half. I like to see events coincide: the Civil War and the birth of Impressionism and the downfall is it? of Napoleon III of France. I like to learn about art history this way, with new facts tossed in as part of the larger story: : Impasto is paint layered thickly. Chiaroscuro is paint getting gradually lighter, with a dark background, to show volume. Painting for Paris of mid-nineteenth century was li...more
Muselmu
"Zum Frühstück ins Freie" erzählt vordergründig von der Malerei in der zweiten Hälfte des 19. Jahrhunderts in Frankreich. Hautnah kann man miterleben, wie einzelne Künstler aus den Normen und Zwängen der École des Beaux Arts auszubrechen versuchen, neue Techniken ausprobieren, verhöhnt werden und sich langsam aber sicher neue Kunstströmungen entfalten - unter ihnen auch der Impressionismus, der mit Vertretern wie Manet, Monet, Renoir, etc zu den Ursprüngen der modernen Malerei gehört.

Es ist also...more
Robert Boyd
Stirring and dramatic. The book tells the story of a sea-change in art by concentrating on two painters, Manet and Messonier. If you've never heard of Meissonier, don't worry--few have. He was the most successful French painter in the second half of the 19th century, but his reputation collapsed almost instantly after his death. But choosing these two artists to focus on doesn't take away from the other artists whose stories intersect in the Paris of the 1960s. Courbet is an especially appealing...more
Lori
Mar 28, 2011 Lori rated it 4 of 5 stars Recommends it for: Serious art students
This is an excellent exploration of the political, social and artistic background that led to the birth of Impressionism. It is a very detailed, in-depth look at the artists Manet and Meissonier, their work and how that work both exemplified and defied the artistic trends and political environment of 19th century Paris - the crucial time period that both shaped and changed the art world.

This is not a book for the casual art observer, but an in-depth exploration for those seriously interested in...more
Adrian Stumpp
King's exploration of the birth of Impressionism, which he considers the greatest revolution in art since the Italian Renaissance, interweaves the stories of two French artists: Ernest Meissanier, the most famous artist of his time who is now derided, dismissed, and virtually forgotten by art historians, and Edouard Manet, considered the father of Impressionism and one of the most influential artists in history who was scorned and insulted for most of his professional career. This dichotomy repr...more
Frank Stein
Ross King, author of the pop-histories "Brunelleschi's Dome" and "Michelangelo and the Pope's Ceiling," writes another great story that combines artistic and political intrigue. This is a tale of the 1860s in France, when Edouard Manet and the not-yet-named Impressionists challenged the artistic establishment while Napolean III's "Second Empire" teetered on the brink of disaster.

Most interesting is King's ability to tease out the relations between the political and artistic world, which were ad...more
Valerie
I loved the accessible writing style. The book would be enjoyable for anyone, not just art history buffs. It was speckled with entertaining and interesting facts, and was not dry at all. I was using the book as a source while writing a research paper and could not put it down.

My only problem was that when cross-checking some of King's quotes and figures I came across references that made me a little uncomfortable with including them in my paper because they seemed to be interpreted a little too...more
T Michael Testi
I found this to be quite an interesting read. There are some points that are a bit dry, but for the most part very readable. I think that although the events took place 150 years ago, the history it teaches is very relevant in today's world.

The book centers around two french painters Édouard Manet and Ernest Meissonier. The latter being very highly acclaimed during his lifetime and the former, being - using today's terms, considered a hack, by many of his contemporaries. The book takes us throu...more
Crystal
I don't know how others who don't care much for art let alone art history would appreciate this but I enjoyed it very much. It's given me a good lesson on the beginnings of impressionism and those artists that dared to challenge the strict traditions of the French art institute and to shock, even offend, the French public.
King is apparently a bigger admirer of the Impressionists because I felt his writing of Ernest Messionier bias and unfair. If in his lifetime the man found his wealth and fame...more
Ellen
This is the first nonfiction book I've ever completed voluntarily, and I absolutely loved it! Ross King's writing is easy to follow and he takes on a subject that is fascinating to me. The book chronicles the story of the Salon des Refuses or "exhibition of rejects" where many of the most famous painters of all time were forced to exhibit their works after being rejected by the jury of the official Paris Salon.

The book focuses a great deal on the life story of Edouard Manet, who is one of my fa...more
Dot
I think this must have been a difficult book to write since it deals with innovations by prominent French artists set against the political backdrop of the Third Empire. King chiefly deals with 2 artists : Meissonier and Manet. The former was hailed as France's greatest artist during his lifetime while Manet was ignored or roundly criticised. Today most people would recognise the name of Edouard Manet but not that of Meissonier. I found the politics surrounding the choice of paintings selected b...more
Michael
I appreciate how Ross King took the time to find actual quotes from art critics that served to deflate and defame great art. The remarks come across as both cruel and comedic. For example, one critic receives the feeling of a painting as "the taste of a sick man's handkerchief." Amusing anecdotes also run aplenty. For example, Napoleon III liked women so much that "he exerted himself in bed until the wax on the edge of his mustache would melt." As a result, the mustache became droopy. A few hist...more
Elise
More of a survey of events, rather than an examination of how the societal conditions affected the success (or lack thereof) of the two artists and styles. It moved slowly and I would have enjoyed reading more analysis of the broader implications of the art, but interesting subject matter nonetheless.
Ann
I enjoyed this book even more than I anticipated. It chronicles the decade (1863-1874) that "gave the world Impressionism." The book is full of history and information about a volatile period in French, especially Parisian, history (Napoleon III's Second Empire, Franco-Prussian War, Siege of Paris, the Commune, Third Republic); however, it primarily revolves around "the two poles of art" Ernest Meissonier ("the most famous and successful painter of the 19th century"--Sic transit gloria mundi) an...more
Sue Pit
The Judgment of Paris , The Revolutionary Decade that Gave the World Impressionism as written by Ross King is a most informative and enlightening book regarding the transition of classical art to modern art. Art regarding noble moral lessons set in the far past or mythical settings were giving way to realistic art depicting not a glorified notion of the past but of the reality of the present. This book focuses on two artists primarily. Ernest Meissonier and Edouard Manet. Ernest Meissonier was h...more
AC
This review MAY contain a spoiler -- I'm not sure..., it's hard for me to tell….

(It has taken me quite a while to write this review -- I wasn't sure why…. I thought maybe I was just being busy, or just being lazy…; but I think the reason is deeper than that.... Anyway, this is what I originally wrote, and didn't post, when I finished the book:)

This was the perfect book for me. I knew just enough to profit from this informed and intelligent review of the roots of Impressionism and this fascinatin...more
Amie
This was really a great book! It was about the opposition faced by the Impressionists under the salon system of Paris, which was the conventional way for artists to gain recognition in the day. King focused a lot on the experiences of Ernest Meissonier, who was the most revered painter in Europe in the mid 1800's, and Edouard Manet, who was constantly rejected from the Salon, or ridiculed and criticized when his paintings were accepted. Ross King was able to tell their stories, along with the st...more
Hotavio
Here Ross King concerns himself with the French art world leading up to the dawn of Impressionism. The book reads as easily as a fictional narrative in that it follows the seemingly disparate careers of Ernest Meissonier and Edouard Manet. The 2 artists could hardly be comparable. Yet, King's selection of the artists resembles two oppositional ages in a France that experiences one cataclysm after another. King adeptly introduces other equally intriguing personalities from all aspects of society,...more
Bookmarks Magazine

Ross King has an impressive track record chronicling the transformative nature of genius. His Brunelleschi's Dome and Michelangelo and the Pope's Ceiling (**** Mar/Apr 2003) wrapped their author's extensive knowledge of European culture in brisk, compelling prose. King continues his march through art history's great moments in The Judgment of Paris and emerges with another triumph. Though the central drama is focused on Manet and Meissonier, The Boston Globe criticizes the book as "at heart an i

...more
Marti
While the book sometimes plodded through French history, it did help me put the rise of French Impressionism into perspective with the times it emerged from. I had never heard of one of the most influential artists of the time, Ernest Meissonier, who plays a huge part in the development of this historical account of the artistic climate that gave birth to Impressionism. I had a hard time finding out very much about him in the library of books I have on the history of world art and an even harder...more
Sue
I have had this book in my to read stack for a while and finally picked it up and read it! I really like this kind of book, but the last half reads too much like a history book. The book follows the events of 1863-the 1870's Paris and the Salon and the events of the time with Napoleon III and then into the Franco-Prussian war in the early 1870's, and how the events affected the artist’s lives. Mostly I find it interesting how Manet plugged along without any success like the other young Parisian...more
Jesse Turner
Admittedly this book was required reading for a art history course, and also embarrassingly enough it was the first piece of historical non-fiction I had, at the time, completed. I found the book to be highly fluid, and never have I read a piece of historical non-fiction so wonderfully engrossing, since.

The tale of the two artist provides an insightful social commentary of 19c. France, and it was this interweaving of social and political history that had me more than ready to attend my first da...more
Candy Wood
Focusing on the painters Meissonier and Manet, Ross King provides a social and cultural history of Paris from 1863 to 1874. I knew about Manet but not Meissonier, some of whose paintings I must have seen in the Metropolitan Museum in New York and the Wallace Collection in London, and that’s part of King’s point: Meissonier’s careful brushwork and historical canvases received high praise then while Manet’s less-finished scenes of modern life were derided, but now their positions are reversed. Kin...more
Carol
If one is interested in 19th C French history, the Impressionists, the Franco-Prussian War, and what the transition was like from highly technical academic art to Impressionism---this is THE book. The author moves back and forth from the life and work of Meissonier (a fanatically realistic painter (you will never believe the lengths to which he went to present anatomical perfection----of horses in battle scenes) to the struggles of Manet and his contemporaries.
The book is extremely well written...more
Lisa
Nov 04, 2011 Lisa rated it 4 of 5 stars
Recommended to Lisa by: Good Reads Art Lovers group
I came across The Judgement of Paris via GoodReads where the Art Lovers group were reading it, and it’s a most interesting book. It’s the story of the birth of the Impressionist movement and the initial hostile reception by conservative forces in Paris, but the book also traverses the tumultuous period of the Franco-Prussian War and the Commune so it’s interesting as a work of general history too.

To represent the opposing forces, King focuses on Ernest Meissonier (1815-1891) and Edouard Manet (1...more
Kasey
Just wanted to make a little note about this book:
I enjoyed it. However, it was really slow. There were many redundant words and some sentences could've been more concise.

But it gave me a new view to Impressionism. In fact, I've never enjoyed walking through art museums as much as I do now. (I'm especially excited seeing Manet's works.) I've never seen Meissonier's works! Ever! I wish I could, their descriptions and feelings that Ross King described really swayed me.

Interested in art/art histo...more
Bruce Jones
An interesting account of Parisian painters, particularly Manet, who never made a living by his art, and Paris' most successful painter, Messionier, through the years 1850-1880. The contrast and comparison between the two and by extrapolation, their peers, presented with the backdrop of the political and social changes of the times, muddies the waters of clear-cut, simplistic assumptions about academic painting, about impressionism. After multiple expletive deleteds, I came to appreciate the boo...more
Tom
I teach American art history, but I don't know nearly enough about European art. This fascinating book explains the beginnings of Impressionism in Second Empire Paris, with plenty of historical context about not only the artists and their mistresses (all had one or more, of course) but also about the politicians, scientists and quirky characters of what was then the virtual capital of the world. The title is a double entendre, referring to the "Salons" at which new paintings were exhibited and j...more
Teri Robus
I enjoyed reading about Manet and Meissonier and how their lives wound around each other's but not actually meeting until the Franco-Prussian War, when Manet served under Meissonier. Didn't even know about Meissonier and i have taken Art History! i think this is because Meissonier painted very realistically as was the fashionable thing to do back then in the early 1800's. Manet was up and coming with his new style and finally at the end of his life (he died way too early at 51!) he was becoming...more
« previous 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 99 100 next »
There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Be the first to start one »
The Judgment of Paris: The Revolutionary Decade That Gave the World Impressionism (Hardcover)
The Judgement of Paris: Manet, Meisonnier and An Artistic Revolution (Hardcover)
The Judgement of Paris: The Revolutionary Decade That Gave the World Impressionism (Paperback)
The Judgment Of Paris: The Revolutionary Decade That Gave The World Impressionism
The Judgment of Paris: The Revolutionary Decade That Gave the World Impressionism (Audio CD)

26293
Librarian Note: There is more than one author in the GoodReads database with this name. See this thread for more information.

Ross King (born July 16, 1962) is a Canadian novelist and non-fiction writer. He began his career by writing two works of historical fiction in the 1990s, later turning to non-fiction, and has since written several critically acclaimed and best-selling historical works.

King...more
More about Ross King...
Brunelleschi's Dome: How a Renaissance Genius Reinvented Architecture Michelangelo and the Pope's Ceiling Ex-Libris Leonardo and the Last Supper Machiavelli: Philosopher of Power

Share This Book

Your website